Computer Repair Shops Put To The Test

This is a blatant attempt at a rip off....hopefully the offender gets fired.

I doubt he would be fired. If anything, he would be promoted for bringing in a lot of money, just like a sales associate would.
 
I charge $50 bucks for the first 2 hours including travel time, and $75 bucks an hour after that. $20 bucks an hour for travel home if total call exceeds 2 hours allotted
 
Nothing new from thr Geek Squad. Plenty of that shit going around Chicago. With me getting calls from all my friends and their friends to fix it, after the Geek Squad managed to create a bigger mess.
 
"Simple stuff" is relative. If the customer revealed that they had been inside the case moving stuff around and unplugging shit and replugging it back in, i would check the IDE cables

but if they tell you that they turned it on one day and got a No Boot Device found, checking the "simple stuff" really wouldn't entail checking to see if an IDE cable is loose (we always assume the customer is telling the truth as best as they can).

unless the coefficient of static friction between two pieces of plastic changed overnight, i'm not going to check for a loose IDE cable. i'm going to check if the HDD is recognized at all in a Bootable Disc Environment (which is on the geek squad MRI disc) or in another "mule" computer (which we have set up in each store). if it does show up there, i'll try repairing the windows installation with the windows Recovery Console (fixmbr, chkdsk, fixboot, etc.)

the fact of the matter is that these news investigations are 1.) isolated incidences and 2.) tricks. if you mislead a technician with false information, they're likely to find a false cause to your problem. still, in this case the technician was lazy and didn't even bother to check just in case. they should have still been thorough.

there was a kid i worked with who was lazy and arrogant and thought he was running the show even though he's only been working for like 7 months. he just got fired because he was so terrible. types of employees working at the geek squad also depends on the management at each store.

there's too many variables in these situations to just say that "Oh, the Geek Squad is terrible and a huge huge ripoff" after one news team rigs up a computer and investigates the technicians diagnosis.

So simple stuff wouldn't entail popping open the case and taking 5 seconds to make sure everything is plugged in? I stopped reading what you wrote after you said that wasn't simple. :rolleyes:
 
Damn no edit. I don't really care that they "tricked" them, this was as a repair as it gets, plug a cable back in. That geek squad was just trying to rip people off, that store shouldn't be allowed to be in business.
 
Or they could just be morons, I think it's a combo of both.

Seriously though, there are simple-stuff checks, but when you work on a few hundred computers over the course of a couple months and not a single one of them had a "loose IDE" cable... or even a customer taking off the side-panel, it's silly to waste time checking things like that right away...

And it's very rare for the BIOS to stop seeing the HDD unless it's dead.

But we were always pretty thorough with testing, I know I tested some HDD's multiple times before determining they were bad...

One that puzzled me was somehow a HDD got set into PIO mode from DMA... the whole computer was slow as hell, HDD benchmarks were a couple megabytes a second. Anyways, did a little research on the googles and checked the BIOS and switched it back to DMA6, but I don't know how it got set to PIO in the first place. Oh well :)
 
Or they could just be morons, I think it's a combo of both.

Seriously though, there are simple-stuff checks, but when you work on a few hundred computers over the course of a couple months and not a single one of them had a "loose IDE" cable... or even a customer taking off the side-panel, it's silly to waste time checking things like that right away...

And it's very rare for the BIOS to stop seeing the HDD unless it's dead.

But we were always pretty thorough with testing, I know I tested some HDD's multiple times before determining they were bad...

One that puzzled me was somehow a HDD got set into PIO mode from DMA... the whole computer was slow as hell, HDD benchmarks were a couple megabytes a second. Anyways, did a little research on the googles and checked the BIOS and switched it back to DMA6, but I don't know how it got set to PIO in the first place. Oh well :)

It may have gotten into PIO from a failsafe settings load due to the PC not being allowed to make it past post(power outtage at just the right time or the user cutting it off during post or some other problem like CPU overheat).

I ran across a PC with a similar problem a LOOONG time ago; most of the onboard devices weren't working in addition to the PC just being generally slow. After some windows checking I looked into the BIOS and holy shit. Damn you Failsafe Defaults!

