EA CEO: We Were Torturing Game Devs

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Electronic Arts CEO John Riccitiello, speaking at an investors meeting, admitted that EA had been “torturing a very talented group of people” with rigorous 12 month development cycles during the development of the Need For Speed series.

Electronic Arts attributes this to the fact that EA Vancouver had been producing a new Need for Speed game every single year for the past eight years. That changed last summer, when EA split the company into two teams, hired more people, and put both teams on two year development cycles.
 
they're also torturing the gamers by putting out the same old crap over and over again
 
the Underground section of the series got old half way through the first one, let alone the second one. Most wanted was a nice change, new features, and races that didn't take place entirely at night...thank fucking god. Carbon was alright I guess. Downhill chases and drifting were dumb modes, and the muscle cars handled like complete shit. ProStreet was the first game I didn't play though, multiple times. As a matter of fact, I didn't even play 1/4 way through it once. Utter garbage. They went from fun arcade racer with exotic cars to Arcade racer full of rice rockets, to badass that's got all of the cops after him, to street racing. It's all been downhill since Porche Unleashed, and I can't tell you how many times I've heard that from so many people.

The whole appeal behind the series initially, was being able to haul ass down roads that were in countries we may never get to go to, in cars that we couldn't afford to buy, or would have to trade our houses for. Now we get to outrun the cops in a rice rocket at night on rain-slick city streets that resemble LA? Who the fuck cares? We're drift racing, going lock to lock in some car that a fucking 16 year old kid can buy for a few grand and take to a high HP shiny version of it's former self? Any kid with a job at 16 can save enough to buy a Honda Civic and trick it out, and for under $10k.

We've gone from the fantasy of grown men (racing exotics on outdoor tracks in foreign locales) to the fantasies of 16 year old (the ones that don't have jobs) and racing Japanese cars that are gutless on a street racing circuit. What the FUCK happened to this series?

Perhaps it is EA's fault (god knows, I blame them for enough shit, already) for driving the timeline so hard that creativity is out the door at this point. Honestly, if they come to market with the next game, and it's Most Wanted 2 (with, or without that specific title) in any way, I'm going to abandon ship, once and for all. I still have all of the older games, and I play through them again, every once in a while. The ones I don't replay are the Underground -> ON titles. I used to love MechWarrior too, but I had to give up that addiction as well. It could be time to let this one go, for better or for worse.
 
If you push devs too hard, creativity suffers. Games aren't assembly line products.
 
the Underground section of the series got old half way through the first one, let alone the second one. Most wanted was a nice change, new features, and races that didn't take place entirely at night...thank fucking god. Carbon was alright I guess. Downhill chases and drifting were dumb modes, and the muscle cars handled like complete shit. ProStreet was the first game I didn't play though, multiple times. As a matter of fact, I didn't even play 1/4 way through it once. Utter garbage. They went from fun arcade racer with exotic cars to Arcade racer full of rice rockets, to badass that's got all of the cops after him, to street racing. It's all been downhill since Porche Unleashed, and I can't tell you how many times I've heard that from so many people.

The whole appeal behind the series initially, was being able to haul ass down roads that were in countries we may never get to go to, in cars that we couldn't afford to buy, or would have to trade our houses for. Now we get to outrun the cops in a rice rocket at night on rain-slick city streets that resemble LA? Who the fuck cares? We're drift racing, going lock to lock in some car that a fucking 16 year old kid can buy for a few grand and take to a high HP shiny version of it's former self? Any kid with a job at 16 can save enough to buy a Honda Civic and trick it out, and for under $10k.

We've gone from the fantasy of grown men (racing exotics on outdoor tracks in foreign locales) to the fantasies of 16 year old (the ones that don't have jobs) and racing Japanese cars that are gutless on a street racing circuit. What the FUCK happened to this series?

Perhaps it is EA's fault (god knows, I blame them for enough shit, already) for driving the timeline so hard that creativity is out the door at this point. Honestly, if they come to market with the next game, and it's Most Wanted 2 (with, or without that specific title) in any way, I'm going to abandon ship, once and for all. I still have all of the older games, and I play through them again, every once in a while. The ones I don't replay are the Underground -> ON titles. I used to love MechWarrior too, but I had to give up that addiction as well. It could be time to let this one go, for better or for worse.

amen.

bring back NFS SE, HP, HS, and PU.

Those were the days. Now for any decent driving Im playing user modded versions of Rfactor and a 7 year old F1 game from EA.
 
If you push devs too hard, creativity suffers. Games aren't assembly line products.

qftx1000

how many games have suffered because of this, and how many studios folded...

as for the need for speed. physics and control wise porsche unleased was one of their best games. however it was all porsche :(

after that though i agree completely, its like they took notes from porsche and then made sure everything they did right were the things to exclude from the next games.
 
