DDR3 1151 boards?

Morlock

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 8, 2012
Messages
509
My old rig died on me and I'm trying to get a new one running on a shoestring budget. The most resource-intensive app I use is Daz Studio, and from what I'm reading it doesn't really take advantage of multi-threading. I'm thinking about buying a Pentium G4560 to tide me over for a year or so, because they're so cheap.

I'm also thinking about stuffing it into a board that uses DDR3, so I can reuse my old RAM (I have 24-32 gigs sitting around, depending on how much of it is still functional). Daz Studio may not make much use of multi-threading, but it definitely uses lots of RAM. More than I can afford at current DDR4 prices.

At this point I don't know if I need to replace my GPU, but if I do, I'm going with the Amazon GTX 1050 special for $131, if it matters.

Can anyone suggest a motherboard that qualifies?

Edit: now I'm seeing that the article I read about the Pentium is a year old, so similarly cheap alternative choices are welcome.
 
https://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=9SIA85V6WC8628

or the ASRock H110M-DVS/D3

or the ASRock Z170 Gaming K4/D3 (probably the best bet)

Gigabyte GA-Z170-HD3 DDR3 is probably another good choice.


I'd probably look at a first gen skylake chip only because you don't want to get stuck with a bios that doesn't like your 2C/4T pentium. The only boards that I remember supporting DDR3 were 1st gen 1151 boards so a B250 or something like that isn't really an option. Maybe get an i3 6100 instead of the G4560?

Another thing to think about is that these boards only officially supported DDR3L (1.35V) memory. If you use regular 1.5V memory, you could fry the memory controller on the chip (according to Intel). These weren't exactly high end boards, so who knows for sure. I didn't play around with them so I don't have first hand knowledge. Just trying to give you some info. Also, these boards tend to be stupid expensive now that they are a few years old (see the link above). Definitely have to look for a deal.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the quick reply.

Wow so DDR3 boards are so far out of date that now they're pricey antiques and they're gonna eat up any savings from keeping my RAM. Great.

If the loaner I'm using right now wasn't such a POS I could stomach waiting a couple months to see if prices come down, but it really is a POS. It's a cheesy HP with notebook hardware - one with the "APU" soldered into the mobo. It craps its pants at any multitasking. It's been installing Office 2013 for like two hours now, and it's still "finalizing."
 
Last edited:
Hell, this old legacy crap is expensive, right? So I can sell my DDR3 Ram for a premium, just like they're trying to charge me for an old DDR3 mobo, right? Lemme guess: no?
 
Hell, this old legacy crap is expensive, right? So I can sell my DDR3 Ram for a premium, just like they're trying to charge me for an old DDR3 mobo, right? Lemme guess: no?

Honestly, your better off getting a H81/B85/H97/Z97/Haswell generation CPU/Mobo if you're set on keeping your RAM. You could probably get a Z97 and Haswell i3 or i5 for under $150.

If you have 32GB of matching DDR3 memory that works, it's worth $125-150. 16GB is $75-85 depending on the type.

Look on Fleabay for those older boards. Might be able to score one for $60-75.
 
Thanks again. I'm gonna have to think about this for a while. I might just bite the bullet and buy a single 8gb stick of DDR4 for now, with the plan of buying more when prices come down or my budget opens up a bit.

I just remembered ReadyBoost. I have several thumb drives laying around. One is 128 gb, if memory serves. Another is 64gb. Do you think one of these would help running Daz Studio?

Edit: I'm also reading up on AMD vs. Intel mobo/cpu combos. I can't tell yet if the savings from the aforementioned Pentium would be eaten by higher mobo costs, so advice appreciated. The loose plan forming in my head is to get the cheapest GTX 1050 I can find, one of these cheap Pentiums, and a nice/decent mobo so when I get the cash upgrading will just be a matter of new CPU and GPU and a couple sticks of RAM.
 
Last edited:
Thanks again. I'm gonna have to think about this for a while. I might just bite the bullet and buy a single 8gb stick of DDR4 for now, with the plan of buying more when prices come down or my budget opens up a bit.

I just remembered ReadyBoost. I have several thumb drives laying around. One is 128 gb, if memory serves. Another is 64gb. Do you think one of these would help running Daz Studio?

I never used it so I have no idea. But thumb drives are slower than SSD's so I'd definitely run one of those over a mechanical drive with ready boost.
 
How about selling the old working parts and moving to a cheap Z370 + i3 8350K?

At least you don't have to buy a GPU... :O
 
I don't know if I need a new GPU or not. TLDR version: my pc died, I took it to a guy I know because he's an in-law, kinda, and he said my GPU was dead. But he's a sketchy sort. I was already skeptical that all the stuff he said was dead was really dead (in my experience, stuff doesn't all die at once, quite the opposite, as long as it wasn't a power surge or some kind of catastrophic power issue, which this wasn't), but after reading about how insane GPU prices are now, my skepto-meter went into the red. So I changed my mind and decided not to take his word for it. But I left 2 sticks of RAM and my GPU at his place, because he said they were dead. This was late evening, and I texted him early the next morning to tell him I wanted it all back. This was the day before yesterday, but he had already told me he was going out of town yesterday, so I'm not worried that he isn't answering my texts - he doesn't answer them when he's in town, either. He's sketchy, but I don't think he's sketchy enough to outright rob me. I can see him lying so he can get my parts and sell them, but not straight up selling them after I told him to give them back.

