Disgruntled s939 owner agrees...

Joined
Jun 10, 2004
Messages
3,986
http://www.overclockers.com/articles1437/


Wake up AMD....I have two AMD s939 mobo's and cpu's and TONS of DDR1, that I
really dread have to go the way of the dodo.Wanna keep me and a few people I know ?
Throw us a bone,a X2 6000+ on 939 would be nice.Show the enthusiast community
we have not been forgotten,like the read headed stepchild. :eek:

Its money in thier pocket,and dont tell me they cant do it ! That is pure utter crap !
nothing more.... nothing less.I would have not gone Intel and C2D,soon to be Q2C
if they had put out a few X2 5600/6000+,etc..... :rolleyes:
 
I agree. 939ers don't want AM2, it's not really faster for the same cpu. We want new 939 cpu's or C2D's.
 
my 165 is the same as a 6000+ X2 with a newer waterblock it might be faster... ;)
 
If I could get a 2.6 or greater speed 65nm part for my 939 board I would be all over of it. I just got my Opty 170 this winter and its a great CPU and I have no intentions of upgrading until my new rig some when Quad core becomes main stream and DX10 is settled in.
 
Some of the better 65nm chips for S939 would be nice. I wouldn't mind an X2 5600+ or 6000+. AM2 is pretty worthless on the whole, A64s never needed more bandwidth. :D
 
I dont want a 65nm AM2 CPU in a 939 socket...

I want AMD to compete with the C2D in raw horsepower.....
 
I, too, agree with the OP. I say we start a new "Disgruntled 939 owner" (instead of the generic 939) club.
 
Unfortunately s939 has been EOL'd for quite some time. No amount of bitching and moaning is going to raise it from the dead. I bought a opty 165 6 weeks ago trying to squeeze a bit more life out of this platform but I can't wait for barkie any longer. This rig is going to my 6 yr old son and I'm going c2d.
 
I also want a faster clocked CPU on S939 but I think that AMD went to AM2 because DDR2 is prefered by the OEM.
 
AMD is doing exactly what they should be... Focusing their resources on newer technology that has a future rather than splitting their resources by using valuable waffers to produce s939 cores with old DDR memory controllers. Funny how I keep reading stuff on the AMD forum like "c'mon AMD, come out with something that will kick Intel's ass!!!" and then I read "c'mon AMD, keep producing old stuff!!!"

I understand where you're coming form and everything, I have a s939 system too with 4GB of ram but the market is what it is. I don't think anyone built their system thinking it was going to be supported forever.

The added bandwidth from DDR2 may not be very adventagous now, but it has other advantages... Higher overclocking, 2GB DIMMs, and they're cheaper now than DDR1 sticks.
 
The only advantage DDR2 has over DDR1 on the Athlon platform is price. The Athlon 64 does not run memory speeds in excess of PC3200 at stock speeds.

AFAIK, because of DDR2's higher latency, DDR1 will be faster than DDR2 at the same clock speed. DDR2 just happens to have specs for speeds beyond 200Mhz...none of which the Athlon 64 takes advantage of at stock speeds.

I realize that because of the integrated memory controller socket changes are more likely for newer technology Vs. Intel's off-chip memory controller allowing them to use the LGA775 for what seems like forever, but then again, that gives Intel another edge for people on a 6-month CPU upgrade cycles.
 
The P4 had 3 Sockets. 423, 478, and LGA775. The Athlon64 is now on it's 3rd socket with AM2. Seems pretty equal to me.

C2D is still fairly new... So we'll see how long they stretch LGA775 with that one.
 
Consider the time frame, though. Socket 423 was introduced in, what, 2001. Socket 754, the first Athlon 64, was introduced in 2004. Actually, AMD is set to go to Socket F or something else soon, whereas Intel will still be on LGA775 for another year or so. So Intel has 7 years/3 sockets = 2.33 years/socket. AMD has 3 years / 4 sockets = 0.75 years/sockets (even lower if you count the initial socket 940 used for Athlon64 FX processors).

Even though a motherboard might not break the bank, getting the latest technology with AMD means spending another $100 - $150 over Intel, which may only require a BIOS flash for the latest models (Depending on your situation.)
 
I agree with the OP. If people want to see why PC gaming is on the decline, they need only look at socket revisions which make very little performance difference, yet require numerous components to be replaced.
 
Heh - you guys sound like us s754 users when s939 came out and AMD said they wouldn't support 754 anymore. Well, I'm still using s754 and I'm not the least bit concerned that I've been abandoned. Its just the nature of change.Your s939 rigs are still more than capable of running the latest software and will be for some time. Just wait it out until the DDR3 architecture becomes available - especially if AM2 is not that much of an improvement. The new chip you crave wouldn't be affordable anyway so you might as well grab a top of the line dual core Opteron and be happy. At least you can get decent dual cores for your socket. I declined AM2 from the beginning knowing that it wasn't a really good option - even for me. Enjoy your "dead" architecture as long as you can. A decent dual core cpu and a good video card will last you a good long time.
 
