Exploit Broker Offers $500,000 For iOS Bugs

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
If you thought $200,000 for finding iOS bugs was a lot of money, these guys have upped the ante big time. I don't care who you are, it would be pretty hard to turn down that kind of money.

The exploit trader has launched a "hit list" of the hottest, most wanted exploits for software including Apple iOS, Google Chrome, Microsoft Edge and Adobe Flash. The company will pay $500,000 for the most dangerous bugs in Apple iOS 9.3 and above -- and researchers can choose to take a lump sum or smaller payments which continue to roll in as long as the exploit is still alive. Exodus is willing to pay researchers by check, wire transfer, Western Union or Bitcoin.
 
I'm not familiar with Exodus, but I'd be making damned sure they aren't buying the exploits for nefarious purposes before selling it to them, even for $500k.

$500k is a lot of money, but even if you aren't the type who has moral compunctions, it's not "worth going to federal - pound me up the ass - prison" money.
 
Why would you go to prison? I don't know of any laws that require you to report software bugs to a dev company. Now if the broker sells the exploit and someone uses it, they will go to jail if caught. But I cant see what they would charge someone with for selling information about a bug they discovered.
 
I'm not familiar with Exodus, but I'd be making damned sure they aren't buying the exploits for nefarious purposes before selling it to them, even for $500k.

$500k is a lot of money, but even if you aren't the type who has moral compunctions, it's not "worth going to federal - pound me up the ass - prison" money.


Just like with firearms, you aren't responsible for what someone chooses to do with your product, unless you have suspicion it is for nefarious purposes.
 
I'm not familiar with Exodus, but I'd be making damned sure they aren't buying the exploits for nefarious purposes before selling it to them, even for $500k.

$500k is a lot of money, but even if you aren't the type who has moral compunctions, it's not "worth going to federal - pound me up the ass - prison" money.

Can the Feds put you in prison though? You aren't the one doing the hacking, whoever Exodus sells the exploit to would be.
 
Can the Feds put you in prison though? You aren't the one doing the hacking, whoever Exodus sells the exploit to would be.

Probably not if you can show due diligence in researching them first. If you just turn a blind eye - however - you are likely fucked. You'd probably be charged as an accessory. There is plenty of precedence for willful ignorance defenses failing in court.
 
Just like with firearms, you aren't responsible for what someone chooses to do with your product, unless you have suspicion it is for nefarious purposes.

...or if you are willfully ignorant...

If someone is offering you half a million bucks for something, that should be triggering your "too good to be true/this is suspicious/what are they doing with the exploit/I should totally research them more before agreeing" alarm.

If you choose to ignore those alarm bells you can definitely be held accountable as an accessory. Being willfully ignorant is usually not an effective defense.
 
Probably not if you can show due diligence in researching them first. If you just turn a blind eye - however - you are likely fucked. You'd probably be charged as an accessory. There is plenty of precedence for willful ignorance defenses failing in court.

Negative. You don't have to do you research.
Ignorance failing in court has to do with other things. An exploit is not illegal.

Example: I put a pistol up for sale on armslist. Guy wants to meet face-to-face for the sale. Hese obviously over 21. We talk about guns for a few, and I have good vibes. I give him pistol, he gives me cash. He goes home and shoots his wife. Not my problem, morally or legally.

What someone chooses to do with an otherwise legal item(gun, bottle of booze, piece of software) is not burdened to the broker or seller unless the law stipulates that other measures must be taken before the transfer of said item can be completed. If you don't follow through with the law, then you just royally fucked yourself
 
...or if you are willfully ignorant...

If someone is offering you half a million bucks for something, that should be triggering your "too good to be true/this is suspicious/what are they doing with the exploit/I should totally research them more before agreeing" alarm.

If you choose to ignore those alarm bells you can definitely be held accountable as an accessory. Being willfully ignorant is usually not an effective defense.


True, but now you're getting to the fringes. $500k for a high level exploit is pennies.
 
Negative. You don't have to do you research.
Ignorance failing in court has to do with other things. An exploit is not illegal.

Example: I put a pistol up for sale on armslist. Guy wants to meet face-to-face for the sale. Hese obviously over 21. We talk about guns for a few, and I have good vibes. I give him pistol, he gives me cash. He goes home and shoots his wife. Not my problem, morally or legally.

What someone chooses to do with an otherwise legal item(gun, bottle of booze, piece of software) is not burdened to the broker or seller unless the law stipulates that other measures must be taken before the transfer of said item can be completed.


But if he seemed sketchy, in a hurry, and was offering you way more money than the gun would sell for normally, you got really weird vibes about the situation, and you still went ahead?
 
But if he seemed sketchy, in a hurry, and was offering you way more money than the gun would sell for normally, you got really weird vibes about the situation, and you still went ahead?

Why would how he acted matter? You go to jail for breaking a law, what law is being broken in either this example, or the OP with selling a bug you found to a broker? Yes, you can't claim ignorance for breaking a known law, but that means there was one in place. So what laws apply to either scenario?
 
Within the letter of the law, even then I'm not legally responsible for his actions unless I believe that he is prohibited from ownership.

