Congress Readying Major Push For Internet Transparency

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
What an absurd notion it is to think the general public has the right to know what politicians are doing. This is madness!

Through a set of almost-radical changes that most Americans would probably view as common sense, the incoming GOP majority is set to approve rules saying that legislation must be posted online three days before a vote and that committee amendments will also be publicly posted. Politicians' formal votes in committees will also be disclosed, and audio and video recordings will be permanently posted "in a manner that is easily accessible to the public."
 
I'm not sold on this congress yet, I'm waiting to see what they actually do. This would be a good step forward, but I'm sure there's an "emergency passage" provision (and there should be), I just hope there are safeguards to prevent everything from becoming an "emergency."
 
I approve of the intent, but as a bunch of old politicians who likely have very little understanding of the realities of technology, I don't think they have any idea how much this is going to cost to store and host. It is very necessary to have these things easily available to the public, but I don't know that the budget is there to do it, especially when the republicans are vowing to cut the budget by 100 Billion.

I applaud the intent.
 
I just wish that Congress couldn't make laws that only apply to themselves and exempt themselves from laws that apply to everybody else. Oh, and give themselves pay raises without public approval.
 
I think a lot of the incoming congress people are actually not "old folks" so much. There is a push to get the old blood out and new blood in so that our representatives can go in with fresh ideas, actually represent its people and not so much baggage to represent their re-electability or financial backers.

I'll re-elect my representative if he is successful at getting the government to stop doing things that supposedly benefit me. In the end, it's going to cost me a lot more.
 
I imagine even less will get done now with these rules. Politicians currently tell their constituencies that they will hold strong and not cave into the other side AKA compromise but that is exactly what needs to happen in order to pass legislation. Secret back room dealings are what allow these politicians to still appear to be "[H]ard Line" while actually getting work done. Just look at what happened in December 2010 lame duck congress ...

I like the ideal of transparency but reality keeps crashing that party.
 
I just wish that Congress couldn't make laws that only apply to themselves and exempt themselves from laws that apply to everybody else. Oh, and give themselves pay raises without public approval.

Term limits would also be nice. Life-time senators and congress persons' is kinda lame.
 
intent sounds good, however it still is politicians doing this... so what is the true motive? Are there earmarks involved?
 
We don't need to know what our government is doing, the government's response to Wikileaks has taught us that.
 
I'm not sold on this congress yet, I'm waiting to see what they actually do. This would be a good step forward, but I'm sure there's an "emergency passage" provision (and there should be), I just hope there are safeguards to prevent everything from becoming an "emergency."

My initial gut reaction is that a 3 day "everything out in the open" is nothing but good. But maybe I haven't thought it through long enough. Are there examples in history where we ever needed emergency speed passage?

The president doesn't need congress to launch nukes back at our attackers. And I don't think a natural disaster needs a bill quicker than 3 days. Is there something I am not thinking of? "Emergency" meetings could be abused.
 
My initial gut reaction is that a 3 day "everything out in the open" is nothing but good. But maybe I haven't thought it through long enough. Are there examples in history where we ever needed emergency speed passage?

The president doesn't need congress to launch nukes back at our attackers. And I don't think a natural disaster needs a bill quicker than 3 days. Is there something I am not thinking of? "Emergency" meetings could be abused.

Yep last summer where Pelosi called the Congress back to vote on the "bailout" aka union briberies.
 
I'm not a huge Republi-Fan, and I don't like Democrats either (I don't know wtf that makes me LOL), but I like the intent here as well.

I guess I'm a "Do what you say, say what you do, and eat your own dog food" kinda guy. Maybe this is a start.
 
My initial gut reaction is that a 3 day "everything out in the open" is nothing but good. But maybe I haven't thought it through long enough. Are there examples in history where we ever needed emergency speed passage?

The president doesn't need congress to launch nukes back at our attackers. And I don't think a natural disaster needs a bill quicker than 3 days. Is there something I am not thinking of? "Emergency" meetings could be abused.

