Feedback / Recommendation for prospective buyer

Mangaroo

n00b
Joined
Aug 19, 2008
Messages
63
EDIT: sorted most of this out, skip to post #6/7

Hey guys, im currently on a macbook (and hence have not registered up until now, but i've been a long time reader, folks at the irc channel convinced me to post (and subscribe with the craglist sex story :D) - and after realising i cant even try the bloody spore creature creator trial on it, i've flipped, come to my senses and decided not to wait for the mac pro Nehalem revision and just get a rig now.

Half the reason i wanted a mac pro was because of its low noise levels. So with everything im buying, im taking into consideration noise levels.

Reasons to buy now VS later (Nehalem) (mostly from what i've learnt from searching the forums):

*i hear nehalem will be expensive at early release
*consumer cpus wont be available for a while also (not sure of the time scale)
*Nehalem mobos will go through a few revisions before being optimum (taking a few months i take it)

*I will be gaming a bit - mostly COD4/UT3/Battlefield 2 (and 3 when it arrives) and Starcraft 2 at high resolutions 1920/2560. I'll be photoshopping lightrooming for around 2 hours a day, so i don't think the performance gain will have such a significant affect on me - but i could be wrong, and would appreciate some feedback
*I've been on this POS for too long!

Now bearing those above needs in mind, that i saved up quite a bit for the mac pro already and the fact that I am hoping my system will be nowhere near obsolete (for my uses) for the next 2-3 years (or until the Sandy Bridge dye shrink) these are the product parts I am planning on getting:

1) CPU - Intel Core 2 Quad Q9550, Yorkfield Core, S775, 2.83 GHz, 1333MHz, 12MB L2 Cache

2) Memory - Need more of your advice:
I) I don't want to have to upgrade memory again when i upgrade again, so was thinking of getting DDR3 - But i don't know if i am actually going to be getting a significant improvement over DDR2?
II) I heard from someone on the hard forum's unofficial IRC channel that the ram speed should match that of the CPU's Bus Speed (which at the current CPU i have my eye on is 1333MHz). I will not be overclocking - is there any advantage to getting faster RAM?
III) Should I get 4 x 2GB sticks or 8 x 1GB sticks (forget pricing advantages) - but for a core 2 quad core what would be the optimum configuration, and how much of a difference will it make?

Seeing as I don't really know the answers to the above, i've found 3 suitable (i think) memory options:

(4x2GB) CorsairTwinX XMS3, DDR3 PC3-10600 (1333MHz), 240 Pin, Unbuffered, CAS 9-9-9-24, DHX
(8x1GB) SuperTalent DDR3 PC3-10600 (1333MHz), 240 Pin, Non-ECC, Unbuffered, CAS 8-8-8-18

3) I'm not sure of what motherboard would suit all these needs (so im holding off looking for one until i really know what i am going to need, although i would like to future proof (2-3years) it as much as possible) - i know mac pros have 8 slots for memory which is why i've given myself this option. Oherwise i'll probably go for DDR2/3 1333/1600 MHz 2 GB sticks

4) Im thinking of getting a PSU that has the following:
very quiet, supports max hard drive slots being used, supports all PCI slots being in use + full USB/firewire connections, very quiet, gives me the opportunity should i want it to power another GFX card in either SLI or crossfire - and did i say quiet? But i dont want to go so much over the top when i wont be using its power 99% of the time for economical reasons - although i dont know how significant that would be! Possibly: Thermaltake ToughPower 1200W

5) Hard drives - was thinking of going 2x 500GB 7200 rpm SATA II, one for photos & music, and one for downloads. And i was thinking about going velicoraptor 10,000 rpm - but i dont know about these for sound/reliability/availability in the uk or even about 150gb vs 300 gb - so will probably decide on that later, but i would like my motherboard to be able to support 4 hard drives if i ever wanted to expand. I will also need to research which ones produce the lowest heat and are the quietest

