DELL and Lexmark pulling the old SWITCHEROO!

lastrites

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 22, 2003
Messages
131
http://www.lexmark.com/lexmark/product/home/17/0,6970,204812589_209295874_215236625_en_0_6,00.html

http://www1.us.dell.com/content/pro...rint_a960?c=us&cs=19&l=en&s=dhs&~tab=specstab

I was watching HSN and they had this Lexmark printer for sale. And I thought, wow, that looks really familiar. Then they were doing close ups of the buttons, etc... and it turns out this is exactly the same as the Dell A960... right down to the fonts they used to label the buttons.

What I found even more strange (after I came online to double check my findings) was that some of the tech specs (pages per minute) were different, when it's really the same exact printer. Both weigh 24.93 pounds.. it'd be pretty hard for them to say it's just a coinsidence they both way the exact same amount down to the tenth of a pound.

But I digress, is this even a big deal? Does this kind of thing happen often? I know more so for smaller parts, but this is the first time I've ever seen something big like a printer in this situation.
 
Dell has never made their own printers, they have always been rebranded Lexmarks. Dell did make a bunch of design changes that makes the printers "their own." Companies rebrand stuff all the time. It happens and is the nature of the business. Did you see the article Steve posted about who actually makes laptops? Same principle.
 
I did a lot of the testing here in Kentucky for Lexmark that led to that printer. It was a pretty high quality machine when it finally left the prototype area.
 
They used to use HP printers before they decided to use the crappy Lexmark ones. According to a friend of mine who works for Dell, it turned out to be a huge mistake and they've been having a lot of problems and returns. As someone esle posted, Dell cuts corners everywhere and now in the past year and a half or so, it's really coming back to bite them in the ass. Makes me smile!
 
Dell rebadges alot of stuff. All (or at least I think all) of their switches (networking) are made by some Taiwanese company that sells them under their own brand name as well. They look identical except that the Dell ones say Dell on them.
 
SarverSystems said:
What kind of ink do you put in your "Dell" printer? I bet it's LExmark ink!

Actually no, it's Dell ink. It looks exactly like Lexmark ink, except it's not compatible.
 
It is Lexmark ink, but no you can not just buy Lexmark ink cartridges fron the store and have them work in the Dell branded printers. The only way i know of to get ink for dells is to order it from dells site. Whoever at Dell thought it was a good idea to have customers wait 3-5 days to get ink delivered is an absolute moron.

Reason 85034 why I will never purchase anything that says Dell on it or Lexmark for that matter (constant driver issues and communication errors)

I worked for Dell, any printer they badge as their own or any Lexmark printer in general is a POS.


djnes...
Dell only used Lexmark printers, never HP under the Dell badge. AFAIK
 
Dell is not the only one who rebrands products. Compaq, before being bought by HP, also used Lexmark printers with a Compaq label. They still use the normal lexmark ink, which also happens to be ridiculously expensive ($35-40 per cartridge).

I'm surprised Dell moved away from HP though. HP is the printing giant and holds the majority of the market share in many areas of printers.

I interviewed with HP when I was looking for a coop, and we ended up discussing the finer points of inkjet technology for most of the time. :)
 
JKA Represent said:
yeah, dell doesnt make their own printers. I hate dell

Actually, Dell started making their own printers in Q1 this year. I admit though, the first batch looked pretty similar to the Lexmarks still. . . so chances are "making our own", meant shifting production locally.



As for the main topic -- Dell has always used Lexmark rebadges, same with the speakers (if they didn't have an Altec or HK logo), monitors, etc. I know different companies have different standards as for testing and optimal conditions, but the main reasoning for stat/performance differences is that Dell printers are often "optimized", basically reworked to make them different/better than private Lex stock, so that you buy the Dell version when you buy a PC, rather than buying your PC from Dell and your printer elsewhere. They just upgrade 'em.
 
AR said:
As for the main topic -- Dell has always used Lexmark rebadges, same with the speakers (if they didn't have an Altec or HK logo), monitors, etc. I know different companies have different standards as for testing and optimal conditions, but the main reasoning for stat/performance differences is that Dell printers are often "optimized", basically reworked to make them different/better than private Lex stock, so that you buy the Dell version when you buy a PC, rather than buying your PC from Dell and your printer elsewhere. They just upgrade 'em.

Optomized = firmware change of the logo for test page printing =)
 
Xeese said:
Optomized = firmware change of the logo for test page printing =)

What are you talking about? Just putting the Dell logo on it doubles the ppm! It also results in double the calls to Dell's fantastic 24 customer service, which wouldn't be necessary if their stuff didn't suck ;)
 
spinelli said:
djnes...
Dell only used Lexmark printers, never HP under the Dell badge. AFAIK


I never said the rebadged them. They sold only HP printers as HP printers...no cover-ups.
 
I don't know why this is such a surprise; folks in the industry have called this "badge engineering" (as in, buy something decent and put your badge on it) for some time. Other than HP, I'm not sure anyone makes their "own" printers....even automobile manufacturer's do the same thing..... :D

Rock On - B.B.S.
 
BlindedByScience said:
I don't know why this is such a surprise; folks in the industry have called this "badge engineering" (as in, buy something decent and put your badge on it) for some time. Other than HP, I'm not sure anyone makes their "own" printers....even automobile manufacturer's do the same thing..... :D

Rock On - B.B.S.


Ah good point. Explains why when I look under the hood of my Jetta 1.8T I see a bunch of Audi logos. Lexus/Toyota, Nissan/Infinity, Honda/Acura, etc.
 