An actual, honest to god Declaration of War? Of course, there hasn't been one of those since late December 1941 (declaring war on Germany and Italy late in the month, after they had declared war on us). Just so nobody takes exception that I don't know my history, we declared war on Japan on December 8th, retroactive to December 7th.

That's about the only thing I can think of right off. There are a few things that I can think of that POSSIBLY could require votes quicker, such as a natural disaster requiring quick relief measures, but not that much.
 
The only time emergency comes into play is when they have to expedite my money into their pockets.

Otherwise, they move at a snails pace, they don't do crap right most of the time, and if they do, you jump through 100 hoops on the way to get there.

So, emergency to the government is kinda laughable. Nothing needs passage within 3 days. Truth be told, this won't matter anyway. It will just get ignored unless its a constitutional amendment that forces it. I mean, the Democrats promised Reagan they would cut spending for raising taxes.

Never happened. So until its forced upon them, they'll just ignore it. "They have more important issues to tend to" they'll tell you.
 
Excellent, we get to read a bill 3 days before it is voted on. That means we get 3 days to... do essentially nothing. Few will read the bills in their entirety, even fewer will care what they read in them. Of course maybe the whole "death panel" lie would have been avoided with such a measure.

At least we can count on them to do the following:

Keep their fundraising activities as secret as possible... http://www.opencongress.org/bill/111-s482/show

Here's one that passed after several attempts to stop it by the new Majority... http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.ph...t_of_2007#Support.2C_opposition_and_critiques


Does this mean Democrats are better? Hell no. This is a political move that does little or no good, aside from providing more points of argument. As long as there are two parties run by endlessly incumbent members and endless campaign funding, these small bills are just smoke screens (despite their appearance to do the opposite).
 
Excellent, we get to read a bill 3 days before it is voted on. That means we get 3 days to... do essentially nothing. Few will read the bills in their entirety, even fewer will care what they read in them.

Exactly. It's pure theater.
 
This will give media organizations time to put legal experts on new bills and hopefully point out to the public any glaring issues with new legislation.

I doubt Obamacare would have passed if this bill was in place!!!
 
The transparency Obama promised brought to you by Republicans.

On January 4th, 2007 the Senate began its legislative work in the 110th session with the introduction of the Legislative Transparency and Accountability Act of 2007 (S.1) by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev).

It was introduced by a democrat btw.
 
The thing is, it's not a republican congress.

An actual, honest to god Declaration of War? Of course, there hasn't been one of those since late December 1941 (declaring war on Germany and Italy late in the month, after they had declared war on us). Just so nobody takes exception that I don't know my history, we declared war on Japan on December 8th, retroactive to December 7th.

That's about the only thing I can think of right off. There are a few things that I can think of that POSSIBLY could require votes quicker, such as a natural disaster requiring quick relief measures, but not that much.

Yeah, I suppose they could make an exception for war, even though the president has free reign for 3 days. Natural disaster... I'm not sure money is needed within 3 days. Action happens before money. Maybe an exception there too, but no other side projects should be added on top of such a bill.

The only time emergency comes into play is when they have to expedite my money into their pockets.

Otherwise, they move at a snails pace, they don't do crap right most of the time, and if they do, you jump through 100 hoops on the way to get there.

lol, true

Excellent, we get to read a bill 3 days before it is voted on. That means we get 3 days to... do essentially nothing. Few will read the bills in their entirety, even fewer will care what they read in them.

How could transparency not be good? The few that will read this will inform us and the media. Many politicians will break down if the bill is embarrassing enough and people make enough noise.

It was introduced by a democrat btw said:
It was introduced by a democrat btw.

heh, you know that's political maneuvering when actions in the past speak in total contrast to what is proposed. Trying to beat Republicans to the punch I guess.
 
It's now 2011. If it takes 4 years and a Republican congress to get it done that's not really helping whatever point you're trying to make you know...

Have you seen what the Republicans have been doing for 2 years? Pretty much anything introduced by a democrat was filibustered or voted down at least once. No matter how much it made sense. The 9/11 first responder bill and the "No rape clauses in federal contracts" bill are great examples.

