Core i7 Build - Suggestions Welcome

Bisectors Fore

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 24, 2008
Messages
480
I am planning to build a new gaming rig around the Core i7 platform. My budget is $2,000, including shipping and tax. I live in central Virginia. I plan to order the components online, most likely from Newegg.com. I have listed the parts I need below. The only parts I will be re-using are mouse, keyboard, and monitor. I will not be overclocking. I have a 1280x1024 CRT monitor. I plan to buy the system as soon as I have all components selected and the i7 platform is stable. I do not need RAID, 1394, or dual graphics card support. I have listed the system as I have it planned out so far below. Any recommendations or advice is welcome. Thank you.

>Processor: Intel Core i7 920

>Mainboard: i7 Compatible Mainboard (X58)

>Case: ATX Full Tower Case

>Graphics Card: Geforce GTX 280

>Memory: 6GB Triple Channel DDR3

>Hard Drives: 2x ~250GB SATA 2

>Power Supply: 700w + PSU

>Disc Drive: Basic DVD Drive

>CPU/GPU Fan/Hearsink: Aftermarket Fan/Heatsink

>Headphones: Basic, good quality wired headphones

Operating System: Windows Vista Ultimate 64 or XP 32
 
Thanks for answering the questions from the sticky... here's a few more...

Which games will you be playing?
Do you plan on getting a larger monitor any time soon? If so, is it part of that $2k budget?
How long do you plan on keeping the system before upgrading the core (cpu/mobo/ram)?

You do know that for gaming, i7 doesn't show a whole lot of improvement over current Core2 offerings, right?

Since you don't need a dual vidcard board and don't plan on OC'ing, I'd suggest waiting for the mainstream i7 motherboards, since only the enthusiast level X58 boards are out right now (and at such a high price premium).

Some popular full size cases are the Cooler Master Stacker series, Cosmos, HAF932; Lian-Li PC-A7xxx series, PC-Vxxxx series, and Silverstone Temjin series (eg TJ10).

You don't need a GTX280 for 1280x1024 gaming. I think you should upgrade that monitor.

G.Skill is a good brand for RAM. Make sure whichever kit you choose operates at 1.5v - 1.65v max.

I'd go with at least 320GB drives, since they use the newer, higher density platters, which improves overall performance a great deal. 250GB platters perform around 65MB/s whereas 320GB+ platters perform around 90MB/s. The Samsung Spinpoint F1 series, 'cuda.11 generation, and WD AAKS and AALS drives utilze these higher density platters.

You don't need 700W for a single vidcard, 2x HDD, quadcore system. A good quality 620W from Corsair is more than enough if you want modular. If not, then the Corsair 750TX is also a good deal at around $100.

For optical drives, Samsung and Asus are pretty quiet. Be sure to get a SATA version.

The HDT-S1283 from Xigmatek performs as good as the TRUE120 but costs much less. Though, wait for an LGA1366 retention kit before buying, if getting an i7.

Sennheisser headphones are thought to be pretty good.

Go with Vista 64. Home Premium is typically enough for most people. Use LogMeIn for remote access.

For a specific parts list, maybe HG, DB, trs, IN, or someone will come along and compile one for you. ;)
 
I will keep a watch on this thread, as well as mine since we are looking to build similar systems.
 
Thank you for your comprehensive post, enginurd.

Games which I will be playing include Stalker Clear Sky, Fallout 3, Crysis, Far Cry 2. I like first person gaming.

I was not planning on getting a monitor and including it in the budget, because getting a meaningfull pixel increase would be fairly expensive. I am planning to max out all other settings at 1280x1024. It seems like nowadays people are having to turn down resolution anyway in order to crank all other settings to max.

I would like to keep this system for as long as I can and still play current (current in the future) games well, and I plan to upgrade the graphics card in the future.

I do know that i7 is not a big performance increase for gaming. I am coming off of a AMD Athlon FX 60 in a laptop, so I have to build from scratch anyway. I don't think it makes a whole lot of sense to buy a platform that just got replaced for a high performance system that I plan to keep for several years.

I think I will wait for mainstream i7 mainboards. I was not looking forward to shelling out $300 for a mobo. Any Idea when they will be available?

Thank you for the case recommendations, I will check them out later.

I want the GTX 280 so I won't have to upgrade for awhile, and because it is the MOST POWERFUL SINGLE GRAPHICS CARD ON EARTH!!! :cool: (I'm sure you understand)

Thank you for the heads up on memory and drives, I'll take it into account.