6) Sound card - i know that a lot of motherboards come with soundcards but im not sure if i want to get an external. I currently use my soundsticks 2 (harmon kardon) and very easy to drive headphones ( ATH-AD700 ). I would like the possibility of going 5.1 +. I'm thinking about the Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Titanium Fatal1ty Pro Series, PCI-Express Sound card however i think i read on some forums a while ago that a lot of people were having problems - but their flash demo sounds awesome! I guess this can always be purchased later

7) Graphics card - alright my monitor is currently a 24" Dell. I'm planning on boosting that up to either the new Apple cinema display 30" or whatever dell has at 30" when the new ACDs are released, so im going to need a bit of a beast unfortunately. Open to recommendations, i'll restate all the games i intend to play (mainly at 1920 or 2560 resolution)

Call of duty 4
half life 1/2 + mods (cs etc)
UT3
Wacraft 3
Starcraft 2
Battlefield 2 & 3
the upcoming new crysis

So bearing in mind i need some hardcore performers to not have to upgrade when battlefield 3 comes out..But i also want silence! Price wise, the GTX 280 is sort of out of bounds really.. i could just about purchase the GTX 260 on a drunken low night but i need the power :(. If i was to get the 4870 now, would it be possible to get another by the time battlefield 3 comes out? I don't know about the whole pins and bobs thing for the power supply..and the whole 16x PCI slots?

8) Blu ray writer, and a dvd writer - not in a rush really for the bluray writer. And i shouldnt have too much trouble finding my own but if someone really has an astounding recommendation or would like to comment then it would be much appreciated

9) Case! i have no idea, i want it to look sleek not too many different coloured lights, be able to accommodate all this. Im not sure that i want fans etc becuase of the reason below:

Now if you thought i was pretty clueless:

The sound proofing part. Ok so i would have purchased parts that are as quiet as i can without sacrificing too much in terms of power and efficiency but for true silence, i figured id experiment and try out watercooling.

Again, i don't plan on overclocking, at least, not in the near future at all.

Also problem with that i know a lot of gpus come with some sort of special fan and i dont want to pay a premium for that fan if im just going to remove it, you know?

Anyway, at first i was considering the RESERATOR v2 from Zalman, but after a few negative posts about it failing and its pump not being strong enough im considering the RESERATOR XT although it is pretty expensive, and it isnt as quiet, but if it does the job..i maybe willing to bite.

Also any other recommendations to make it silent? Im planning to use the watercooler to cool the CPU and GPU and maybe memory

Thank you very much for reading, any help is much appreciated for any of the parts at all!

Summary: I would like any recommendations or feedback/comments with any of the parts i am planning on purchasing, or any thoughts about my own reasoning for purchasing now.

I've basically listed out all the system parts i am considering getting and my thoughts around them and would like the pro's opinions!

Formatted to help jump to the key parts since its a huge post
 
That's too much for me to answer all at once. I'll focus on some of the general issues and let others take care of the rest.

Long story short on the memory issue is that your math is missing some figures. While you are correct that you should get RAM which speeds match the FSB speed of the processor, Intel's FSB speeds are "quad pumped" (listed at four times their actual value) and DDR2 RAM use "double data rate" (or, list their speeds as twice their actual value).

In other words:

Danny Bui said:
Stated FSB/4 = Actual FSB
Multiplier x Actual FSB = CPU Speed
1:1 Ratio: 2 x Actual FSB = RAM Speed
1:1 Ratio: FSB = 1/2 RAM speed

You won't need DDR3 RAM. There is no significant performance benefit from it over DDR2 RAM to justify its higher costs (especially with DDR2 at near-rock-bottom prices). Since you have no intention on overclocking, you could go with DDR2 800 RAM, which normally provides the best bang for your buck. (It has enough headroom for a modest overclocking session, should you decide to do it later on.) Most motherboards only have four RAM slots, so you'll need to purchase four 2GB sticks.

