Desktop PC Platform: Saved By Overclocking

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Benchmark Reviews has posted another overclocking editorial, the latest in a series of overclocking articles, this one explaining how the desktop PC platform has been saved by overclocking.

For the past few articles of this series, I've concentrated on playing devil's advocate for the demise of desktop PCs. Some say it will live on past the imminent threat of notebook computers, mobile smartphones, and gaming consoles; others think the market has already passed its glory days. Each of my articles posed a narrative perspective describing real-world scenarios that continue to impact this industry. Each topic offered a form of speculative research, which I like to call job security, on the relative health of our hobby. That's right, I called it a hobby.
 
This is the dork that wrote the article:

Desktop PC Platform: Killed By Overclocking

that garnered so much controversy last time here. So all along his entire point was to be argumentative and contradictory? What is his real opinion other than being an annoying devil's advocate?
 
This is the dork that wrote the article:

Desktop PC Platform: Killed By Overclocking

that garnered so much controversy last time here. So all along his entire point was to be argumentative and contradictory? What is his real opinion other than being an annoying devil's advocate?

His real opinion is irrelovent. He's writing on the web and doing what he thinks gives him the best chance for more web clicks.

That being said, it's time Intel moved out of the dark ages and started offering a CPU that at stock would reach 4Ghz. You to AMD. Hell, it's time the whole damn offerings gave a 500Mhz bump with no change in speed. I'm tired of having a 2.X processor at work because I can't OC my work machine :p
 
Same author...not even worth a read after the last one.

the last one created a ton of angry feedback, so he publishes an article from the complete opposite viewpoint and calls his flip-flopping "playing devils advocate" as a "hobby".

write an article about how abortions tickle, then write another one later about saving the children. none of it matters, as they arent your opinions nor are either of these articles factual. youtube video comments are more interesting to me than what this guy has to say.

unfortunately i clicked the link and gave him +1 ad views :(
 
Until laptops and everything else are as cheap, versatile, powerful, and easily upgraded the desktop will keep on chugging.
 
Well, I don't really wanna read his previous article, and this author sounds like a douche. But I can say that if PCs didn't OC I may have gone completely into consoles years ago. The fact that we have the ability to let our hardware stretch it's legs (given the right cooling, and OC technique) and IS a reason to keep the platform alive. It's hard to kill off such a widely adopted open platform, especially since nothing better has come along, the fact that the user is able to tweak it makes it that much better. Sure, there are alot of folks that fry their gear from OC'ing, but it helps manufacturers get better at implementing failsafes and improves engineering too!
 
The reality is the desktop isn't going anywhere for a while. Why? Because most people who are over the age of 30 don't want to be connected all the time, or even consider a computer all that important. I deal with them every day. Heck, my mother-in-law refuses to even own a cell phone.

So it's going to be a generational change before we really see the desktop going away, so I'd say probably around 40 years.
 
I can see the desktop fade away with proper external video cards. Say the docking station has a ridiculous video card (ala SLI, crossfirex, etc.) in it which has ample cooling is used when gaming. A proprietary PCI-E connection connects the laptop to the docking station for maximum throughput.

When undocked, a VPU integrated into the CPU is activated and used for the other stuff. With the extra space in the laptop (since the monster VPU is no longer integrated), a beefier cooling setup is implemented for the processor for overclocking when gaming. Hell the dock can also provide some extra airflow for the laptop.

There, now the desktop is dead. Modular video cards are the future.
 
The desktop will always be around for its power, storage, price, and non-portability. As long as there is gaming and work to be done, the desktop will stay.

Sure aspects may change such as inputs and outputs, but it will always remain as a "base" that all the mobile devices will be able to interact with.

I'd be saying more and more that the laptop / netbook is going to die. Tablets and phones will overtake them. As much as I like my laptop, it's really a strange mash of desktop and tablet that will get outed by more defined and more usable while portable devices. EG, you need a desk to use a laptop these days as they run too hot or need ventilations, and are too unwieldly to hold and use at the same time. Plus they're not that durable. Screens fail, hinges, hard drives, etc all crap out Especially if you spill on them too and make the whole machine a paperweight, (a desktop you just spend a few $ and buy another keyboard).. While a tablet, you just hold it and use it. In other words, what works better on a train, construction site, warehouse, or anywhere else you're walking around and talking to people, etc? A tablet does.

To me the only good use of a laptop is to use at the dinner table or to take to a gaming lan if you get one that can play games just for the fact you only need one bag then as it still needs to be setup like a desktop (external mouse/keyboard) and plugged into the AC. Sure it meets a need, but it's becoming a pretty specialised one.
 
