Friends Computer Advice (help him believe me)

Funky_Junk

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 1, 2005
Messages
353
My friend is trying to build himself an ultra budget gaming box, and Im trying to give him some advice. Here are the parts he picked:

EVGA 7900GT KO---$247
Antec Sonata II---$105
MSI RS482M-IL ATI RS482 (socket 754)---$70
AMD Sempron 3400 (socket 754)---$95
2GB (1x2) Buffalo Memory---$170
The rest (Optical, HDD) he already has.

So heres the advice I gave him:

First off, I told him its useless to have 2GB of memory when he has such a slow processor. I recommended he ditched the 2gb of ram for 1gb and put the extra hundred dollars towards a better processor (suggestions?).

If for some reason he was compelled to keep the 2gb of memory and cheapy processor, I recommended that (for the same price) he get a socket AM2 instead of a socket 754 and OCZ gold brand memory instead of the generic buffalo memory.

So, Im asking you to give further imput, and also confirm what I have said so he believes me. Try to put emphasis on why he should get AM2 socket instead of 754 should he decide to go with the Sempron. Thanks.
 
It IS a slower processor, and I WOULD suggest that your friend spends more money on that before he gets more than 1GB of memory, but it wouldn't totally cripple his system, either. A Sempron 3400+ isn't a totally crappy setup, just not the best one out there. His 7900GT, in other words, won't do any "bottlenecking" despite what others say. There will be a performance decrease, but how much of a performance decrease is hard to say.

Just tell him that if he's getting this as a gaming machine, he owes it to himself to get a processor designed for gaming. Semprons were designed for being put in machines that maybe surf the net once in a while. I mean, they put semprons in school computers.
 
Socket 754 is dead
Socket 939 is on life support.
Socket AM2 is the way to go.

If he ever wants to upgrade cheaply in the future he needs to go with AM2.

As far as the Athlon vs Sempron, some games will suffer from the small L2 cache the Semrpon offers. If he's not planning on overclocking there's no point in buying more expensive RAM. the buffalo stuff will work fine as long as it works to begin with. Another thing, DDR2 prices are coming down, and DDR is going to go way up in the coming year. If he plans on upgrading to say 4GB of DDR a year from now he;ll be ass raped compared to if he was using DDR2 now.
 
No offence, but I got a 3400+ in my box and for a 'budget' chip, it does for all my gaming needs.

Although if at some point I want to upgrade the chip, I'll have to buy a new motherboard. So you might want to point that out.
 
Here's some things I would tell him:

I can't understand why anybody would buy a new Socket 754 motherboard with PCI Express on it. It only makes sense if you have an old AGP video card and buy a Socket 754 board with AGP. Because.......

If you want to buy a cheapo Sempron, that's fine, it can be upgraded later. It'll do ok for now. But why would you buy a 754 Sempron for $95 when AM2 Sempron chips are out and don't cost any extra? And furthermore......

You can buy an actual Athlon 64 AM2 CPU that's FASTER and costs LESS THAN $10 MORE!!!

Besides, Socket 754 doesn't support running your RAM in dual channel mode. That's not exactly going to help your gaming performance any. Even worse, 2GB is the max on that board you selected. Better hope you never want more RAM after Vista comes out and you decide you want to switch to the new OS.

Overclocking on 754 boards when running 2 sticks of RAM has been shown in the past to be iffy. It often limits your potential.

With an AM2 board you can stick a brand spankin new CPU in it a couple years from now when you want more power. What are you going to put in a 754 board? Another Sempron? Will they even make any 2 years from now?

Are there going to be BIOS updates for that board in the future to support new processors or will it be abandoned soon?

AM2 and DDR2 are the way to go. You don't buy old technology when you build a brand new computer. It always comes back to bite you in the ass because you cripple yourself on upgrade options. I learned a long time ago that "if you CAN'T upgrade your system, you WILL want to upgrade". It's like Murphy's Law or something.


That's what I'd say... word it however you want.


Oh and I have to disagree on your not recommending 2GB for a slow processor. A slow system with a lot of RAM can make it perform similarly to a fast system that is stuck paging data to and from the hard drive all the time because it's running out of RAM space. That fast computer is suddenly brought to a halt while it sits there waiting for data requests to be copied back from the hard drive into your RAM and vice versa.


And one last thing... Just remember it's his money so if he ignores your advice and still makes a poor choice, it's his money to spend. There's no point in pissing him off if he doesn't want to listen. Of course, that doesn't mean you can't bag on him endlessly about it the first time he complains that his system sucks. :p
 
Wait for Conroe... I would even rather get a 939 than AM2...however DDR is going bye bye.... then again AGP has been dead for a while now too....
You could do a lower end onroe and much cheaper and NAME brand DDR 2 memory.
 
MC FLMJIG said:
Wait for Conroe... I would even rather get a 939 than AM2...however DDR is going bye bye.... then again AGP has been dead for a while now too....
You could do a lower end onroe and much cheaper and NAME brand DDR 2 memory.
While that may be the best option, I think the OPs friend doesn't have the money to spend on even the lowest end Conroe, which MSRP is $200ish I believe.

Here's what I would do.

AM2 Athlon 64 3200+(Orleans) $105
Less expensive case. $75ish
There are a ton of AM2 motherboard choices in the same price range...research and pick a decent one. (I don't know any) $70-$90
You can get pretty damn good 2x1GB DDR2-800 OCZ stuff for $140-$160.

Ends up practically the same, but MUCH better overall.

If he can wait for the price cuts at the end of july, he may be able to get even more for his money.
 
So then wait for Conroe and you will get CHEAPER AMD chips - or buy a nice dual core intel 805 right now.
 
Yes, don't buy 754. Also, you are absolutely wrong about the memory, why the hell would it be useless? Are his programs not going to want to store stuff in memory because they think his CPU is too slow? Could the money be better spent? Yes, probably, but that goes for most of the stuff you mentioned.
 
Back
Top