Critique my new Intel Build

naxos

n00b
Joined
Apr 19, 2004
Messages
60
Hello all please critique my new build. I'm hoping to order all the parts tomorrow but I'm still a little iffy on a couple components. I will be using it for gaming, work, personal audio/video encoding. Looking for a powerhouse but don't want to hear it.

The full system build with links/prices can be found on Newegg

Quick run down of the Core:
Case: Antec P182 (Leaned towards this over the Coolermaster Cosmos1000)
Proc: Intel Core 2 Quad Q9300
Mobo/s: ASUS P5E X38 or DFI LANPARTY DK X38 (Going with X38 for the "future-proofing" of PCIe2 x2 - Please let me know if this is misguided.)
Video:eVGA 8800GTS
Memory:4GB (2x2GB) gSkill DDR2 1066
HDD:Western Digital Caviar 750GB 7200RPM
PSU: CORSAIR CMPSU-620HX 620W


Feel free to be harsh ;)

Also, any suggestions for a solid, quiet CPU Cooler? or is (heaven forbid) stock OK?
 
get a GeForce 9800 GTX
if u plan to upgrade your PC soon, then u can buy a 8800GT, and then Step-up in June to a brand new GeForce 9900 GTX or G200 or whatever they want to call it now :p
 
You don't need DDR2 1066 ram because your processor can't reach fsb that high. Buy the G.skill DDR2 1000.
 
You missed the PSU. That is a core part BTW. And please just list out all the parts. Linking Newegg lists is a pain.

I concur with pedophilekiller (awesome name BTW:D) about the DDR2 1066 RAM. It's overpriced considering that you can get the DDR2 1000 RAM for $60 cheaper:
G.SKILL F2-8000CL5D-4GBPQ 2 x 2GB DDR2 1000 RAM - $85

You can get the Corsair PSU for cheaper here:
Corsair 620HX 620W Modular PSU - $140

However, if you don't really need Modular cabling, I highly recommend getting this PSU instead:
Corsair 750TX 750W PSU - $105

As for HSF, here's a few recommendations:
Xigmatek HDT-S1283 120mm Rifle HSF - $37
Tuniq Tower 120 HSF - $45
ZEROtherm Nirvana NV120 120mm HSF - $50
Thermalright Ultima-90 HSF - $46 & Panaflo FBA09A12M 92mm Fan - $3
Noctua NH-U12P HSF - $60
Thermalright Ultra-120 Extreme HSF - $57 & Scythe S-Flex SFF21E 120MM Case Fan - $14
 
Thanks for the thoughts guys.

As far as the Graphics goes - I kind of thought that the 8800GTS was the one to buy these days? Does the 9800GTX dominate it in performance?

I'm certainly going to get the DDR21000 cheaper memory. Thanks!

Thanks for the HSF recommendations. Looking through them now. What do you think of the Zalman 9500A 92mm (on sale at Newegg for 43 bucks) Know if it will fit on those mobos?

Speaking of the mobos - any thoughts between the 2 of them? I just can't seem to decide.

Thanks again.
 
Thanks for the thoughts guys.

As far as the Graphics goes - I kind of thought that the 8800GTS was the one to buy these days? Does the 9800GTX dominate it in performance?

I'm certainly going to get the DDR21000 cheaper memory. Thanks!

Thanks for the HSF recommendations. Looking through them now. What do you think of the Zalman 9500A 92mm (on sale at Newegg for 43 bucks) Know if it will fit on those mobos?

Speaking of the mobos - any thoughts between the 2 of them? I just can't seem to decide.

Thanks again.

No, the 8800 GTS 512 is a great value, stick with it. Check out the Accelero S1 if you want it to be quiet.

The 9500 is a decent heat sink, but not in the same league as the Xigmatek or Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme. Those are the only 2 I'd consider, especially if you want something quiet for a overclocked quad core.

On the motherboards, I don't have experience with either of them, but from what I've read, the DFI is better if you are into tweaking a bunch of different settings whereas the Asus is more n00b friendly. That's just a generalization, either one should work fine.

