Folly to make an interim build?

Mnx4

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jul 29, 2005
Messages
1,039
My computer of about 3 years has pretty much died. The northbridge is dying, and the ram has given me more than enough headaches (if I replaced, it'd be the 4th RMA:mad:). I'd like to just replace the parts with other 939 era parts, but they're rare and expensive. I feel if I'm going to pay for some computer parts, I should get an upgrade rather than a replacement.

I'm just weighing out my options right now. It seems a lot of cutting edge stuff is comin out at the end of the year, and I know there's no way to futureproof a system, but I can at least minimize my losses when I decide to upgrade.

Is it more of a waste of money to buy a cheap interim build than goin all out for a solid build system? I'm just concerned about the slot changes occurring at the end of the year and don't want to get behind the curve again, as with my 939 system.
 
.
Is it more of a waste of money to buy a cheap interim build than goin all out for a solid build system? I'm just concerned about the slot changes occurring at the end of the year and don't want to get behind the curve again, as with my 939 system.

Not really IMO. Unlike the days of old, a cheap costing PC does NOT mean it's of lesser quality. You really don't have to spend much to get a great quality PC these days. There's really not that much difference, at least in terms of quality or speed, between a $2000 PC and an $700 to $800 PC IMO.

In addition, it's gonna be at least another year before prices on the new socket motherboards, CPUs, and RAM to come down to reasonable levels.
 
It depends on your budget. How much do you expect to pay for an interim build?

Moreover, how much do you expect to pay for an all-out build later on, e.g. when Nehalem comes out?

Though, I agree with Danny, you can get a decent computer for a small budget these days.
 
Yup, exactly. Some people who haven't been keeping up with Tech stuff as often feel that what they spent before for a good pc, they feel they need to spend that same amount to get a good pc today. But, in PC technology, fortunately as it goes faster, it does not mean that it will also be more expensive. It's not really a waste of money now to upgrade if your situation requires you to have a PC since your pc is crapping down. This is understandable.
 
For the interim, I'd probably go no more than 300-400. All I'm looking to replace is the motherboard, ram, and CPU. The PSU is negotiable, as I don't know if I'll have to upgrade that as well due to plugs being different on the motherboard.

For a final build system, my max would be around 1500. This would be pretty much an all inclusive upgrade, i.e. CPU, mobo, ram, a high capacity SATA drive, video card, PSU, and monitor (I'm still using a mistubishi crt from 7 years ago :p). I'm just reluctant to get all that if this next generation is going to blow this one out of the water. I'm also concerned about PCIE 2.0 and DDR3 performance needs as I think I'm going to wait to upgrade my vid card after the 9 series generation.
 
A cheap build like this is ideal. This setup at stock speed is comparable to your current setup. When overclocked, it will be much faster than your old socket 939 setup

Cpu - Intel Dual Core Allendale E2180 - $80
Mobo - P35 chipset Gigabyte GA-P35DS3L $80
RAM - G. Skill 2 x 1gig DDR2 800 $45

Total - $205 Good enuff for now. At least your system is up and running.
 
Thanks for the input. I'm really likin that sample build. I was considering upgrading from your suggestion to at least the C2D e4400, but in lieu of the price/performance thing, I think i'm just going to put the money towards a nice aftermarket cooler and a case with better airflow.
 
Cpu - Intel Dual Core Allendale E2180 - $80
Mobo - P35 chipset Gigabyte GA-P35DS3L $80
RAM - G. Skill 2 x 1gig DDR2 800 $45
Western Digital Caviar SE16 WD3200AAKS 320GB 7200 RPM 16MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s $75, or
Western Digital Caviar SE16 WD6400AAKS 640GB 7200 RPM 16MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s $130

to have near Raptor performance. The hard drive is the slowest part of your computer. If you can swing that at around $300 then you'll be happy for a good while.

p.s. I'm on about my 25th interim build in the last 14 years.
 
