DoT Wants a Cell Phone Kill Switch

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
The Department of Transportation is exploring methods required to make your vehicle a dead zone for cell phones. Citing the high rate of accidents attributed to cell phone use while driving, the DoT is looking for ways to block the use of cell phones within the confines of your vehicle.

DoT spokesperson Olivia Alair went on to clarify that although the agency is analyzing such technology, it has "no intention" of requiring it as law at this point.
 
I think it may be time to revolt. Next they will tell us only those who have a 4 year degree in automobile navigation will be allowed to obtain a drivers license because the masses are just too stupid to know how to do it.
 
If only the person on the phone causing the crash is the only one who gets killed...

Disabling cell phones on a moving vehicle should be simple, the radio transmission from the cellphone will give off a detectable red or blue shift to cell towers, allowing them to cut the call off if it's not to 911. It's basically marking the person's relative velocity like a radar gun.
 
Hope I don't get in an accident and have to call 911. Or my wife doesn't need to call or text that we are running late. Or use my phones GPS.

I have an idea. Let's get rid of cell phones, car stereos, GPS, OnStar, radar detectors, and cup holders. They distract us while driving.
 
If only the person on the phone causing the crash is the only one who gets killed...

Disabling cell phones on a moving vehicle should be simple, the radio transmission from the cellphone will give off a detectable red or blue shift to cell towers, allowing them to cut the call off if it's not to 911. It's basically marking the person's relative velocity like a radar gun.

Also, if you're stuck in a traffic jam or stop on the side of the road, the phone works immediately.

Much better idea than installing anything in your car.
 
While I think that texting and having a phone shoved in your ear is equivalent to drunk driving in most cases, I don't believe a that jamming cell phones is the answer. Most state already have serious fines for that. If a cop sees you breaking the law, he can pull you over and ticket you same as for other infractions.

A more realistic though not proactive approach, is pulling phone records. In the case of a crash, just subpoena phone records. Oooops caught you there, here is your fine and points on your license. Good luck affording or even getting insurance with what amounts to a DUI as far as the insurance companies are concerned.
 
This is dumb. How could they tell the difference between a driver using the phone or a passenger? Fuck the government and their intrusions. If a civil war is what they want they'll get one soon enough if they keep it up.
 
A more realistic though not proactive approach, is pulling phone records. In the case of a crash, just subpoena phone records. Oooops caught you there, here is your fine and points on your license. Good luck affording or even getting insurance with what amounts to a DUI as far as the insurance companies are concerned.

Since that is a reasonable and well thought out solution to the problem, it will never fly. Politicians like to appear to be proactive rather than reactive to win voter support. Even if that means restricting our personal liberties.
I really do not believe jamming is a great idea. Since it seems like they want it to only jam devices inside the car, why not stick your hand out the window while texting, then I can patent my phone leash idea so you won't accidentally drop it out of your moving vehicle. NVM, I do support jamming.
 
While I think that texting and having a phone shoved in your ear is equivalent to drunk driving in most cases, I don't believe a that jamming cell phones is the answer. Most state already have serious fines for that. If a cop sees you breaking the law, he can pull you over and ticket you same as for other infractions.

A more realistic though not proactive approach, is pulling phone records. In the case of a crash, just subpoena phone records. Oooops caught you there, here is your fine and points on your license. Good luck affording or even getting insurance with what amounts to a DUI as far as the insurance companies are concerned.
Phone records won't tell you who in the vehicle is talking on the phone, only who the phone is in the name of.
 
A more realistic though not proactive approach, is pulling phone records. In the case of a crash, just subpoena phone records.

I've heard of detectives doing this already and I'm sure you have to. I have a list of things the DOT should outlaw before cell phones.

1. Eating while driving
2. Women doing their makeup
3. Fiddling with radios/mp3 players
4. Reading (books/maps/etc)

I think those are more dangerous than using a cell phone.
 
I'm amazed when driving to see how many people still hold the phone to their ear when 99% of phones sold have speaker phone, or blue tooth capability. Give me a break. Use a handsfree, it makes a difference.
 
Phone records won't tell you who in the vehicle is talking on the phone, only who the phone is in the name of.

Agreed.

"No your honor, I'd asked my brother to take my phone and call the #. He then put it on speaker."

;)
 
Phone records won't tell you who in the vehicle is talking on the phone, only who the phone is in the name of.

Yeah, the driver could have said to his child, 'Hey, call your mom and let her know we'll be home soon.' Unless you want to outlaw speech inside cars too.
 
I've heard of detectives doing this already and I'm sure you have to. I have a list of things the DOT should outlaw before cell phones.

1. Eating while driving
2. Women doing their makeup
3. Fiddling with radios/mp3 players
4. Reading (books/maps/etc)

I think those are more dangerous than using a cell phone.

I don't see how any of these are more dangerous than operating a cell phone. They all distract the driver in the same way.
 
I think it may be time to revolt. Next they will tell us only those who have a 4 year degree in automobile navigation will be allowed to obtain a drivers license because the masses are just too stupid to know how to do it.
Well, that is actually true. I figured that part was obvious. Heh.

Maybe they should test it in movie theaters first.

Good one, I would love that.
 
Since it seems like they want it to only jam devices inside the car, why not stick your hand out the window while texting, then I can patent my phone leash idea so you won't accidentally drop it out of your moving vehicle. NVM, I do support jamming.

This is why this won't work. People immediately start thinking of ways to get around it - usually in ways that only cause MORE danger than letting people outright use the phone.

