DNA Solves Phantom Serial Killer Mystery

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Contrary to what you’ve learned from popular TV shows, sometimes computers, DNA swabs and science can actually hinder an investigation more than they help.

Police in Germany hunted a sinister phantom killer for two years after finding the same DNA at 39 different crime scenes - only to discover that the source was a woman who made the cotton buds used to collect the sample!
 
I can't decide whether this beats Boston police, although I'm leaning towards no.
 
Not the brightest popple working there. One would imagine that somebody would test clean swabs for quality periodically, which in this case means for contamination with foreign DNA before actually using it!
 
thats just a shame...they should have lied to the public and said they caught her but she set herself on fire and was burned to a crisp before they could identify her...
 
Just imagine how many perpetrators avoided conviction because of this. Once the Police tested & found lab worker DNA they'd stop looking for other DNA that may have led to the real perpetrator.
 
That's brilliant! Reminds me of Dexter... she could've committed all of those crimes, and then said that the DNA test was "contaminated" and thus they can't make a case against her.
 
... what ever happened to having a control when performing any type of scientific analysis?

I'm no expert here, but wouldn't it make since to test a "clean" swab to rule out any contamination?
 
I hope they still investigated her, or at least the first murder, even after realizing it is probably just contamination...

(Just because the "sterile" swabs were contaminated with her DNA doesn't mean she didn't do it to create an alibi...)

Weirder things have happened...

If I killed someone (the first victim, doesn't have to be the first one found...) and just happened to manufactured the swabs, I'd start contaminating 'em for an alibi...

Again, I hope they at least investigated her a little...
 
Just goes to show technology is only as good as the people using it.How many other clues were missed because the police depended too much on the DNA and not enough on the basics?
 
Another thought:

Since CSIs undoubtedly have their DNA on record to quickly catch contamination, maybe now anyone responsible for the tools at any level should now also be in the system?

It would have caught this problem much sooner...

(although just testing the sterile swabs for anything would obviously, too, but two years were wasted over this... what if not every swab was contaminated? We don't know how many sterile swabs they had to go through to discover this... Again, having her DNA on file would have figured it out from day one what was probably up... If you're going to be involved in the process, maybe you should be on file... Save time, expense, and makes things safer when they're not following or relying on false leads...)
 
... what ever happened to having a control when performing any type of scientific analysis?

I'm no expert here, but wouldn't it make since to test a "clean" swab to rule out any contamination?

Ding! Ding! Ding! The trick will be to make sure the analyst isn't just pulling a control swab from a box off the shelf. Have the investigator provide a 'clean' swab along with their samples at every collection.
 
They should be using individually wrapped, sterile swabs.. Not Q-Tips off the rack from the local supermarket! Sheesh.
 
Not the brightest popple working there. One would imagine that somebody would test clean swabs for quality periodically, which in this case means for contamination with foreign DNA before actually using it!

So people that work in a DNA lab are not the brightest? I would think they would have to be pretty intelligent to even work there. (shrug)
 
So the phantom killer was as non-existent as the Phantom console... interesting.
 
So people that work in a DNA lab are not the brightest? I would think they would have to be pretty intelligent to even work there

Well, you'd be surprised how many 'smart' people are quite 'dumb' :p
 
scary.........it took 2 years to find this out?

I don't feel safe now, I may have touched a few Q-tips.....:eek:
 
So people that work in a DNA lab are not the brightest? I would think they would have to be pretty intelligent to even work there

Well, you'd be surprised how many 'smart' people are quite 'dumb' :p

Yeah, Like some smart dude not being able to figure out the quote function...:)
 
So people that work in a DNA lab are not the brightest? I would think they would have to be pretty intelligent to even work there. (shrug)

It only takes motivation to even be an MD. Some have average (and below) IQs...

Probably the dumber you are, the easier it is to "fake it 'til you make it" as you're faking it anyway...
 
It only takes motivation to even be an MD. Some have average (and below) IQs...

Probably the dumber you are, the easier it is to "fake it 'til you make it" as you're faking it anyway...

There are definitely some idiot doctors here in my town. The kind who cant seem to do anything right the first time.
 
Back
Top