Major forces in the industry want the desktop dead for the same reason big media is pushing things like the iPhone and iPad. Control. A considerable part of the appeal of Cloud computing is that big business retains permanent ownership and control of their services, and this is all part of moving control away from end users. Small compact devices, including laptops, are comparatively sealed appliances that limit end user control of the platform. They're full of proprietary parts and form factors. When there is no need for desktops, and only big OEMs can supply complete sealed and effectively unserviceable systems which already include the OS, computing is going to be impenetrable for those who otherwise would truly innovate, invent, and simply own and control their own hardware and environment. When the desktop is dead, Cloud computing, artificial hardware and software restrictions, and vendor lock-in is going to skyrocket to the point that x86 and Windows will become completely irrelevant and no one will know or care what's powering their devices or how they work. I hope there are enough open-minded people around to prevent this from happening, but after seeing what Apple users are prepared to happily accept I really doubt it.

The future of computing as more than a mindless consumer is very bleak indeed.
 
This fucking guy again?

One of the points made in my Killed By Overclocking article was that pre-tweaked enthusiast products were slowly driving down the number of people who qualify as overclockers. If you followed my logic in that piece, you'd agree that it's our special ability to do the unthinkable with computer hardware should be revered; not something bottled and sold to the highest bidder. Some may disagree, but I still believe that it's our unique ability to tune every last drop of performance out of component hardware that will keep the desktop platform alive. It's not easy watching our hobby get dumbed-down to the point where the push of a button can replace years of trial-and-error experience. At some point, the real overclockers will return to save the desktop platform.

This guy is an idiot. There is no way you are going to push a button and get the same type of OC that I get on my machine. You might get a bit of a boost. Then what can you do if it isn't stable? You can't even push the button right! That is just not the way that it works. It took me days to find find stable settings, and that was just for my particular chip.

Gaming is what is keeping the platform going. We have to change hardware too often for something portable. If we actually try to purchase a "Gaming PC" from any of the vendors, we might as well bring the lube.

My desktop doesn't even have the side on it. It runs cooler that way, and who knows when I might be in it next.
 
This guy is an idiot. There is no way you are going to push a button and get the same type of OC that I get on my machine.

No, but it's getting to the point where newer motherboards offer one-automatic overclocking that can get quite close to the hand-tweaked performance of your machine. ASUS, for example, offers a number of overclocking options, from simple pushbuttons on the motherboard to more elaborate utilities that will change settings, run stress tests, and repeat until crash, then automatically resume with the last known settings.

The overclocks achieved with these features may fall short of what a talented enthusiast can achieve, but increasingly you'll be dealing with differences that are only measurable in synthetic benchmarks. And getting 80 or 90% of the result with a few minutes (instead of hours or days) of effort will appeal to many.

(I can see Model T owners sniffing that those new-fangled cars will never be able to adjust the fuel mixture and spark advance as well as they can do manually with those little levers on the steering column...)
 
desktop pcs are definately in steep decline. one of the big parts of the business i work for is building desktop machines and because of economic factors and laptops etc we have seen a very massive drop in demand for desktop pcs. i've spoken to some of our client businesses and they report the same thing too that their notebook sales have jumped and their desktop sales are almost at a standstill... personally i don't like using laptops its too restrictive...
 
If you want to make money selling laptops is the way to go.
When it comes to actually having an enjoyable experience and high productivity, a custom PC is the way to go.
 
One of the points made in my Killed By Overclocking article was that pre-tweaked enthusiast products were slowly driving down the number of people who qualify as overclockers. If you followed my logic in that piece, you'd agree that it's our special ability to do the unthinkable with computer hardware should be revered; not something bottled and sold to the highest bidder.

Nice cop out.

i think desktop sales for home users has likely dropped, but for businesses, you just cant get the performance from a laptop you get from a desktop and often for a fraction of the cost.
 
I don't know what's the guy's obsession with overclocking, the same argument as for his previous article applies: Overclockers are such a negligible portion of the market that overclocking cannot kill or save the PC, it has virtually no influence on the market.

Modularity and extensibility of PCs are probably better arguments for his new article, although it also concerns only a small share of the market. But if anything should "save" the PC, I see gamers playing that role more than anyone else: They are the real industry drivers, requiring faster and bigger graphic cards, faster disks, CPUs and memory, large double or triple monitor configs, dedicated keyboards and mice, all things that are just not possible on a laptop, netbook, or smart phone.

