Disgruntled EA Employee Blog

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Everyone loves industry dirt and the stuff in this “EA Louse blog” is just that, good ol' 100% industry dirt. Who knows, it might be complete B.S., it might not be but quotes like this make it an interesting read:

And Bioware? Don’t make me laugh. They’ve spent more money making the Old Republic than James Cameron spent on Avatar. Sh*t you not. More than $ 300 million! Can you believe that?
 
Did anyone expect diffrent? It will be an "ok" game for the hardcore SW nerds but I don't see it keeping much replay value.
 
Is this a viral ad to Dantes Inferno 2???
I'm hoping for a EA staff mob hit on that man from activision. Oh ok, activision.
 
I've been a huge fan of Bioware for years now. Name the last game they released that was mediocre? Dragon Age took 5 years (and I'm sure a lot of money) and it showed. The Mass Effect series has been superb.

Maybe EA is just finally getting around to screwing Bioware up.

But as of late,Bioware has released some really, really good games. In Bioware I trust. For now.
 
if you read past the hate, there are some interesting tid-bits. I am wondering why the EA management style of treat your employees like crap and promote ignorant management past their "Peter Principle Potential" hasn't caught on more ... sheesh. :rolleyes:
 
Seems like the excriment just hit the fan. We shall see if there is truth to any of this.
 
if you read past the hate, there are some interesting tid-bits. I am wondering why the EA management style of treat your employees like crap and promote ignorant management past their "Peter Principle Potential" hasn't caught on more ... sheesh. :rolleyes:

all companys do that. :mad:
 
I've been a huge fan of Bioware for years now. Name the last game they released that was mediocre? Dragon Age took 5 years (and I'm sure a lot of money) and it showed. The Mass Effect series has been superb.

Maybe EA is just finally getting around to screwing Bioware up.

But as of late,Bioware has released some really, really good games. In Bioware I trust. For now.

Bioware Mythic is not Bioware Edmonton. EA lumped them together.
 
Fake or not, I love reading those, the anonymity does ruin it a little bit, Luke Halliwell's blog series about what happened with APB: Where Realtime Worlds went wrong was better since it was 100% legit, but still, good to get some insight into what's happening in game development and that it's not nearly as glorious as many think or make it out to be.
 
Nowhere did it say SWToR would be bad. Simply said they spent a lot of money and were pouring more resources at it to finish it in a timely manner. So it's big. Everything else is just disgruntled grunt worker talk.
 
I've been a huge fan of Bioware for years now. Name the last game they released that was mediocre? Dragon Age took 5 years (and I'm sure a lot of money) and it showed. The Mass Effect series has been superb.

Maybe EA is just finally getting around to screwing Bioware up.

But as of late,Bioware has released some really, really good games. In Bioware I trust. For now.

Bioware Austin is unproven yet though. They were started specifically to make TOR, and have so far taken 4 years in development on it. Until they can prove that they can pull it together, being skeptical is not a bad idea. This isn't the first I've heard of issues down there anyway, so I'm not too surprised about news like this.
 
I've been a huge fan of Bioware for years now. Name the last game they released that was mediocre? Dragon Age took 5 years (and I'm sure a lot of money) and it showed. The Mass Effect series has been superb.

Maybe EA is just finally getting around to screwing Bioware up.

But as of late,Bioware has released some really, really good games. In Bioware I trust. For now.

Agreed. Bioware makes quality games , I take EA Louse's opinion on if SW:OR will suck and be a failure with a ocean's worth of salt. However it doesn't sound like the rest of his information is off the mark for some of the greed and rampant disregard for employment EA is know to have.

Warhammer sucked during beta and out the gate during release. The idea of Warhammer was great but it just wasn't put together in the best sense that it could have.

I think some of EA Louse's jealously of the money invested in SW:OR comes from his anger over being pink slipped and not from an area of objective thought.

We'll see how this develops over time.
 
He said most of it is voice over work. No shit, Bioware is well known for their amazing voice overs in video games. And I am glad to have them developing TOR.
 
Doesn't it bother anyone else that the blogger is portraying himself as educated enough to work in game design but, his spelling and grammar is horrible?
 
Nowhere did it say SWToR would be bad. Simply said they spent a lot of money and were pouring more resources at it to finish it in a timely manner. So it's big. Everything else is just disgruntled grunt worker talk.

I guess you failed to read the following :

And Bioware? Don’t make me laugh. They’ve spent more money making the Old Republic than James Cameron spent on Avatar. Shit you not. More than $ 300 million! Can you believe that?

And you know what they’re most proud of? This is the kicker. They are most proud of the sound. No seriously. Something like a 20Gig installation, and most of it is voiceover work. That’s the best they have. The rest of the game is a joke. EA knows it and so does George Lucas,they’re panicking , and so most of Mythic has already been cannibalized to work in Austin on it because they can’t keep pushing back launch.

