FBI To Gain Expanded Hacking Powers

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
While this may seem like bad news, we are still talking about the FBI here. You know, the people that couldn't hack an iPhone. Having the authority doesn't automatically give them the ability. :D

The changes will allow judges to issue warrants in cases when a suspect uses anonymizing technology to conceal the location of his or her computer or for an investigation into a network of hacked or infected computers, such as a botnet. Magistrate judges can currently only order searches within the jurisdiction of their court, which is typically limited to a few counties.
 
As long as they are still using the term hacking this much, probably nothing to worry about unless you are looking up child porn on windows ME.
 
Sadly, the initial attempts to delay/overturn prior to implementation has failed, but it is important to push on and attempt to have Rule 41 changes repealed and let Congress know that we object to the expansion of these sweeping powers and the threat to privacy and fair, due process their (mis)use can create.

If you want more information on this as well as why it is a problem, check out https://www.fightforthefuture.org/news/2016-11-29-urgent-the-fbi-cia-and-other-law-enforcement/ . Note that the EFF is against this as well - https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2016/...ess-time-debate-new-government-hacking-powers . This is a time to call your Senators and Representatives and encourage them you want to see this stopped, including support FOR the "Stopping Mass Hacking Act" - https://www.congress.gov/bill/114th-congress/house-bill/5321 - but if nothing else at least to support this bill delaying the implementation of the expanded privileges until July of next year, giving more time for legislation to be passed - https://www.congress.gov/bill/114th-congress/senate-bill/3475?q={"search":["coons"]}&r=1 - .

Overall this is yet another intrusive power-grab that further erodes the 4th amendment protections that have been violated repeatedly over the past 15 years, especially when computers / the Internet are involved.
 
Last edited:
I think having those abilities is okay as long as a warrant is properly issued for the use of them. Given the lack of physical borders on the internet, I think it is quite reasonable to expand the scope of hacking warrants provided that probable cause is justified.
 
I think having those abilities is okay as long as a warrant is properly issued for the use of them. Given the lack of physical borders on the internet, I think it is quite reasonable to expand the scope of hacking warrants provided that probable cause is justified.

Have you looked into it at all? Their probable cause under this is ANY computer running a VPN. In the WORLD. Not deven just the US. They now consider VPN use suspicious activity and any computer running a VPN would be fair game to be hacked and probed under this blanket warrant. Pretty much all education/medical systems, lots of business. Let alone all the people that just want to stay safe on the internet using the governments own suggestions to have safe browsing habits.

https://www.consumer.ftc.gov/articles/0014-tips-using-public-wi-fi-networks.

/tinfoil hat. So they have been advocating VPN use to stay safe while browsing on-line, for what? to build a bigger potential pool of computers that will allow them to spy easier under this blanket bullshit? This is seriously fucked up.
 
This is the same argument being made against Cash across the world: Cash is only used by Terrorists now, or people who are trying to HIDE something. You shouldn't be allowed to use cash, which cannot be easily tracked, and if you do...well, you're a suspicious individual...
 
I can promise all of you that Windows 10 has a built-in b4ck door that the gov3rnm3nt can easily access. The reason I am hiding k4y words that they prolly scan for.
 
I can promise all of you that Windows 10 has a built-in back door that the government can easily access. The reason I am hiding key words that they prolly scan for.

Wow, i bet they never thought to scan for words containing numbers that look similar to vowels. l33t sp34k y0

Also, FTFY just in case :p
 
This is just a formality. They probably already have a supercomputer running with AI hacking every computer as we speak.
 
This is the same argument being made against Cash across the world: Cash is only used by Terrorists now, or people who are trying to HIDE something. You shouldn't be allowed to use cash, which cannot be easily tracked, and if you do...well, you're a suspicious individual...
Um, they already have RFID chips inside each dollar bill produced. They already know how much you're carrying.

He added that such authority, which was approved by the Supreme Court in a private vote earlier this year, but was not subject to congressional approval, was especially troubling in the hands of an administration of President-elect Trump, a Republican who has "openly said he wants the power to hack his political opponents the same way Russia does."

