File-Sharing Heroine is a Copyright Hypocrite

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Say it isn’t so!?! Musicians don’t like their music being ripped off but have no problem ripping off someone else's work? I am in shock! Dumbfounded! Flabbergasted! Yada, yada, yada.

The war against file-sharing has found a new figure-head. After she wrote an interesting post on MySpace, singer Lilly Allen’s words have been relayed around the world – she has even started a new blog where many artists are supporting her. But what if the new face of anti-piracy was just as bad as those she criticizes?
 
Of course. They're all hipocrites. I'm not ashamed of the fact I pirate music: I support (via CDs, merch, tours, etc.) the artists I like, and I delete (i.e. don't continue to share) those I don't. As 50Cent said, it's now part of the marketing of music. Gone are the days of the '90's where you could prepackage shit and expect to sell it en masse. We have more discerning listeners who are more likely to pirate the music to check it out first, and if they don't like it, they won't buy it. I can see why those who are/were riding high on that methodology are getting pissed off.
 
Funny article, although when reading the actual blog post it looks more like she tried to quote him but didn't put in a citation.
 
Addendum: But that doesn't change the fact that the new Internet creates a different arena, and it's time to work with it instead of continuing to demonize it. How many years has it been since Napster and filesharing is still going strong?
 
I'm with djBon2112 on this point. I buy CDs and DVDs still. But, I now no longer buy music or movies that SUCK BUNGHOLE because I can try it out, in entirety, before buying it. So if the whole album sucks, but the one song of it being played on the radio is the only good song on the album, I don't end up buying the album and delete the whole thing.

There is not a single MP3 on my archive that isn't legitimately backed up by the original CD. Oftentimes, I don't even unwrap the CD itself and keep it in mint condition for my collection while still enjoying the songs off of it.

Since I payed for every single song I own, I DARE the MF's to give me any grief over my method. I think I'll be in good standing to tell them where to shove their whining.
 
Funny article, although when reading the actual blog post it looks more like she tried to quote him but didn't put in a citation.

What a coincidence; That's exactly what I was trying to do when I posted her songs on-line for others to download.
 
if piracy is so bad then why are people still making millions off of music/movies/etc? /boggle
 
Funny article, although when reading the actual blog post it looks more like she tried to quote him but didn't put in a citation.

I am thinking that also, since it would be absolutely foolish for her to copy it all. She could not have gotten this far at that level of stupid.

I am wondering how she is going to respond, or if at all.
 
I'm with djBon2112 on this point. I buy CDs and DVDs still. But, I now no longer buy music or movies that SUCK BUNGHOLE because I can try it out, in entirety, before buying it. So if the whole album sucks, but the one song of it being played on the radio is the only good song on the album, I don't end up buying the album and delete the whole thing.

There is not a single MP3 on my archive that isn't legitimately backed up by the original CD. Oftentimes, I don't even unwrap the CD itself and keep it in mint condition for my collection while still enjoying the songs off of it.

Since I payed for every single song I own, I DARE the MF's to give me any grief over my method. I think I'll be in good standing to tell them where to shove their whining.

I like this guy...

This is exactly the mentality and attitude I've attempted to instill in countless people, but, too many are selfish, greedy little bastards that don't have enough within themselves to understand respect.

As a well-known musician of 22 years and someone who runs (and has run a few) independent labels and been involved in the "business end" of the industry for the last twelve years, I can honestly say that I'm fine with this mentality.

I myself do the very same thing. If anything, it's a good thing to be able to save money by hearing for yourself what you might or might not like personally. As opposed to the old days of having to walk into a record shop and take a gamble at buying albums you might end up hating.

All I've ever said was: "if you like it, buy it!", and support the band/labels, because it costs money to press shit; it ain't free. I'm not about the money, just simply breaking even is fine with me, just so I can release more music.

But, see... that's where the hypocrites come in: the one's who whine, are the ones who are not about the music, which I and some others are. They're the ones who want to see a profit, and that's just not likely to happen and not why you should be playing music in the first place.

There are a few like me, who are very high on principal, who cannot stand piracy because of selfish shit-heads who feel "entitled" to everything under the sun (music, games, movies etc.) and want everything for free. So, those who raise a ruckus out of principal, that's a good thing... people need to learn to have some honor and respect.

Otherwise, to those who "try before they buy", that's fine with me... as long as they buy it if they like what they hear.
 
I LOVE how once this got published on torrent freak (and I'm sure HardOCP's post helped too) everyone and their mother got on her blog and bashed her to no end
 
The whole blog(not just the one post) is plagiarism. Every argument presented has been presented before, and it's as if she's specifically choosing the worst ones!

People lose their jobs over piracy? Sure, just like people die from smoking pot.

Free (illegal) music prevents new forms of distribution from becoming successful? Fuck you, iTunes, you're not successful even if your bottom line says you are!

Girl needs to stick to writing music.
 
iTunes is successful, to think otherwise is ... i dont know.. ....their bottom line wouldnt be so high if it wasnt successful.


Since I payed for every single song I own, I DARE the MF's to give me any grief over my method. I think I'll be in good standing to tell them where to shove their whining.

Too bad, pending on the law and where you live, that wont hold up in court, you dont own anything, you bought a license to play those songs basically.

It sucks arse really, i hate this direction the world is going in that you pay for a license to use something, soon when you buy that new car, you wont own it, you will be licensed to drive it.


Piracy doesnt prevent anything as you said Spewn, problem is the record, movie industry has their heads so far up their butts, and stuck in the days of selling CD's for $20 with 1 good song, they cant move on to better distribution methods, meanwhile all of the smart bands realize they dont need the RIAA anymore and can release their own music on the net.
 
Looks like she is nothing more than just a bonehead that doesn't know how to work the internet and couldn't figure out how to use quote tags.
 
I like this guy...

This is exactly the mentality and attitude I've attempted to instill in countless people, but, too many are selfish, greedy little bastards that don't have enough within themselves to understand respect.

As a well-known musician of 22 years and someone who runs (and has run a few) independent labels and been involved in the "business end" of the industry for the last twelve years, I can honestly say that I'm fine with this mentality.

I myself do the very same thing. If anything, it's a good thing to be able to save money by hearing for yourself what you might or might not like personally. As opposed to the old days of having to walk into a record shop and take a gamble at buying albums you might end up hating.

All I've ever said was: "if you like it, buy it!", and support the band/labels, because it costs money to press shit; it ain't free. I'm not about the money, just simply breaking even is fine with me, just so I can release more music.

But, see... that's where the hypocrites come in: the one's who whine, are the ones who are not about the music, which I and some others are. They're the ones who want to see a profit, and that's just not likely to happen and not why you should be playing music in the first place.

There are a few like me, who are very high on principal, who cannot stand piracy because of selfish shit-heads who feel "entitled" to everything under the sun (music, games, movies etc.) and want everything for free. So, those who raise a ruckus out of principal, that's a good thing... people need to learn to have some honor and respect.

Otherwise, to those who "try before they buy", that's fine with me... as long as they buy it if they like what they hear.


Chad?:confused::cool:
 
Back
Top