I would like to get a PSU that has some expansion room for my system, though I don't know much about them. Also, what is the difference between modular and not?

Thanks for the recommendations on the cooler and headphones, I had heard that Seinheiser is good.

I own a copy of XP 32 and I don't know if it is worth going to Vista right now. I know that I will be capped @ 4GB of RAM with 32-bit, but I had heard that a6GB kit would still work.

Zhyn, that is cool, I will check out your thread also.

I gotta go guys but thanks and I will be back later.
 
Mainstream parts for Nehalem aren't scheduled for release until Q2'09, unfortunately. I'm not sure if you can wait that long. :eek:

Even upgrading to a 22" Widescreen will improve gaming experience, and since you're set on the GTX280, it would still last you a while. ;)

Modular PSUs have detachable peripheral cables, so you don't get a huge clutter of unused cables in your case. They make cable management a bit easier.

If you're getting all new hardware right now, there's really no reason to avoid Vista 64-bit unless you're on a tight budget.
 
While I won't discourage you from getting a Core i7 build, you make it sound like Core 2 is already dead on the vine. The mainstream Core i7-based motherboards are expected to arrive some time between the second and third quarter of next year -- basically, you'd have to wait at least another six months for cheaper motherboards. Core 2 parts will still be available during that time, and will be comparatively cheaper for the time being. If you can wait for the mainstream Core i7 components, then wait. But don't discount Core 2 parts because they aren't the latest and greatest things around.

While I understand your mentality for wanting the GTX 280, that's the wrong mentality to have. Though the GTX 280 is one of the best cards around today, you wouldn't see much of an improvement from it, at a 1280x1024 resolution no less, than you would from either the 9800GTX or the HD4850. Video cards are also the fastest depreciating part of the computer nowadays. The "high-end" refreshes itself with newer, better (and, occasionally, cheaper) models at least every six to nine months. You would be better off waiting for one of the GTX 260 cards to go on sale for around $200 (some models have been getting pretty close to that price recently) than you would spending nearly/over $500 on a GTX 280. You'll max out most of your games with either card.

OK, rant over. I'll offer some positive input...

Though 32-bit XP does have the 4GB limitation, you could get three 1GB sticks to take advantage of the DDR3 tri-channel mode.

Modular power supplies have removable cables so you only have to keep the cables you need. Though they make for a cleaner case (and, due to a lack of excess cabling, help improve airflow throughout the case), they are more expensive for the non-modular power supplies. A good power supply of at least 500 watts with Active PFC and 80 Plus certification is all you need for your build. Some good brands to look at are Corsair, Silverstone, Seasonic, PC Power & Cooling, and Enermax (though there are others).

Sennheiser makes some pretty good headphones, but their better varieties may be more expensive than what you're looking for. I'm a big fan of them myself, as I have several pairs of headphones for my various electronic/multimedia products.
 
Case - I like my Antec 1200. It's expensive (about 200 USD in Poland), but very well built and finished. One drawback is that you get all the fans connected to their own controllers, so no way to connect them to mainboard. Plus of this solution is that you don't need to spend additional money to fan controller, as everything is already in store :)

Optical drive - I'm using currently Asus Sata drive. It's quiet, and has very nice error correction (reads even those which my old Plextor couldn't see :p).

HDD - If you don't go raid, get one HDD :)

PSU - the difference between modular and normal is that in modular you can disconnect all the not needed cables, thus using less space, and improving a bit the airflow. Speaking not of the case looking much more organised.

Headphones - I'm using the Creative Fatality headset - but not becasue of their audioquality. Frankly... I don't hear the difference on different headsets, but they fit my head most comfortably, and that's what matters :)

And 22" display works nicely with 280gtx with all the goodies on (at least for newest Call of Duty)
 
Thanks for the info about modular power supplies. Based on that, I would probably want a modular one, if it fits in my budget ($2,000).

Wow guys I had no idea it would be so long for the mainstream i7 boards. I thought the 32nm platform was going to be out by then. I certainly don't want to wait that long. I guess I will just have to spring for a high end board, although I get the impression you guys think I should go with Core 2. I know it would be cheaper, but my impression was that i7 was a pretty big step forward, and having my computer last a long time is very important to me.

Tiraides, I did consider getting 3x1 sticks of RAM, but it seemed like then I would be stuck with lower capacity sticks in my RAM slots when I upgraded to a 64-bit OS. If I can afford Vista and the 6GB, I am leaning towards that.