Just exactly who was in that private voting session? Russia hacks political opponents? Which ones and whom? Sketchy article is sketchy.
 
This is just a formality. They probably already have a supercomputer running with AI hacking every computer as we speak.

Though I suspect hyperbole in your description, it is a good chance to remind everyone that there is a big difference between governments and private (mostly multinational corporate, banking etc) interests having the technical capability versus the legal justification! There are some entities, often government-directed but not always (and I think those that are not are even more pernicious), such as three-letter-agencies that may have the technical or operational capability to do all kinds of things; for the sake of clarity, I'll keep to electronic surveillance for this discussion. However, their use would be relatively rare, for fear of giving away or "using up" capabilities on adversaries that only REALLY warrant them, as well as avoiding any pitfalls regarding legalities and civil liberties. However, when you codify the use of these abilities legally, such as the Patriot Act, NDAA, use entities like FISA courts to provide wide-reaching, often secret warrants etc.. that's when the real problems start. What used to be used only in cases where it would absolutely seem justified becomes commonplace and spreads FAR beyond its original intentions/specifications, with civil liberties being the first casualty. For instance, the Patriot Act and methodology it covered for surveillance and intelligence gathering was intended to be used exclusively to stop immenent terrorist attacks. However, once the floodgates were opened we all matters of other less serious crimes, including and especially non violent drug sales on the Internet, prosecuted on evidence gathered entirely under these provisions! So it has gone with a ton of things in the past 15 years from drone-based assassinations, to cracking encryption, to a constant and encroaching war on privacy and much, much more. Lets not forget that governments are an easily identified target but aren't the only ones that work this way - private interests are no better (and that's aside from things like regulatory capture where private money controls government's direction and uses its might to accomplish their goals).

There was a time when such actions by governments were secrete rarities and corporate interests were indefensible, but when individual rights and the common good are cast by the wayside, these entities get a bit bolder each time. Once cloaked by a facade of legality they come out of the shadows and fearlessly tread on any supposed opposition unless advocates can weather the horrendous storm and try to restrict their moves again through legislation. Its a ponderous affair but part of the reason we must not permit any intrusion and must work to roll back the clock lest we lose privacy and many civil liberties forever, bit by bit.
 
"When we were colonists........................................................................................".





 
This is the same argument being made against Cash across the world: Cash is only used by Terrorists now, or people who are trying to HIDE something. You shouldn't be allowed to use cash, which cannot be easily tracked, and if you do...well, you're a suspicious individual...

Actually, your comment doesn't have a thing to do with this legislation, but you are not alone.

First off, "Anonymizing technology" is not a euphemism for VPN.

This legislation is based essentially on what happened around an FBI Operation known as "Pacifier" where the FBI seized a Child Porn Site's servers, used the system logs to identify users who were already actively downloading child porn, then ran the site for about two weeks so that when these guys came back they could infect their machines with malware in order to locate and identify who they were.

The site was already running, the FBI didn't create it. The users had already been visiting the site, the FBI knew which users(by their account activity) that they wanted to catch. But this is where things get tough, because the site used the TOR network they could just trace the traffic back to the machines, then get warrants for searches. Instead, they infected the computers with malware, (A NIT), so that the computers would report back, their identity and location. out of several visitors to that site during the two weeks, 187 were charged, some of those cases have been dropped or thrown out, I don't know of any convictions for sure, but I suspect that some have been convicted prior to the best legal defense approach being identified and used. That legal tactic is to challenge the FBI to reveal how the NIT works. I don't know why the FBI is so reticent to explain it but frankly I don't even see that it matters at all. The NIT didn't collect evidence of illegal activity, that was already present on the servers that were physically seized and confirmed during the repeat visits during the time the FBI operated the site. All the FBI lacked was identifying who was doing the crime.

Now this wasn't a fishing trip, those people accessed the site, accessed the illegal materials, and downloaded the NIT all on their own. And the idea that they FBI "entrapped" people doesn't stand up either because the server logs already had historic evidence of which users were the serious repeat kiddie porn junkies. The FBI just needed then to come back again to download the NIT so they could be located. And until they are located you can't find out where they are to get a proper warrant. So this is a catch 22 type of situation and the FBI wants new legislation that will provide a fix for this problem.

