Expect Windows 8 in October

I'm a little bit stoked about taking Win 8 for a test spin as long as I can ditch that god-awful UI.
 
I don't agree that W8 will be another Vista... What I do see is that there are a few optimizations, GUI/frontend and some slicker ways to "refresh" your OS. In theory it'd be kinda nice to get your system running like new again, without having to do a clean install each time. I'd like to see how that happens.
 
I still think if they’re going to a more frequent release schedule they need to update their pricing structure to fit that faster release cycle I know I for one am not paying 100-200+ every couple years times all the machines I have.
 
What always amuses me about these threads, is the hand wringing of short memoried people or people that weren't even their when their beloved xp dropped.
 
So how likely is it that history will prove Windows 7 to be the same situation as XP, with individuals and companies still using it after a decade with little reason or desire to upgrade? Everyone seems to love it so much...

Agreed. I don't see upgrading systems at the office unless there is some "must have" feature in windows 8.
Besides, I doubt I'll have finished upgrading everyone to Windows 7 by then.
 
I'm holding off on doing a new computer build until Win 8 is out, but I don't know if I can hold out 'til Oct. : \
 
Agreed. I don't see upgrading systems at the office unless there is some "must have" feature in windows 8.
Unless you have a tablet, so far there are no must-have features in Windows 8. The ribbon in Explorer is a good addition. The new restore mechanisms should be advantageous (but you should be leveraging what System Restore has to offer already, and that should be good enough for most people). Built-in image mounting is going to be helpful, but format support will likely be too limited for you to be able to abandon your existing image mounting app entirely. As far as gaming is concerned, Direct3D 11.1 brings native support for stereoscopic 3D, but that won't be a justification to upgrade until A) games begin to support D3D stereo rendering, which I suspect will take an incredibly long time, and B) you actually feel like investing in 3D-ready hardware.

Things could change between now and October, but I don't think much will. Once the beta is released, we should have a clearer picture as to whether 8 is going to be worth thinking about or not.
 
I love Win 7 so much, I iz skeered to leave it. At work, most of our workstations are still XP. Businesses with 5,000 desktops dont upgrade unless theres a gotta have it reason.
 
Because

a5djch.jpg
I support this post. :D
 
I don't understand how people will try to apply their own "logic" of what Windows 8 will be like. The public release was stable, and the install time was very minimal. Boot times were quick on older hardware I had it on.

This release is mainly out there to push out the whole touch screen revolution. It's suppose to change how we use our computers.

It still has the same stability and light weight install as 7.

I'm not so sure about a few GUI changes to the interface from the public release.

I won't feel compelled to buy and upgrade to it. Perhaps the next computer I will buy will come preloaded with it.
 
Do keep in mind that Windows 7 and prior won't run Metro apps. The number and quality of Metro apps will have a lot to do with Windows 8 sales I think.
 
Do keep in mind that Windows 7 and prior won't run Metro apps. The number and quality of Metro apps will have a lot to do with Windows 8 sales I think.
It's a competition against the App Store for iPads and iPhones. :)
 
oh my, geez, i can hardly wait for the next retarded childish crap from MS...
 
Lets kill a few of these all at once, shall we?
If I am forced to use the dumb tiles.. I am going to stick w/ windows 7.
You will be able to disable the Start Screen and use the good-old Start Menu that you're familiar with from Windows 7.

1. Microsoft has already said that the Start Screen (and all metro elements) will become disabled if your screen resolution is below 1024x768. (This functionality is present, but broken, in the developer preview).

2. There's a registry key that disables metro that doesn't yet have a settings GUI linked to it.

3. There's a group policy for disabling metro that has been discovered in later builds of Windows 8 (so network administrators can disable metro through Exchange Server).

I've been playing around with the Windows 8 developer preview... I'm not seeing a need to upgrade... I'm happy with 7

The developer preview is nowhere near feature-complete, and in no way represents what the final experience will be like.