Mr. Riccitiello has apparently forgotten our policy - "The US does not torture." Although apparently "enhanced motivation techniques" may have been used... :)

Like many others have stated, I miss the old Need for Speed series... I dropped out after Hot Persuit 2 or so... just lost interest I guess... I'd like to give it another shot, this is if they can get their "mojo" back.
 
i quit playing uo... for many reasons after EA got to involved.. i started disliking their antiamerican 100 hour workweeks that forced employees to skip holidays and time with families... to meet deadlines.

then im like... maybe they have 1 year of hell... then 3 years enjoying their sucesses. the game had to reach a certain deadline... it went into beta (the 3d expansion)... i was a beta tester for about 24 hours before they made it go gold... with thousands of horrible bugs. they made it go gold. what was the point?

it was met with horrible reviews, people were in shock that it was released when beta was only a few days long and no issues were addresses. so what happened after their hard work paid off? "reorganization" aka firing of all their staff.

this might sound ok... but when OSI was completely shut down by EA (uo's genious creators)... they fired each of their employees as well.

so 3-5 expansion packs later:
1 year 100 hour work week... followed by incomplete released... followed by rushed deadline... followed by entire staff or parts being fired... followed by shitty reviews and thousands quitting

its not piracy killing ea's business, its the ability to fuck their own employees and games over to make quick money now rather than longterm money later.
 
bring back NFS SE, HP, HS, and PU.
There is no better NFS game than Porsche Unleashed, you ask me. Take the same basic concept (perhaps with the Ferrari brand), add a dash of Hot Pursuit, simmer for two years and we'd be talking about one killer game.
 
I am trying to find this guys e-mail address, and turned up this:

Mr. Riccitiello has served as Chief Executive Officer and a Director of Electronic Arts since April 2007. Prior to re-joining Electronic Arts, he was a co-founder and Managing Partner at Elevation Partners, a private equity fund. From October 1997 to April 2004, he served as President and Chief Operating Officer of Electronic Arts. Prior to joining Electronic Arts, Mr. Riccitiello served as President and Chief Executive Officer of the worldwide bakery division at Sara Lee Corporation. Before joining Sara Lee, he served as President and CEO of Wilson Sporting Goods Co. and has also held executive management positions at Haagen-Dazs, PepsiCo, Inc. and The Clorox Company. Mr. Riccitiello holds a B.S. degree from the University of California, Berkeley.
http://www.portfolio.com/resources/executive-profiles/John-S-Riccitiello-13884

Here's the timeline (from Wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Need_for_Speed):
2.1 The Need for Speed Release Date:US: May 27, 1997
2.2 Need for Speed II Release Date:US: April 12, 1997
John S. Riccitiello in office @ EA
2.3 Need for Speed: V-Rally Release Date: US: November 4, 1997
2.4 Need for Speed III: Hot Pursuit Release Date:US: September 27, 1998
2.5 Need For Speed: V-Rally 2 Release Date:US: November 16, 1999
2.6 Need for Speed: High Stakes Release Date:US: June 20, 1999
2.7 Need for Speed: Porsche Unleashed Release Date:US: March 24, 2000
2.8 Motor City Online Release Date: US: October 31, 2001
2.9 Need for Speed: Hot Pursuit 2 Release Date:US: October 21, 2002
2.10 Need for Speed: Underground Release Date:US: November 20, 2003
2.11 Need for Speed: Underground 2 Release Date:US: November 9, 2004
2.12 Need for Speed: Underground Rivals Release Date:US: March 18, 2005
2.13 Need for Speed: Most Wanted Release Date:US: November 15, 2005
2.14 Need for Speed: Carbon Release Date:US: October 30, 2006
John S. Riccitiello in office @ EA
2.15 Need for Speed: ProStreet US: November 13, 2007
2.16 Need for Speed: Undercover (2008)

Just thought it would be interesting to note when this guy was in office, and for what games. Still looking for the e-mail address.
 
There is no better NFS game than Porsche Unleashed, you ask me. Take the same basic concept (perhaps with the Ferrari brand), add a dash of Hot Pursuit, simmer for two years and we'd be talking about one killer game.

PU did have cops, in factory driver mode.

qftx1000

how many games have suffered because of this, and how many studios folded...

as for the need for speed. physics and control wise porsche unleased was one of their best games. however it was all porsche :(

after that though i agree completely, its like they took notes from porsche and then made sure everything they did right were the things to exclude from the next games.

Agreed, I am not much of a Porsche fan.

amen.

bring back NFS SE, HP, HS, and PU.

Those were the days. Now for any decent driving Im playing user modded versions of Rfactor and a 7 year old F1 game from EA.

NFS SE / NFS 2SE were actually more realistic than most of the others.
 
I am trying to find this guys e-mail address, and turned up this: *snip*

:eek: Didn't realize they came out that quick in a row :eek:

There is no better NFS game than Porsche Unleashed, you ask me.

QFT - That game was fun.... looked pretty dang nice, too, imo.

If only there was a racing game with nothing but Vipers... *dream* (yeah, yeah... not as aged and storied as Porsche... but they're still awesome... and $/hp is pretty decent, too... well, for that number of ponies, at least :D)
 
The next one should be "Tesla Roadster: Unleashed" ... all electric baby, 100% Torque, 100% of the time!
 