Since you have a 24 inch monitor, and you plan on migrating to a 30 inch monitor later, you should be looking for a multi-card setup. You should look for a motherboard with either the Intel X38 or X48 chipset and DDR2 RAM support (again, you don't need DDR3 RAM). These boards support dual x16 CrossFire (AMD/ATI's multi-card setup), which would allow you to play games on your 30 inch monitor with little to no trouble. Here are a few motherboards to consider (ignore the US prices; the links are provided as a reference):


With high-end video cards, the trade-off for performance is heat and noise. I recommend an HD4870 -- for your needs, you may be better off with the HD4870X2, but it's in the same price range as the GTX 280 -- but you may have to turn some settings down in certain games.

I'm not touching the subject of sound proofing. For one, it's very subjective -- two people can have varying differences about the noise coming from the exact same location. Additionally, you constantly referred to wanting both excellent performance and virtually silent operation. Unless you spend a lot of money -- and a custom water-cooling setup isn't cheap -- you'll have to make some compromises in one or both areas.

A few questions (so you could help others help you out further)...

- How much, at most, can you spend on this rig? Are shipping, VAT, and other charges included within that total?
- Where are you going to purchase everything at?
- In addition to gaming, what are you going to use this system for?
- Which features do you want on the motherboard?
- When were you planning on buying the 30 inch monitor?
- Have you check some of the other "help me build" threads (and/or the GenHard FAQ) for further ideas on which parts you should get?
 
A few questions (so you could help others help you out further)...

1- How much, at most, can you spend on this rig? Are shipping, VAT, and other charges included within that total?
2- Where are you going to purchase everything at?
3- In addition to gaming, what are you going to use this system for?
4- Which features do you want on the motherboard?
5- When were you planning on buying the 30 inch monitor?
6- Have you check some of the other "help me build" threads (and/or the GenHard FAQ) for further ideas on which parts you should get?

Thanks a lot tiraides, i know it was a huge post! i'll check out your recommendations now and to answer the questions

1 - At most (including shipping and VAT) i would say £1500 ($2,800) - since that is how much i would have spent on the mac pro with my higher education discount. This is probably excluding the sound card and bluray writer since I've decided to focus on getting a system as soon as possible and don't need those parts at the moment.

2 - I would probably purchase everything online, usually from sites like scan.co.uk and ebuyer.com

3 - I haven't gamed on a computer for about 3-4 years so im not sure how much i will be doing, but when i do i want it to be a great experience since i dont really have much free time with the course i am doing. I will be doing a lot of digital compositions in photoshop and painter.
In about a years time i will be also using it for photography (probably photoshop+lightroom).
Down the line (2 years) i will be getting back into 3d modelling.

4 - Features to be honest i have absolutely no idea. Apart from firewire, plenty of usb slots and for it to be able to support my components as well as be flexible with future upgrades (not cpu of course). Anything else is a bell and whistle i guess since i dont really know much about it. But if there is something important/significantly improve performance then of course i would love to have it :D

5 - I would love to dive in right now and purchase the Dell 30" but if i can hold out, it will be until around Jan 09 which is when apple is rumoured to release details of the new apple cinema display.

6 - I've been reading a few of the help me build threads which are recent and i am reading through the Faq now.

Thanks for your help again!
 
Some of the answers overlaps Tiraides' answers so yeah:

By the time you upgrade, faster and cheaper DDR3 RAM will be out. In addition, there is no guarantee that you would be able to use what DDR3 set you buy today in newer builds. Intel does have a history of dropping support for slower/older RAM speeds. So absolutely no reason to get DDR3 RAM now.

Since quiet is the main feature of this build, you should definitely check out this website:
http://www.silentpcreview.com/section13.html

PSU wise, let's determine that after we determine the rest of the parts.

As for the hard drives, if the Velociraptor drives aren't available or overpriced, this drive has been shown to be a very quiet and fast drive:
Western Digital WD6400AAKS 640GB 7200RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - $85

Well no one knows when BF3 comes out so cannot say whether or not you could get a HD4870 when it is finally released. If you can fit it into your budget, I concur with Tiraides' recommendation for the HD4870X2.

