Does this sound like a problem w. GPU, or PSU, or other component?

Jones2504

n00b
Joined
Apr 1, 2007
Messages
61
Hi,

I built a PC about 4 years ago. For nearly the whole time, I've had Geforce 7600 GS graphics card. About a month ago, I replaced it with a second-hand Geforce 8800 GT card (Inno3D, 512 MB, with passive cooling.)

When playing Skyrim on medium settings, or above, after some time, the screen would freeze/"melt", and a horrible hissing noise would come from the speakers.

So I set it to the lowest settings, and it seemed to work fine.

Then after a couple of weeks, the PC started 'crashing' - the screen would suddenly go blue (not a BSOD, no error messages) - sometimes with a different coloured 'bar' on top (red?). This happened even when I wasn't playing any games - eventually, this would happen right (or at least a few minutes) after Windows loading.

So I put the old GF7300 back in, and haven't had any problems with it. I assumed the GF8800 card I bought must have been faulty and have just ordered an Asus 560 GTX (non ti) card. But while waiting for it to arrive, I have become concerned that the problem wasn't really with the GF8800 card, but with some other component malfunctioning - maybe the PSU? (Seeing how the GF8800 requires a lot more power than the GF7300.)

From my description, does it sound like this could be the case, or would a PSU problem rather result in the PC simply shutting down or giving me a BSOD?

The PSU is a Corsair 620HX, which should have plenty of power for a GF8800, but, like I said in another post, it is 4 years old, and has been running about 10 hours a day, in a very dusty case, so it may have some dust inside it - it's located it the bottom of the case.

Thanks for reading!
 
The issues you've mentioned sounds PSU, GPU, and mobo related.

That Corsair 620HX does have a 5 year warranty so I'd RMA that part first if anything. Though it should be more than enough power for your GTX 560 or 8800GT. Hence why I think it's a defective PSU, mobo, or GPUs.
 
Thanks, Danny Bui!

I'm hoping to receive the GTX 560 in a day or two, so the logical next step would be to install it, and then if the problems persist, that would indicate that the fault lies with the PSU or mobo, right?

But if this turns out to be the case, could the other components (including the new card!) be damaged? If it's a PSU problem, could it "fry" my PC?

Google says the PSU has "Over Current/Voltage/Power Protection, Under Voltage Protection, and Short Circuit Protection", but, being a clueless noob, I don't know how effective these things really are.
 
I'm hoping to receive the GTX 560 in a day or two, so the logical next step would be to install it, and then if the problems persist, that would indicate that the fault lies with the PSU or mobo, right?
Yes
But if this turns out to be the case, could the other components (including the new card!) be damaged? If it's a PSU problem, could it "fry" my PC?
It could if was that badly defective.
 
Well it is possible, but I don't think it's very likely. If you want a piece of mind, swap out the PSU with a good working unit first. Then you know for sure.
 
Thanks for your replies, Skillz and Danny Bui!


It could if was that badly defective.

Hmm.... :confused:

Do you/anybody have an opinion about whether it might be that defective?

Like I said, the PC is working fine with the GF7300 - I'm using it to write this.

Is it likely that a PSU could have some defect that wouldn't be noticeable at all with a GF7300 but would still be so serious that it could fry the PC if a more powerful GPU was installed?

Also, you don't think the Current/Voltage/Power Protection is any good then?

From my description, you guys don't think it's most likely a GPU issue?

I'm sorry if I seem to be beating a dead horse here, but I would really appreciate some more input! (I need to figure out what to do before the card gets here, probably later today. I don't think I can get hold of a different PSU.) :/
 
Did you completely uninstall drivers and reinstall fresh when you swapped to the 8 series? It doesn't sound like PSU, although it might be. Are you overclocked at all?
 
I say wait and test the powersupply with your new video card. If the problem persists then RMA your powersupply. The warranty is still good so go ahead and get a new one through Corsair while you can.

Once you have the new powersupply (if your new video card has the same issues) and the problem is still there then it most definitely is a motherboard issue in which case you'd need a new motherboard...which lucky for you are crazy cheap now, especially a used board here on the forums.