But, maybe someone more technical than I am can weigh in; I think it's very improbable that a mobo, CPU, GPU, and 2 sticks of RAM would all die at once (He says it was heat death; I buy that for the CPU because as soon as the rig died I saw that the heat sink was hanging half-off). What do you guys say?
 
Last edited:
As for z370, I was just looking at them, but apparently they don't work with G4560s, so I dunno. I'm going to look at the last generation of boards that work with G4560s (z270s?) and see how the prices compare to the z370 boards.

I'm also mulling over waiting for the new, budget-oriented boards that I keep reading will be out in March.

And yeah I'm currently putting the eyeball on everything I've got laying around for stuff I can sell. I've got to check my DDR3 RAM to see what's still operational, but I have no idea where I'm going to check that. I have an extra Corsair CX600 PSU that I'm going to yank out and sell. And various stuff like old heat sinks.
 
The other option I'm toying with is looking for a prebuilt with a nice video card that I can yank out and sell for a tidy profit. And sell everything else but the mobo/CPU/RAM, buy a GTX 1050, and put it all into my case.
 
Most likely just a dead board. CPUs themselves are generally pretty tough and can even endure multiple cycles of max thermal threshold before any real degredation. Even less likely all of your sticks of RAM died simultaneously. From the sounds of it the VRMs got cooked on the board. Have you priced any on eBay
 
He kept talking about all the blueing on the mobo and cpu, as if it made it obvious that everything was dead, how he wanted to take a picture cause he'd never seen anything so bad, etc.

He said he plugged every part he was claiming to be dead into a mobo and couldn't get it to post/got error beep codes. I realize in hindsight that he could just be an asshat, and not sketching out on me. Using a crappy board, or something. Or he could be right. I just don't believe he's right about all of it. I see how heat issues could kill a GPU, but not at the exact same time it killed the mobo or CPU, not without an amazing coincidence.

Dunno what a VRM is, so no I don't know prices. :)
 
Last edited:
If what you say is exactly what he told you, he seems like a backyard technician to me... Wouldn't trust him...

Blueing of the motherboard... :O
 
If what you say is exactly what he told you, he seems like a backyard technician to me... Wouldn't trust him...

Blueing of the motherboard... :O
This. I have never heard of the phrase and I can't even guess as to what he means by it.

VRMs are Voltage Regulator Modules. They're simply the component on your board responsible for controlling the voltage or power that feeds your CPU. They can come in many different configurations depending on the board and often times can overheat and fail if not properly cooled or are over utilized. By pricing I meant new boards. Here's a brand new Asus Gaming Z170 for $79 which is about as fair as it gets.
https://m.ebay.com/itm/ASUS-Z170-PR...890039434?epid=1059031947&hash=item2398f4dc8a
 
As an eBay Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Blueing, as in blue-colored discolorations on metal on the board (some capacitors, the gate that locks down the CPU, etc.). He definitely seems like a backyard technician. I kept looking at his prices (he has a computer repair business but his employee pretty much runs it for him while he does other stuff) and thinking I should open my own shop. $130 to wipe the C drive and install fresh OS is easy money.

Flawlez thx, that is a very good price. I've only been looking at B250/H270/Z270 boards because I know they'll work with a G4560, will Z170 boards work?
 
Blueing, as in blue-colored discolorations on metal on the board (some capacitors, the gate that locks down the CPU, etc.). He definitely seems like a backyard technician.

Flawlez thx, that is a very good price. I've only been looking at B250/H270/Z270 boards because I know they'll work with a G4560, will Z170 boards work?

They will work, but you have to make sure they have an updated bios.
 
Ah, okay. I think I misinterpreted what I read. It said something like "these will work right out of the box," I suppose that's what it meant - no need to update the BIOS. Which is kinda nice, but got transposed in my mind to "I need one of these boards."
 
You could buy a used one and just make sure that the bios is updated. I sold my Maximus VIII Ranger here the other day for $80 shipped and it had an updated bios.
 
Heh, I just talked to him about picking up the GPU and he abruptly told me he wouldn't replace the screen on the laptop I left for an estimate. Maybe he's reading this forum and doesn't like "sketchy." Hey, if you're reading this, what do I know? Maybe you were right about everything and it all died at exactly the same time. No offense meant. Thanks for the loaner. On the other hand, when I leave your house at like 9pm, and text you the next morning at 7:30am to tell you not to throw my CPU into the junk box, only to find out it wound up in the junk box, that's kinda sketchy.

