External HDD or Internal HDD With Enclosure

djfunz

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 2, 2007
Messages
161
Title of the post pretty much sums up the question. Curious as to what the opinions are around the [H] Forums. I like the ability to swap drives using an enclosure and also having eSATA support. Do they really protect a HDD as well as a 'real' external HDD? I think I would want one with a fan as well. If the enclosure is the way to go some good model suggestions would be great. Thanks fellow hardware junkies. :)
 
Six of one, half dozen of the other. External hard drives are simply internal drives in enclosures. Depending on the particular drives and enclosures chosen, a choice from either pool might be better than the alternative.

I like my Rosewill RX-358-S (also in black). The large fan keeps it cool quietly and it seems to be built pretty well. The blue LEDs on it can be a bit annoying though. Their description is a little weird though. As it sits in the picture, I would say the fan pulls air "in the top and out the end" (as opposed to their description "in the side and out the rear"). The drive mounts by the sides, giving the enclosure lots of contact area with the frame of the drive, which should help transfer heat away. An enclosure that mounts on the bottom of the drive won't have as much direct contact and therefore won't transfer as much heat.
 
If you get one with an internal power supply, be sure it's UL listed because I got one that wasn't, and it was a potential Shock-O-Matic piece of junk.
 
I've had all kinds of enclosures... Well most kinds, I had a "real" external drive from WD as you call it, 250GB model, the enclosure failed within two years (royal PITA to rip it open, drive is still working flawlessly inside a system tho). I had a nice metal enclosure with a large fan from AMS... The drive mounting wasn't the best (plastic sled) but it was solidly built otherwise and had large side vents, that one lasted about two years. The 500GB drive that was inside it survived unscathed tho, still using it as my backup drive...

Which brings me to my newest enclosure from Ultra (model number in sig)... Unlike the AMS enclosure it doesn't have a fan, but it's USB/e-SATA just like the AMS was, tho it uses the more secure e-SATA cable w/prongs, the AMS enclosure just used a regular SATA cable, it was made/bought before e-SATA really caught on. The entire enclosure is very thick aluminum tho, and the sides grab unto the sides of my HDD very well so it channels heat away from the HDD super well (it always feels noticeably warm to the touch, which is a good sign that it isn't trapping the heat).

Drives are warmest around the sides, due to how they're built, so the issue of how it's mounted within the enclosure probably matters as much as whether it has a fan or not (unless you plan to stuff it in a cabinet or something). The power button and single LED are on the back, it's a bright one but since it's on the back of the unit it's very unobtrusive, and it comes w/a sturdy stand to hold it up vertically if you want. Can't say it'll last any longer than my previous two, but it seems solid so far, heh. I wouldn't spend too much on it either way, given my experience.
 
Back
Top