Five Things to Hate About HDTV

lol, HD content is free from my provider, mind you you have to pay $7 a month extra for a box that can get HD content (on top of the normal box we are required to get to get cable content). Funny how Cox has a bunch of services it advertises as "free" Digital content, DVR, HD and HD DVR (additional fee for being able to record HD content), but require a service charge or equipment usage fee.
 
I'll take SD cable on my 42" 1080p Panasonic plasma over my parent's 32" Toshiba SD flat-screen CRT any day of the week. I like it way more than the Sharp LCD's we use at work even.

Terrible article, I hope her other articles aren't that annoying.
 
I think this report should lift his lazy ass off, go pick up a book and start reading. After all if what he wants is escaping he should use his fucking imagination and not his eyes.
 
Worst article EVER on HD drawbacks. Maybe the full moon is affecting her menstrual cycle and she has no husband to bitch at (big surprise), so she chose the Internet as an estrogen-rage target.
 
You can see too much detail? Come on...you can't even pretend this is "journalism." This isn't even opinion. This is stupidity.
 
Note to self, write to MSNBC editor to fire this woman. She needs to at least be moved to another department as she has no business writing tech related article. If she was old enough she would probably be extolling the benefits of a BW set versus Color because with old movies that are in BW, you can't experience the benefits of color anyway.
 
Some people don't like change, oh black bars on the sides. Wtf do you think happened when you got a color tv and the stations were still broadcast in black and white? You think they just all of a sudden were in f'n color now? This article is stupid
 
Article is definitely deserves the 1-star rating it has.

MSNBC should fire that writer, obviously doesn't have a clue.
 
The points are sound but dont apply! Yes, nobody wants to see the reporters THAT well! But seeing the REST of the game is worth those few minutes

Yes, HDMI cables are a pain - mainly because only high-end devices have them! (oh, forgot that little tidbit?) cost is nothing. People are GIVING THEM AWAY on many forums if you just ask nicely and pay the shipping! (I bought a "grab bag" of cables and got a nice Belkin HDMI 8' cable along with a dozen others (including VGA extention and KVM) for I think $10... and that included shipping) It's so nice to have a HDMI port on my 360 when my TV only has RCA jacks (though yes it has component input so I'm not losing much of anything) Though I will admit she was right that many people arent getting the major boost in SOUND from HDMI. I had a "nice" sound setup and it sounds like cats mating now that I've heard from a Technics surround-sound system (~$700) but most people arent that much of an audiophile ot care!

Yes, calibration is annoying, but have you ever watched SD on a poorly calibrated TV? I had no idea that Darth Vader's costume was PURPLE! (yes I had a friend who's TV was THAT badly calibrated)

Black Bars have been around long before the modern crop of HDTVs, before LCDs were even in existance (minus crappy laptop ones) you'd get "theatrical cut" of a movie with blakc bars on the top and bottom.

I dont even remember the other point, but it probably only applied obscurly too. The article was written, it seems, by a layman who stumbled into HDTV when her grandson bought her one after her old 12" from the 70s broke down.

Oh and for those of you suffering from SD issues, look into Upscaling. I've done that with some of my videos (you can get a program for PC that will rip and upscale AVI then spit it back out onto a flashdrive or DVD) on most clips this works. But on some (read: those off youtube, etc) it makes you barf...
 
If you read the responses to the original article, they are all saying the same thing that most of you have said. This was a pointless article and off base on all of the points. Love the point about calibration, like any SD CRT has good calibration out-of-the-box. Mentioning the high price of HDMI cables, when most know they can get cheap ones that work just as well (the author could have taken this as an opportunity to mention that an $8 digital cable works just as well as an $80 one).

Biggest con about HD, some Wii games look like crap on my 60". Oh wait, that's the Wii's fault.
 
He is a "She" if you can call her that.... written by Suzanne Choney

She seems to write alot of tech articles on msnbc http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/3033118/ns/technology_and_science-tech_and_gadgets

Note to self, write to MSNBC editor to fire this woman. She needs to at least be moved to another department as she has no business writing tech related article. If she was old enough she would probably be extolling the benefits of a BW set versus Color because with old movies that are in BW, you can't experience the benefits of color anyway.

Remember we are talking about MSNBC here;
What passes for "tech" on MSNBC is like what passes for "reporting" on MSNBC.
There's a somewhat tenuous connection to reality at that organization.
 
Football should only be seen in high def. To actually be able to see the texture of the turf is a thing of beauty I tell ya.

Yeah. Sports are great on HD. Golf is amazing.