Absolutely agree. That is why I've been after a 4800+ or an Opty 185. I want to max out this socket because I know it still has a lot of potential to go.

That being said, I could make the same argument for AGP, but that's a whole other bloodthirsty debate. ;)
 
Consider the time frame, though. Socket 423 was introduced in, what, 2001. Socket 754, the first Athlon 64, was introduced in 2004. Actually, AMD is set to go to Socket F or something else soon, whereas Intel will still be on LGA775 for another year or so. So Intel has 7 years/3 sockets = 2.33 years/socket. AMD has 3 years / 4 sockets = 0.75 years/sockets (even lower if you count the initial socket 940 used for Athlon64 FX processors).

Even though a motherboard might not break the bank, getting the latest technology with AMD means spending another $100 - $150 over Intel, which may only require a BIOS flash for the latest models (Depending on your situation.)

Socket F is for Opteron CPU's. If you're going to count that it's only fair to count the Xeon socket's as well which adds two more from Intel's side to the mix. Socket 771 and Socket 604.
 
Consider the time frame, though. Socket 423 was introduced in, what, 2001. Socket 754, the first Athlon 64, was introduced in 2004. Actually, AMD is set to go to Socket F or something else soon, whereas Intel will still be on LGA775 for another year or so. So Intel has 7 years/3 sockets = 2.33 years/socket. AMD has 3 years / 4 sockets = 0.75 years/sockets (even lower if you count the initial socket 940 used for Athlon64 FX processors).

Even though a motherboard might not break the bank, getting the latest technology with AMD means spending another $100 - $150 over Intel, which may only require a BIOS flash for the latest models (Depending on your situation.)

Socket F is for Opteron CPU's. If you're going to count that it's only fair to count the Xeon socket's as well which adds two more from Intel's side to the mix. Socket 771 and Socket 604.

In any event, I stand by my original statement. AMD is stretched WAAAAYYYY to thin as it is, splitting their already low resources to continue production on s939 CPU's would be very bad for them.
 
I would love to bring back the 939, with something pumped up more in it lol

i am looking for and fx-60 retail , but geez.. still 500 bucks whew.. bit much for my blood LOL but hey hey if anything C2D or C2Q is where i might be headed too but i have to agree s939 was and probably still is the best update AMD has made unless the K10 just dominates everything.. gawd i wish it does! lol
 
There's nothing new for 939 because the K8 architecture is DONE. At 90nm it cannot scale any higher unless you throw voltage at it. The move to 65nm did almost nothing for it, either. (400 MHz is nothing comparatively)

Ed is a fucking idiot, and traipsing around pulling his line of BS makes anyone look the same.

Don't like it? Buy something else. Most who aren't blinded by zealotry already have. The rest? Head down to the corner store and pick up some reality. I hear it's cheap these days.

K8 is done. It's been done since the release of the first 2.6GHz chip.
 
I just wanted the ability to buy a 4800+ when the prices came down. Thats where I think AMD bent us backwards. I think disgruntled is best term for alot of us. I don't care that the 4800+ won't have the same horse power as the C2D. I just wanted to buy something that was already out for a cheaper price. They how-ever discontinued it all together after AM2 came out.
 
If I remember correctly (IIRC), there were still a few options AMD kicked out for S754 after the launch S939.

However, a couple near high end S939 chips would benefit AMD greatly and would recoup some financial losses. There are still millions of S939 platform users out there that are not willing to upgrade to entirely new platforms as yet, but would be willing to upgrade to stronger processors.
 
I just wanted the ability to buy a 4800+ when the prices came down. Thats where I think AMD bent us backwards. I think disgruntled is best term for alot of us. I don't care that the 4800+ won't have the same horse power as the C2D. I just wanted to buy something that was already out for a cheaper price. They how-ever discontinued it all together after AM2 came out.

After the EOL announcement, I started eyeing the 4800s right away (to upgrade my old 3000+)

i got one for $260 back in October off ebay (OEM - NIB). There was a very small window to get them, although there are still some on ebay for "reasonable" prices (meaning, it's still cheaper than upgrading to C2D memory, mobo, chip)

RamonGTP said:
AMD is doing exactly what they should be... Focusing their resources on newer technology that has a future rather than splitting their resources by using valuable waffers to produce s939 cores with old DDR memory controllers. Funny how I keep reading stuff on the AMD forum like "c'mon AMD, come out with something that will kick Intel's ass!!!" and then I read "c'mon AMD, keep producing old stuff!!!"


QFT!
 
If I remember correctly (IIRC), there were still a few options AMD kicked out for S754 after the launch S939.

However, a couple near high end S939 chips would benefit AMD greatly and would recoup some financial losses. There are still millions of S939 platform users out there that are not willing to upgrade to entirely new platforms as yet, but would be willing to upgrade to stronger processors.