If you push devs too hard, creativity suffers. Games aren't assembly line products.

This is so true.

But your forgetting, this is EA policy on creating games. Need for Speed and the Madden series are huge examples of this. BF2 to BF2142 is another example. BF2142 is just a futuristic mod for BF2, nothing more. Im honestly shocked BF3 isnt out yet. I know they been focusing there attention on Bad Company for the consoles, but with the popularity of BF2 and the semi popularity of BF2142, I thought for sure another one would be out for now. The Sims 2 expansions at one point were another example too, but those seemed to slow down since there gearing up for Sims 3.
 
If only there was a racing game with nothing but Vipers...
Why, there is. 1998's Viper Racing. The funny thing about the game is that the damage model can basically go on forever. It's actually possible to turn your car into a tiny little ball of wreckage with wheels if you figure out a way to smash it up enough.
 
You had to go and mention NFS PU.. now I want to play it again.

The only downfall to that game was that it was rediculously easy to make money by buying used cars, fixing them, and then selling them for a profit.

After basically mastering the game, it was my goal to own one of every single car in the game... some cars were available used that were not available to buy new.
 
the Underground section of the series got old half way through the first one, let alone the second one. Most wanted was a nice change, new features, and races that didn't take place entirely at night...thank fucking god. Carbon was alright I guess. Downhill chases and drifting were dumb modes, and the muscle cars handled like complete shit. ProStreet was the first game I didn't play though, multiple times. As a matter of fact, I didn't even play 1/4 way through it once. Utter garbage. They went from fun arcade racer with exotic cars to Arcade racer full of rice rockets, to badass that's got all of the cops after him, to street racing. It's all been downhill since Porche Unleashed, and I can't tell you how many times I've heard that from so many people.

The whole appeal behind the series initially, was being able to haul ass down roads that were in countries we may never get to go to, in cars that we couldn't afford to buy, or would have to trade our houses for. Now we get to outrun the cops in a rice rocket at night on rain-slick city streets that resemble LA? Who the fuck cares? We're drift racing, going lock to lock in some car that a fucking 16 year old kid can buy for a few grand and take to a high HP shiny version of it's former self? Any kid with a job at 16 can save enough to buy a Honda Civic and trick it out, and for under $10k.

We've gone from the fantasy of grown men (racing exotics on outdoor tracks in foreign locales) to the fantasies of 16 year old (the ones that don't have jobs) and racing Japanese cars that are gutless on a street racing circuit. What the FUCK happened to this series?

Perhaps it is EA's fault (god knows, I blame them for enough shit, already) for driving the timeline so hard that creativity is out the door at this point. Honestly, if they come to market with the next game, and it's Most Wanted 2 (with, or without that specific title) in any way, I'm going to abandon ship, once and for all. I still have all of the older games, and I play through them again, every once in a while. The ones I don't replay are the Underground -> ON titles. I used to love MechWarrior too, but I had to give up that addiction as well. It could be time to let this one go, for better or for worse.
I just have to say that I'm with you here. I had been a big Need for Speed fan since I was a kid playing Need for Speed 1. NFS 3 was the best game ever. EA lost me at Need for Speed Hot Pursuit 2, which I thought was just lame. With the exception of Most Wanted, which I enjoyed, every one of the last several NFS games has ranged from suck to "meh."

I think you're definitely onto something about EA bringing their target audience from adults to kids. They must think that adults don't want to play video games at all now, judging by all their recent crap.

And for the record, I used to love Mechwarrior too (especially Two).
 
Why, there is. 1998's Viper Racing. The funny thing about the game is that the damage model can basically go on forever. It's actually possible to turn your car into a tiny little ball of wreckage with wheels if you figure out a way to smash it up enough.

i forgot about viper racing. one of the best pc racers ever, and thats solely because it was creative and different. i LOVED crashing those things up!
 
...And for the record, I used to love Mechwarrior too (especially Two).

Oh man, I loved mechwarrior, those games were awesome! EA has gone so far downhill though... I made the mistake of playing Mechwarrior: Lone Wolf 1 and 2.... horrible, horrible games.
I can't believe no one in this thread has called out BF: Heroes for the obvious TF2 ripoff. No doubt it will suck just as hard as the other crap EA has been forcing onto the shelves lately....
EA used to be so good. What happened? Like we can't tell they're just recycling the same crap games.
 
Soon as they bought Origin, trashed UO, and canceled the partially done sequal, I put EA on my forever shit list.
My wife is really into the sims games, sims 2 though she often downloads user made mod packs that have MUCH MUCH more content than the actual expansions... Better textures too, etc...
 
Mr. Riccitiello has apparently forgotten our policy - "The US does not torture." Although apparently "enhanced motivation techniques" may have been used... :)

EA Vancouver is up here in Canada, so this is clearly an example of "Extraordinary Rendition", which is U.S Policy. ;)

Or should that be "Extraordinary Rendering"?
 
Back
Top