unhappy_mage said:This. Hard drives don't spontaneously make gouges in themselves. And the fact that the motor controller is what burned out is what makes me suspicious of your whole setup. Sorry.
Agreed. I had a maxtor drive that had a head crash. I took it out and ended up showing a couple of friends the nice noises it was making. After about 15-20 seconds that same chip melted down. The motor control chip on those maxtors run crazy hot. All it takes is a little extra friction on the platters and it will have a nice little meltdown. A head crash is more than enough to cause it.
So back to dracos. You had a nice head crash, the motor controller overheated and went poof. These things happen, and people need to get off dracos' ass about it. A head crash does not equal bad treatment. Hard drives can have manufacturing defects like any other product.
The problem I have is that you can in no way compare it to the whole Dell/Apple/Sony battery problem. The laptop battery burn much longer, are extremely hot and can do things like burn your house down. These are all very good reasons to have a recall and be worried. However when a maxtor drive melts down like this, 99.9% of the time it is going to be sitting inside of a metal case and the flames only last a few seconds. There is no real worry that this small fire will disfigure someone or burn their house down, like a laptop battery can. So I say just take out the Dell references and I have no problem with your article.