Consumers Still Not Buying Blu-ray

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The latest consumer survey conducted by ABI Research paints a pretty grim picture for Blu-ray with most people showing little to no interest in the high-def format. The good news is, PS3 sales have been trending upwards and gamers have been buying Blu-ray discs so that helps.

“Consumers were happy to embrace standard DVD when that format arrived because the improvement in quality over VHS videotapes was dramatic. Standard DVD didn’t require the purchase of a new TV either. In contrast, while half of the respondents to our survey rated Blu-ray’s quality as ‘much better’ than standard DVD, another 40% termed it only ‘somewhat better,’ and most are very satisfied with the performance of their current DVD players.”
 
A lot of people are intimidated by any forms of HD. Once they see HD in their home and really the simplicity of it, they are hooked.

When I saw my first HD prono...eerrr I mean show... I was hooked.
 
Why buy a $400+ dollar Blu-ray player and $25 movies when you can get a 1080p up converter for $70 and DVD movies for $15?

It doesn't take a genus to figure out where the consumer wants to spend his cash.
 
I was buying a decent amount from both sides during the war. Once it ended the deals stopped, and strangely so did most of my disc purchasing.
 
One thing I'll never understand is what the point of watching something on dvd is, if you've already seen it at the movies.
 
One thing I'll never understand is what the point of watching something on dvd is, if you've already seen it at the movies.

Because you liked it? :confused:

Anyway, i don't think the world was/is ready for a new movie format. VHS --> DVD HUGE NOTICEABLE UPGRADE on any tv. DVD --> Blu Ray (& HD DVD for that matter), not so much.
 
Why buy a $400+ dollar Blu-ray player and $25 movies when you can get a 1080p up converter for $70 and DVD movies for $15?

Lets be fair thats hardly the same as a "GOOD" Bluray disc.

However The visual quality on some of the newer blurays is absolute garbage and in some cases HD broadcasts are better. Its gotten to the point whereby i wont blind buy everything and have to wait for screengrabs to be posted on various sites. Ive also got really picky on what i buy anymore as ive gotten sick of double dipping and also seeing a collection of movies just sat there in the cupboards.
 
I've been buying it. There really is no comparison between a Blu-ray disc (especially if the master is digital) and DVD. Maybe most consumers are blind, or to them it's not worth the money. Most movies can be had for between $20 and $25, so it's not like it's ridiculous compared to DVD.
 
Economic situation doesn't exactly entice people to be spending $500+ on a setup that worked perfectly find before.
 
I'll buy BD only when BD-R drives drop to $150 or below & the media is cheap. The movie media needs to drop hardcore before I start to build a library after making an optical drive upgrade.
 
I got Juno in Blu-Ray from Netflix to watch on my PS3 and I was not impressed. My upconverting DVD player had the same or better quality.
 
I got Juno in Blu-Ray from Netflix to watch on my PS3 and I was not impressed. My upconverting DVD player had the same or better quality.

Lenscrafters is currently having a special on prescriptions, you should look into it ;)
 
I've been buying it. There really is no comparison between a Blu-ray disc (especially if the master is digital) and DVD. Maybe most consumers are blind, or to them it's not worth the money. Most movies can be had for between $20 and $25, so it's not like it's ridiculous compared to DVD.

QFT.

Been buying since 3rd quarter of last year, knowing it would win the 'war'. Prices are actually quite cheap considering DVDs at the age that BR is at now were still going for $25-$30 anyways. And you get so much more.

There is no real comparison for native 1080p video that's mastered wonderfully versus an upconverted 480p picture. That's an old argument. It's there, you just have to open your eyes to see it! ;)
 
Then again I've been viewing most recently on a 106" screen, so I'm probably not your "typical consumer".

That being said, it still looks fantastic on my 32" bedroom set.
 
I they can get the price of Blu-ray down to under $20 for new releases then I'm sold. I'm still a little burned by the HD DVD movies I bought that are collecting dust. I only own three Blu-ray titles. DVE (a must own for HDTV owners), BladeRunner (Have the HD DVD version as well), and Resident Evil (came with the PS3).
 