Also, a bit off-topic, but what's the address for the HardOCP's unofficial IRC channel? Never even heard of it before today.
 
Here's a quick prelim build:
Intel Core 2 Quad Q9450 CPU - £200
Gigabyte GA-X48-DS4 Intel X48 Motherboard - £140
2 x Kingston 2x2GB DDR2 800 RAM - £90
Gecube HD 4870X2 2GB GDDR5 - £327
2 x Western Digital WD6400AAKS 640GB 7200RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - £98
Antec P182 ATX Case - £90
Xigmatek HDT-S1283 120mm Rifle HSF - £23
Corsair 1000HX 1000W Modular PSU - £151
-----
Total: £1119 Inc VAT.

The Corsair 1000W PSU is complete overkill for your current system but since you want to fill up all your hard drive slots in addition for the possibility of getting a second HD4870X2 for some Crossfire action, I figured why not? :)

The Antec P182 is one of the quietest cases out there (in fact was partly designed by the owner of the website I linked to above). The Xigmatek HSF is also one of the quietest HSF out there, again shown by the site link in my last post.
 
Here's a quick prelim build:
Intel Core 2 Quad Q9450 CPU - £200
Gigabyte GA-X48-DS4 Intel X48 Motherboard - £140
2 x Kingston 2x2GB DDR2 800 RAM - £90
Gecube HD 4870X2 2GB GDDR5 - £327
2 x Western Digital WD6400AAKS 640GB 7200RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - £98
Antec P182 ATX Case - £90
Xigmatek HDT-S1283 120mm Rifle HSF - £23
Corsair 1000HX 1000W Modular PSU - £151
-----
Total: £1119 Inc VAT.

The Corsair 1000W PSU is complete overkill for your current system but since you want to fill up all your hard drive slots in addition for the possibility of getting a second HD4870X2 for some Crossfire action, I figured why not? :)

The Antec P182 is one of the quietest cases out there (in fact was partly designed by the owner of the website I linked to above). The Xigmatek HSF is also one of the quietest HSF out there, again shown by the site link in my last post.

for
fuck
sake!!

i spent the last 5 hours searching forums, reading faqs and questioning people (thanks PF and MatDef) on irc ( irc channel is #genmayhem on efnet ) ... and this is what we came up with

Antec P182
2x WD6400AAKS
Western Digital VelociRaptor WD3000GLFS
Corsair 1000W HX
Auzentech X-FI Prelude 7.1 Sound Card
ASUS Maximus Formula Republic of Gamers iX38 Socket 775 8 channel audio
Ati 4870x2
Intel Core 2 Quad Q9550 LGA775 'Yorkfield' 2.83GHz 12MB-cache (1333FSB)
4GB (2x2GB) Corsair XMS2, DDR2 PC2-6400 (800MHz), Unbuffered, CAS 4-4-4-12, DHX

basically the exact same system!

Thank you so much! though it just reinstills a lot of confidence into the purchase.

Ok just two things the motherboards really screwed me over in that i was basically lost with all the options...didnt think i needed x48 for any of my items? but for some reason my mobo is still more expensive

most importantly, the 4870x2. you have recommended the Gecube HD.

http://www.scan.co.uk/Index.aspx?NT=1-0-94-575-0

shows a few options, but i have no real idea how to choose between them? and would really appreciate much help!
 
shows a few options, but i have no real idea how to choose between them? and would really appreciate much help!

Click on the links I gave you. They all lead to British stores, not American. The GeCube should take you straight to ebuyer's link for the HD4870X2. Scan.co.uk doesn't have the HD4870X2 in stock yet.

Yeah, definitely similar systems that's for sure. But I'm willing to bet that my rig is cheaper and will provide about 98% of the performance of that IRC rig.

The X48 chipset is good to have since it will allow you to go Crossfire later on. The X48 chipset is pretty much a slightly faster version of the X38 chipset. That Asus mobo is more expensive since it's suppose to be highest of the high-end motherboard.
 
Back
Top