So let's be real here. If you guys can figure out another way to do it than be my guest, explain how to do it the right way. If the TOR network didn't work so well than the FBI wouldn't have to deploy a NIT in this manner. The FBI isn't going to stop looking for ways to catch assholes but as long as something like this works they are going to use it and be less inclined to see a need for other ways. If you think this was a bad idea on the FBI's part, then if it is shot down, what will the next bright idea be, and how much risk will their be for it's misuse?

I for one don't see that what they did was wrong or unreasonable in any way beyond the fact that there is a problem with the Jurisdiction of the warrant. This law will correct that problem. The question becomes, is this new law too broad ? Is there too much room and does it invite misuse. If it does, then we will see it in court. It won't be the first time that the cops ask for changes and then when abused, adjustments must be made. But this one looks like it will pass and at the moment I see no reason to try and stop it.
 
Though I suspect hyperbole in your description, it is a good chance to remind everyone that there is a big difference between governments and private (mostly multinational corporate, banking etc) interests having the technical capability versus the legal justification! There are some entities, often government-directed but not always (and I think those that are not are even more pernicious), such as three-letter-agencies that may have the technical or operational capability to do all kinds of things; for the sake of clarity, I'll keep to electronic surveillance for this discussion. However, their use would be relatively rare, for fear of giving away or "using up" capabilities on adversaries that only REALLY warrant them, as well as avoiding any pitfalls regarding legalities and civil liberties. However, when you codify the use of these abilities legally, such as the Patriot Act, NDAA, use entities like FISA courts to provide wide-reaching, often secret warrants etc.. that's when the real problems start. What used to be used only in cases where it would absolutely seem justified becomes commonplace and spreads FAR beyond its original intentions/specifications, with civil liberties being the first casualty. For instance, the Patriot Act and methodology it covered for surveillance and intelligence gathering was intended to be used exclusively to stop immenent terrorist attacks. However, once the floodgates were opened we all matters of other less serious crimes, including and especially non violent drug sales on the Internet, prosecuted on evidence gathered entirely under these provisions! So it has gone with a ton of things in the past 15 years from drone-based assassinations, to cracking encryption, to a constant and encroaching war on privacy and much, much more. Lets not forget that governments are an easily identified target but aren't the only ones that work this way - private interests are no better (and that's aside from things like regulatory capture where private money controls government's direction and uses its might to accomplish their goals).

There was a time when such actions by governments were secrete rarities and corporate interests were indefensible, but when individual rights and the common good are cast by the wayside, these entities get a bit bolder each time. Once cloaked by a facade of legality they come out of the shadows and fearlessly tread on any supposed opposition unless advocates can weather the horrendous storm and try to restrict their moves again through legislation. Its a ponderous affair but part of the reason we must not permit any intrusion and must work to roll back the clock lest we lose privacy and many civil liberties forever, bit by bit.


Ummm, I have some problems with some of the ideas you seem to be taking on faith. At the same time I want to say, I agree with most of the sentiment and the ethical thought and reasoning behind them.

For instance, what makes the FISA Court a "Secret" court. It was known, it's existence wasn't a secret. And it's scope and power and limits were all known, and weren't secret. And because of it's limits and it's purpose, to provide judicial review for legal activities that involve information and activities that are themselves "Secret" and can not be exposed to most people, such a court isn't what most people imagine a "secret court" to actually be. The FISA Court isn't hearing court cases carried out in secret where people are being tried secretly. that isn't within the power of the FISA court, not it's purpose.

This is a better explanation;
The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) was introduced on May 18, 1977, by Senator Ted Kennedy and was signed into law by President Carter in 1978. The bill was cosponsored by nine Senators: Birch Bayh, James O. Eastland, Jake Garn, Walter Huddleston, Daniel Inouye, Charles Mathias, John L. McClellan, Gaylord Nelson, and Strom Thurmond.