Pretty sure that doesn't mean anything but "bad".
 
Nowhere did it say SWToR would be bad. Simply said they spent a lot of money and were pouring more resources at it to finish it in a timely manner. So it's big. Everything else is just disgruntled grunt worker talk.

in the blog:

"Old Republic will be one of the greatest failures in the history of MMOs from EA. Probably at the level of the Sims Online. We all know it too ……"

I would call that bad. lots of other references in the comments about how bad it will be as well.
 
Doesn't it bother anyone else that the blogger is portraying himself as educated enough to work in game design but, his spelling and grammar is horrible?
Just reread this and realized it isn't so bad just a guy blowing off steam
 
Doesn't it bother anyone else that the blogger is portraying himself as educated enough to work in game design but, his spelling and grammar is horrible?

Actually from the perspective of another coworker who was let go (and talks about some of the stuff he mentions specifically about herself) his grammar and spelling is above the average for Mythic employees.

I think attacking a person for their spelling and grammar is stupid as long as they are understandable.
The voracity of his comments should be in question and based on the link I provided he's off base in some of the ways (s)he has demonized their bosses and from my past observations of WAR's marketing (s)he's even more inaccurate.

Still considering observation from other known former employees it can at least be assumed the person was in a position to gather information even though they may not have gotten all of the facts straight.
 
Yeah it is kinda funny how this guy is worried about EA spending $300 million on what they hope is gonna be the next AAA MMO title to dominate the entire market but saying they are spending more than was spent on Avatar.

The voice acting alone is probably multi thousands of dollars for each actor, then there is the licensing the Star Wars IP which I'd imagine Lucas isn't giving them a discount on either.

This game has big time ambition and has years of work being put into it so it isn't surprising to me at all that it costs more than a big Hollywood movie. A movie is scripted, filmed, scored, and edited, from that point on it isn't changed. Any resources needed for the film were already paid for from prior projects or are rented so there isn't a need for a dedicated infrastructure who's sole purpose is to let the film exist.

And while a MMO, on the other-hand doesn't need some of the staff or actors after it goes live, for sure needs many more resources and money just to get to release and is dynamic so the planing for expansions and using the same voice talent in the future could easily such up 1/3 of that $300 million before the launch happens.

I'd say it is comparable to running a few TV shows across multiple season for the investment but if it pays off you are looking at millions each month for years to come and unlike a movie only having to premier well to cover it's costs, this game has to serve rabid fans and newcomers alike for years to ensure a large ongoing subscriber base.

So yeah it isn't a big surprise to me that EA is tossing every possible asset at this game with disregard for its workers to ensure it makes them money cause they are like every other business that has shareholders. Their first priority is revenue and stock price. They are probably the Foxcon of game publishers in terms or how worker are treated but that is how the got to be one of the biggest.
 
Read that earlier thanks to David Jaffe mentioning it on his blog. Its interesting, but a lot of it screams of the "they didn't do what I said so they're all wrong and stupid" that people, especially those far removed from management, tend to get. Still looking past some of the likely BS it sounds like EA is the same as any other company.

This is Jaffe's response: http://criminalcrackdown.blogspot.com/2010/10/my-response-to-ea-louse.html
 
war is dead because they could not get it through there heads that rock paper scissors, does not work in pvp where some of the classes totally dominated the others in PVP. In the beta they nerfed chaos so that people would play order. The art was amazing but some of the concept art was a thousand times better than the stuff that made it into the game. It still amazes me how little variation there was in the armors. Look at wow when it first released there were ten different sets of armor for all the armor in war, I know higher quality takes time but most of the cool armor was on NPCs not players. I don't know maybe it is me but quest givers should not look cooler than players, unless they are iconic.
 
I have been playing WoW for a couple years now, and althuugh I think they have done a really good job of keeping the game relavent, I am always yearning to try something a little more modern looking.

I most recently tried Final Fantasy 14 Online and while it is very nice looking the User Interface is 100% percent fail (coming from MMO's like WoW & Lord of the Rings Online). Mostly because they force the keyboarders (PC'ers) to play with an interface that works well with a PS3 controller.

So heres to putting a little bit of hope in one of the last big MMO's scheduled to come out any time soon.
 
Well, hooray! Now gaming geeks know what the rest of us know. The middle management, ass kissing corporate structure sucks ass. Isn't this very same reality that drives grown-ups to bury themselves in MM O's to avoid this harsh reality?
Capitalistic corporatism requests you please leave your soul at the door as you just sold out. All new employee's please form a line opposite those collecting their Pink Slips. You will be assigned a cubical soon. Please be patient. :D

PS- rent "Office Space".
 