Also, transparency is great but it's not like this affects the executive in the slightest. Only congressional laws and votes are affected. Not the hundreds of agencies enforcing them. And another thing, this will still be lies and jargon simply because they can't list classified spending projects nor classified briefings.

As for "Obamacare" as it's being called. There was ample time to read it, understand it and explain it to the base. I'm not sure there was a more looked over piece of legislation this past decade. Despite all that, people still complain about it.

On another note, budget cuts are great.. in theory. The problem is, no one wants to actually defund any projects that are attached to social security, medicare or the military. That's most of the budget outside of Homeland Security and the Department of Housing. It's preposterous to even think you can make a dent in anything without pulling out of Iraq and/or Afghanistan and eliminating all funding to private contracting agencies. On top of that, cutting the budget is fine and dandy but you still HAVE TO raise taxes to fill the shortfall. Given the fact that Republicans fought tooth and nail to keep taxes low (which has proven to do NOTHING but line the pockets of the ultra wealthy), I assume they want to submarine Social Security completely. Just like companies are getting rid of retirement benefits by putting them on ledgers for bankruptcy proceedings while they do little to actually fix the problem of their own business.

On an up note, out of work lawyers will no get jobs on network cable explaining bills.
 
Everyone calling it "Obamacare" didn't get the memo. They had some spin doctor come up with a new phrase--the "job killing healthcare bill"-- to try to rile people up into a frenzy. No joke, they literally proposed an Act in the House of Representatives called "Repealing the Job Killing Health Care Law Act." It will, of course, never pass and is nothing more than a cheap political stunt, which is all anything that happens in Washington has become anymore.

A professor of mine once said that when there is a goofy name to a bill, it is usually 100% the opposite of what it actually does: "Job Killing," "Patriot Act," "Net Neutrality," etc. Guess he was right.
 
How is this news? The president made a similar campaign promise what, 2 years ago? Only his was a week or 2 before voting, not three days.
 
It was introduced by a democrat btw.
While it was introduced by Harry Reid in 2007, both the Congress and Administration never upheld it. "We have to pass the bill so you can find out what is in it". The Republicans are calling them out on it but it remains to be seen whether it's a PR stunt or not.
 
Too bad they shot down the requirement to disclose whether or not they are on free government healthcare.
 
Have you seen what the Republicans have been doing for 2 years? Pretty much anything introduced by a democrat was filibustered

I stopped reading right there. The Democrats have had a filibuster-proof majority in the senate, control of the house, and control of the presidency. Health Care Reform got passed, despite nobody having read the bill. If Democrats can't get anything done with both houses of congress and the presidency under their control I'd say you have zero room to blame Republicans on this one.

As for Republicans opposing what the Democrats do... well, duh. That's what the Democrats do when they're the minority. Why is it that every time Republicans get in office they're supposed to "Reach across the aisle! They must respect the rights of the minority (party)!" but when Democrats have control it's "We were given a mandate by the people! We WON! We're going to do the people's work, stop getting in our way!" Republicans passed plenty of compromise legislation when they had control of the House and Senate, but what compromised has Pelosi's house and Reed's senate made on any Republican-backed legislation? You want to know why the Republicans lost the house and senate in 2008? It wasn't because Democrats had a better idea, it was because the Republican party didn't do what the voters put them in office to do, and they got disgusted with the Democrat agenda going forward under a Republican-controlled congress. It was a case of if Democrats are in control, their agenda passes, if Republicans are in control, Democrat agenda passes. So why bother voting Republican if they're just going to do the same thing as the other party anyways?

That all changed with the Tea Party movement. Tea Party candidates don't follow the marching orders of the Washington blue-blood country-club Republican leadership. That's why the Republican leadership attacked Christine O'Donnell after she had won the Republican primary. They sabotaged their own candidate because she wasn't party rank and file. They'd rather have a Democrat in office than someone in their own party! Why? The elites in Washington do not WANT grass-roots representation. They don't WANT the people to have a voice. The Tea Party and other grass-roots organizations - let's be fair here - represent a threat Washington's usual political machinery. That's why they're demonized by the press and made fun of by the useful idiot bloggers on the internet.