Everything else looks great. Fantastic choices on the case, hard drive and PSU. :)
 
Both boards have CrossFire support -- which isn't a good long-term solution if you intend on sticking with NVIDIA cards. Also, which monitor/resolution are you using?
 
No, the 8800 GTS 512 is a great value, stick with it. Check out the Accelero S1 if you want it to be quiet.
Very cool - is replacing the heat sinks on new gfx a pain? I did it LOOONG ago and I just remember it involved me freezing the card to break the heat sinks off cleanly. I really like the looks of that Accelero though! very cool.
The 9500 is a decent heat sink, but not in the same league as the Xigmatek or Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme. Those are the only 2 I'd consider, especially if you want something quiet for a overclocked quad core.
Cool - I'll keep those in mind. Thanks!

Both boards have CrossFire support -- which isn't a good long-term solution if you intend on sticking with NVIDIA cards. Also, which monitor/resolution are you using?
Is it actually a problem to run the nVidia cards here on the Intel chipset? Are you referring to the fact that down the road I can't just pair up another cheaper (at that time) nVidia card and put them in SLI?

I will be using the Dell 24'' Ultrasharp @ 1920x1200
 
You can only implement SLI on nVidia based motherboards. SLI will not work on an X38 motherboard ever.

If you're only going to use a single graphics card, you could save some money by using a P35 based motherboard which has one x16 slot and one x4 slot. Both ATI and nVidia are rumored to be releasing their next generation of products starting in June, so you might want to wait for that to drive down cost or make new products available in your price range.
 
The 9800GTX is nothing but an 8800GTS overclocked from 650/1625/970 to 675/1688/1100 (core/shader/RAM). If you want something high-end, I'd say wait for the new cards from ATI and Nvidia.

All Intel motherboards (except the D5400XS) only support crossfire not SLI. This means you will not benefit performance-wise from installing a second Nvidia card.
 
Hey, this is similar to what I just built (last week!) and I love it- i did go for a Q6600- but that's def up to you

Intel - Q6600

Tuniq Tower 120- huge, but WILL fit in the case, has selectable speed for quiet or game time. It takes time to get it on the mobo- make sure to torque the screws down in a cross pattern to do it right and have it sturdy, this thing weighs a ton!!

Abit IP35 Pro- (no SLI for me, I use dual monitors sometimes and game on a 22" widescreen so the need isn't there)
I went w/ evga 9800GTX for the reasons above- This card is great, but very long, I had to take out the middle hard drives (and put them in the lower cage) to get it to fit, I think the 8800 are a bit shorter, but still might not clear it-

P182(se) Case- I LOVE THIS CASE!

Corsair 750w psu - non modular, but after some time working on the cable routing (P182 has GREAT cable management) it all fits and doesn't hurt the airflow

Good luck on the build!!
 
Thanks for all the input guys. I get so stressed out when I'm trying to order a new system! Just too many options and I want to try and get it spot on :) For instance - I'm back onto an "i should buy a ddr3 rig" kick right now...

Gonna keep digging around and try to order the parts later today - I'll keep you posted. If anyone has anymore insight or advice I would still appreciate it!
 
Don't get DDR3.

Yes, the 8800GTS is shorter than the 9800GTX and it will fit with two HDD's in the upper bay, though it is a tight squeeze.

My Antec NeoPower 650's modular cabling worked very well in my P182, I'd recommend it. Newegg has the NeoPower 650 Blue for $109, but the Corsair 750W is more bang for your buck. The Antec is built by Seasonic while the Corsair is built by Channel Well.
 
A modular PSU should be preferred to lessen cable clutter, which would provide better airflow in your lower chamber. Don't forget to route your cables behind the motherboard tray.
 
A modular PSU should be preferred to lessen cable clutter, which would provide better airflow in your lower chamber. Don't forget to route your cables behind the motherboard tray.

Yeah I really want to make this a super clean build - thats why I am going with the modular PSU and the p182 for the routing.
 
Any reason other than SLI to run one of the Striker boards with the nVidia 790i chipset?

