EU Going After Google Now

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The European Commission has launched an anti-trust investigation against Google after getting complaints the company is abusing its dominant position.

Telegraph.co.uk can reveal that the Commission has written to Google with a series of questions over how its search functions operate and also questioned the way it sells advertising. It acted after complaints from the UK search site Foundem, a price comparison site, Ciao, an online shopping site owned by Microsoft, and ejustice.fr, a French site which details legal cases and solicitor services.
 
Eu have to investigate after so many complaints and so on...

meaning they.. HAVE TO, they can't actually drop it.

But the problem is:
okey, i wanna know something about the 5870 for instance, cause i wanna know what there is about it, possible issues like gsod, how it stacks up to previous cards.

I go on google, and type in "ATi HD 5870"

what i see is amd's site, a norwegian site( obviously since i live in Norway.) some review sites, and abit down i start to see other search sites which compares prices, this is what google have done, moved them down.

sometimes i see a new search engine like that, and they do get moved down after a short while.
And that wikipedia usually gets on top is probally google's work too, it has very relevant facts, and it is a non-profit organization so i won't complain about that either.

I myself wudnt like the first page to be spammed down with just price comparison sites, so thats the question, is it right or wrong?
 
I don't know how they really have a case here. It's not like Google sells it's search engine or packages it in some way. People have to type in www.google.com into their web browser of choice. They are free to not do it and nothing other than the reputation of Google is preventing them.
 
sooner or later people will just stop dealing with these asshats

let them have their amd cpus and bing search engine and *nix based OS

If intel, ms and google just walk away maybe they'd stfu
 
The biggest question I've had from all this is. If a company is based in the US and their servers are in the US. How can some other country have any legal claim against them? Doesn't that company just have to abide by the laws of the country they and their equipment is in?

Like if I was hosting a site from my home in Texas that was accessible by anyone in the world and what I was doing violated Italy's, EU, Japan's privacy laws but not the US's laws. I'd assume I could simply give them the proverbial finger
 
The biggest question I've had from all this is. If a company is based in the US and their servers are in the US. How can some other country have any legal claim against them? Doesn't that company just have to abide by the laws of the country they and their equipment is in?

Like if I was hosting a site from my home in Texas that was accessible by anyone in the world and what I was doing violated Italy's, EU, Japan's privacy laws but not the US's laws. I'd assume I could simply give them the proverbial finger
Well, typically most of the companies the EU goes after, American or not, have offices located somewhere within the EU, and so between that and the fact they do business in the EU, it opens them up for investigation/fines/etc (not that I agree that it's right per-say).

As for Google, they have data centers in Europe and all over the world, so they're pretty well exposed to the restrictions and regulations of other countries.
 
YAY yet another shameless ploy by the EU to steal money, to help cover costs of their unsustainable governments, just a preview of things to come in America sadly.
 
YAY yet another shameless ploy by the EU to steal money, to help cover costs of their unsustainable governments, just a preview of things to come in America sadly.

Someone has to bail out the govt's of Greece and Spain.
 
Eu have to investigate after so many complaints and so on...

meaning they.. HAVE TO, they can't actually drop it.

But the problem is:
okey, i wanna know something about the 5870 for instance, cause i wanna know what there is about it, possible issues like gsod, how it stacks up to previous cards.

I go on google, and type in "ATi HD 5870"

what i see is amd's site, a norwegian site( obviously since i live in Norway.) some review sites, and abit down i start to see other search sites which compares prices, this is what google have done, moved them down.

sometimes i see a new search engine like that, and they do get moved down after a short while.
And that wikipedia usually gets on top is probally google's work too, it has very relevant facts, and it is a non-profit organization so i won't complain about that either.

I myself wudnt like the first page to be spammed down with just price comparison sites, so thats the question, is it right or wrong?

I don't see anything wrong with that, as I think priority should be given to the search results that the user is looking for. I don't think any user will google something just to click on another search engine to search for that item again.

If I google a graphic card, then I'd expect to ati nvidia page comes first, followed by perhaps wikipedia and other review sites. This is exactly the result that I'm searching for, I'm not looking for another search engine to search for me that item agian. So, theres nothing wrong with Google returning the results that I expect to get.

Its not googles fault that the user prefers direct results rather than some other search engine which is not what the user is looking for. Google is merely returning what the user wants.
 
these lawsuits are beginning to be annoying in the states, for god-sake, stop being greedy over yourself....its exactly it, people trying to get away with more money. I would hate to have to have my own company.
 
Damn I'm starting to hate Brussels, they are getting involved in crap that does not need meddling with. Does Alta-Vista, or Lycos advertise like Google...nope, who else can you think of that does web searches off the top of your head....Google, Yahoo, or Bing, all US based search providers, I'm failing to see how Google is unfairly cornering the market when the European search engines aren't advertising themselves in the slightest, besides being bundled with an internet service provider installation disc.
 
Give the people the power to choose what browser to use and still call it unfair....yep sounds about right.

Does the EU ever lose one of these cases or is it just rubber stamped FTW ?
 
Like someone posted, you do not have to use google. People choose to do so, the EU needs to DIAF, big government extortionists.
 
Back
Top