MarbMild said:
I did a lot of the testing here in Kentucky for Lexmark that led to that printer. It was a pretty high quality machine when it finally left the prototype area.


you're in lexington? hehe so am i :D
 
Three little letters for you...

OEM

There is nothing new, scandalous, or bad about it...

Now if the original equipment sucks (lexmark) rebadging it ain't gonna help.
 
Dell hardly builds anything they sell, even most of the components to their computers like the power supplies, motherboards, etc. are all outsourced and made by someone else. Dell is more of an assembler and seller than actually manufacturing anything.
 
tdg said:
Dell hardly builds anything they sell, even most of the components to their computers like the power supplies, motherboards, etc. are all outsourced and made by someone else. Dell is more of an assembler and seller than actually manufacturing anything.
and they modified parts so it can only be used with other dell parts... i remember trying to help my friend upgrade his dell with a new faster mobo ending up having to get a new case, a new processor, and a new heatsink

i HATE dell...
 
Ok, so if they are the same printer, can someone explain why the "page per minute" numbers are different on each of their sites?
 
most dell ink cartragies and lexmark carts have break away lids in the case of my dell a940 (lexmark x5150) all you have to do when the dell carts run out is take a flat blade pop the top off and put them on a couple of lexmark 32 or 42 carts the color cartraiges are really nice in that they have a Gasket seal which makes removing and refilling down right awesome cost wise
 
Vision864 said:
most dell ink cartragies and lexmark carts have break away lids in the case of my dell a940 (lexmark x5150) all you have to do when the dell carts run out is take a flat blade pop the top off and put them on a couple of lexmark 32 or 42 carts the color cartraiges are really nice in that they have a Gasket seal which makes removing and refilling down right awesome cost wise

They put puncuation keys on your keyboard for a reason :)

It's possible that Dell makes small modifications to the Lexmark brand printers, in addition to having its own proprietary software/driver for it, which may account for the ppm difference.
 
Yes, the Dell printers are Lexmark's. The A920, A940, A922 and A960 are all made by Lexmark.

No, you can not use Lexmark cartridges in them (more on this in a minute). The tops of the cartridges are keyed differently.

I don't know why people complain about having to mail-order cartridges. I personally think its great that they send them to my house for the same price as going out and buying it. I mean jeez, just order a new one as a spare and when you go to use it, order a new one.

It is possible to modify your Dell printer to take Lexmark cartridges. Do not cut the top of the cartridge off. Instead, when you take the cartridge out, the lid that snaps down on the cartridge has a small tab inside it. If you look you will see it. Break this tab off. You should be able to just put your thumb on it and break it off. You should be able to use Lexmark cartridges at this point.

*NOTE* - I have not tried this and do not gaurantee that it will work. Also, don't forget about your warranty.
 
You dont see a problem with mail order ink being the ONLY way to get it without running the risk of voiding a warranty?

Guess I am the only one who runs out of ink when I have a report for school/work due. This happens without fail BTW.
Yes keeping a spare would alleviate that problem though.
 
spinelli said:
You dont see a problem with mail order ink being the ONLY way to get it without running the risk of voiding a warranty?

Guess I am the only one who runs out of ink when I have a report for school/work due. This happens without fail BTW.
Yes keeping a spare would alleviate that problem though.

As for ink? Dell has a overnight/24 hour policy on ink - you order, they overnight it for free b/c they realize they are at a disadvantage to ink you can just go pick up at the store. Their solution for knowing when to change ink so you have a 24 hour heads up, is some software that I doubt anybody here would want on their machine.
 
AFAIK, Dell only overnights ink for free from the SB site.

The Home site is usually only 3-5 day free shipping. Although it usually only takes 2-3.

EDIT: Just checked and neither have free NDA shipping right now. Guess you just have to kind of catch it.

Out of intrest though, I noticed that the 2 Black/1 Color combo pack for the A940 sells for 77.85 on the Home site and 86.85 on the SB site. So even if the SB site runs free NDA:

(Carts)(Ship)(Tax)(HOME)-(SB)(Tax)(Ship)(Carts)
77.85+4.95+0.00=82.80 < 92.06=5.21+0.00+86.85

Looks like home is probably a better deal if it doesn't charge tax in your state, but if it does, SB may be a better deal. I belive that SB charges sales tax in every state though.
 
Bearxor said:
AFAIK, Dell only overnights ink for free from the SB site.

The Home site is usually only 3-5 day free shipping. Although it usually only takes 2-3.

EDIT: Just checked and neither have free NDA shipping right now. Guess you just have to kind of catch it.

Out of intrest though, I noticed that the 2 Black/1 Color combo pack for the A940 sells for 77.85 on the Home site and 86.85 on the SB site. So even if the SB site runs free NDA:

(Carts)(Ship)(Tax)(HOME)-(SB)(Tax)(Ship)(Carts)
77.85+4.95+0.00=82.80 < 92.06=5.21+0.00+86.85

Looks like home is probably a better deal if it doesn't charge tax in your state, but if it does, SB may be a better deal. I belive that SB charges sales tax in every state though.

SMB charges tax in every state because they contract tech support companies to do their on-site labor in every state. You can ALWAYS price match one to the other, we always told people that you couldn't if it would make us personally lose money. So pricematch + tax w/ free overnight on SMB side, or price + overnight charge on DHS.

Also, if you ask to be transferred to the software and peripherals dept (S&P), they may give you a better deal. A systems rep is not going to care enough to discount a $70 item unless there is opportunity for the future.
 
Back
Top