The FISA resulted from extensive investigations by Senate Committees into the legality of domestic intelligence activities. These investigations were led separately by Sam Ervin and Frank Church in 1978 as a response to President Richard Nixon’s usage of federal resources to spy on political and activist groups.[4] The act was created to provide judicial and congressional oversight of the government's covert surveillance activities of foreign entities and individuals in the United States, while maintaining the secrecy needed to protect national security.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Intelligence_Surveillance_Act

Another problem I have is your apparent understanding of Patriot Act and that it was only supposed to apply to terrorism. That is like an Urban Myth of epic proportions.

From the first page of the document;
"To deter and punish terrorist acts in the United States and around the world,
to enhance law enforcement investigatory tools, and for other purposes.
"

https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/BILLS-107hr3162enr/pdf/BILLS-107hr3162enr.pdf
https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/BILLS-107hr3162enr/pdf/BILLS-107hr3162enr.pdf
That doesn't say, "..... to enhance law enforcement investigatory tools for Anti-Terrorism purposes, and for other purposes."
 
So basically, we lost our government a long, long time ago. Right, Piper?
 
I remember being at an FBI recruiting talk at my university, they wanted Math and Physics majors and told everyone, don't worry about programming, you can pick it up. As a Computer Engineering major I did a major mental eye roll to the idea of math majors suddenly programming for the FBI. (Not to mention during the talk they referred to everyone as "targets" and "bad guys" and seemed very critical about personal privacy)
 
We didn't lose our Government, our Government decided to take its own course as time progressed and having people entrenched in Government jobs for decades, Congressmen especially - ok, not all of them are bad but honestly, if there's someone serving in Congress in either the House or the Senate and they've been there for more than 2 terms, it's time they get the fuck out, seriously, that shit was never meant to be a damned career.

As I stated in another thread recently, this is a wedge in the door so to speak, leaving it cracked open just enough for other stuff to start working its way through and soon enough it'll be far far worse than most can imagine and of course far far too late to do anything about it save for a damned revolution that will only serve to make it even worse - there's more bullets out there than people, and with the Department of Homeland Security still having that order for 1.6 billion rounds of ammo means somebody out there is prepping for something and it ain't some damned show on the National Geographic channel. :)

"He who gives up freedom for safety deserves neither"

-Benjamin Franklin

The problem there is that's not actually what he said but it's been mangled forever in the press and in casual use by people that don't have the slightest clue about what Franklin actually did say which was:

Benjamin Franklin said:
Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.

Now while you and others might argue that's exactly what people are saying when they mangle the original quote with their own rewording of it, what's relevant is the context in which Franklin was saying those words because in the statement he made the text before and after that particular sentence that gets mangled shows that he was speaking about money (hence the word "purchase" in the original unmodified statement that gets left out when people mangle it) - read the last paragraph here on page 99 (bottom right hand corner) continuing onto page 100 to understand the actual text from his statement:

Memoirs of Benjamin Franklin, Volume 2

So, when you get right down to it and while I appreciate and wish good old Ben was talking about what everyone else thinks he was talking about, when you actually read the statement in the original context it just kinda blows the fuck right outta what people are doing to the original meaning, sadly.

But hey, that's America for ya... ;)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I really hate that phrase. People use it like it is some philosophical gold. Hell, even a seatbelt sacrifices freedom for safety, or sides of bridges, etc. I get what it is saying, but in its literal sense, is terrible.

The sentiment of the quote is pretty valid, though it was in a day when it was impossible for a single act to kill hundreds, thousands, or possibly even hundreds of thousands of people.

More importantly, liberty and comfort have become confused in the world today. There are tribesmen in Africa that have more liberty than any of us will ever have in our lives yet not many of us would switch places with them. Comfort and security, even prosperity, are pretty good too.
 
I remember being at an FBI recruiting talk at my university, they wanted Math and Physics majors and told everyone, don't worry about programming, you can pick it up. As a Computer Engineering major I did a major mental eye roll to the idea of math majors suddenly programming for the FBI. (Not to mention during the talk they referred to everyone as "targets" and "bad guys" and seemed very critical about personal privacy)

Well actually it's completely true that it's easier to teach a math major how to code then to train a coder how to solve problems. That has been a common problem for decades, that colleges pump out people who can write code all day long but they are not always very good at problem solving. Even if they hire a guy with a programming degree they will likely have to retrain him on the newer tools in use, but a math major who has learned how to approach real world problems and apply logic and mathematic principles to solve them, learning how to code is no big deal.