Plus, don't jammers have to be more powerful than the thing they are jamming? In order for a car jammer to work you'd have to subject everything in the car to a higher level of radiation than a cell phone normally operates at the entire time people are inside the car. I guess that would at least accelerate research on 'does cell phone radiation cause cancer'.
 
I've heard of detectives doing this already and I'm sure you have to. I have a list of things the DOT should outlaw before cell phones.

1. Eating while driving
2. Women doing their makeup
3. Fiddling with radios/mp3 players
4. Reading (books/maps/etc)

I think those are more dangerous than using a cell phone.

And driving with a dog in your lap...I can't say how many times I've seen this and thought "There's a DOA waiting to happen...".
 
In all seriousness. They are needed in case of an emergency, so why not treat it like a DUI? Most of these people are repeat offenders, so 3 strikes and your license gets revoked.
 
People against cell phones in cars have no lives or don't spend any time in their car.
 
...<snip>... because the masses are just too stupid to know how to do it.

Well, you may have a point there! I mean where I live its illegal to talk on a cell phone while you're driving without a headset. But it seems like people ignore that law, just like they ignore speed limits, and traffic lights... etc. It really is incredibly "STUPID"! And the best solution might be to NOT let them drive. I would actually be for their own good.
 
i have microsoft sync in my car, i dont even have to glance at my phone to answer it, or get text messages to me. it uses text to speech to read them to me.

almost all ford vehicles have it now, hyundai has a spin off with the same features.

this is rediculous. just give people tickets for putting their cells up to their faces.
 
I don't see how any of these are more dangerous than operating a cell phone. They all distract the driver in the same way.

Well that's sort of my point. There are tons of in-car activities that are just as distracting or more so. I think children screaming in the back seat should be outlawed. When a phone is on speaker, there is absolutely no difference between talking into the speaker or talking to someone in the car.
 
So the people who drive vehicles for the DOT would be subject to this as well?
 
If only the person on the phone causing the crash is the only one who gets killed...

Disabling cell phones on a moving vehicle should be simple, the radio transmission from the cellphone will give off a detectable red or blue shift to cell towers, allowing them to cut the call off if it's not to 911. It's basically marking the person's relative velocity like a radar gun.

I've said they should do that for years and even stated it on this board. I generally got ripped a new one too. My wife texts and drives and I can't friggin stand it. She is endagering others AND herself.
 
what did you ever do before cell phones...

once again, driving is a privilege not a right
 
What if my family needs to get a hold of me in an emergency while I am driving?

I am also on call for my job. How would they get a hold of me? I am not going to sit at home waiting for a call to go to work like a prisoner in my own home.
 
Would the red or blue shift thing really work? I wouldn't have thought that a change in 30-60MPH out of 186,000 MPS would shift it enough to measure. Not to mention that the shift happens in parallel with the signal - what if you are moving transversally to the tower? You'd be better off trying to triangulate the phone, although I doubt the cell companies want to triangulate hundreds or thousands of active phones at once.

This is a stupid idea though. What if someone is on a train or plane or something? What about people whose jobs require pagers, such as firefighters, police, etc?
 
Just looking at the speedometer is distration enough to cause a crash. Nowadays with NAV, LCD screens piping weather, directions, streaming content and what not "accidents" are destined to increase.

If they outlaw cell phones, all billboards should follow suit. Those new LED super bright insanities on the highway are a major distraction to some people. People are drawn to flashing/bright color. So when those bright displays change their ad/message people gawk and start veering all over the place. Just like they do when they pass accidents and stare at the emergency vehicle lights. Some people are nothing more then zombies.
 
What if my family needs to get a hold of me in an emergency while I am driving?

I am also on call for my job. How would they get a hold of me? I am not going to sit at home waiting for a call to go to work like a prisoner in my own home.

This was my thought. Oops sorry I was driving to the gas station and the government decided I can't answer the hospital while I'm in my car. So sorry for your loss.
 
What if my family needs to get a hold of me in an emergency while I am driving?

I am also on call for my job. How would they get a hold of me? I am not going to sit at home waiting for a call to go to work like a prisoner in my own home.

So true - look they're already enforcing the no cell phone rules while driving. It didn't use to bother me as much before but so many people are just such dickheads while driving that them having a cell phone is such a bad idea. If I get a message or a call I'll wait till I'm at a light or something to check what's up and if it's important I'll stop and call back. If there's no traffic I see no wrong in talking on the cell phone, but here in LA where I live, that's rare - but driving out of town why the eff not.

Killing cell phones in cars is absolute rtard:

-passengers
-in cabs
-on busses
-calling in drunk drivers (I've called in before after seeing some MAD drunk drivers swerving and nearly hitting people - if you've ever seen a REALLY drunk person on the road, it's f* scary)
-emergencies
-streaming radio
-navigation/directions
-dooo I need to continue?
 
There's already a killswitch...it's called an M82A1 with HEIAP ammunition.
 
I was stopped in traffic on Interstate 95 in a long line of cars in a backed up exit lane. I was the last vehicle. A woman from a neighboring state crashed into my rear bumper at full interstate highway speed. She was talking on the cell phone and never saw us stopped. She never hit the brakes. Miraculously I wasn't severely injured, but she was.

That said, I hate the "nanny state" mentality. Every new rule and reg causes the government to become more ponderous in more ways than one.
 
I would rather the DOT explore methods of affixing bombs to cyclists that explode should they decide to swerve into traffic for no apparent reason fifty feet in front of me when I'm doing 45 miles per hour.

That I would like. I'd take the fucking cellphone killswitch as a compromise if the cyclists have to wear explosive devices to keep their dipshit habits in check.
 
Back
Top