Alright, so instead of the g.skill, i think imma go with the Corsair XMS 2GB kit at clubit:
http://www.clubit.com/product_detail.cfm?itemno=CA4330522

Also, for an aftermarket cooler, what would be a good idea? I've currently got the xp-90 with a fan on my Athlon X2 and I'm reading around that it can also be used for the 775 socket. Anyone have experience with a 2180 or similar series with an xp-90?

Also, this is my current PSU:
http://http://www.newegg.com/product/product.aspx?Item=N82E16817171009

That should do fine with this build right?
 
[LYL]Homer;1032215388 said:
Western Digital Caviar SE16 WD3200AAKS 320GB 7200 RPM 16MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s $75, or
Western Digital Caviar SE16 WD6400AAKS 640GB 7200 RPM 16MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s $130

to have near Raptor performance. The hard drive is the slowest part of your computer. If you can swing that at around $300 then you'll be happy for a good while.

p.s. I'm on about my 25th interim build in the last 14 years.

The 320GB version is still luck of the draw whether you get the new single platter, FAST revision, or the old dual platter, SLOW version. The 640GB is two 320GB platters, so go with that if you can.
 
I'm definitely considering the 320, but how much slower is it with a double platter? I've already got a dedicated main hard drive (haven't updated sig) so i'd be using it for archiving things, like music or pictures.
 
The performance of the 320GB is fast -- if you get the right one. Most retailers, including NewEgg, are selling the new single platter 320GB drives with the old stock, so getting one is the luck of the draw. I haven't seen the benchmarks yet for the new 640GB drives, as they were just released recently.
 
wd3200aaks (old one, 2 platters)

HDTune_Benchmark_WDC_WD3200AAKS-22VYA0.png

By request, here's the HDTune results:

hdtunewd3200aakssc3.png

Western Digital Caviar SE16 640GB WD6400AAKS-00A7B
HDTune_Benchmark_WDC_WD6400AAKS-00A7B.png

58MB/s vs 90MB/s? I wouldn't risk it, lol.
 
[LYL]Homer;1032217139 said:
What I'm noticing is the access time on the 640gb one, much nicer.

KenF had his drive suspended in his P150, so that affects the seek times a bit.
 
Great discussion here. After replacing the NB fan on my LanParty Ultra-D last weekend, I found myself pricing out new builds as well.

Then I saw Micro Center had the Q6600 for $199, and I nearly jumped in the car right then and there.

I too have been amazed at the cost of current hardware. Taking rebates into account, I priced out a Q6600 on a decent board w/ 2GB at about $350.

I don't see prices going up anytime soon though, so I've decided to keep my system intact for a little while longer.

If you bust out the interim build, let us know how it goes.
 
Thanks for the info on the hard drives.

I did decide to go with the interim build as there was a pretty good deal on the ram that ended friday. I got it all from clubit, simply because I was impressed by the competitive pricing along with a guaranteed M0 stepping processor.

I got the e2180, Gigabyte DS3L-P35, 2GB Corsair XMS2 CL4 ram, and the 320GB caviar. I know the 640 has better specs but I don't like to put all my eggs in one basket when it comes to hard drives. I've got 3 120GB WD's already, one SATA, two PATA, and I'm gonna have to leave one out of the build as there's only one PATA plug, and my DVD drive needs to be in there. I don't know which aftermarket cooler I'm going to get though; I may just get the LGA 775 retention kit for the xp-90 as i've already got a really good fan paired with it.
 
The retention kit for the XP-90 should do the trick for cooling that chip up to 3.2Ghz.

Both the 320GB and 640GB drives using 320GB-platters are fast. The problem is, you may or may not get a newer revision for the 320GB. So, good luck getting the newer revision. ;) If you do get it, please post an HDTune screenshot when you get a chance. :D

As for the stranded IDE drive, you can pickup an external enclosure for it, and turn it into an external drive. ;)
 
Alright, so got everything and set it up. It's hella late and haven't totally installed all the drivers or checked temps, but everything seems to be in tip top shape.

Also, as requested:
2jdjt3k.jpg


Good, yes? :D :D :D
 
Back
Top