And of course the FBI talks about targets and bad guys, though a target shouldn't be understood as a weapon target, but instead as a surveillance target. They aren't supposed to be in the business of chasing good guys. And I don't think it's personal privacy they are critical of, but instead I think it's the people who work to hamper their efforts under the flag of personal privacy.

Just like in the case I brought up, The Playpen kiddie porn case, The FBI charged over 180 people with Child Porn offenses. Now maybe some of you don't think there is anything wrong with kiddie porn and it's mostly beside the point anyway.

My question is, do any of you think these people were innocent?

Keep your answer to yourself, you don't owe it to me. But when you read this stuff at least try and keep your answer in mind.

Before, when we discussed this PlayPen sting and the FBI running the site, I was of the opinion the FBI had screwed up by being lazy and not getting a warrant for each bad guy. But now that I look back on it I realize that you can't get the warrant until you know where the fucker lives and they couldn't track them down so the used the NIT for that.

What I am saying is, the FBI is right. Current law is inadequate for allowing them to successfully pursue cyber criminals. This new law should help.
 
Snip for length "

With regards to the FISA court, I agree that it isn't a "secret" court under the "old school totalitarian" definition where someone is whisked away in the dead of night, tried by a magistrate in a secret underground location without public record, and sentenced harshly etc. I did not mean to imply that the two were similar. I probably could have chosen another wording. However, while the court's existence is public and we have a broad understanding of its mission, the majority of its actions are conducted in secret by design. However, as we have seen in the past several years this secrecy as well as other aspects of the court has been exploited frequently in order to provide a rubber stamp of approval for actions that would not be as easily, nor allow those involved to escape the public record, if it was forced to be handled in an open court. There are many criticisms of it and I'd think it better to link to the wikipedia page on the FISA Court as oppose to FISA itself - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Foreign_Intelligence_Surveillance_Court . The incredible amount of granted warrants compared to denied ones as well as the inability for the public to, even after the fact, vet the validity of said warrants is a major problem, as is the fact that such data attained via FISA court warrant (or even justification of warrant-less surveillance) can be used as evidence in other court cases without being able to be challenged on the circumstances of its collection. To save everyone time, I won't go over many of the criticisms of the court that can be found in the Wikipedia link above (though I can also provide links from other sources if really necessary) but suffice it to say the secrecy aspect of its procedure, not to mention the possibility to exploit such secrecy essentially without much worry of repercussion, is a worrisome issue.

With regard to the Patriot Act, I believe that your objections seems like a technicality based on that verbiage. While yes, the Act itself does include what you note, it is a similar vague "legalese" as the following "and for other purposes" element. Even in the description you note, "To deter and punish terrorist acts in the United States and around the world" is the first stated objective and it would be a reasonable decision that both elements to follow are in regards and relation to the original mission. Now, there's also a worthy discussion to be had about the dangers of allowing the kind of vague language in laws, as well; many supposed that certain elements within the government purposefully allowed for that vagueness to obtain a wider expansion of powers. That said, ultimately the Patriot Act - even if you look at the debate and discussion on the floor of Congress at and around the time of its passing, not to mention the multitudes of statements from government representatives, the media, and elsewhere - was "sold" to the American people as an expansion of powers exclusively (and at some times, assuredly temporarily) for dealing with Terrorism. Now the few who had the courage to object to the Patriot Act around its patriot act, noting that it could be used beyond the mission to fight terrorism based upon that language, were told their worries were groundless and they were "letting the terrorists win". Its also noteworthy that in the years after the Patriot Act's passing, when its features were used against non-terrorist suspects, the government itself often concealed that evidence was obtained via the Patriot Act and engaged in parallel construction at times. The ACLU shows some of the mismanagement - https://www.aclu.org/letter/aclu-ro...ctor-general-s-review-fbi-s-use-national-secu - and the Administrative Office of US Courts showed that the vast majority of "sneak and peek" requests under a Patriot Act were drug offenses! http://big.assets.huffingtonpost.com/SneakAndPeakReport.pdf ; there are also other examples. Ultimately the Patriot Act was "sold" to the people as a counter-terrorism strategy and especially when concerns were raised that the more invasive permissions could be used beyond that mission, they were assured that civil liberties wouldn't be violated and that those "new" investigative techniques were only to be used against "terrorists:" and related "bad guys".
 
