Electronic Arts Addresses 'Spore' DRM Issues

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
After taking a beating online over DRM issues with Spore, Electronic Arts says it will release a patch “soon” to allow the game to be installed on more than three computers. People hoping EA would dump SecuRom are out of luck though.

Perhaps the one reassuring thing that Multiplayer learned was that EA will be fixing the inability to install the game on more than three computers without having to call customer support and beg for an additional install allotment.
 
Crysis Warhead has that SecruRom crap too. I wish I would have known prior to launch. Oh well too late now, at least the game is fun.
 
Crysis Warhead has that SecruRom crap too. I wish I would have known prior to launch. Oh well too late now, at least the game is fun.

I'm sorry if I sound like a broken record, but we had multiple threads concerning this issue in "General Gaming", that explained (or tried to) that Crysis WarHead had SecuROM, much like the original Crysis and it was quite probable for it to enforce install limits.
 
To little to late and its only a mediocre game anyway.

Yup. I don't give my money to companies who feel that they need to treat their customers like filthy criminals just because someone inside the publishing company is leaking the game to p2p networks.
 
At least it's something. Not enough to appease me though (not that I was interested in playing Spore anyway).

I think companies should be required to state on the box whether a product contains DRM and exactly what that DRM comprises of.
 
The long and the short of this, is EA IS LISTENING. So lets keep shouting.
 
There was some kind of secure program with Crysis which was I think the only reason I didn't play it. CD emulation didn't work past patch 1.2 and it was a crappy game.
 
So what exactly is the issue? You can't install the game on more than one PC at all? Or you just can't play it at the same time? I'm not following.
 
At least it's something. Not enough to appease me though (not that I was interested in playing Spore anyway).

I think companies should be required to state on the box whether a product contains DRM and exactly what that DRM comprises of.

The long and the short of this, is EA IS LISTENING. So lets keep shouting.
In my eyes, this should never have been as issue as this should never had happened in the first place. Coming in after the fact and after hordes of angry people lambasted your decision to play damage control doesn't cut it for most people. Had this been a genuine, honest mistake, that's different. This was not a mistake by any means. Even after the changes, I will not buy this product.

If EA had *truly* listened before the game came out, they would have made the changes to the DRM. In theory LOL.
 
I'm curious, could it be that all the stories of DRM and piracy, and people pirating because of DRM being a setup by EA to pull the "We didn't sell very well because of the piracy that occurred" move?
 
So what exactly is the issue? You can't install the game on more than one PC at all? Or you just can't play it at the same time? I'm not following.

I think the issue is that you can only install the game a certain number of times and that's it. Once you hit the limit (reformatting, catastrophic loss, casual piracy, etc), it'll no longer activate and you've end up with a $50 box with a piece of round plastic inside.
 
In my eyes, this should never have been as issue as this should never had happened in the first place. Coming in after the fact and after hordes of angry people lambasted your decision to play damage control doesn't cut it for most people. Had this been a genuine, honest mistake, that's different. This was not a mistake by any means. Even after the changes, I will not buy this product.

If EA had *truly* listened before the game came out, they would have made the changes to the DRM. In theory LOL.

Oh, don't get me wrong. I won't be buying the game now. It still contains Securom, which I won't be putting on my computer.
 
You can install the game three times, each install requires online verification. After three installs you now have a game that will never verify online. Instead you have to call EA and 'convince' them that your fourth, fifth, whatever install should be verified and activated.

What is to stop me from saying "my tenth hard drive in five days crashed"? And who is some EA phone monkey to call me a liar?

The sad thing is I pre-ordered this piece of crap game. Warning about the game: IT SUCKS. It's short as hell, it's more like four little redundant flash games rolled into one. The graphics look like they targeted my girlfriends three year old laptop (the game runs fine on it). I especially like how they delayed the release of the game to increase the gameplay. At one time they were going to release this game with less gameplay????!!!

So now I have a shitty game I don't like and I don't even really own it. If I want to install it in the future I have to face either knowing that I may have surpassed my 3 installs, the EA verification servers may no longer exist, the patch that fixes problem #1 may be difficult to find (and it doesn't exist yet), and the patch to fix problem #2 ditto.

If I was going to play Spore I would uninstall the real official paid for version I have and just steal the fucking game anyway. Makes me mad, I could have spent that money on any number of other games.
 