Do you honestly think the Republican party elites or the Democrat party elites care one bit about you? They only care about your vote so they can stay in office. Look at Obama, he's broken just about every campaign promise he's made to his voter base. Gitmo's still open, Afghanistan is a mess, troops are still in Iraq...

Look, I could rant all day. My point is that you need to stop following the party talking points and ignore the blame game. That's what they want you to do - blame the other guy and not think for yourself. Don't question, just follow your marching orders. People can make fun of the Tea Party movement all they want, but the fact is it's citizens standing up for what they believe and trying their damnedest to bring Washington in line with that and actually represent them for a change. That's the sort of thing the country NEEDS.

You like Democracy? Your policy preferences at odds with the Tea Party? Then you need to do the same thing with the Democrat party. Get together, organize, and take the party back from the inside and make it work for YOU. The Tea Party movement proves one thing, regardless of whether you like them or not - it CAN be done. Take that fact seriously! I may disagree with people over policy and principles, but I will always be in favor of the government doing what the people say it should do, and not the other way around.

Ok, end of rant and off the soapbox now. I promise. :)
 
They really only work from Tuesday to Thursday afternoon, with mid-Wed. the only time to get almost all of them together, how will this work? Posted on Monday or wait 6-7 days?
 
Too bad they shot down the requirement to disclose whether or not they are on free government healthcare.

I work for the government, probably for longer than you've been potty trained. I pay $240 roughly every two weeks for my "free government healthcare". That's not what I pay for our medicines (my wife has a prescription that costs her over $100/month, for example). None of us is particularly unhealthy, and it covers me, my wife, my son in college, my daughter in college, and my daughter who is ten. We have deductibles, we have coasts, everything, just like everyone else. Yeah, it's a nice healthcare program, BC/BS, but it sure as hell isn't free. If I elected to decline paying that, I world have no health insurance at all.

I'm so tired of no nothing parrots repeating stupid things. I saved the US Navy between $180m and $300m over the next twenty years by the invention and development of the work I've done the last two years. My thanks is being told that my salary won't get to keep up with even the rise in the price of milk for two years. And my salary even now is only 70% what I was offered a dozen years ago when I took my current position, moving from NASA, and I've doubled my salary, nearly, since then. I'm overplayed the easy pigs spontaneously levitate with marginal aid from their fairy like wings.
 
I work for the government, probably for longer than you've been potty trained. I pay $240 roughly every two weeks for my "free government healthcare". That's not what I pay for our medicines (my wife has a prescription that costs her over $100/month, for example). None of us is particularly unhealthy, and it covers me, my wife, my son in college, my daughter in college, and my daughter who is ten. We have deductibles, we have coasts, everything, just like everyone else. Yeah, it's a nice healthcare program, BC/BS, but it sure as hell isn't free. If I elected to decline paying that, I world have no health insurance at all.

I'm so tired of no nothing parrots repeating stupid things. I saved the US Navy between $180m and $300m over the next twenty years by the invention and development of the work I've done the last two years. My thanks is being told that my salary won't get to keep up with even the rise in the price of milk for two years. And my salary even now is only 70% what I was offered a dozen years ago when I took my current position, moving from NASA, and I've doubled my salary, nearly, since then. I'm overplayed the easy pigs spontaneously levitate with marginal aid from their fairy like wings.

Coasts is copays
World is would
Overplayed is overpaid
Easy is way
 
I'm sorry, but if you call the act Obamacare, you have clearly identified yourself as a kool-aid drinking partisan. Thus, you have no credibility with anything you say on such matters. All these false accusations ranging from a "budget busting bill" to "publicly funds abortion" is such outright bullshit it makes me wonder who actually believes such Neanderthals.

3 days is great, seriously. Its real transparency that only the _______ party could provide. Its so transparent that Congress will be able to put a bill up for a scheduled vote on a Friday afternoon at, say 5pm, and vote on it the following Monday with almost no media or public attention. Perfect amount of time to provide a veil of "responsibility and transparency" while not actually having to be accountable. Drink it up partisans!
 
Back
Top