I see where you guys are coming from about vidcards and monitors, thinking that my performance will be wasted on a 1280x1024 display. But it seems to me like getting a new monitor would open a Pandora's Box of costly upgrades: New monitor -> Need better vidcard -> Better vidcard -> Need better monitor to fully appreciate it. Etc, etc, and there goes all my money.

Morgoth, Thanks for the recommendation on the Antec 1200. I have looked at it, and I like it, but a review I read said the fans were very loud on high setting. Can you notice yours on high RPM while wearing headphones and gaming, to the point where it interferes with the experience?
 
Well, if put on fast setting, they are a bit irritating but not as 280gtx on 100%. But I never put them on max, actually run them on low/medium settings, and have no problem with cooling.

Besides would be hard to describe for me the gaming on max fan noise, as I usually use the speakers, and have my headphones only for ventrillo and Pirates of Burning Sea :) Otherwise it's always speakers -benefits of being alone, and not being that hardcore player that I've to get perfect headphone sound to know who is behind my back and exactly where behind :)
 
Well, if put on fast setting, they are a bit irritating but not as 280gtx on 100%. But I never put them on max, actually run them on low/medium settings, and have no problem with cooling.

Besides would be hard to describe for me the gaming on max fan noise, as I usually use the speakers, and have my headphones only for ventrillo and Pirates of Burning Sea :) Otherwise it's always speakers -benefits of being alone, and not being that hardcore player that I've to get perfect headphone sound to know who is behind my back and exactly where behind :)

You have a GTX 280 in your 1200 and it doesn't get to hot even on only medium fan speed? Do you play intensive games? Also props on the Fatal1ty headset, a friend of mine has it and says it's great.
 
Out of curiosity, what is your current specs of your computer? Or, do you only have the Athlon FX-60 laptop? My advice is this: Spend cheap on an LGA 775 build and enjoy this for now until the Core i7 gets more mature with more reasonable prices in DDR3 Ram, Mobo and a wider variety of Core i7 cpus. The way I look at it, yeah I know what's the point of getting an LGA socket 775 platform when something new has come out to replace it. BUT, it's not like an E8400 dual core or Q6600 quad cpu is not up to the task of delivering a good gaming experience. Certainly not a bottleneck for any graphics card especially when you consider single slot video cards. Besides, it's good to build an LGA 775 platform cpu/mobo knowing the fact that you paid less than what others paid for on their Q6600 and E8400 cpus when they first came out.
 
You have a GTX 280 in your 1200 and it doesn't get to hot even on only medium fan speed? Do you play intensive games? Also props on the Fatal1ty headset, a friend of mine has it and says it's great.

I meant that the system ain't getting hot on the CASE fans set on medium, not the gfx fan :)

For the GFX card, I keep it on auto in evga precision (running the SC version), and no I barely hear the noise of the fan (opposite to my earlier 4870, but that's another story, and ati folks should be painfully forced to watch "Bold and beautiful" for the fans/temps of stock cooling of 4870 :p). Last time I heard it was when I had to OC it to the specs of FTW edition, to play the CoD 5 on max details with all gimnicks on at 1680x1050 :) (but then temps went over 70C, and fan went to about 90% :p)
 
The laptop is the only computer I have. If I did what you are suggesting, don't you think I would end up spending more money in the long run on two different systems?
 
I meant that the system ain't getting hot on the CASE fans set on medium, not the gfx fan :)

For the GFX card, I keep it on auto in evga precision (running the SC version), and no I barely hear the noise of the fan (opposite to my earlier 4870, but that's another story, and ati folks should be painfully forced to watch "Bold and beautiful" for the fans/temps of stock cooling of 4870 :p). Last time I heard it was when I had to OC it to the specs of FTW edition, to play the CoD 5 on max details with all gimnicks on at 1680x1050 :) (but then temps went over 70C, and fan went to about 90% :p)

Ok, thanks for the info.

I'm headed to bed folks, but any more advice or input would be much appreciated.:)
 
CHDD - If you don't go raid, get one HDD :)
Let me offer a different perspective......

I have two drives in my system and don't run an array. I have a program that copies everything on the #1 drive onto the #2 drive once a week. Mail, documents, photos, MP3's, etc....everything I care about. Unless both hard drives crash at the same instant, or unless the PSU goes south and takes the whole box out, I have an automated backup system that keeps things in two places. I'm very happy with it. The #2 drive also gets used for DVD ripping / encoding, storing big files, etc.