The sentiment of the quote is pretty valid, though it was in a day when it was impossible for a single act to kill hundreds, thousands, or possibly even hundreds of thousands of people.

More importantly, liberty and comfort have become confused in the world today. There are tribesmen in Africa that have more liberty than any of us will ever have in our lives yet not many of us would switch places with them. Comfort and security, even prosperity, are pretty good too.


I think I get what you mean here.

It's like Cypher;
If you'd told us the truth, we would've told you to shove that red pill right up your ass.
 
With regards to the FISA court, ........................ in order to provide a rubber stamp of approval for actions that would not be as easily, ..........................There are many criticisms of it ..................

But here is where the critics repeated fail to underscore the context.

Focus on this until you understand it fully;

The act was created to provide judicial and congressional oversight of the government's covert surveillance activities of foreign entities and individuals in the United States, while maintaining the secrecy needed to protect national security.

Where no such Judicial and Congressional oversight previously existed.

the government's covert surveillance activities of foreign entities and individuals in the United States

The FISA Court does not overseas government surveillance activities of US Persons ..............................................

Let that sink in please. This is a hugely important distinction that the media repeatedly leaves unsaid.

The FISA Court overseas activities against foreign nationals, not US Citizens, not even US Persons.

Foreign Nationals are not protected under the US Constitution, they do not have the rights of a citizen, with one exception, some foreign nationals do have US Person status and gain the rights and protections of a citizen. It's why I repeatedly say US Person over Citizen, because it's more accurate and truthful.

So when you look at the numbers of actions by the FISA court that are a "rubber stamp" it's because one of two things apply. Either the individual involved is a foreign national so there is no protection, rubber stamp. Or, the Court Action concerns information in which the nationality and citizenship is not yet known and until it's known, there is no reason to worry. After they find out a US Person is involved, then they issue the warrant, until then, rubber stamp.

A court that overseas activities of this nature is going to do a lot of rubber stamping, it's the nature of how it is fundamentally different in what it presides over that makes for the differences.
 
Last edited:
While this may seem like bad news, we are still talking about the FBI here. You know, the people that couldn't hack an iPhone. Having the authority doesn't automatically give them the ability. :D

The changes will allow judges to issue warrants in cases when a suspect uses anonymizing technology to conceal the location of his or her computer or for an investigation into a network of hacked or infected computers, such as a botnet. Magistrate judges can currently only order searches within the jurisdiction of their court, which is typically limited to a few counties.
Wow, that is an incredibly dangerous and naive take on this. Let's all just laugh about it and poke fun at the FBI until it comes out in 5 years that they are mass storing personal data and then we can all get pissed about it again. Just like the patriot act.
 

I understand that is its identified role - on paper. However, there is considerable evidence that it strays from that strict mission Furthermore, It doesn't only have to do with investigations on foreign nationals, but (especially in recent years) "suspected agents of foreign powers" - a nebulous term that can be applied to American citizens through everything from legitimate usage (ie suspected spy for a foreign power reporting secrets back) to incredibly tenuous connections. This Washington Post article (which is rather even-handed in its presentation) shows that things are not so cut and dry and the FISA court - https://www.washingtonpost.com/poli...9eaae6-d9fa-11e2-a016-92547bf094cc_story.html . One of the key facets in the problems of the surveillance complex today is the difference between the rigid, literal definition of a mission, the real world actions taken that push the boundaries of said mi, and various legal justifications that attempt to rectify (and at times, justify) the difference between the two and what it means.
 
