First time build. Any problems with this?

north1

n00b
Joined
Apr 4, 2004
Messages
48
I'd really like to know if there are any compatibility problems with bus speeds, memory, power, cooling and such. It won't be overclocked or used for gaming but will do a lot of video encoding and editing. Lots of Photoshop work with RAW images from cameras too. Cost is a major issue -- don't want to go any higher than the totals below. Also, quiet/cool is a big plus. Win XP pro for OS.

CPU: Intel E6750 194.00

MB: MSI P6N SLI Platinum 149.99

RAM: Patriot 2 X 1GB DDR2 800 PC2 6400 118.99 (-45 rebate)

VIDEO: MSI NX7600GS-T2D256E 78.99

VIDEO CAP/TV: AVerMedia M780 (AverTV Combo) 89.95

PSU: Zalman ZM450b 89.95

I'll be using an existing case, DVD-RW, and 3 hard drives, 2 of which are PATA, so that's why I went with the MSI board. I couldn't find any P35 or G33 boards with more than one ide connector.

Since there's no gaming, the vid card just needs to be something decent that doesn't produce a lot of noise and heat. The NX7600GS seemed like a good compromise, especially with the two DVIs.

I know very little about RAM other than to look for DDR2 800 PC2 6400 with lower timings, so I just relied on reviews at Newegg. Most of the RAM discussion is oriented toward overclocking, but I'd still like to do the best I can even without OC. Also considered OCZ and A-DATA.

For PSU, also considered a Corsair 520HX but not sure if it's needed or worth the extra $. Modular connections are nice though.
 
If you can afford to go Quad Core, I would. That would definitely be your best bang for the buck. Same applies to encoding and such. Multithreading actually helps in this case. Yes it is nearly $100 more. So you might want to check your budget.

I'd consider the Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3R for a motherboard especially at $129 you can't go wrong. **argh, didn't see that line in regards to the harddrive issues.
 
I'm already pushing it about as far as I can. Originally I was thinking about the E4300, to save $$, but after 7/22 decided that the E6750 was so much better that it would be worth the extra $70, but that's really the financial limit.
 
Since you are using IDE drives, stay away from intel chipset boards. There is no native support on those for IDE anyway. Cable management is easier with a modular powersupply. As for the tv tuner, my pick would be SAPPHIRE Radeon Theatrix 650 PRO on newegg for $65.
 
A PCI IDE controller card should be <$15. You could also transfer those IDE devices to external enclosures... thats what I did with mine. I use them as backup media, now. I don't like the MSI BIOS... I guess I'm just spoiled by DFI's and Gigabyte's. The Patriot sticks are cheaper at frys.com I believe (no rebate; two individual sticks are 40 each, the kit is 90). The 7600GS is overpriced. You should be able to find a GT for $80AR. Oh, you're not gaming. Go for a $35 vidcard then, like the X1550 or something.
 
MSI P6N SLI Platinum is the best 650i chipset board on the market right now. On the intel motherboard forum. It is now on page 89... As the guy posted he has no plans for overclocking and is on limited budget.
 
lt_shiro:

Yeah, I had noticed no Intel boards ever came up when PATA was specified in the search. As far as I can tell, the MSI is a pretty good one. I just need to know if everything else is compatible and good quality for the money.

As for the capture/tuner card, that's been the biggest headache so far. I even have a separate thread on it but no one seems to know about the 2 requirements that are most important for me. I really want to be able to capture uncompressed/huffyuv video from the composite output of a VCR by using Virtualdub -- meaning the card's hardware encoder must be bypassed. And when using the hardware encoder I want to be able to choose the bitrate. Even reviews of the cards don't mention these things. I did eliminate Hauppauge cards because they require you to use the hardware encoder.

enginurd:

Would I really want to attach the OS hard drive to a PCI IDE controller? Is the MSI BIOS an issue if you don't overclock? As long as it's OK at stock speeds it's good for me. I do like the fanless X1550, just wish it had the extra DVI.
 