(I'm bogged down in mobos atm...once I make up my mind I'll be able to buy...i hope)
 
Not really. The Intel chipsets are more stable than any of the NVIDIA chipsets, especially overclocked. With your monitor, a single high-end video card, like the 8800GTS, could play games all by itself (with a few notable exceptions).

If performance is your overall concern, and if you're willing to wait for the new video cards expected to arrive this summer, consider a P35-based board instead.
 
Not really. The Intel chipsets are more stable than any of the NVIDIA chipsets, especially overclocked. With your monitor, a single high-end video card, like the 8800GTS, could play games all by itself (with a few notable exceptions).

If performance is your overall concern, and if you're willing to wait for the new video cards expected to arrive this summer, consider a P35-based board instead.

Really I like a few of the P35 mobos better in what they offer as the full package (wifi, eSata, etc) but I got sold on pci express2 being supported on the X38 boards. I got screwed on a previous build by going with AGP right when pci-express was coming in and have regretted that decision ever since. Thats why I was picking the X38 board over the P35...am I way off base?
 
Very cool - is replacing the heat sinks on new gfx a pain? I did it LOOONG ago and I just remember it involved me freezing the card to break the heat sinks off cleanly. I really like the looks of that Accelero though! very cool.
No it''s easy. Google some reviews of the card and you can see the installation process.
 
...I got sold on pci express2 being supported on the X38 boards. I got screwed on a previous build by going with AGP right when pci-express was coming in and have regretted that decision ever since. Thats why I was picking the X38 board over the P35...am I way off base?

The move from AGP to PCI-E was a complete changeover, whereas the move from PCI-E1.x to PCI-E2.0 is a simple upgrade. The only difference between PCI-E2.0 and PCI-E1.x is the increased power delivery through the slot and the increased bandwidth. PCI-E2.0 cards are backwards compatible with PCI-E1.x slots. However, current PCI-E2.0 cards do not saturate the bandwidth of PCI-E1.x slots. Therefore, theres no point in spending a huge amount of money for the sole purpose of getting a PCI-E2.0 slot right now. By the time PCI-E2.0 cards are severely limited by the lower bandwidth of the PCI-E1.x slots, it will be time for a new motherboard anyhow (by which time PCI-E3.0 will be out; which would put you back into the same predicament).

If you don't need dual 16x Crossfire, stick with a P35 board.
 
Really I like a few of the P35 mobos better in what they offer as the full package (wifi, eSata, etc) but I got sold on pci express2 being supported on the X38 boards. I got screwed on a previous build by going with AGP right when pci-express was coming in and have regretted that decision ever since. Thats why I was picking the X38 board over the P35...am I way off base?

Somewhat. Today's PCI Express 2.0 cards are backwards compatible with the PCI Express 1.x (x16) slots on most of the P35-based boards. Additionally, no single PCI-E 2.0 card fully saturates the bandwidth bus of the PCI-E 1.x slot.
 
The move from AGP to PCI-E was a complete changeover, whereas the move from PCI-E1.x to PCI-E2.0 is a simple upgrade. The only difference between PCI-E2.0 and PCI-E1.x is the increased power delivery through the slot and the increased bandwidth. PCI-E2.0 cards are backwards compatible with PCI-E1.x slots. However, current PCI-E2.0 cards do not saturate the bandwidth of PCI-E1.x slots. Therefore, theres no point in spending a huge amount of money for the sole purpose of getting a PCI-E2.0 slot right now. By the time PCI-E2.0 cards are severely limited by the lower bandwidth of the PCI-E1.x slots, it will be time for a new motherboard anyhow (by which time PCI-E3.0 will be out; which would put you back into the same predicament).

If you don't need dual 16x Crossfire, stick with a P35 board.

Somewhat. Today's PCI Express 2.0 cards are backwards compatible with the PCI Express 1.x (x16) slots on most of the P35-based boards. Additionally, no single PCI-E 2.0 card fully saturates the bandwidth bus of the PCI-E 1.x slot.

Both of you just made my choice a lot easier! Thanks for the great explanations. Puts me back looking at the P35 boards :) Back to the reviews for now! Cheers!
 
Back
Top