What's keeping me away from BR is HDCP. I basically need a HDTV with it or I have to watch it in shit quality on a CRT because of Macrovision and other bad ideas.

Then there's the fact that it's just not worth it for me at the moment, then that HDTVs are too expensive, still. 32" LCD? Costs as much as two Nintendo Wii here.
 
Economic situation doesn't exactly entice people to be spending $500+ on a setup that worked perfectly find before.

Agreed. I was thinking about picking up a PS3 for a game or 2 and also for the BD drive, but now that I can barely pay the monthly bills, that's going to be put off for a long time down the road.

Insurance > Blu-ray movies I can upconvert with my current DVD setup.
 
I have Blu-ray, but I am an electronics/computer geek who doesn't have probelms with using new tech and troubleshooting. Blu-ray is still not ready for prime time- there is not a single blu-ray player that will play all discs without the consumer having to update the player's software. The average joe will not understand this- they expect it to work just like DVD. The picture is fantastic with Blu-ray but it is not like it was when people stepped up from vhs to dvd. To me Blu-ray has 2 things going for it- the PS3 and their are plenty of standard dvds that have poor picture quality out there.

If all standard def dvds we encoded like the Superbit dvds and the PS3 did not include a blu-ray drive BD would not be able to survive at all.
 
Again, the LARGEST impediment to the advancement of Blu-ray is NOT the cost. Rather, it is the utter lack of compelling selections. Most folks would rather buy a $12-16 DVD then a $30 Blu-Ray. Anything recently released on Blu-ray was either complete crap, or was something folks wanted and already bought on DVD. When this summers hits are FINALLY released on Blu-ray, I guarantee you will see a monster jump in sales. Ironman, Hulk, etc will put things back on tack, and the increased adoption will end up driving prices down, starting a somewhat diluted shift to the new medium.

ANYONE who claims an upconverted DVD can compare in ANY way to the quality of a non-crap HD (there are a bunch of really crappy upconverted HD/Blu-rays that are criminally bad) is smoking crack.

I think the only setback to HD is the shock some people get when a closeup on a favorite star reveals every tiny flaw. LOL.. in Fantastic Four 2, there is a closeup of Jessica Alba that reveals all her acne under piles of foundation and makeup, and in some seens she almost looks like Tori Spelling (shudder)
 
What's keeping me away from BR is HDCP. I basically need a HDTV with it or I have to watch it in shit quality on a CRT because of Macrovision and other bad ideas.

Then there's the fact that it's just not worth it for me at the moment, then that HDTVs are too expensive, still. 32" LCD? Costs as much as two Nintendo Wii here.

You'd need an HDTV to watch it anyways to benefit from anything having to do with, well, true HD signals! ;)

I'm using a gen-1 CRT HDTV at 30" that doesn't have digital inputs or even a built-in tuner, and i'm watching off my PS3 set to 1080i with the component wires along with a tos-link direct to my receiver. Sure, it's not 1080p, but I get a beautiful picture with awesome uncompressed audio (most of the time).

No HDCP issues here, because I'm not using digital connections. And many titles shipped don't actually have the flag engaged on them anyways. Some do though.
 
Maybe if their compression wasn't so bad. All of the promo stuff I've seen looked pretty bad. Actual 1080p would look dramatically better, but a lot of this stuff isn't much better than upscaled 480p.
 
I love watching movies in BR now, you can really tell a difference over DVD on my 52" LCD. Only problem, like others have said, is price. $30 for a movie is just ridiculous, and the players are still outrageous. If not for the fact that I have a PS3, I would probably have never even seen a BR movie yet. The video stores selection of BR's sucks too, so I don't have much to watch. The only movie I've bought for far is Lost Boys (which is even more awesome in BR :D), the rest all came free via rebate, or with the purchase of my PS3.
 
well I think it depends on your TV/monitor. If you guys are watching these movies on higher end/newer TVs it can make a difference VS an entry level 1080p tv. Perhaps on the nicer setups the difference can be huge while on an average-lower end set the difference is just not there.

when I moved from VHS to DVD the image quality on the TV I had at the time time didn't really show how much better the picture was. I made the jump to get away from tapes moreso than picture quality. Blu-ray has no such incentive.