Last edited:
I understand that is its identified role - on paper. However, there is considerable evidence that it strays from that strict mission. It doesn't only have to do with investigations on foreign nationals, but (especially in recent years) "suspected agents of foreign powers" - a nebulous term that can be applied to American citizens through everything from legitimate usage (ie suspected spy for a foreign power reporting secrets back) to incredibly tenuous connections. This Washington Post article (which is rather even-handed in its presentation) shows that things are not so cut and dry and the FISA court - https://www.washingtonpost.com/poli...9eaae6-d9fa-11e2-a016-92547bf094cc_story.html . One of the key facets in the problems of the surveillance complex today is the difference between the rigid, literal definition of a mission, the actual real world actions taken, and various legal justifications that attempt to rectify (and at times, justify) the difference.

"suspected agents of foreign powers" is not a nebulous term to the people in the business.
A US Person, which can include foreign nationals who work for US companies for instance, can find themselves in the target of an Intelligence collection mission because they have gotten themselves involved in things. Take an American who has traveled overseas and gotten themselves involved with ISIL / ISIS. Under normal circumstances, when US intelligence Agencies are collecting information and it becomes apparent that someone they are listening to is an American, the collectors have to "roll off them", and stop. But if it is obvious that the American is involved in something, the rules quickly change. Essentially it can quickly become a matter for the FBI, and if the FBI opens an investigation then it's possible that this would have to go before the FISA court because of how the information was gained and possibly because of how the FBI would pursue. Such a case would not be one of those rubber stamps.

I want to keep reading that article, but one thing is clear about it. That is a very early article written at a time by people who know very little about what they are writing about. And it features comments from Sen. Wyden who is anything but even handed. But I need to knock out something here at work and then I have to go home, they will be closing the building.

Tomorrow I'll pick this back up.

Alright, picking up. I don't know what a surveillance complex is. I suppose there are people who don't have experience with the Intelligence Community who think such a thing exists, but as someone who has been a part of it, I can tell you that this is a term that is completely unnecessary.

The Intelligence Community is a clearly defined construct with some pretty serious rules. As such it has some very strict definitions, words like intercept, collect, analyze, etc, all have specific meanings that do not necessarily mean what a layman might think they mean. Information and activity is controlled, and the lines only cross in designated ways and places.

But I don't want to drift into details of Intelligence Operations, I want to bring up something else. Most of us realize that if the Constitution and the initial Laws of this country had been perfect, and that if the world never changed, that those laws would never have needed to change at all. We never would have needed an amendment to the Constitution because everything was perfect.

But the founding Fathers knew that the world does change, that the founding documents would need to change, and that laws must be articles that can be changed as needed. The Constitution, as a founding document, is supposed to provide guidance on the principles of our government which are much more important than the laws enacted to govern "by those principles". The Constitution should be our "compass" that helps us keep to the right course. But even the Constitution must be changeable and it is. So as our world changes, so must our laws, and when needed, even the Constitution.

It only follows that sometimes these changes will be less than perfect and require adjustments.

So it is with everything else the Government does.
 
Last edited:
I don't think the Washington Post can be considered a reliable source of information.
 
I really hate that phrase. People use it like it is some philosophical gold. Hell, even a seatbelt sacrifices freedom for safety, or sides of bridges, etc. I get what it is saying, but in its literal sense, is terrible.
In the proper context, I think it's a great phrase. My usage felt appropriate. But you're right, it doesn't apply to everything.
 
I would assume that the FBI have to explain how NIT works so that they can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that NIT isn't identifying random computers on the internet. The FBI can "say" that NIT is their software and can only be on child porn surfers computers, but they need to prove that.
 
Another problem I have is your apparent understanding of Patriot Act and that it was only supposed to apply to terrorism. That is like an Urban Myth of epic proportions.

From the first page of the document;


https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/BILLS-107hr3162enr/pdf/BILLS-107hr3162enr.pdf
That doesn't say, "..... to enhance law enforcement investigatory tools for Anti-Terrorism purposes, and for other purposes."

Oh, it says "and for other purposes"

Some people may have missed the obvious catch all that means this can be used for anything.

Silly citizens!
 
Oh, it says "and for other purposes"

Some people may have missed the obvious catch all that means this can be used for anything.

Silly citizens!

No, because it specifically says "to enhance law enforcement investigatory tools"

And saying "and for other purposes" doesn't mean you can use it for anything.