I started doing this at work, as well. I'm pretty happy with the way it works out.....:cool:
 
Nehalem doesn't offer a leap of performance in regards to gaming -- only 15% at most, compared to Core2. And it will be a while until future games will need such horsepower. We're saying you don't need i7 for a new gaming rig, as Core2 is more than enough. However, if you want it, we can't stop you. :p

Its not like you have to get a 24" monitor or anything 2MP or higher. A 22" is the sweetspot right now where you don't have to spend too much on the monitor nor the vidcard. With a drop from the GTX280 to the GTX260, you could use that money saved on a 22" monitor, and the 260 would still perform well at the 22" monitor's resolution.

BBS, out of curiousity, which program are you using?
 
I don't think so. See, the way I look at, it depends on what you primarily do on a PC. If it's primarily gaming, mainly an upgrade to a GPU is the contributing factor especially when gaming at 1680 x 1050 res and above. The CPU of course plays a part to. But, if you have a 45nm dual core or quad core cpu, you can easily O/C it for more performance and it can deliver. The area where the Core i7 really shines in gaming is when you have low res set at 1024 x 768. But, who wants to game at that resolution? Also, Core i7 will benefit more when you do SLI or Tri SLI setups. But, it seems like you're not concerned about that. Plus, a single video card is already plenty for 1680 x 1050 res. The main thing is that it will show an improvement over your existing setup. An Athlon FX-60 is blown by a Core 2 E8400 cpu. This is already a massive upgrade on the CPU. If you get Q6600 or Q9550 this is still a big upgrade. I mean..right now, most programs/games don't take advantage of 4 cores. So, it's not like a Q6600 or Q9550 will be or considered obsolete. When it reaches a point where a Q6600 cpu or Q9550 is simply not cutting it due to advanced programs that's being released or games are getting too demanding, then upgrade. If you do alot of things on the PC other than gaming, Photo Editing, Media Encoding and using scientific application software like Mathematica or Matlab etc. Then, I can see a more valid justification to jump on a Core i7 cpu. Now, let's say a Core i7 920 cpu is at $300, a cheap X58 mobo at $220 and 6gigs of DDR3 ram at $220 on average. Total is $740. Hmm.. what can I do with $740 with an LGA 775 build:

CPU/Mobo - Intel Core 2 Quad Q9550(2.83ghz) + Asus P5Q Pro($15 MIR) for $400
RAM - OCZ Fatal1ty Edition 4gig DDR2 800 for $43 w/free shipping
Video - XFX Geforce GTX 260(216) Black Edition w/free Far Cry 2 game included in the box for $300 and free shipping

$743.

The CPU/MOBO/RAM was $443 total which is about $300 cheaper than a Core i7 cpu, X58 mobo and DDR3 ram. The Core i7 920 build is 67% more expensive than the Core 2 Quad Q9550 build. Is it 67% faster than the Q9550 build in gaming? Nope. Is it overall 67% faster also? I don't think so.
 
I am considering the possibility of buying a new monitor. I noticed this one today and I was wondering what you all thought of it. It is 22" and I could afford it.

As for Core i7 vs. Core 2, I realize that a Core 2 is more bang for the buck, but I in the long run I would rather get a Core i7 now for maximum system longevity.
EDIT: Another thing I should mention, I am 17 and my parents are splitting the cost of this system with me. They consider it to be a learning experience, but I doubt if they would split the cost of a future system with me. For that reason, I would rather pay more now (I'll be paying half of it) and have a system that lasts longer, rather than pay less now but have to pay for upgrades by myself sooner.

Thanks everyone for all your input, more is welcome.:)
 
The Acer X223Wbd is an inexpensive monitor that's good for gaming. You could also get it at NewEgg for $165 with free shipping.

For most games, though, all you need is the GTX 260 (preferably the 216 shader core model, or the 1GB HD4870).

Besides the monitor (a good, inexpensive option) and the video card (listen to us on this one, please! ), is there anything else that you already have in stone?
 
What? your parents don't realize that the cost of a computer is ongoing? You have to keep pouring money into it every year. Therefore, they should keep paying for half of whats going into it! :p If you can sell that, my friend, go into sales. ;)
 
I am open to suggestions on any component. Do to the reasons I have stated before, however, I will be using the Core i7 platform. I have considered the options, and made my decision. Advice on any other aspect of the system is welcome and appreciated.

If you all think that the Acer monitor I mentioned before is a good one for me, I will most likely request it for Christmas in order to save room in my budget.
 