In second position I'd put Microsoft bloatware: They are the enterprise standard apps, so most people use Windows and Office, but instead of being more and more optimized with each version, these software require more and more powerful hardware: For instance, none of the first netbooks sold after Windows 7's release could run Windows Vista let alone Win7, they were all XP machines.
 
But if anything should "save" the PC, I see gamers playing that role more than anyone else: They are the real industry drivers, requiring faster and bigger graphic cards, faster disks, CPUs and memory, large double or triple monitor configs, dedicated keyboards and mice, all things that are just not possible on a laptop, netbook, or smart phone.

Right on the money. Were people buying Pentiums to balance their checkbooks or run spreadsheets faster? No, they wanted to play Quake. All the high-speed hardware on the consumer market is aimed at gaming. Office machines, unless you're doing 3D design or graphics work, do not have high-powered graphics cards and 1000 watt PSU's. They're mass-produced Dell or HP budget machines. Gaming pushes the consumer market, period.
 
Video killed the radio star.

No, wait, that's not true.

I'm just playing devil's advocate.
 
What a tard. I'm not even going to read this new article after reading the previous. I find it mind-boggling that he thinks a few vanity PC parts sold at extreme markups to a tiny portion of the market could be "killing" the PC industry. And his assertion that overclocking is pointless because computers are fast enough is equally ridiculous. A stock i7 will not even keep up with SLIed cards in a lot of games.
 
Nice cop out.

i think desktop sales for home users has likely dropped, but for businesses, you just cant get the performance from a laptop you get from a desktop and often for a fraction of the cost.

Even more important than that (or at least as important) is the reliability and interoperability/universality of replacement parts. Being able to get universally compatible components from different competing suppliers makes repairs much easier and cost effective. It's easier to work on a desktop, and it breaks down far less than a laptop will. There are always exceptions, but years in this industry has shown me trends that desktops require less maintenance and care, and less frequent repairs with far lower costs. Just the nature of the beast.
 
Even more important than that (or at least as important) is the reliability and interoperability/universality of replacement parts. Being able to get universally compatible components from different competing suppliers makes repairs much easier and cost effective. It's easier to work on a desktop, and it breaks down far less than a laptop will. There are always exceptions, but years in this industry has shown me trends that desktops require less maintenance and care, and less frequent repairs with far lower costs. Just the nature of the beast.

Bang/buck and fix/upgrade potential, and expandability is what seals it for me.

My last system went through 3 graphics cards (1 original, 1 upgrade, 1 failure) and 2 CPUs, a ram upgrade, DVD burner upgrade, failed PS replacement and is still running with a relative.

My current is already on it's second GPU (I plan one more), it's second CPU (I am done), already upgraded the RAM, Blu Ray upgrade, and is running 3 internal HDs.

I have zero desire to carry a laptop anywhere, so a desktop being anchored isn't a downside. Desktop is pure win.

Overclocking has nothing to do with the decision. I am overclocking, but even if I couldn't I would have a desktop for the above reasons.
 
I know the trend is to not watercool nowadays, another advantage of the PC desktop platform and the whole overclocking thing, is that you do have the option to go extreme on a project, i.e. watercooling, LN2, Bong types, House type watercooling, etc.

While there are laptops that overclock, they tend to always end up being poorly implemented, or the increases are barely noticeable.

The sky's the limit when you're building a desktop. Also, the scalability is also another factor. With desktop PCs, and the right configurations, you can purchase additional GPUs for more performance, etc. You can't do that with laptops or consoles... Yet.

=)
 
Why would you want to add another GPU to an Alienware, Asus or Rock laptop that already contain 2? ^-^
 
I have to believe there's always going to be place for a desktop. There always will be with me anyways. :)
 
I've never seen or heard of a 2 CPU laptop. But I was talking about GPUs above...
 
You can get dual, quad, six cores instead.
Triple SLI on a laptop, I surrender... :p
 
I did not know tri-sli was available on a laptop.

The battery life must be terrible. :p

Well it says it is TriSLi it sounds like its dual 9800s and a 9400 (for physx!?) But most gaming laptops get about...1 whole hour!
 
Is it tri-sli if its using 2 different gpus?

Theres an article here

Apparently

Thanks to Nvidia’s Hybrid SLI technology, users are able to easily switch between the powerful dual Geforce 9800M GTS GPUs and the integrated Geforce 9400M, depending on whether scorching performance or quiet operation is desired

Damnit! Can't you turn them all on at once!? $4,199 in 11/2008. Weighing 4kg (9lb). YOu probably could override the hybrid as use one for physx. Just it would kill the battery. Unless the PSU wouldn't allow it.
 
Back
Top