Dual Mac G5 2.5GHz

D3v1an7

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Oct 22, 2003
Messages
1,256
Did anyone else read that review from the main page?
Using the free Temperature Monitor app, the CPU temp is observed to stay primarily in the 75-85°C range for CPU A, and a bit cooler for CPU B.

85°C!!!!!

That is nearly 200°F. I don't care what kind of chip that is, silicone has its limits and that has got to be right at the max before permanent damage is done to the chip.

and these tests were done under ideal conditions. What kind of temps is this thing going to have after a family of dust bunnies makes their home in the case and on that shiny heat exchanger?

Looks to me like Mac has built a $3000 fire hazard

At least now you can photoshop and cook a Cup-O-Noobles without having to get up from your computer...
 
I guess price is directly porportional to cost for Macs. I'll be sticking to my x86 platform thank you. If Apple really wanted to impress me and get my business, they'd release their version of OSX that is built for x86 platforms. It does in fact exist, as they demoed it to a select few at their least Mac Cult Meeting.
 
djnes said:
I guess price is directly porportional to cost for Macs. I'll be sticking to my x86 platform thank you. If Apple really wanted to impress me and get my business, they'd release their version of OSX that is built for x86 platforms. It does in fact exist, as they demoed it to a select few at their least Mac Cult Meeting.

Your right it does exist, that would be a great first step into opening a ton of opportunity.

wtf is steve jobs thinking by not doing this?
 
Big Worm said:
Your right it does exist, that would be a great first step into opening a ton of opportunity.

wtf is steve jobs thinking by not doing this?


I like OSX....I've used it several times with friends of mine. But, I could buy 2 brand new Centrino laptops for the cost of one apple laptop. Their hardware costs are insane and so are the people willing to pay them. There are quite a few people fed up with Microsoft, but love the hardware they have. Apple would have such a postive response if the decided to do this. Positive from everyone but Microsoft, of course.
 
Big Worm said:
Your right it does exist, that would be a great first step into opening a ton of opportunity.

wtf is steve jobs thinking by not doing this?

Hes thinking: If i release a cross platform version of my OS, i can make some money, but then ill loose the profit generated off my over priced computers i sell that weight roughlt 75lbs each.
 
Not only that, but they loose control.

The whole reason MACs have a reputation for stability is they have no variables in hardware configuration.

To fully port OSX to X86 computers, MAC would have to deal with the same issues that MS has been dealing with for years, namely poorly designed hardware and terrible drivers.

Bottom line, they simply don't have the experience in programming an OS that is compatable with the open market.
 
Well the maximum temperatures on some of the Athlon64's is 95 degrees Celsius, so it's not like they're running them out of spec.
 
Is that the max temp they can reach before damage or is that the normal temp under load?

The article said that these new chips run at 75-85C

If my chip was hot enough to boil a bot of water on, I would be a little bit worried.
 
Worse, if it is water cooled, it is a bad idea to run it at temps that approach the boiling point of water. (boiling water in pipes -> high pressure steam -> ruptured WC system -> $3000 paperweight and a complete and total ass raping by apple tech support. (which, last time I experienced it (~3 years ago) sucked))
 
I may very well be wrong, but from the pictures, it looked like more of a funky heat-pipe cooler than a true water cooling setup. I saw metal pipes going from a block to a radiator, sorta like a shuttle ICE cooler. Could be looking wrong though. Either way, that seems way too hot. Even if its max temp is 100C, a slight change in conditions or loss of effiicency in the cooler could fry those chips before you knew what happened.
 
Tim said:
Well the maximum temperatures on some of the Athlon64's is 95 degrees Celsius, so it's not like they're running them out of spec.

True, but the cooler they run, the better. I still agree on the priciple of "if it ain't causing problems, it ain't too hot"

Still, you have to wonder why something running at stock speeds requires water cooling. Secondly, Delphi designed the Corsair HydroCool that Kyle and Co. didn't seem all that thrilled about, and the response they got from Delphi was something like "we know what we're doing so bug off". If the [H] is right on the money with the HydroCool, it could be that the same engineering issues were inherited on the G5 H2O setup. This is all pure speculation, but something to think about.
 
Back
Top