Now...if after getting a new motherboard and the problem is STILL there then we're looking at a possible RAM or harddrive issue...but lets tackle the more probable choices first shall we? ;-)
 
Did you completely uninstall drivers and reinstall fresh when you swapped to the 8 series? It doesn't sound like PSU, although it might be. Are you overclocked at all?

In addition to what I said above this and most importantly THIS!!!

Drivers could VERY well be the problem and 9 times out of 10 they are. Use Driver Sweeper in Safe Mode and completely delete ALL things nVidia...even Physx...restart your machine and install the latest and greatest driver for your card.

Honestly can't believe no one else here suggested this before now...myself included :-p
 
Thanks, guys! I'm starting to feel a little more at ease now! :)

JoeUser, sounds like a good plan. :)

HeavensCloud/JoeUser, I haven't done any overclocking.

Hmm... I think I did do a complete uninstall, but only using add/remove programs, and not in safe mode. Also, I only did it a couple of days after installing the card, IIRC.

Now that I think of it, I tried installing drivers several times, and it didn't work the first time. I noobishly tried doing it with Windows Update first, and the second time directly from Nvidia's site, I think.

Is that bad? :eek:
 
Do what JoeUser said. Get driversweeper, boot into safe mode, and run it on everything nvidia. Reinstall from nvidia site. Still might have a bum GFX card though.
 
Yeah a failed Windows Update driver installation followed by a second driver installation can very well cause that problem. Do a driversweeper, and also google the exact file locations of those windows/nvidia drivers, and delete them manually if need be.
 
Again, many thanks for replying!

I received the 560 GTX today, and thought I would try installing it, before sweeping the drivers. (I now realise you probably meant I should have done it in the opposite order!)

Anyway, the result is: The monitor doesn't receive any signal from the 560 GTX!

The card's fan is spinning alright, and when I start the PC, I hear the other fans spin like normally. But of course I don't know if it actually POSTs and loads Windows.

The monitor is a Samsung 22" SyncMaster 226BW. I tried connecting via DVI, and VGA (to both the syncmaster and an old crt-monitor) using an adapter, and I also tried with a TV via HDMI. Same result.

The dvi cable is dvi-i single-link. The connectors on both card and monitor seem to be dvd-i dual-link. (At least they have all 24 holes.) Some people say that 22" and above screens should have have dual-link cables, but I doubt it if this in itself could lead to no signal at all?

I have connected both pci-e power cables to the PSU.

The card seemed to be seated OK. (I tried reinstalling it many times. Now I've put the trusty GF7300 back in.) The only thing is that the screw holes in the card weren't completely aligned with those in the case, when I had placed the card it in the pci-e slot, so I had to push down on the card a little to be able to get the screws in. Not sure if this could be problematic?

Could it be an incompatibility issue between the card and the mobo? Abit ip-35 e has pci-e x16 (1.0 I suppose), whereas the card, from what I understand has pci-e 2.0. From what I had read on the web, this shouldn't be a problem, as long the card didn't have pci-e 2.1.

Though, I've never flashed the bios, so it's from before the 2.0 standard was introduced. After reading other people's horror stories, I really don't feel like flashing the bios. (Unless you really think it would help?)

I've googled and seen that many people's monitors didn't get a signal from certain 560 ti cards (mine is non ti), but that seemed to be connected with certain Asus mobos only...

So what do you think? Have I simply been unlucky and gotten a bad card, again!, or what else could be causing it?

I have a feeling this is too serious to be caused by the remnants of old drivers, but I will of course sweep them tomorrow in any case. Afterwards I will also try clearing CMOS.

By the way, I also tried the GF8800 card again. Sure enough, a few minutes after Windows had finished loading, the screen turned black. The different colored bar at the top I mentioned was not red, but blue. And I now noticed it was the exact same color as my desktop. Sometimes I would get a short glimpse of a couple of desktop icons.

You'll have noticed that the 8800 loads Windows fine, but after a couple of minutes gets this black screen, whereas the 560 doesn't seem to output any signal at all.