Though the cg scenes for SW:TOR are awesome...the actual gameplay vids are not.
 
Though the cg scenes for SW:TOR are awesome...the actual gameplay vids are not.

I can't name one single MMORPG that I've ever seen gameplay vids for that it looks exciting. They all look dull, boring, and repetitive, mainly because that exactly what the gameplay is.
 
I am... Skeptical. Reason is that this person has a heapin' helpin' of anger going on. They are losing their job and they are all kinds of mad about that. Ok, fine, however that means their judgment may not be so objective. Also there are always many sides to a story, I'm sure this isn't the whole truth.

We'll have to see with regards to The Old Republic, but I wouldn't take this guy's word for anything. He's bitter and lasing out, which means what he's saying isn't all that reliable.

I've heard many people talk some serious shit about their bosses. In few situations was it ever 100% true.
 
I can atleast take comfort in the fact that Bioware has never made a bad game.

I think the only way this could be a 'bad' game is if it DOESN'T get released, like Starcraft:Ghost.
 
I can't name one single MMORPG that I've ever seen gameplay vids for that it looks exciting. They all look dull, boring, and repetitive, mainly because that exactly what the gameplay is.

I find GW2's gameplay to be pretty cool. And Swordsman Online to look extremely awesome.

Of course... they are cut pieces most of the time, but they looks tons better than TOR.
 
I can atleast take comfort in the fact that Bioware has never made a bad game.

I think the only way this could be a 'bad' game is if it DOESN'T get released, like Starcraft:Ghost.

It's really Mythic who is making this game. EA merged Bioware and Mythic.
 
Doesn't it bother anyone else that the blogger is portraying himself as educated enough to work in game design but, his spelling and grammar is horrible?
Irrelevant.
I know some incredibly brilliant engineers who would embarrass themselves in a 3rd grade spelling bee. And reading emails from them is like deciphering another language... *shrug*
 
Is a designer really in a good position to judge how well a game is going to pan out?
 
Is the chef really in a position to judge how well a meal is going to pan out?

Yes!

NEXT!

In your example, we must assume the chef is the one making the meal in its entirety. I do, however, like the "pan out" pun :D
 
Is the chef really in a position to judge how well a meal is going to pan out?

Yes!

NEXT!

Well I'm not sure what this guy was designing. If he designed saber hilts and beam colors, then well he's just a utensil for the Chef.
 
Is the chef really in a position to judge how well a meal is going to pan out?

Yes!

NEXT!

Stupid analogy. A chef prepares an entire meal. Games can have hundreds of people working on them. There isn't one single programmer or artist that knows how every single thing is coming together. They're not in a position to say if something outside of the part they are working on works because they're not going to know why some decisions were made that dictated why those elements were designed the way they were.
 
Stupid analogy. A chef prepares an entire meal. Games can have hundreds of people working on them. There isn't one single programmer or artist that knows how every single thing is coming together. They're not in a position to say if something outside of the part they are working on works because they're not going to know why some decisions were made that dictated why those elements were designed the way they were.

It was a stupid question imo.

Look, if you work on a project, you have a good idea on how it is going to turn out, even if you only own a minor portion of it. Hell even if you don't work on the project but have friends that do, you know how it is going to turn out. This is from professional experience at HP, specifically the division that makes printers. I knew which printers were going to suck and which were going to be awesome based on rumors and hallway conversations, even though I only had input on the electronics.

When i comes to product development, there are very few secrets inside companies. If it's crap everyone knows it and you try to make it better/acceptable. Doesn't change the fact it is still crap.
 
It was a stupid question imo.

Look, if you work on a project, you have a good idea on how it is going to turn out, even if you only own a minor portion of it. Hell even if you don't work on the project but have friends that do, you know how it is going to turn out. This is from professional experience at HP, specifically the division that makes printers. I knew which printers were going to suck and which were going to be awesome based on rumors and hallway conversations, even though I only had input on the electronics.

When i comes to product development, there are very few secrets inside companies. If it's crap everyone knows it and you try to make it better/acceptable. Doesn't change the fact it is still crap.

I won't disagree with that.

True you will know if something sucks, but lets say for some reason they decided to change how the ink is loaded into a new printer. You thought it was a terrible idea and so did a lot of people. While they might be right (and probably are) there might have also been a big reason why the change was made and only the people in charge of making that decision (and maybe the ones who worked on the change if they were able to ask why) know the details. Thats kind of what I was saying with that post.
 
Why don't you guys just replace chef with sous-chef. They don't do everything either but they would be pretty incompetent not to be aware when the dish preparation is going south.

You must have worked in projects that are divided among multiple teams to notice that regardless of the segregation of responsibilities the impact of other teams fucking up or your own team fucking up is going to be felt in some appreciable manner to be commented on by the other teams.
 
Back
Top