That all being said, personally my HDTV is a bit older and I bought it as a holdover till the technology settled down some (at the time LCD-RP, DLP, LCOS, CRT-RP, Plasma, and LCD were all on the market). I don't think my TV will give me much of an upgrade going to blu-ray so I am holding off till the stand alone players mature and perhaps when a upgrade TV is budgeted.
 
The problem is not all blu-ray movies are made the same. Some are extremely poor quality and others are great. Juno DID look terrible in BR but Planet Earth looked gorgeous.

Because of the lack of consistency, I don't see BR being the format standard anytime soon.
 
VHS --> DVD HUGE NOTICEABLE UPGRADE on any tv. DVD --> Blu Ray (& HD DVD for that matter), not so much.

QFT, but there are enough fans of it that have spent hundreds of dollars, they've got to argue in defense of their purchase SOMEHOW.

Big(ger) differences noticed at 50" or so, in my experience. Anything lower than that, most consumers don't give a rip about a few subtle details, the majority of which you won't notice unless they are pointed out to you.

I still hold the opinion BlueRay will never take off. Isn't near the jump in advantage as VHS to DVD, and that even took over 5 years to transition in a big way...
In 5 years, something better will come along. Then BlueRay will just turn into Betamax, a novelty item for historical technical junkies I guess.
 
Well duuuur

Between that stupid format war that went on faaaar to long and the simple fact that majority of ppl don't have a big enough TV to really make use of HD (ie DVD still looks great) AND from an end user P.O.V. the difference between DVD & HD is not alot w.r.t. VHD and DVD

so why bother


As an attrition format sure BUT only if players come down ALOT
 
Bang for buck. Just not getting enough quality for my dollar. Everyone has their price for performance limit, and right now it just isn't worth it for me.

Player < $80 and New discs at the $20 mark and I might get interrested.
 
it's expensive

tv + blu-ray player + movies is just too much for me to even consider the switch to blu ray making it something I'd like to switch to but not that big of a deal if I don't.

Factor in bad economic times and of course its going to be a slow adoption.

For me I tend to pay more attention to the movie itself rather than how it looks. I can watch a movie in bad quality and still get immersed in it if its good (or even bad at times) and ignore bad image quality. So i might as well stay with the cheaper product and be just as satisfied.
 
Why buy a $400+ dollar Blu-ray player and $25 movies when you can get a 1080p up converter for $70 and DVD movies for $15?

It doesn't take a genus to figure out where the consumer wants to spend his cash.

Aren't they all limited to 1080i? Tried several dvds on my upconverter like LOTR and Wedding Crashers and its not even close to Blu Ray 1080p.
 
I'm getting tired of the revisionist history of DVD. I was the only person I knew with a DVD player for about a year, and I didn't buy a player until the format had been available for almost 2 years - it took that long for a halfway decent library to be available (and there were still holdouts like Fox and Disney) and for players to reach a price I considered affordable. Further, I only fixed my lonely DVD situation by buying five $200 Toshiba players and giving them as Christmas presents. It took six years (1997 to 2003, according to the wikiality) from launch for DVD rentals to overtake VHS despite DVD being considered to have an extremely fast adoption rate.

I was talking with my dad about this a couple weeks ago because he and my mom recently bought two brand-new Sony 1080p LCDs (a big one for the living room and a small one for their bedroom). He told me that he'd only buy one a) as a replacement for a DVD player and b) if the price was near that of a DVD player. What that tells me is that once Blu-ray players come down under $200 dollars, and really closer to $100 than $200, my parents will probably buy one (my mom's 20 years younger than he is, so she'll probably drive the purchase a little faster than his preference). So, despite the fact that they're not hugely interested, they'll probably buy into Blu-ray next year - only 3 years after launch and still ahead of where they would have purchased a DVD player on their own.