List of additional features coming to the final version of Windows 8 (I'm sure I'm missing a few, but these are the highlights):
- Same (or lower) system requirements as Windows 7.
- Faster boot times.
- Memory deduplication.
- Integrated drive pooling.
- Integrated Hyper-V.
- Integrated antivirus.
- Integrated USB 3.0 support (Windows 7 doesn't comer with USB 3.0 drivers).
- Built-in ISO mounting.
- Multi-monitor aware taskbar.
- Multi-monitor aware desktop wallpaper.
- Easy factory-reset.
- System-wide SkyDrive integration.
- Roaming settings (preferences sync between Windows 8 devices).
- ARM support.
- Overhauled on screen keyboard (much improved over the Windows 7 OSK).

That image is highly inaccurate for multiple reasons... Windows 95 was one of Microsoft's most successful and largest product launches EVER. That alone throws off your little chart.

Don't forget, Windows XP was almost written off as a failure as well. A LOT of people coming from Windows 98 were unhappy with the tremendous lack of hardware and software support, crashes and instability, and the WAY higher system requirements... Gee, sounds a lot like people who moved from Windows XP to Windows Vista, doesn't it?

Microsoft managed to save Windows XP's reception by releasing Service Pack 2. What you have to keep in mind is that Microsoft had been preparing to ramp up development on the next version of Windows (to be released in 2004), but they decided to divert those features and resources into Windows XP SP2 in order to avoid having two failures in the consumer space in a row (ME followed directly by XP).

They saved XP but missed a product release cycle in 2004. Businesses and consumers settled in deeply with Windows XP, and then Microsoft had trouble getting people to switch when the time finally came to modernize things with Windows Vista. It also didn't help Vista's launch when hardware OEMs were ill-prepared, and didn't have stable hardware drivers ready for the new OS. Microsoft released a pie chart a few years ago that showed where most of Vista's crashes were being generated. The vast majority of the table was taken up by an Nvidia video driver DLL (yup, most of Vista's release-day crashes were caused by Nvidia).

Guess what? Drivers matured. Go ahead and install Vista today, with modern hardware drivers, and it's just as stable as Windows 7. If you have a large quantity of RAM, you may actually find Vista performs a tad better than Windows 7 once caching settles down (Windows Vista's SuperFetch is more aggressive than Windows 7's, and can lead to higher performance when there's ample RAM available). There's nothing really wrong with Vista, and I know more than a few people that stuck with it rather than upgrading to Windows 7.
 

I got a good laugh at this... :D

Lets kill a few of these all at once, shall we?

You will be able to disable the Start Screen and use the good-old Start Menu that you're familiar with from Windows 7.

1. Microsoft has already said that the Start Screen (and all metro elements) will become disabled if your screen resolution is below 1024x768. (This functionality is present, but broken, in the developer preview).

2. There's a registry key that disables metro that doesn't yet have a settings GUI linked to it.

3. There's a group policy for disabling metro that has been discovered in later builds of Windows 8 (so network administrators can disable metro through Exchange Server).



The developer preview is nowhere near feature-complete, and in no way represents what the final experience will be like.

List of additional features coming to the final version of Windows 8 (I'm sure I'm missing a few, but these are the highlights):
- Same (or lower) system requirements as Windows 7.
- Faster boot times.
- Memory deduplication.
- Integrated drive pooling.
- Integrated Hyper-V.
- Integrated antivirus.
- Integrated USB 3.0 support (Windows 7 doesn't comer with USB 3.0 drivers).
- Built-in ISO mounting.
- Multi-monitor aware taskbar.
- Multi-monitor aware desktop wallpaper.
- Easy factory-reset.
- System-wide SkyDrive integration.
- Roaming settings (preferences sync between Windows 8 devices).
- ARM support.
- Overhauled on screen keyboard (much improved over the Windows 7 OSK).


That image is highly inaccurate for multiple reasons... Windows 95 was one of Microsoft's most successful and largest product launches EVER. That alone throws off your little chart.

Don't forget, Windows XP was almost written off as a failure as well. A LOT of people coming from Windows 98 were unhappy with the tremendous lack of hardware and software support, crashes and instability, and the WAY higher system requirements... Gee, sounds a lot like people who moved from Windows XP to Windows Vista, doesn't it?