Unlicensed Persons | Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives

Why would how he acted matter? You go to jail for breaking a law, what law is being broken in either this example, or the OP with selling a bug you found to a broker? Yes, you can't claim ignorance for breaking a known law, but that means there was one in place. So what laws apply to either scenario?


Yeah, I know very little about gun legislation. I've never owned one and never will, so I've never really bothered to read up on the details.

I do know that everyone always tends to have a collective freakout about even the slightest little restrictions to gun laws on second amendment grounds, so based on this I don't think gun laws are a good comparison.

If a court can show that you had reason to believe that your work was going to be used to commit a crime, you can be charged as an accessory, even if you weren't the one directly using it in that way. Where that line is drawn is often a little fuzzy though, and depends from case to case. I wouldn't take any risks though, both because of the potential repercussions, and because I don't want to be helping Russian intelligence, or custard hackers in the slightest, regardless of how much money I'd be offered.

I take great pride in seeing myself as incorruptible in my values, so I wouldn't let any amount of money sway me. That being said, this is awfully easy to say in the hypothetical.

IMHO exploit brokering ought to be 100% illegal. If you have come across an exploit, the ONLY ethical thing to do with that exploit is to notify the maker of the code, and hope they take it seriously, fix it in a reasonable amount of time, and offer a reward.
 
Last edited:
I'm not familiar with Exodus, but I'd be making damned sure they aren't buying the exploits for nefarious purposes before selling it to them, even for $500k.

$500k is a lot of money, but even if you aren't the type who has moral compunctions, it's not "worth going to federal - pound me up the ass - prison" money.

Pretty sure it's for nefarious purposes. That's a lot of money and the fact they offer you the ability to be paid smaller amounts as long as it stays live. The only reason you'd want an exploit to stay live is for nefarious reasons.
 
I think that gun laws are a perfect place to work with an example.

You are correct- If I sold a gun/software to someone and I knew that they were going to use it for illegal means, then I could ne charged as an accessory to that crime. However, if I had reasonable ignorance to their plans (again, this goes back to the goods in question are legal, but can be used in illegal activities) and didn't know what they were up to (again, I don't have the burden of proving such claim, unless there are laws that state that I do), then my hands are clean. Sure, I might feel bad if they turned around and used said goods in an illegal action, but that is a moral concern, not a legal one.

There has to be services like this. Making it illegal to find (and therefor possess the software to exploit the bugs) exploits is a huge issue. The only thing this does is prevent law abiding citizens from finding them. It doesn't prevent criminals from being criminals. If laws actually worked, there wouldn't be drug abusers, rapists, murderers, or hackers. Laws only keep "good" people from doing things the government doesn't want them to do. I'm one of those people- I choose not to do cocain because it's illegal and I don't wanna go to prison. If it was legal, I would have blow off my wifes ass on a nightly basis. However, even with the laws, people do these things anyway.

Leaving it up to a software vender to patch a bug is bad. If there wasn't risk of the exploit getting into the wild, many of them would remain unpatched. It's this very risk that encourages a vender to fix their stuff.
 
Pretty sure it's for nefarious purposes. That's a lot of money and the fact they offer you the ability to be paid smaller amounts as long as it stays live. The only reason you'd want an exploit to stay live is for nefarious reasons.


Or the vender simply won't patch it...
Google and Apple offer amounts even larger than this for high-level exploits.
 
I am in the camp of if this is a nefarious broker then they should be given some harsh treatment like broken knees, public whipping post and all assets seized and put on a chain gang for eternal life.
 
I am in the camp of if this is a nefarious broker then they should be given some harsh treatment like broken knees, public whipping post and all assets seized and put on a chain gang for eternal life.

Drones
 
Or the vender simply won't patch it...
Google and Apple offer amounts even larger than this for high-level exploits.

There was just a report that Apple is offering up to 200k bounty for exploits... Last time I checked 500k > 200k. I don't believe I've seen any reports of google paying anywhere near that for exploits either.
 
Or the vender simply won't patch it...
Google and Apple offer amounts even larger than this for high-level exploits.

There have been some limited cases of higher amounts offered on a case by case basis, but in those cases it has been closer to blackmail, and not the good deed reporting an exploit is supposed to be.

If I recall Googles chrome program has rewards ranging from $5k to $10k
 
There was just a report that Apple is offering up to 200k bounty for exploits... Last time I checked 500k > 200k. I don't believe I've seen any reports of google paying anywhere near that for exploits either.


So it is. However, it's very well known that the government pays millions for exploits stemming from the civilian sector, regardless the color of their hats.
 
There have been some limited cases of higher amounts offered on a case by case basis, but in those cases it has been closer to blackmail, and not the good deed reporting an exploit is supposed to be.

If I recall Googles chrome program has rewards ranging from $5k to $10k


Last I remember on that, it was $100k to take control of ChromeOS, and another $50k or something if it would stick after a power cycle. I remember this because they were offering $3.1415.... million in bounty cash lol
 
Why would you go to prison? I don't know of any laws that require you to report software bugs to a dev company. Now if the broker sells the exploit and someone uses it, they will go to jail if caught. But I cant see what they would charge someone with for selling information about a bug they discovered.


If you can sell it to them, they can sell it to someone else.
 
How much would the government buy the exploits for? I'm sure they would love another way into the iOS.
 
Back
Top