>Processor: Intel Core i7 920 (no need no pay 2-3x more for a few more Mhz)

>Mainboard: Core i7 Compatible Mainboard

>Case: ATX Full Tower Case (overwhelmed - so many options)

>Graphics Card: Geforce GTX 280/260 (depending on how much money I have left over)

>Memory: 6GB Triple Channel DDR3 (not sure what speed)

>Hard Drives: 2x ~320GB SATA 2 (higher density platters - not sure what brand is best)

>Power Supply: 700w + PSU (I know you said I don't need that much, but I'd like to have some growing room)

>Disc Drive: SATA DVD Drive (I don't even really need a burner but I might as well get one I guess)

>CPU/GPU Fan/Hearsink: Aftermarket Fan/Heatsink (Xigmatek? I don't know much about these)

Operating System: Windows Vista 64 or XP 32 (leaning towards Vista, If I can afford it)

Budget: $2,000 Including shipping & tax Ideally. Paying less than $2K is not an advantage in my situation.
 
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Thanks Danny, that looks extremely solid. :D I may make a few tweaks but that is just my preference. I am tempted to throw in an Antec 1200 and buy that right now.
 
Question here: If a motherboard says the memory standard is up to DDR3 1600(OC) does that mean that you have to overclock something if you use DDR3 1600 memory? On a related note, what do those memory timing numbers (8-8-8-24 etc) mean, exactly? I know that lower numbers are better, but is it worth paying more for them? Thanks.
 
Question here: If a motherboard says the memory standard is up to DDR3 1600(OC) does that mean that you have to overclock something if you use DDR3 1600 memory? On a related note, what do those memory timing numbers (8-8-8-24 etc) mean, exactly? I know that lower numbers are better, but is it worth paying more for them? Thanks.

No, the memory standard is just the maximum memory speed the motherboard is rated to handle.

The memory timings are the number of clock cycles the memory waits between being told to access the memory, and when the memory is actually read. Whether or not it is worth it to pay more is completely subjective. But it does improve performance.

If I were you I would opt for a better monitor with Danny's build. Spending that much on the rig, and that little on the display doesn't seem right to me. You could opt for an LG l227wtf-pf, or for a nice 24'' monitor. I think 22'' is more than enough personally... But might as well buy a nice one if you have that kind of budget
 
Here's a guide that explains memory timings, but I don't know (yet) which timings are preferred for DDR3 memory. The general rule of thumb, though, is to not to pay an exorbitant amount for lower/tighter timings (over what is considered the JEDEC standard for that particular memory speed... it's a long story, and I don't know what the standard is for DDR3 memory).

I believe the DDR3 1600(OC) standard means that if you are overclocking, you could use DDR3 1600 memory. (I don't really know the particulars of the MSI X58 Platinum enough to tell you whether or not that would be a good idea.)
 
Well, I ordered my first component yesterday - the Antec 1200 from Newegg for $120. Hard to beat that, I'd say. One thing I was wondering about, though, is because the power supply mount for the 1200 is at the bottom, I should get a power supply with the fan on top, right? I am looking for something modular in the 700W + range. Any reccomendations would be great. Thanks.
 
One thing I was wondering about, though, is because the power supply mount for the 1200 is at the bottom, I should get a power supply with the fan on top, right?.

You can install PSUs upside down you know. So if the PSU has the fan pointing down, you can still flip it over and have the PSU fan "on top" or facing up.
 
I know, but wouldn't it be easier to just get a PSU that had the fan on top? (they do make these right?) I have heard of people flipping their PSUs and then having problems because then all the cables were on the wrong side and didn't reach far enough.
 
Believe it or not, the majority of cases out there have the PSU mount on top, which is probably according to ATX specs? And so is the fan being on the bottom, I'm guessing (but too lazy to confirm).
 
So I have to just flip the PSU then? The fan will be sucking air into the PSU right? Thank you and sorry for my ignorance.
 
They don't? Well then what do people do with cases where the PSU mount is at the bottom?

We just mount the PSU normally if the case allows for it: with the PSU fan "pointing" down. My P180 case allowed for this. This allows the cables to be closer to the system and partially solves any cable length problem. If the case doesn't allow for a PSU to get air when the fan is pointing down, just flip it over with the fan side up. Slightly more cable length problems but nothing huge.
 
I think in the 1200 the is less than an inch between the floor of the case and the bottom of the PSU. Probably not enough room, but IDK.
 
Looking at the pics on newegg, it doesn't look like there's much room at all to mount the PSU "normally" with the fan pointing down, nor is their a vent spot on the bottom of the case like the Cosmos S. So yes, you'd want to flip it.
 
Yeah, you're right, I'll flip it. Sorry I didn't know that. Any recommendations for a modular 700W + PSU?
 
Back
Top