Yeah, I googled the issue and found out the scoop. It's like having to activate Windows. I was confused by the original post here that said you couldn't install the game on more than 3 computers (which I guess is true too, but a bit misleading). Yeah, that's total crap. I reformat and change hardware a lot. I don't want to get stuck not being able to re-install a game. I was going to get Spore for my son for Christmas, but I think his PC already needs a reformat but I'm not ready to do it in the near future. That'd be like throwing away 1 install. I like to install my games on different computers that I have, for instance on my laptop. I also play the same copy on the LAN many times. I'm sorry, but I don't feel I should have to have a copy of the same game to put on my own 4 computers.

The thing about Steam and Warhead...I thought that was one of the things Steam bragged about was the ability to download your games from any where and that the game was tied to your account, not necessarily a liscense. What happened to that?
 
I'm sorry, but I don't feel I should have to have a copy of the same game to put on my own 4 computers.

Businesses don't like that for obvious reasons. That's probably one of the biggest reasons why publishers are so persistent on using DRM. Not to prevent piracy since we know that doesn't work, but to make honest customers pay for multiple licenses to install on multiple computers. Otherwise gamers would just install the same copy on all their machines.

Since installing a legit copy on several of your own computers is generally considered acceptable publishers can't outright try to criminalize it or risk severe backlash. Instead, they have to implement technological means to prevent this while using piracy as an excuse.

EA is a business. Their primary goal is to make money, not to make customers happy. Making customers happy may be a means to an end, but it's not the only way. EA knows that Spore is going to be a good seller despite the DRM, so there's no way they're going to get rid of it; not when they can profit off of it.
 
I refuse to buy a game that relies on the publisher's servers for the ability to play. I still occasionally play games I bought over 10 years ago. Do you honestly think EA will still have the Spore activation servers up 10 years from now? This is EA we're talking about here.

SecuRom is just another nail in the coffin. C'mon, EA, start respecting and listening to your customers.
 
I refuse to buy a game that relies on the publisher's servers for the ability to play. I still occasionally play games I bought over 10 years ago. Do you honestly think EA will still have the Spore activation servers up 10 years from now? This is EA we're talking about here.

I think EA said that they were going to release a patch to remove the activation if they ever permanently shut down their servers.

Of course, whether I can trust that they'd actually do this is another matter. Several years in the future and they won't have any financial incentive to do that. They'd rather sell new games than support old ones.
 
I have to say that EA actually does listen to their customers some. Apparently EA hosed my key on an update to BF2. After trying to get a hold of them, I was told I would have to send the CD back / key to get a new one. I am not running through a bunch of hoops to play some EA game that has been mutilated to badly by patches that most of the balance has been eliminated.

Regardless, I emailed them, and asked where I could send my cd back along w/ my two downloaded expansion packs. They said they were sorry it happened, yadda yadda. And offered me one free game from their library 360, wii, PC! It arrived a couple days later!

While I am not impressed w/ the BF2 stuff, I was somewhat impressed with their customer service.
 
I love this statement:

EA said as an example that of 437,138 people who had installed the game, 0.4% of which tried exceeding the limit.

So since 500,000 Non-DRM copies have been downloaded as of Tuesday, BitTorrent has successfully out done Big Box Retailers Sales.

This is not a black eye, this is an "Pulmonary Embolism" in the Brain of the Gaming Industry. If they don't know how to address DRM soon, then they drive consumers to copy their software from other sources.

DRM only looks to destroy the fun of actually owning a piece of software, not copying it.
 
Of course not, someone brought up the very valid point over at shacknews that who the hell will try to install the game 3 times in the 2 weeks its been out. Wait 4 months and then see how many people go over that limit. Also Spore was available a week ahead of retail release, as far as numbers go.
 
You know with all this Spore DRM stuff going around I can almost remember a time where the person who bought the software actually owned the software.
 
What makes things worse is when you can't play a game that you paid for when you're actually trying to use the disc! Two of my games, Ghost Recon: Advanced Warfighter and Star Wars Battlefront 2 won't play because when I put the ORIGINAL disc in, it tells me to please insert the original game disc! I'm able to play GRAW because I put a fixed .exe in, but SWBF2 doesn't have one. I tried to mount it in Daemon and use ProtStop, but when I try to hide Daemon it says there's nothing to hide. So I can't play that at all. I have to jump through hoops to play something I LEGITIMATELY own!
 
You know with all this Spore DRM stuff going around I can almost remember a time where the person who bought the software actually owned the software.

Most software sold after 1985 was sold as a license to use the software. You never owned the software, the company who makes the software owns it, you just get a license to use it, most of the time it is a single user license.
 
I guess for Battle of Middle Earth XLVIII, the Eye of Sauron will popup on your monitor and start deleting your executables for trying to install it on more than 1 PC.
 
'Bout time EA poked their ears up.