Microsoft managed to save Windows XP's reception by releasing Service Pack 2. What you have to keep in mind is that Microsoft had been preparing to ramp up development on the next version of Windows (to be released in 2004), but they decided to divert those features and resources into Windows XP SP2 in order to avoid having two failures in the consumer space in a row (ME followed directly by XP).

They saved XP but missed a product release cycle in 2004. Businesses and consumers settled in deeply with Windows XP, and then Microsoft had trouble getting people to switch when the time finally came to modernize things with Windows Vista. It also didn't help Vista's launch when hardware OEMs were ill-prepared, and didn't have stable hardware drivers ready for the new OS. Microsoft released a pie chart a few years ago that showed where most of Vista's crashes were being generated. The vast majority of the table was taken up by an Nvidia video driver DLL (yup, most of Vista's release-day crashes were caused by Nvidia).

Guess what? Drivers matured. Go ahead and install Vista today, with modern hardware drivers, and it's just as stable as Windows 7. If you have a large quantity of RAM, you may actually find Vista performs a tad better than Windows 7 once caching settles down (Windows Vista's SuperFetch is more aggressive than Windows 7's, and can lead to higher performance when there's ample RAM available). There's nothing really wrong with Vista, and I know more than a few people that stuck with it rather than upgrading to Windows 7.

Great post. Once Vista matured, it was a great OS for me. I never had a problem with crappy hardware and had one driver issue with a sound card, so it worked fine for me.
 
Windows ME should have never saw the light of day.

Most of Windows ME's problems are caused by the beta version of Internet Explorer that it shipped with (and the shell is heavily based on IE... see the problem?)

Patch internet Explorer to the latest version, and ME suddenly becomes quite stable.
 
I always viewd their release more like innovate polish, innovate polish. Unfortunately people do not like change. Especially the programmers who create all the drivers and programs for windows. As such they often sour the innovative OS with lack of support or buggy software.
 
You will be able to disable the Start Screen and use the good-old Start Menu that you're familiar with from Windows 7.

There's been NO official word from Microsoft that this will be the case, indeed Microsoft doesn't seem to want the classic Start Menu in Windows 8 and there's a lot of reasons why they wouldn't one being that it would in essence allow a user to break Metro apps.

There are rumors going around that the classic Start Menu is COMPLETELY gone in the lastest build, not sure how true that it but I would be surprised if this is an option but the pressure on Microsoft to allow the classic Start Menu in Windows 8 some way my be to great. I think it'll have a lot to do with beta feedback but I would expect the classic Start Menu no to be easily enabled if at all.
 
There's been NO official word from Microsoft that this will be the case, indeed Microsoft doesn't seem to want the classic Start Menu in Windows 8 and there's a lot of reasons why they wouldn't one being that it would in essence allow a user to break Metro apps.

There are rumors going around that the classic Start Menu is COMPLETELY gone in the lastest build, not sure how true that it but I would be surprised if this is an option but the pressure on Microsoft to allow the classic Start Menu in Windows 8 some way my be to great. I think it'll have a lot to do with beta feedback but I would expect the classic Start Menu no to be easily enabled if at all.

They need to do one of 2 things. Either:

1. Get rid of the metro screen altogether. Admit its a broken lump of crap and they were just wrong, as all feedback seems to suggest. Replace with standard start menu and allow launching of metro applications from it. In years after launch 99.9% of programs will not be metro. Will be annoying using a special screen to find puzzle games and silly applications then having to search around for proper stuff.

2. Make it so metro applications aren't full screen. If photoshop was fullscreen only, it would be stupid. When using reference material, id have to close one program, move to another and open the photo browser. Same with video editors and renderers. Production software usually relies on more than one application at the same time. Otherwise metro is a huge huge step back wards in so many ways. I know it stays up in a suspended state, but in "normal" windows I can just have a pile of programs open at the same time and quickly flick between them. We're well past the days of MB ram.

Them acting like a dictator and saying "this is the way you use our crap" isn't very progressive. Give people more options, but don't take away or force people to use them. Otherwise why would anyone choose windows 8. "hey it's like windows 7, but you can't do..." isn't a great advertizement. "hey it's like windows 7 but you can also do..." is.
 
