EU Sends Microsoft Formal Antitrust Complaint

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Ugh. Not this again.

In 2009, the European Commission said it suspected Microsoft of using its dominant market position to foist its Internet Explorer browser on users. In negotiations, Microsoft agreed to create a screen where users could choose among competitors’ browsers. The Commission accepted that concession and made the creation of a ‘‘browser choice screen’’ legally binding.
 
Is it really that hard to open IE, type in www.google.com/ or mozilla.org and download a different browser?

Windows is Microsoft. I think they should be able to put whatever browser they wish on the OS they make.
 
Ridiculious... EU needs to f*ck off with this shit. No one is forcing people to use IE or even Windows for that matter. What's next? Hey, I can't play Playstation games on my XBox... waahhhhh... EU punish Microsoft for me!

It's insane.
 
Guys... they're foisting lots of Microsoft software onto those European people...

Just check all the programs that come pre-installed on Windows...

Calculator
Paint
Notepad

There is tons more than just those!

It's almost as if... It's freaking Microsoft Windows... if people are that whiny about this "issue" why don't they just download some free Linux distro... or will they complain that it is foisting some software written by that distros developers on it?
 
So, what if I buy an iMac? do I get the choice of using something other than Safari when I turn it on ? What about using something other than iTunes for my music management? This is a complete joke. At least with a Windows based machine I have the OPTION of using something else.
 
DriZzLe makes a very good point.

But Apple is aloud to do whatever they want... so your point is invalid.
 
I'm so sick and tired of these ass clowns making these claims. Every OS maker puts their own perfered web browser above any other. If it was such an issue they should be going after apple too. Also if a user doesn't know how to get another browser, they are too incompetant to care what browser they are using.

They might as well come out and say what they really mean, they need more money and microsoft is a easy target.
 
I think they should get a os with no browser then let them figure out how to DL another one.
 
So, what if I buy an iMac? do I get the choice of using something other than Safari when I turn it on ? What about using something other than iTunes for my music management? This is a complete joke. At least with a Windows based machine I have the OPTION of using something else.

Uh, EU + Apple = bedmates, didn't you know that? Just look at all the judges/courts over in Europe siding with Apple in a lot of the lawsuits over there... Seems Judge Koh here in the US procreated a bunch of clones over there LOL.
 
Next up, the EU brings an antitrust suit against Microsoft to force them to create a screen where users can choose among competitors’ Operating Systems. :rolleyes:
 
Microsoft could simply bundle installers for other browsers like Chrome on the desktop that users can run if they don't like or want IE.

Oh wait, no one will see the desktop now that Windows 8 hides it. And malware scanners will tag Chrome as spyware anyhow. :D
 
Isn't the EU's reason for not going after Apple something to do with them not being in a dominant/monopolistic position, unlike Microsoft?

Although I'm not sure if that's a good enough excuse.
 
I don't know what all of you are complaining about. A (potential) fine of $260 per copy of Windows 7 SP1 which didn't display the browser ballot (28 million out of around 170 million total) is completely fair and reasonable. Windows totally hasn't dropped down to the 50% market share that Nellie Kroes said MS deserves.

The EU can totally use that cash to subsidize* it's own home-grown monopolies to be more "competitive" in the rest of world.

* lol "subsidize". How it works: the EU "loans" money to industries like Airbus, for example, and doesn't require that it is repaid.

Can anyone explain to my while during the whole computer revolution these past couple of decades why the EU has been a total failure at producing a success in that industry? Bueller? Bueller?
 
Isn't the EU's reason for not going after Apple something to do with them not being in a dominant/monopolistic position, unlike Microsoft?
It is strange, isn't it? The EU investigation of Apple over iTMS and iPod kind of disappeared without Apple making any changes at all. Both of those represent monopolies in portable media players and downloadable music about as much as Windows is a "monopoly" on desktops.

Now, even with the various investigations over ebook price fixing, the EC is silent.

My guess is that despite Apple having the deepest of the deep pockets, it just doesn't attract the kind of support amongst (idiots|fine eurocrats) because Apple is beloved and MS is "hated".
 
I still think MS should see Windows in the EU with no IE, not medial player, no TCP/IP Stack.

Then tell the EU it was to protect themselves from lawsuits. Let MS resellers outside the EU get the business of selling the OS in the EU
 
Never understood this horseshit. Apple has a stranglehold on their part of the market; they make the hardware, the OS, everything. There is zero consumer choice, you can't buy a clone, etc.