I guess it just takes a 1/2 million people screaming at the top of there lungs to get EA to listen, They should have heard us long ago! That is the problem enough people have to start yelling and threatening there bottom line before they listen, if they had listened before this they would have sold twice as many copies of Spore and there bottom line would look a lot better.

Its actually a pretty sad site to see EA is finally showing signs of listening to there customers, because there customers have been aching for a while now.
 
The thing is that I don't want to install my games on more than one computer. It's just that I don't want to be arbitrarily penalized, if I need to reinstall the game more than 3 times. Seriously EA I'm NOT pirating your games!! And I'm not helping others pirate your games. Why do you feel that you have to screw your customers? People like me are the ones keeping you in business.
 
I like EA's rational that only 0.4% of users had to install on more than 3 machines... alright, ummm how about you give me those numbers when the game has been out longer than a couple weeks, I dunno 6 months from now, a year, or two.

Bottom line, if you make a good game people are going to buy it... wait people buy the sims in large numbers for some reason... ok who knows, maybe it's like the average voting American, they're just stupid.
 
I bought the game, but I won't keep it with a three install liimit. I'm returning it today. I don't care how good a game is, the three install limit is a bit much. My issue isn't that I have a fundamental beef with copy protection. My problem is with how it is implemented. Consider this:

You have a clean Windows image of your rig, which is only used used for gaming. Every 3-6 months you restore the rig. Takes about 15 minutes. After you restore you only install the few games you're playing at the time. It's a whole lot quicker and cleaner than unistalling ten games, and trying to clean up all the crap left behind. It's a practical and a legitimate use of my computer.

If Spore is one of the games you want to reinstall you could be begging EA for an activation every few months. EA could say add Spore to the image, which might be fine for one game. If you had several games with the same limitation, that would ultimately make imaging pointless. So my beef is that I'd have to fundamentally change the way I use my computer.

There are certainly ways to accomplish what EA wants to do. Take Steam as an example. I hated it when I got HL2, but once it matured I became a big fan. It's a convenient and effective way to to ensure software is only being used by one licensee. Copy protection becomes a moot point, so it's one less development issue to wrangle with. Users can install their games on as many computers as they want, since you can only start one instance of the game for each account. EA could easily use something like Steam to meet their goal.

The DRM in Spore is just one more reason why I dislike EA. Spore was the first game I looked at from EA in almost two years, so I'll just go back to my boycott.
 
I agree about Steam.. I thought I would hate it, but I finally decided to give it a try and buy a cheap game or two to see how it would work. So far it has worked great. I suppose I'll eventually run into some activation brickwall, though - I've had to redownload half a dozen times already when reformatting due to upgrades, an OS switch and just general "housekeeping".

On the other hand, I also decided to give both iTunes and MSN Music a try... I lost my iTunes songs when reformatting (not to mention I couldn't move them to my mp3 player) and well, we all know what happened to MSN Music.

Also, when reinstalling Two Worlds for the fourth times or something, Zuxxez expected me to make a long-distance call to Germany and beg them to grant me more activations. Also this was on a friday after business hours and I wanted to play the game over the weekend. So they won't get my money again. I shouldn't have to pay for an international call and then beg for more activations when I've already paid €50+ for the game.

So I'm still against any form of copy protection that requires the software (or media) to "phone home" to validate.
 
I agree about Steam.. I thought I would hate it, but I finally decided to give it a try and buy a cheap game or two to see how it would work. So far it has worked great. I suppose I'll eventually run into some activation brickwall, though - I've had to redownload half a dozen times already when reformatting due to upgrades, an OS switch and just general "housekeeping".

On the other hand, I also decided to give both iTunes and MSN Music a try... I lost my iTunes songs when reformatting (not to mention I couldn't move them to my mp3 player) and well, we all know what happened to MSN Music.

Also, when reinstalling Two Worlds for the fourth times or something, Zuxxez expected me to make a long-distance call to Germany and beg them to grant me more activations. Also this was on a friday after business hours and I wanted to play the game over the weekend. So they won't get my money again. I shouldn't have to pay for an international call and then beg for more activations when I've already paid €50+ for the game.

So I'm still against any form of copy protection that requires the software (or media) to "phone home" to validate.

Yeah, I got hosed by MSN music, too. Only for a couple of tunes, though. I'm still not a member of any on-line music store because of that experience.

You can save time with Steam by creating a local backup. I keep them on my external backup drive. I also keep copies of the game keys (if I got one with the game). I haven't had to try it, but I think you could reinstall in off-line mode with the local files and the keys.

Your point makes a lot of sense, though. You shouldn't have to contact a remote system to reinstall your software. Even Vista lets you run the installation, then gives you 30 days to activate.
 
Back
Top