Unfortunately, the CPU is gone. It's now in the junk box with 50 other CPUs.
 
Heh, I just talked to him about picking up the GPU and he abruptly told me he wouldn't replace the screen on the laptop I left for an estimate. Maybe he's reading this forum and doesn't like "sketchy." Hey, if you're reading this, what do I know? Maybe you were right about everything and it all died at exactly the same time. No offense meant. Thanks for the loaner.

Unfortunately, the CPU is gone. It's now in the junk box with 50 other CPUs.

What kind of GPU is it? He probably wanted to sell it for mining or mine with it himself.
 
It's old. An ASUS GTX 760. He said it's "fried." He said he did some soldering work on it, and one of the fans was dead.
 
But it turns out the surprising 16gb of RAM in the crappy HP charity case is from my old computer, so I already have that back and it's working fine. That leaves the two 4gb sticks for me to check (he said one is fried).
 
Hey Kirby, do you happen to know roughly how much I could sell two of these for?

team group vulcan 4gb ddr3 1600 1.5v tlyd34g1600hc9bk
 
Thanks. What's FS/FT?

If both of the 4gb sticks check out and I can get like $110 for them plus my two 8gb sticks, that would really help out a lot.

I was just looking through an old box and I've got like 5 old motherboards in there. I wish I had some way of knowing if they work or not, given the looney prices people are paying for old mobos.
 
LOL. I just got back from picking up my graphics card. Suddenly the card went from "fried" to "I got it to post but one of the video ports is dead."

I wouldn't be surprised if he's been reading this thread, because he was definitely in sulk mode when I got there, like I'd done him wrong. My sister is mother to his wife's brother's child, and I loaned his wife 20k no interest unsecured some years back (long before he ever met her, so I wouldn't be surprised if he never heard that story) on nothing more than an IOU. So forgive me for expecting something like the family treatment, since money is supertight right now and I can't afford to be throwing away parts that are gonna cost me over a hundred bucks to replace.

Oh well, whatever.

Edit: Kirby: ah, thx.

Honestly I kinda hope he has been reading this thread, because otherwise he's got absolutely nothing to be miffed about, except being caught out changing his story.
 
Last edited:
Both of the DVI ports on the video card still work.

I'm shocked, shocked I tell u.

Just the fact that he made it sound like he only tried it on one mobo and he never said anything like "it could have just been the mobo I tried" made me wonder.

Fuckwad. I hope he is reading this thread.

CPU was probably fine, too. I probably could have gotten away with just replacing the mobo for $150 instead of shelling out $475 for a new everything. Once the CPU was "gone," I was looking at $250 just to sidegrade so why not upgrade at that point.
 
Last edited:
CPU's don't go bad. 99 times out of 100 it's the motherboard. Sounds like he's ripping you off, especially after he was hassling you about getting your video card back.
 
It wouldn't be accurate to say he was hassling me, I don't want to give that impression (not that it matters, since I have graciously opted NOT to put his name or the name of his business out there), but he was definitely in sulk mode after I told him I wanted it back.

If I had an extra board that would take that CPU, I would put together a case and insist on sitting down with that box of "dead" CPUs of his and test every chip of that type until I had found mine, or confirmed them all dead.

Thing is, he's barely even ripping me off; he keeps the "dead" CPUs to "melt down for gold" one day. Or maybe he was lying and it didn't go into the box at all, what do I know?
 
It wouldn't be accurate to say he was hassling me, I don't want to give that impression (not that it matters, since I have graciously opted NOT to put his name or the name of his business out there), but he was definitely in sulk mode after I told him I wanted it back.

If I had an extra board that would take that CPU, I would put together a case and insist on sitting down with that box of "dead" CPUs of his and test every chip of that type until I had found mine, or confirmed them all dead.

Thing is, he's barely even ripping me off; he keeps the "dead" CPUs to "melt down for gold" one day. Or maybe he was lying and it didn't go into the box at all, what do I know?

Do you still need a cpu? I have an i5 6600 that I replaced with a kaby lake I7 that I can send you and if it works for you, you can make me an offer. I will have to find it first though lol.
 
Not at the moment, no, but thanks for the offer. I do have this vague idea of upgrading the lame charity rig I got from him. I wish it had a real board in it; it's got like a 6 year old thing with the CPU soldered into it. But I kinda like the case (HP Pavilion), it's small, decent-looking, and would make a fair HTPC or seed box (or both). But I don't have the money for any of that right now, in fact I'm probably going to wind up selling my DDR3 RAM to recoup some of my losses from my new system.
 
Sounds like he has a "nice" bench mobo for testing all those "fried" parts on, and doesn't even have the common sense to realize it's "fried" itself. Or he's a scammer from the get go.

I have several old Core 2 E series combos I could send you if you need them, on the house except shipping. They won't do much more than web browsing and office work, but they are free. I buy them from a charity, and build usable Linux towers for the needy. One has been running 24/7 as my camera server for two years+, on WinXP.
 
Back
Top