... but OMG... IE !!! No you crossed the line Microsoft!
 
EU is on average ... retarded, thats why they have greece and spain in such deep sh!t now...
 
This is arguably the most ridiculous complaint in the tech industry. If you don't like IE, don't use it. Download another browser. It's Microsoft's right (whether the EU, US, or any other governmnet body challenges) to package their products together. ITS A FREAKIN BARGAIN. Imagine the uproar if MS completely removed the ability to surf the web from their OS. IE doesn't disable, prevent, or deter you from using any of the other browsers.

Imagine if MS removed IE and decided to charge us extra for it. This would result in another uproar and probably another lawsuit forcing MS to include it....

Not to mention, we'd all start getting those CD's with Chrome, Mozilla, Firefox, etc. in the mail.. like AOL used to do. No thanks, I'll take IE and start from there.
 
Not to mention, we'd all start getting those CD's with Chrome, Mozilla, Firefox, etc. in the mail.. like AOL used to do. No thanks, I'll take IE and start from there.

How about this, MS requries other browser makers to ship them CD's with their product on it, MS then includes that in the boxed copies of windows 8 that it sells, brilliant!!!
 
I think they should get a os with no browser then let them figure out how to DL another one.

This.

Microsoft just needs to pull out of the EU and let them figure out how to operate with the rest of the Windows machines on the planet on their own. Can't see how getting fined a few Billion dollars is good business for Microsoft.

The Logic here is too baffling to reason with. Why can't I put Ford parts in a Chevy then? Or why doesn't CBS show ABC's shows? On and on and on.

If you can't download your own browser without a prompt screen, then you probably should be sticking with the default anyways.

I can just see Apple laughing to itself in the corner.
 
Think of how many network monitoring software companies are stuggling while Microsoft continues to ship ping.exe for free!
 
For some reason the German goverment is obsessed with Firefox...

There are "N" versions in Europe which lack things like media player, yet no one buys them.

Uh, EU + Apple = bedmates, didn't you know that? Just look at all the judges/courts over in Europe siding with Apple in a lot of the lawsuits over there... Seems Judge Koh here in the US procreated a bunch of clones over there LOL.

They lost their lawsuits in the EU. It was in the EU where they were made to publically apologize to Samsung. :p

The only place crApple won was the US, in CA. :D
 
Gee, here I was unknowingly using Chrome on my Mac. Didn't know I was breaking some sort of rule.

Seriously people? Any excuse to bash Apple right? The reason MS is being targeted is because of their sheer OS market share, if Apple had the same market share, they would be in the same boat. And last I checked, I can install whatever I want on OS X. :rolleyes:

Same with Windows too, which is why the antitrust suit is laughable to me as well.
 
Oh yea: MS should stop shipping copies of windows with IE in the EU, and make them learn some DOS commands if they want to find any browser to install :p
 
Wait until they figure out that Windows 8 has Security Essentials built into Windows defender... that should stir up some more lawsuits.
 
How about this, MS requries other browser makers to ship them CD's with their product on it, MS then includes that in the boxed copies of windows 8 that it sells, brilliant!!!
But first ship them to the EU board that's heading this travesty for official approval, after which the board can forward them on to MS. :p
 
I'm so sick and tired of these ass clowns making these claims. Every OS maker puts their own perfered web browser above any other. If it was such an issue they should be going after apple too. Also if a user doesn't know how to get another browser, they are too incompetant to care what browser they are using.

They might as well come out and say what they really mean, they need more money and microsoft is a easy target.

That's is why anti-competitive laws are so funny. It is only illegal, if you are the big dog and people don't like you. So you as a company can be sitting there doing everything a certain way, as MS did and this exact business model is what allowed you to make a whole OS that created a unified experience people liked. But then all of a sudden everything that made you who you are is now illegal.

From what I understand the reason really great software like MS mesh and movie maker are not incuded in the OS, but are a free download is because of these silly rules. In fact one might even consider that MS may have wanted to price the surface lower, and now doubt their was pressure from their hardware partners, but what few talked about is, if MS priced surface even at 499 with a keyboard and that came with office, that would have been one hell of a deal about $200 worth of free features to get a decent tablet. And surely the EU would have made a couple billion off that.
 
EU needs more money to put into their "don't let Greece go bankrupt" fund. Let's get some of it from MS.

I don't think they should be charging 10% of MS's revenue. It makes money in a lot more markets than just a damn browser in their OS. They should charge on the revenue that MS makes from IE. All $0.
 
Back
Top