To those complaining about the chart and bringing up 2000 and NT..a couple things need to be noted as I am tired of that argument.

2000 and NT were not targeted at home computers, those were Business Targeted and not in the same league as everything else listed in that little chart. Same as XP home and XP pro were quite different in who they were targeted at.

Also to the comment on rose colored glasses concerning XP, I agree. XP home was absolute shit on initial release and frankly didn't really become usable until Sp2, SP1 being debatable. Now Pro was a bit different, but it was quite unstable until SP1 at the minimum.

Vista likewise catches quite a bit of undue shit as well. Th majority of its problem was lack of third party support for a completely new architecture. While it certainly was a resource hog until SP1, it still ran well out of the box on a well setup machine. However version comes into play here as well. Vista Home Basic was a sad joke and likely everyone's main experience. It was absolutely awful and remains awful through sp2. However Vista Business and Ultimate on the other hand out of the box performed very well and perform even better with SP2. Much like XP though, old Legacy hardware performs like shit with Vista and frankly that is a good thing. I prefer MS to limit legacy support to a degree as you start introducing instability if you try and support everything, including that 15 year old printer that grandma tuttle should of replaced 12 years ago.
 
There's been NO official word from Microsoft that this will be the case, indeed Microsoft doesn't seem to want the classic Start Menu in Windows 8 and there's a lot of reasons why they wouldn't one being that it would in essence allow a user to break Metro apps.
They HAVE given official word on the matter, and I told you exactly where it came from. When they were talking about screen resolution limitations, they CLEARLY defined the breakdown.

1366x768 and higher = Full Metro experience.
At least 1024x768 = Metro experience with split-screen functionality disabled.
Any resolution below 1024x768 = Metro is automatically disabled.

The Windows 7 start menu is sticking around to service those small screens, and I've heard every indication that there will be a use-accessible setting to force it for larger screens (and a group policy so administrators can easily disable it on all of their machines).
 
They HAVE given official word on the matter, and I told you exactly where it came from. When they were talking about screen resolution limitations, they CLEARLY defined the breakdown.

1366x768 and higher = Full Metro experience.
At least 1024x768 = Metro experience with split-screen functionality disabled.
Any resolution below 1024x768 = Metro is automatically disabled.

The Windows 7 start menu is sticking around to service those small screens, and I've heard every indication that there will be a use-accessible setting to force it for larger screens (and a group policy so administrators can easily disable it on all of their machines).

This is something I don't get as it seems completely backwards. Metro was designed for small sub 10" screens (mobile) and in that world it works great. Using it as the default on 1366x768 and larger is just a huge waste of screen space. It isn't a UI that is designed for Mouse and keyboard and if anything works horribly with it. It is designed for a touch interface and I am sorry but I am not using a touch screen that large over a mouse/kb.

I have tried giving metro a chance, I have kept it enabled with every single build I could get my hands on. At the end of the day I still love it on a phone and utterly hate it on a desktop. I think it is a completely Terrible design decision and it is going to garner Win 8 A LOT of otherwise undeserved hate. Now beyond metro, Win 8 is fairly good. It is essentially what Win 7 was to Vista. Same basic platform with some polish applied in a few key areas. However For those already with Win 7, it presents very little reason to consider it an upgrade path in the near future.
 
This is something I don't get as it seems completely backwards. Metro was designed for small sub 10" screens (mobile) and in that world it works great. Using it as the default on 1366x768 and larger is just a huge waste of screen space. It isn't a UI that is designed for Mouse and keyboard and if anything works horribly with it. It is designed for a touch interface and I am sorry but I am not using a touch screen that large over a mouse/kb.
Why does high resolution automatically = large screen? What's wrong with a 10" high-DPI screen that runs at 1366x768?

And Metro still works all the way down at 1024x768, which is a rather popular resolution for 10" tablets (that's the screen resolution of the iPad 1 and 2)...so I don't really see the problem.