I'm not sure if these different kinds of symptoms could be caused by the same underlying problem (with mobo, psu, etc.) that just manifest itself in different ways, depending on the video card? :confused:

Anyway, as you can see I am very confused and would really appreciate your thoughts!

Thanks for reading!
 
Considering that 2-3 different GPUs exhibit issues, you would have to have incredibly shitty luck to get three defective GPUs.

At this point, swap in a different PSU and see what happens.
 
Thanks for replying!

Considering that 2-3 different GPUs exhibit issues, you would have to have incredibly shitty luck to get three defective GPUs.

It's only two, and the first one was a used card. :) But I do see your point. :/

Other comments are of course still most welcome!
 
You still haven't cleared out your old drivers?

Not yet, to be honest. :eek:

I'll do it when I've had some sleep. It's past 6 am here - I've been up all night struggling with these issues. At one point I couldn't even get the GF7300 to work, but after a very frustrating hour, I realised I had forgotten to plug in the ATX 12V cable! :)
 
Windows XP basically requires a full reformat for any hardware changes. Well, not really but almost. However, the BIOS has no idea what operating system you're running so if the computer will not POST it's not a driver related issue.
 
Does your MoBo have a built in speaker to beep when it posts so you'll at least know if it posted?
 
Time for an update:

Today I uninstalled all nvidia drivers and ran Driver Sweeper in safe mode, as you suggested, before (and after) reinstalling the 8800.

No matter how many times I ran Driver Sweeper, it still reported that there was a driver "fragment" left in the registry, called "HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\System\ControlSet002\Enum\Root\LEGACY_NVSVC\"

I then downloaded the driver from http://www.nvidia.com/object/winxp_181.22_whql.html.
and installed it, and it seemed to work, as I didn't get the familiar black screen for a couple of hours.

Then in the evening, Windows started crashing with strange lines and patterns accross the screen, and upon rebooting I got an error message like this one: http://support.microsoft.com/kb/293078
"This issue occurs if the graphics adapter is caught in an infinite loop while it waits for the video hardware to become idle. This can indicate that there is a problem with the video hardware, or that the graphics adapter cannot program the hardware correctly."
I then booted into safe mode, but similar weird color patterns also showed up here! This would seem to indicate that it's the card itself that's faulty and not the driver, wouldn't it?

Here are some screenshots/photos, from safe mode: [See next post]

So in the end I had to reinstall the 7300 again!

I don't think I got the 8800 drivers completely uninstalled, because when I tried, Driver Sweeper naturally decided to crash as well. Still, the 7300 seems to work...

Now, if I can't get the 560 to work, I'm seriously considering getting an xbox in stead! :(
 
as.bmp





DSC03347.JPG
 
Thanks again to all who's replied!

Tsuyoi, no, I've never heard it beep, and I can't find anywhere in the bios where I can make it beep.

If it's not against any forum rules, I'll post a message in the gpu section asking if anybody has had experiences similar to mine with a GF 560 card.
 
You sure you can't swap out PSUs? I ask because the pictures you've posted shows a GPU that's artifacting or defective.
 
You sure you can't swap out PSUs? I ask because the pictures you've posted shows a GPU that's artifacting or defective.

And you think the artifacting is caused by the PSU? Is there any way I could check this out?

PSUs are pretty pricy here, so I'd rather not buy one unless I was sure that was where the problem was.

A PSU would cause artifacting by sending out a voltage spike, or something, right? But this wouldn't explain the 560 card not outputting any signal at all, would it? :confused:

Thanks for replying!
 
And you think the artifacting is caused by the PSU? Is there any way I could check this out?

PSUs are pretty pricy here, so I'd rather not buy one unless I was sure that was where the problem was.

A PSU would cause artifacting by sending out a voltage spike, or something, right? But this wouldn't explain the 560 card not outputting any signal at all, would it? :confused:

Thanks for replying!
That's my guess, yes. But it could very well be a defective GPU and you just have shitty luck.

Only way I can think of to rule this out is to get another PSU for testing. Either that or risk trying a 4th GPU.
 
Back
Top