Yes, you are correct. Even though AMD did say s754 was done they did come out with the Semprons and A64's that had the 90nm architecture (Palermo and Venice cores - same core-different cache sizes).
I don't know that a higher end cpu would benefit AMD though. The price would be extremely high more than likely and many would find the cost prohibitive or at least complain long and hard about it. The alternative is to find Opteron cpu's and make do with them - which is probably the best way to go anyhow.
But who knows? AMD has shown that they have the ability to pull some stuff out of their sleeves. I agree that a 65nm s939 would be extremely cool, but I have my doubts that they'll do it now that they are having trouble meeting quotas on the new products and in such financial straights. It would be sweet but it seems highly unlikely unfortunately.
 
Sorry folks, but the official word is that S939 is obsolete. As of now AMD is not manufacturing a single part that is socket 939. The last orders are supposed to or have already been fulfilled - S939 has gone the way of the dodo.
 
I agree, the whole AM2 was a mistake. No benefits over s939, just screwing people who bought s939, which wasn't even released that long ago. Right now I would be considering a 6000+, but I'm not dumping my mobo+ram for it.

And now K10 is supposed to be initially an AM2+ socket, but will probably change by 2008? Oh, ok, I guess I won't buy ANYTHING from you AMD. Job well done!
 
Well, I am PO'd because AMD doesn't have an answer for the C2D, and that is the cpu to beat.

I cannot justify spending more cheese on another AMD setup, if I was going to blow more money, I would go C2D. Sorry, when the ship is sinking, I ain't going down with it.
 
It is the way of technology. Nothing lasts forever unfortunately. I've made peace with the fact that I am "out of date." Intel does the same thing. Its nothing new for either manufacturer. New processes and techniques reguire different technology to accomplish the goal. Its not about getting burned. Software companies in essence do the same thing. Autodesk says "we won't support revision <fill in the blank> of AutoCad anymore so you have to upgrade." They FORCE you to upgrade. Sure AMD and Intel "abandon" us but our systems still work for us and no one is holding a gun to our heads forcing us to upgrade. To be honest most everyone here has more than enough power to run any app they want and continue to do so for another 1-2 years at least. Why do you want to spend hundreds of dollars just to play a $50 game anyway? Just about everyone agrees that to get better performance the best place to invest in upgrades is in memory and video cards anyhow. A 200-400mhz faster cpu isn't going to help all that much - especially when you can overclock your present system to match the performance of a more expensive chip anyhow. I see no difference between my s754 3000+ Venice at 270x10, my 3400+ Venice at 244x11.5 and my 3700+ Clawhammer at 217x12. The only difference I see is in benchmarks, not in games. They all run fast and I can do anything I want with any of them and I don't "see" any difference in any of them unless I run benches. Benches are fine, but as long as my real world performance is good I really don't much care.
And as for C2D - just wait. The cpu that replaces it will more than likely require a new socket tech to implement it. If not it will at least require a new chipset which will then possibly require a new mobo so there you go. Welcome to the wonderful world of "planned obsolescence."
 
Originally Posted by RamonGTP
AMD is doing exactly what they should be... Focusing their resources on newer technology that has a future rather than splitting their resources by using valuable waffers to produce s939 cores with old DDR memory controllers. Funny how I keep reading stuff on the AMD forum like "c'mon AMD, come out with something that will kick Intel's ass!!!" and then I read "c'mon AMD, keep producing old stuff!!!"

Sadly I have to say QFT! I have a Sc-939 as well.

Also I think you might have missed counted the Sockets. 754, 940-Res-DDR1, 939, 940-DDR2 AM2 and Sc-1207. Now doesn't the last 940 for AM2 have pins moved? This makes it not compatible with old 940. Of couse 1207 4 X 4 is aimed at the Desktop market. The desktop or that Pentium M version of the Sc-478 known as Sc-479.
 
socket 775 has a lot of life left in it if you look at the intel roadmaps...Intel is treating users with more respect.
 
socket 775 has a lot of life left in it if you look at the intel roadmaps...Intel is treating users with more respect.

Intel cares about its bottom line and could give a flying flickering #uck about us unless it fattens their pockets. AMD and Intel don't give a flip about any of us personally. That's one thing they have in common. That's NOT to knock them, they're a business, not anyone's friend.
 
:) Right back at ya! :D
And Donnie is quite right. Big businesses care more about $$$ than our personal preferences. They lead and we follow - like lemmings to the sea. As long as they make $$ and make the shareholders happy that's all that really counts. Sure they'll toss us a bone every now and then but business is business and if it takes a new socket tech to make their product work they are going to do it regardless of how we feel about it. They know that if we want the newer tech we'll buy it. As Donnie said - both AMD and Intel are guilty of this. Tech leads - consumers follow. Sad but true. If we didn't demand better products we could all still be happy with what we had in the past. But we all want and DEMAND faster products so we have to suffer the consequences. Look at all the people who have switched from AMD to Intel. They demanded better performance and Intel delivered. They opted to pony up for the better performing product which meant they had to "switch sockets" and just about everything else too. If you want to play you gotta pay. If not, then use what you have and be happy until you need to upgrade. Then get the best you can get within your budget. It has been like this since the dawn of the personal computer age. I saw the 8088 come in, then the 286, 386, etc. Its no different now than then.
 
Back
Top