First htpc & using spare parts

fourty03

n00b
Joined
Feb 14, 2011
Messages
18
Hello all,

I hope someone can give me some feedback regarding using parts that I have accumulated over the years, in making a htpc. I've got the basics down, and just need some advice.

I have two platforms in which I could base the htpc from. I can either use:

System 1:
AMD Athlon 250 x2 3.2ghz
Biostar 785g
2gb OCZ DDR3
Sapphire 4650

System 2:
Dell Pentium 4 @ 3.2ghz
2gb RAM
Sapphire 4650

I have 3 4650's laying around, and it has an HDMI port, and both motherboards do not have HDMI.

I also bought a Corsair V32 32gb SSD for use with this system (I am unsure if I should use it to boot or use it as a hot swap drive to transfer movies or anything else on the go).

I also have 2 80gb IDE drives that I could throw in the works. I would like to use the HDMI sound, but I do also have a "y" splitter cable which has the 3.5mm to rca for sound.


Should I use the SSD has the boot? The htpc will be booted probably once a week or less, and it will be sleeping most of the time, so once the programs are in memory, will the SSD be beneficial as a boot drive? I do plan on getting mass storage in the near future (3tb+),
just not at this time.
I was thinking if the SSD will not be beneficial, then I can throw it in my current system I am using.

Thanks!
 
Maybe I should ask, what would be the disavantages using the P4 system? I wanted to build my nephew a desktop with the parts that I do not use (he's only 5).
Thanks again!
 
The only real disadvantage to using the P4 is heat. I wouldn't use it for an HTPC personally. The first list of parts would work great. I will point out that if you want to watch Blu Rays that video card will not decode the loss less codecs.
 
The only real disadvantage to using the P4 is heat. I wouldn't use it for an HTPC personally. The first list of parts would work great. I will point out that if you want to watch Blu Rays that video card will not decode the loss less codecs.

The 4650 will not bitstream the HD audio, however it will send the HD audio as uncompressed PCM over HDMI. Many feel it sounds identical to bitstreaming the HD, however it will not light up the pretty True HD, or DTS-HD Master lights on your receiver. ;)
 
I tried using a 3.4Ghz P4 for my HTPC and it did ok for regular DVD's, but could not handle BD's at all. Not even close. It also could not handle full screen flash (such as hulu) worth a crap. It was just bad enough to be really annoying.

Now I use a AMD system with a 785g motherboard (MSI) and I use the onboard video without any issues at all. Hopfully your Biostar has onboard HDMI and you wont even need the 4650.
 
I have the Biostar 785g mtx board.

It has DVI and VGA . I could search in my spare parts bin to see if I have a DVI - HDMI converter, but I will lose audio over HDMI ..

I suppose this question comes up a lot, and could be pointless, but should I even use the 32gb ssd in this build as the boot drive? At first, since I am just starting out, I was figuring that I could easily transfer files from one system to the other via the SSD (hot swap)..

I mean, dont get me wrong, I would like to throw the SSD in my main system (I have 2 already), and installing apps and games fill them up pretty quick.

Thanks for the feedback everyone
 
The only real disadvantage to using the P4 is heat. I wouldn't use it for an HTPC personally. The first list of parts would work great. I will point out that if you want to watch Blu Rays that video card will not decode the loss less codecs.

Heat and efficiency. The Athlon 250 while being a dual core is just plain faster.

The only use of an old P4 is as a file server/WHS.
 
I have the Biostar 785g mtx board.

It has DVI and VGA . I could search in my spare parts bin to see if I have a DVI - HDMI converter, but I will lose audio over HDMI ..
Actually you might not. Some motherboards provided audio via the DVI port when a DVI to HDMI adapter is used.

I
I suppose this question comes up a lot, and could be pointless, but should I even use the 32gb ssd in this build as the boot drive? At first, since I am just starting out, I was figuring that I could easily transfer files from one system to the other via the SSD (hot swap)..

I mean, dont get me wrong, I would like to throw the SSD in my main system (I have 2 already), and installing apps and games fill them up pretty quick.

Thanks for the feedback everyone

It's overkill but if it's a spare SSD, might as well use it.
 
Back
Top