Now beyond metro, Win 8 is fairly good. It is essentially what Win 7 was to Vista. Same basic platform with some polish applied in a few key areas. However For those already with Win 7, it presents very little reason to consider it an upgrade path in the near future.
A lot of the features in the list in my previous post are far from minor polish. Integrated drive pooling and integrated Hyper-V are gigantic new features, as is the Windows Live integration (SkyDrive integration and settings-sync between PCs).
 
Why does high resolution automatically = large screen? What's wrong with a 10" high-DPI screen that runs at 1366x768?

And Metro still works all the way down at 1024x768, which is a rather popular resolution for 10" tablets (that's the screen resolution of the iPad 1 and 2)...so I don't really see the problem.

The point was it shouldn't be defaulted for larger resolutions as generally that resolution means a larger screen. Most smaller devices don't run that resolution, a minority do. Or they can do what they should of in the first place and make a different version for Tablets and not enable Metro in the non tablet version. Either way it is stupid to default it on larger resolutions and make it optional at the smaller resolutions.

A lot of the features in the list in my previous post are far from minor polish. Integrated drive pooling and integrated Hyper-V are gigantic new features, as is the Windows Live integration (SkyDrive integration and settings-sync between PCs).

Neither Drive pooling or integrated Hyper V are gigantic features for the overwhelming majority of users. I would dare say that those features aren't even applicable to the majority here. So no those aren't major features unless you fit in the minority that benefits from them and even then there are well established third party methods that those users likely already have in place. So really those are a nice perk but not much beyond that. Same applies to Windows live and skydrive integration, affects an extremely small minority.

Again, there is little major reason to upgrade to Win 8 if you are already running win 7.
 
They HAVE given official word on the matter, and I told you exactly where it came from. When they were talking about screen resolution limitations, they CLEARLY defined the breakdown.

1366x768 and higher = Full Metro experience.
At least 1024x768 = Metro experience with split-screen functionality disabled.
Any resolution below 1024x768 = Metro is automatically disabled.

The Windows 7 start menu is sticking around to service those small screens, and I've heard every indication that there will be a use-accessible setting to force it for larger screens (and a group policy so administrators can easily disable it on all of their machines).

You are correct on this specs but here's the thing. If you look at the Building Windows 8 blog practically every other post in that blog, which most of the topics having nothing to do with Metro, slam Metro and not a soul from Microsoft has mentioned anything about being able to disable Metro, and Steven Sinofsky himself posts on that blog.

If Microsoft intends for Metro be user enabled or disabled, they certainly aren't spreading the word. I thinks it's pretty obvious that at this point Microsoft isn't ready to commit on the matter one way or the other. Disabling the Start Screen effectively kills Metro apps considering the reliance that many Metro apps have on the Start Screen and the new Metro UI search system.

Personally I think this is nothing but another form of the bickering over the Office Ribbon and that turned out VERY well for Microsoft. Yes there's a number of keyboard and mouse issues with the Developer Preview but most of those are simply bugs. I think allowing users to easily disable would be a mistake as I think that would take a ton of steam of out the desire for developer to build Metro apps. For most people the mouse and keyboard are going to work just fine for what they do, all desktop[ programs work with mice as keyboards as they do in Windows 7 and Metro apps will be required to work with mice and keyboards as well as touch.

But again, it's pretty clear Microsoft is taking a wait see approach here, there may even be things that add to Metro to further enhance it's keyboard and mouse friendliness but considering all that Microsoft is putting on the line with Metro in Windows 8 there's just no way they want people to be able to disable the Start Screen unless there's just no other choice.
 
IMO they need to meld the metro UI and windows 7 desktop into 1. Basically maye the bottom row of the metro UI the windows taskbar, then make metro hang on the desktop. Flipping between the 2 is going to flip most people out. I cannot see it working well for MS in the end. THis version of windows is going to have a bad rep like vista (deserved or not)
 
Most of Windows ME's problems are caused by the beta version of Internet Explorer that it shipped with (and the shell is heavily based on IE... see the problem?)

Patch internet Explorer to the latest version, and ME suddenly becomes quite stable.
While it did have some problems, ME just wasn't needed because XP was just around the corner or you could have upgraded to Win2k.
 
Back
Top