Does Intel's FMA (Fast Memory Access) feature make a difference?

Synomenon

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Feb 10, 2007
Messages
7,662
I'm trying to decide between two boards:

Asus P5Q-EM:
http://www.asus.com/products.aspx?l1=3&l2=11&l3=761&l4=0&model=2413&modelmenu=1

Asus P5QL-EM:
http://www.asus.com/products.aspx?l1=3&l2=11&l3=699&l4=0&model=2246&modelmenu=1


The P5Q uses Intel's G45 which supports up to 16GB of RAM and has the ICH10R + Intel's FMA (Fast Memory Access) feature.

The P5QL uses Intel's G43 which supports up to 8GB of RAM and has the ICH10. It doesn't have the FMA feature.

The P5QL also has an eSATA port, but the P5Q doesn't. I thought you needed the ICH10R to get the AHCI / hotswap feature that eSATA brings?

Also, with the P5Q having this FMA thing, will it far outperform the P5QL? I really won't be using the onboard video since I have a 9800GX2.

What makes the P5QL so attractive to me is that it has a superior SATA port layout (one that won't be blocked by the 9800GX2). I have a P5E-VM HDMI right now and it has the exact same SATA port layout as the P5Q. My 9800GX2 blocks four of the six ports and I need at least four of them. On the P5QL, the SATA ports are mounted on the edge of the board so they won't be blocked.

I don't know which board to get. Everything in my sig. will be transplanted to whichever of the above boards I get.
 
wasnt fast memory access something that came in a couple gens ago with the 965 boards? some kind of tweak to the mem controller? anyway, if it had made a difference, there would be a lot more responses here.
 
The P5QL might have eSATA over a Marvell or SI controller? That's how it was done on the P5K before it went native on the P5Q I think... I've no idea if it's hot-swappable or not though, heard it both ways. If you go to the Global ASUS site and hit up Product Comparison (under IE, not FF, won't work) you'll get an easier to read chart that might better highlight the differences btw. AFAIK FMA would only be relevant if you're using the integrated graphics.
 
I've compared the two already. The main differences I can find:

P5QL-EM:
G43 - X4500 IGP
ICH10 w/ AHCI, but no FMA
eSATA port (Asus doesn't say what SATA controller they use)
SATA ports mounted at edge of board
Max 8GB RAM
VIA firewire controller
Not sure if the PCIe 16x slot is v2.0, the manuals says, "Supports PCIe 2.0/1.0 Architecature", but don't PCIe 16x v2.0 cards also work in PCIe 16x v1.0 slots too?
Conductive Polymer Caps
No Firewire header on board
No SPDIF on back



P5Q-EM:
G45 - X4500HD IGP
ICH10R w/ FMA and AHCI
No eSATA ports
SATA ports mounted in the way of the PCIe 16x slot
Max 16GB RAM
Agere firewire controller
PCIe 16x 2.0
Solid caps
Has firewire on board
Has SPDIF on back


I just watched the FMA demo on Intel's site and it looks like it processes data coming from the CPU, PCI express bus, DMI, and graphics bus.
 
Sure, but it doesn't always work right regardless. Depending on the controller/driver a lot of people with different boards simply can't hot-swap properly and drives won't be recognized unless they're present at bootup.
 
i have a sata hot swap rack and even when v64 recognizes the drives, it wants a reboot anyway after loading "drivers". somebody is going to have to work on that.
 
sorry to revive such an old thread but im seeing conlficting info on Intel's site, some of which says G43 is 8GB ram, other sections which say 16GB.
Does anyone know for sure? Even wikipedia says it's 16GB and v2 PCIe and says the G41 is the more crippled one....

http://www.intel.com/Products/Desktop/Chipsets/G43/G43-overview.htm
http://www.intel.com/Products/Desktop/Chipsets/G45/G45-overview.htm

http://compare.intel.com/pcc/showchart.aspx?mmID=34469,36520&familyID=10&culture=en-US

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_chipsets
 
frack it, seems like even though officially it does up to 16gb, most actual mb implementations have it up to 8gb only.
Going to get g45 based mobo just to be safe, even though i don't really need x4500hd..

Does anyone know if the IGP shuts down on these things entirely if a discrete card is being used?
 
What I will say is that in very few situations will your memory speed make any noticable difference. Daily browsing/gaming you will absolutely see nothing unless your running at 800x600 on low settings and want 250 FPS rather than 225. In some rendering you'll likely see a difference if it's something you do daily.

This FMA sorta sounds a lot like that EPP or whatever SLI memory is called where it automatically OC's it up to 10% :rolleyes: Just a marketing tool.
 
chances are you will have to turn it off in your BIOS, but from there it will be compleatly off and no worries to you :) atleast thats how it has been on the mobo's ive owned that had integrated video
 
Back
Top