Still, I don't give a fuk about HD otherwise. Unless I'm watching sports, I don't care about it.
 
based on all your repsonse i'm not even going to read the article, I think it will kill some of my brain cells.

I recently did the jump to a HDTV last year 46` 1080p Samsung 120hz and I won't go back to SD. My provider gave me a HDbox for free and I get about 30HD channels. While its true SD looks like crap on the LCD, I didn't buy it to watch SD crap.

After watching HDNET and shows like Infocus, or National geographic in HD it was worth the money I paid. As for Sports, watching them in SD for me is like looking through a dirty mirror. And if you want to make a quick buck, whenever there is sporting events you charge per head lol. 5 bucks per person for a UFC event, eveyone get to bring there own beer and not pay Bar prices and in the comfort of a house!!!!

Some of the post you guys made are valid points. And the guy with the mitsu tv, I use to work for them. Some of the best picture quality I ever saw was from a mitsu, its to bad they no longer sell them in canada where I live. Tho DLP's still have their issues, picture quality was never one.

Why do they let tools like this write articles about subjects they know nothing about, its like the guy running the hot dog stand telling a doctor how to administer medication.
 
I buy my HDMI cables online for $6-$12 plus free shipping, As for seeing the flaws in a person's face... Everyone has thsoe like he is just so perfect. My gripes about HD is that the HD DVR box I have from Cablevision has issues and my girlfriend who has the same box at her hosue has the same problems. There are sound synching issues. you may loose sound for no reason as well. When you record to channels at once and try deleting one you may end up accidently deleting them both. Scientific Atlanta makes these boxes owned by Cisco. But that is more of cablevision giving cheap flawed equipment. I love My HDTV. I cannot wait untuil all programming is in HD and 1080P becomes the standard. We do need more standards for how sound and picture is encoded. And how non HD sources are upsampled.

As for the wide screen issue my TV usually Adjusts on its own. I have a Sony 32inch XBR6. 1080P set.

I love HDTV, They keep adding moree programming which makes it difficult to keep track of all the channels moving around but I still love Watching Hosue and Lost nd all my favorite shwos in HD.
 
I bought like a 900 foot long cable for $10, it works perfectly.
It's nice and wrapped in some kind of mesh sleeve for some reason, and it has so much slack left over it coils about a million times on it's way from my cable box to TV.

I probably could have got it even cheaper yet if I bought it online. Laff, $90 cables.
I had to restart my cable box once I switched to HDMI though. The cable guy that connected everything was apparently too retarded to get it to work himself, so he just used component. 5 minutes of waiting for the box to restart later... bam HDMI worked fine.


On HD feeds, the picture on the left in the article looks like shit because it's from a recording, this happens all the time on news stations. The live feeds are usually crystal fucking clear and then they play back something and it looks like ass.

My TV can blow up the picture to avoid black bars if you really want, though it can damage the quality of the picture, obviously. Almost every fucking channel has an HD equivalent for us though, so it's rare that you'll ever see them.

And who fucking doesn't like the fact that you can see more detail? My parents were like "holy shit, I can see individual hairs", and from that moment on were cemented on HD greatness.

I went through calibration, but my TV already came about as close to optimal as it could hope to get. The presets were pretty close to perfect.



Article is retarded, all it's good for is potentially scaring grandmas and hilariously un-tech savvy people who are convinced one little error in their operations will break or make the thing explode in a fireball.
 
This is what I posted as a comment on the article:

This article is insanely ridiculous. I mean, the only point you have here is that some HD is excellent and some of it is poor quality. But seriously, you try to make a con on HDTV's part because of having to calibrate the monitor? Come on now; if you want ANY monitor to display true colors, then you'll have to calibrate it - weather it's HD or not, and you'd better forget about those $20 DVD's. If you want true-so-spec image quality, then be prepared to pay hundreds of dollars for a qualified technician to tweak settings, weather your set is HD or not.

Tweaking the set’s color, contrast and brightness is advised because often the picture you see on a set in a store is different than the one you’ll get in your own home.

Are you serious? You say that so condescendingly, as if the display model will be of higher quality than the model you'll actually get. Stores normally have brightness and contrast cranked up on monitors so the image is more attention grabbing to customers.

Next, HDMI cables. Yes, stores like Best Buy depend on unwitting customers to spend money on accessories like HDMI cables, but where your article fails is where you totally miss what the problem is. The problem isn't that Best Buy sells $100 HDMI cables; the problem is this article itself. You fail to explain that HDMI cables can be had for around $5 from online retailers such as Monoprice, or at other low prices from etailers like Tigerdirect or Newegg. You fail to give any actual help. What kind of advice is "get an SD monitor"? Not only are they scarce, but they're no longer cost-effective. They're also dirty technology - not safe for the environment with all of the lead-based material that makes up CRT (tube) TV's. Also, most standard definition TV's don't accept digital signals, meaning that on top of the TV, you'd have to buy a set-top box for over the air signals, which could set you back an addition $100 or more.

