Corsair 520 modular any good?

ZMTToxics

Gawd
Joined
Nov 4, 2004
Messages
686
I just replaced my wonky Thermaltake 560 Silent Purepower (it was doing werid things, like wouldn't turn on unless it was warmed up for a few minutes stuff - took like 20 trys to turn on the computer). But I noticed it didn't have nearly as high as a max watt draw as the 560 (the 560 peaks out at 600watts max) and it has about half the current on all of the lines (24A versus 40A).

Is this Corsair 520 a mistake? Should I have gotten another Thermaltake?
 
The 520HX is a very nice PSU and will power your main system very nicely.
 
I have the 620HX and I love it. Never had a problem with it, and it's really quiet too.
 
I just replaced my wonky Thermaltake 560 Silent Purepower (it was doing werid things, like wouldn't turn on unless it was warmed up for a few minutes stuff - took like 20 trys to turn on the computer). But I noticed it didn't have nearly as high as a max watt draw as the 560 (the 560 peaks out at 600watts max) and it has about half the current on all of the lines (24A versus 40A).

Is this Corsair 520 a mistake? Should I have gotten another Thermaltake?

Ok, you need to read this FAQ:
http://jonnyguru.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1036

Second, as shown above, wattage isn't THE major factor. What matters a lot is how much power is available on the +12V rail. The vast majority of PC parts today draw their power from the +12V rail. If you look at the 520HX, it has 480W on the +12V rail or 40A on the +12V rail. The Purepower 560W only has 22A or 264W on the +12V rail. So despite having a higher wattage, the Purepower is a poor poor PSU due to the ridiculously small +12V rail.

So no, the Corsair 520HX was not a mistake. Excellent choice. It actually offers more power for your PC than the Purepower and it's of superb quality.
 
Ok, you need to read this FAQ:
http://jonnyguru.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1036

Second, as shown above, wattage isn't THE major factor. What matters a lot is how much power is available on the +12V rail. The vast majority of PC parts today draw their power from the +12V rail. If you look at the 520HX, it has 480W on the +12V rail or 40A on the +12V rail. The Purepower 560W only has 22A or 264W on the +12V rail. So despite having a higher wattage, the Purepower is a poor poor PSU due to the ridiculously small +12V rail.

So no, the Corsair 520HX was not a mistake. Excellent choice. It actually offers more power for your PC than the Purepower and it's of superb quality.

You must have looked at the wrong version, my 560 was rated for 40A and 520 watts on the 12v rail.

EDIT: Or I read it wrong. The website seems to match your findings. I should look at it tomorrow and check again.
 
You must have looked at the wrong version, my 560 was rated for 40A and 520 watts on the 12v rail.

It probably can't provide all 40A at 12v at once; adding the maximum amp draw of all rails together does not equal the maximum output of a unit in most cases. The Corsair however is actually a single rail unit, so it can provide its total rated output on all rails at 12v.
 
I know from personal experience that the is one heck of a power supply, It's what I am using on my system, and my system has a larger power usage then yours.
 
I just recently bought a 620w version and it had the infamous "buzz" even when nothing was connected using the paperclip test :(

I'm in Australia so i have to deal with the store, have not received replacement yet :(

I'm sure they're a great unit when they work as intended though and yes it does look well made and does feel expensive when you hold it haha :D
 
the 520HX works good, i used the corsair website and it says the little 520watt can even handle the 4870x2
 
Back
Top