The doom and gloom seen in these kinds of analyses are FUD and should be treated as such.

PS- For the record, I wanted HD DVD to come out on top, I still don't have a Blu-ray player (or a TV for that matter), and I don't care of Blu-ray is successful. Again, my issue is with the mistaken belief that DVDs were hugely popular at the same stage of their existence.
 
Player cost aside, most forget to mention that you also need $1k TV set to truly notice/enjoy HD content... and sound system... now you can see why people are not willing to spend $1.5k+ just to contribute to Blu-ray sales.
 
They need to stop being to up tight with the pricing of blu-ray players. Put out a 2.0 spec 1080p player for $200 and drop blu-ray movie prices by $10 and it will start to take off.
 
Why buy a $400+ dollar Blu-ray player and $25 movies when you can get a 1080p up converter for $70 and DVD movies for $15?

It doesn't take a genus to figure out where the consumer wants to spend his cash.

I don't think the average consumer knows much about upconverting DVD players, therefore it isn't really option for them. It just boils down to DVD or Blu-ray.
 
my problem is that I am a poor college student, my wife just graduated college, but is still not making a lot of money, and I have two boys that are in school. We still have the same 27" SDTV, that we have had for 4 years. We cant justify spending all that money when we are fairly content with older technology. I know, HDTV looks really fucking sweet and all, (trust me. I go to best buy just to drool over the stuff I can not afford.) but we don't have the money.
 
I don't think that we need to continually revisit the DVD adoption timeline either. The fact is, Blu-Ray is presently competing against several economic factors, consumer indifference (or lack of knowledge), VOD services (including online HD feeds) and even DVD sales. I find it interesting that despite the "overwhelming" studio support and constant "3-for-2" promotions from Amazon and other retailers, BD sales still haven't taken off. The only reason that I bought a PS3 was because of the death of the more consumer-friendly HD-DVD format and I had several gift cards to offset the cost. I couldn't see trying to buy one of the 2 or 3 BD players that "might" be future proof.
 
i'm not very much convinced by bluray. HD in general gets a big "yes" from me, but bluray isn't worth it for me for a couple of reasons:

- i absolutely don't need uncompressed 7 channel sound (i dont even have room for 2 more speakers...).i don't hear the difference between compressed and uncompressed sound, sorry. it's not like you're listening to music where you can focus on certain instruments or melodies and such.

- on my 36" 1080p tv the higher resolution and better picture does not make a huge difference to justify a new player and more expensive movies.

- i already have a lot of movies on dvd so i won't buy them on bluray again. and the selection of bluray movies is still limited here in Austria with stores not advertising them

- and a reason that is valid for surely a lot of people: you need all kinds of new hardware to watch bluray discs. you need the player and a tv that can handle hdmi. many people like me use a pc in the living room as a source of music for the sound system or dvd player for the tv set. now, try getting bluray to work on an energy efficient media pc (or get it to work at all)...

to me bluray is like multicore cpus. it does have some benefits, but it really is nowhere near where the marketing guys proclaim it to be. but then, even though i like new tech stuff, i'm not like others who buy a new mobile for 100 bucks every half a year. i use the one i get for free and have had it for 2 years now. some people must have everything there is while others focus on what they think is an upgrade for them (and i'm below 30 hehe).
 
My humble opinion is that a new media format is not what I care about. From vhs to dvd and now a different type of dvd. I'd wrather be able to stream. I wish more R&D would go into that area. Like netflix's play on pc and on-demand services like on comcast.
 
In 5 years, something better will come along. Then BlueRay will just turn into Betamax, a novelty item for historical technical junkies I guess.

YES! someone had to say Betamax.

They need to stop being to up tight with the pricing of blu-ray players. Put out a 2.0 spec 1080p player for $200 and drop blu-ray movie prices by $10 and it will start to take off.

Thats true, but they won't because its Sony. Anyone who thinks that cost isn't a factor isn't living in reality.
 
Back
Top