Also, what about Blu-Ray players, or video game consoles? Those output in up to 1080p resolution and can only play HD material on HDTV's. There's absolutely no point in using these units on standard definition TV's. If you want to watch movies in standard definition, then just skip the Blu-Ray player and go back to your old, dusty DVD player. See, there are more reasons to get an HDTV than just watching HD cable.

This is one of the worst, most uninformative and MISINFORMATIVE articles that I have ever read regarding HDTV's, or pretty much ANYTHING. This writer needs to seriously check facts and maybe gain a little actual experience in the field of HD monitors and technology before he spouts another BS article like this.
 
^ Good reply, "HeartAttack". :cool:

Also, LOL @ one guy who wrote: "The suckage factor of this article was amazing."
 
I would also like to be the fifteen-hundredth person to say that this article was effing stupid. The only thing to hate about HD televisions is not knowing WTF you're doing with it. I've got a 52" and a 32" HDTV and both look great on HD and SD channels because I know what the hell I'm doing with the television.

They got a person that buys a piece of electronic equipment and expects it to work right out of the box and had him write an article. He should review toaster next.
 
I still have a SONY CRT in my bedroom to play PS2 on when I feel like it. PS2 and other SD things do look better on a good SD CRT than on a HD LCD. The calibration thing is also not just for HDTV it's just that people didn't know about calibrating before.

A good CRT is still unmatched in black levels. Both my LCD and CRT are SONY, both cost about $800 when new and the 6 year old CRT is light-years ahead of the 1 year old LCD when it comes to black levels. I would still never use a SD TV as a main TV because the higher resolution of HD is really great and it's much more pleasant to watch a LCD than a CRT with it's eye-straining interlacing.
 
Article's bottom line: we shouldn't have to pay, learn, or change anything to get moving pictures in our face.

"I'm a woman, how can any of this possibly matter to people? You're spending money to challenge your manual-reading skills as well as patience. All for a better picture that you're not supposed to appreciate because either I say so or claim the networks won't let you. HDTV is a scam to get you to spend money, it couldn't possibly just be the same idea as computer monitors only much larger. Connecting your computer isn't an option either, because in the 1970's no one did it, so today we aren't supposed to either. Computers can't do video, they can only do myspace and youtube."
 
I contacted the publication itself about how idiotic the article is. I've never done that before...that's how stupid I find this article.
 
I contacted the publication itself about how idiotic the article is. I've never done that before...that's how stupid I find this article.

What contact information did you use? I can't seem to find anything for contacting a publisher of MSNBC.com itself.
 
I'll condense it to one: it's way more expensive for the exact same content. More pixels do not cost more to distribute.
 
What contact information did you use? I can't seem to find anything for contacting a publisher of MSNBC.com itself.

I dunno...I just clicked "contact us" where the "contact us" button is usually located on websites lol.
 
Top 5 reasons to hate having a nose:

1) It gets itchy sometimes

2) It makes mucus, which is gross

3) Sometimes I have to get rid of hair that grows out of it

4) Sneezing

5) That guy over there stinks

I think I could write for MSNBC, I'm sure I could flesh those out!
 
fuck SDTV....there's been enough time for people to adapt, and there's even been vouchers to make buying an adaptor for SDTV sets affordable.

HD over the air, now....fuck the rest.
 
This guy's lame, instead of b***hing about how HD has all these flaws, I'd have a grain of respect for him if he mentioned HD hasn't fixed many of these flaws that have been around for ages.

. Have you ever looked at the back of a recent SDTV, White, red, yellow, silver, OMG all these plugs! My my my I just have to buy em all or it's the end of the world and I'm going back to rabbit ears!

. Since when have you seen all SDTVs be perfectly calibrated?
. Have you ever seen black bars on SDTVs?
. Do all stations looks equally good in SD?

Freaking lame, though some things should have been worked on. Widescreen formats should have been ironed out a bit more, movie makers, stop trying to make a wider and wider format would you!
 
Meh, I cannot stand idiots like that. I bet he is still watching that 26" Magnavox that he bought back in 1989...
 
Meh, I cannot stand idiots like that. I bet he is still watching that 26" Magnavox that he bought back in 1989...

The writer is a "she", which probably explains why it's such a crappy article about tech. Relax people, I'm j/k! :p
 
Back
Top