The statement is descriptive of what is in the legislation, it's not a definition of legal scope.
 
Last edited:
No, because it specifically says "to enhance law enforcement investigatory tools"

And saying "and for other purposes" doesn't mean you can use it for anything.

The statement is descriptive of what is in the legislation, it's not a definition of legal scope.
It's just a way of saying there are some additional extraneous things that are not specific to fighting terrorism or expanding law enforcement investigatory power.

As long as it's extraneous cases, since those would be rare. I would hate to find out the PATRIOT Act has been used for normal crimes like drug enforcement or being used for secret property searches.
 
As long as it's extraneous cases, since those would be rare. I would hate to find out the PATRIOT Act has been used for normal crimes like drug enforcement or being used for secret property searches.

Again, the Patriot Act concerns Fighting Terrorism, and expanding law enforcement investigatory tools, and there are additional things in the law not related to the first two areas.

There is shit in there about A, and B, and some other shit that has nothing to do with A or B.

Tell me about the secret property searches though I think I know what you are talking about. That's the Sneak and Peek Search Warrant issue right?

I'm reading up on it here;
http://digitalcommons.law.uga.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1104&context=fac_pm
 
Last edited:
I first heard about this ruling several months ago and it brought to my attention an aspect of the supreme court I was not aware of.

I think most people think of the supreme court as a reactionary body. Somebody believes they were mistreated because of their race and they file a lawsuit which the supreme court eventually rules on and a new law or precedence is set. That's probably how most people view the supreme court. And that seems fair.

But this ruling showed a completely different aspect of the court. This is also the more common use of the court. Other government agencies can approach the supreme court and ask them to change or amend laws, without an actual lawsuit or defendant. In this case, the Justice Department presented the new "Rule 41" (among others) to the supreme court. The supreme court passed the amendment back in late April 2016. But it clearly said that the amendment was open for debate, and should it not be opposed for several months it would then go into effect.

And so here was are, several months later. No large effort was made to stop this new law. A couple people raised their hands and protested, but that means nothing. But now in the midnight hour suddenly everybody jumps and says "We were so close to dong something". They had time, and they did nothing.

The government made the suggestion. The government approved the suggestion. The government executes the suggestion.

To me, the "quiet" usage of the supreme court was the eye opener here.
 
I should read up on this, "quiet" Supreme Court activity as you put it.

I was surprised at the article I linked. I never realized that the first Sneak and Peek warrants go back to the 1980s. There weren't a lot of them, but anyway, I like thee article I linked to, it has good info in it. I still haven't finished reading it.
 
Again, the Patriot Act concerns Fighting Terrorism, and expanding law enforcement investigatory tools, and there are additional things in the law not related to the first two areas.

There is shit in there about A, and B, and some other shit that has nothing to do with A or B.

Tell me about the secret property searches though I think I know what you are talking about. That's the Sneak and Peek Search Warrant issue right?

I'm reading up on it here;
http://digitalcommons.law.uga.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1104&context=fac_pm

This part is fun...

Section 213 of the USA Patriot Act, enacted on Oct. 26, 2001, contains
the first express statutory authorization for the issuance of sneak and
peek search warrants in American history. Section 213 is not restricted
to terrorists or terrorism offenses; it may used in connection with any
federal crime, including misdemeanors.
 
Have you looked into it at all? Their probable cause under this is ANY computer running a VPN. In the WORLD. Not deven just the US. They now consider VPN use suspicious activity and any computer running a VPN would be fair game to be hacked and probed under this blanket warrant.

What the.....$#%^%^%$^@@
 
This part is fun...

Section 213 of the USA Patriot Act, enacted on Oct. 26, 2001, contains
the first express statutory authorization for the issuance of sneak and
peek search warrants in American history. Section 213 is not restricted
to terrorists or terrorism offenses; it may used in connection with any
federal crime, including misdemeanors.
I know he always insists "It's just terrorists" yet there's court cases aplenty that dispels that assertion. The NSA was caught spying on girlfriends etc. If you build it they will use it period. To pretend there's this force field preventing bad people from doing bad things is laughable.
 
Back
Top