My opinion on the BIOS was simply personal preference. It was mainly to let you know you don't get all the overclocking options as you would in a DFI or Gigabyte board. If you're not overclocking, then, of course, this wouldn't bother you. These core2 chips are so easy to OC, I just assumed you would OC, even if it were a tiny bit. Even so, the BIOS is fine for any OC'ing, really, lol. I just prefer the other brands. I actually picked up a P6N to play with, and thats just one of the things I noticed about it that nobody mentioned to me before.

No, you wouldn't want to attach the OS drive to a PCI controller. However, since you have a SATA drive, it would be best to use that as the OS drive, and keep the PATA drives as additional storage.
 
Are there any issues with the Patriot RAM in this setup? I noticed the voltage was listed at 2.2, which seems pretty high. The G.SKILL has the same 4-4-4-12 timings but only 1.9-2.0 voltage. Is this better? Actually, I had originally planned to go with 1.8v A-DATA sticks with 5-5-5-18 timings, but assumed that meant they were too slow. So what's more important in a non-overclocked system, getting lower timings or lower voltage?

The OCZ Titanium is a very good deal right now at Newegg but the customer reviews are bad.
 
OK thanks, those do seem like good specs for the price. It's just that I know so little about memory and was put off by some of the problems I've read about. It seems every RAM pair out there is problematic for some people. One guy says it won't work with his P6N SLI, 2 more say it's working fine in theirs.

Other than the capture card then, the only thing I'm still a little unsure about is the power supply. After searching through the forums, there's a lot of people wanting/suggesting the Corsair 520HX, so it's starting to make me wonder if the Zalman is a poorer choice. As I understand it, Corsairs are made by Seasonic and Zalmans are made by FSB. I read 2 lab tests (Corsair, Zalman) where concerns were raised about the Corsair's lack of "over current protection" and buzzing noises, and the Zalman's +5V being "somewhat unstable but in the green zone" but I don't know how significant any of that is.
 
Seasonic make some of the best quality power supplies out there. And from what I remember, the Corsair power supplies are Seasonic PSUs that have gone through even more rigorous testing for quality. The buzzing noise in jonnyguru's review was actually just isolated to his 520HX, not the general population of the 520HX if I remember correctly.

This is a somewhat biased recommendation considering I own a 520HX but I say get the 520HX. It's quiet and comes with a five year warranty. Plus I think it looks better :)

Corsair HX520 520W PSU - $100
 
Thanks. The Corsairs do seem to get a lot of love around here. I just read a thread about the 520HX and it's pretty unanimous. I wanted modular connections anyway, so I guess that settles it. Dunno about buy.com though. A great price but worry about their bad feedback. Maybe zipzoomfly for $105.
 
Thanks. The Corsairs do seem to get a lot of love around here. I just read a thread about the 520HX and it's pretty unanimous. I wanted modular connections anyway, so I guess that settles it. Dunno about buy.com though. A great price but worry about their bad feedback. Maybe zipzoomfly for $105.

Whoever puts you at ease. I bought my 520HX from ZZF.com for $113 with tax. And zipzoomfly.com packages their items pretty damn well.
 
You won't notice the difference between 5-5-5-15 and 4-4-4-12 in normal everyday usage. The tighter timings aren't worth any price premium, imo. You'll only see the difference in benchmarks.
 
Well that makes it easier. The 1.8v 5-5-5-18 A-DATA actually seemed to have fewer complaints from users than most of the faster memory. If the speed difference isn't significant, I'd prefer whatever's most stable/reliable.
 
Well that makes it easier. The 1.8v 5-5-5-18 A-DATA actually seemed to have fewer complaints from users than most of the faster memory. If the speed difference isn't significant, I'd prefer whatever's most stable/reliable.

A-DATA is one of the largest manufacturers of memory, so they made their sticks compliant with Intel's official support for DDR2 (1.8v, 5-5-5-15). Those are the specs to look for when taking stability/reliability into account. Though, most newer boards support the high voltage Micron chips now anyways, so it doesn't matter as much.
 
Back
Top