Turns out the guy's HSF fan got blocked by a ribbon cable coming into contact with it that caused the CPU to overheat and the PC to shutdown. After a few attempts at cutting it on he looked inside his case and saw what was happening, and moved the offending cable and his PC worked again, albeit at much reduced functionality. And thats when the above came in.
 
So simple stuff wouldn't entail popping open the case and taking 5 seconds to make sure everything is plugged in? I stopped reading what you wrote after you said that wasn't simple. :rolleyes:

no, it wouldn't because it's all relative to the situation. in some situations, simple stuff entails popping in a bootable disc environment to see if the drive is even recognized. if a customer is being completely honest with you and they don't mention anything about them opening up the case and fiddling with something, then i'm not going to check something that isn't going to unplug itself over night.

maybe if you actually read the rest of my post you would actually understand where i was coming from rather than being deluded by your own arrogance.
 
if a computer is working one day, and then it's not working the next, and the customer only says "all i did was turn it off one night and then i tried to turn it on the next day and it didn't work," then it's EXTREMELY unlikely that the IDE cable unplugged itself overnight unless the coefficient of static friction between two pieces of plastic changed as well.

for all of the computers i've worked on at the geek squad, i have never seen a problem arise from an IDE cable that was unplugged. VERY unlikely.

it's RELATIVE.
 
if a computer is working one day, and then it's not working the next, and the customer only says "all i did was turn it off one night and then i tried to turn it on the next day and it didn't work," then it's EXTREMELY unlikely that the IDE cable unplugged itself overnight unless the coefficient of static friction between two pieces of plastic changed as well.

for all of the computers i've worked on at the geek squad, i have never seen a problem arise from an IDE cable that was unplugged. VERY unlikely.

it's RELATIVE.

So? It's still stupid not to check the hardware first. No matter what you're told.
 
no, it wouldn't because it's all relative to the situation. in some situations, simple stuff entails popping in a bootable disc environment to see if the drive is even recognized. if a customer is being completely honest with you and they don't mention anything about them opening up the case and fiddling with something, then i'm not going to check something that isn't going to unplug itself over night.

maybe if you actually read the rest of my post you would actually understand where i was coming from rather than being deluded by your own arrogance.

ur errogent
 
Makes me wonder though, why are we doing an in depth discussion on how Geek Squad could have gotten it SO wrong when all the others knocked it out no problem?

It seems the others did the simple thing, so why exactly are we arguing for Geek Squad?
 
So? It's still stupid not to check the hardware first. No matter what you're told.

visually inspecting the hardware isn't always the first logical step. checking an hdd's functionality via another OS (such as a BDE or plugging it into another working computer) is another way of the "checking the hardware."

busting out the screw driver isn't always a necessity and it isn't always the simplest and most efficient way to check something.

seriously, how often does an IDE cable just become unseated by itself? probably never.

it all depends on what the PROBLEM is. it's all RELATIVE.
 
Makes me wonder though, why are we doing an in depth discussion on how Geek Squad could have gotten it SO wrong when all the others knocked it out no problem?

It seems the others did the simple thing, so why exactly are we arguing for Geek Squad?

it's not THE geek squad's fault. it was that employee's fault for being an idiot. it's not that all geek squad employees have a combined consciousness simply known as The Geek Squad which is in control of all geeks at the best buy stores. for a situation like this, it mainly boils down to the employee, NOT the company.
 
if a computer is working one day, and then it's not working the next, and the customer only says "all i did was turn it off one night and then i tried to turn it on the next day and it didn't work," then it's EXTREMELY unlikely that the IDE cable unplugged itself overnight unless the coefficient of static friction between two pieces of plastic changed as well.

for all of the computers i've worked on at the geek squad, i have never seen a problem arise from an IDE cable that was unplugged. VERY unlikely.

it's RELATIVE.

Yea, its all relative if the customer is being 100% honest. 99% of the time customers do not tell you every thing, even if its just by accident.
 
Yea, its all relative if the customer is being 100% honest. 99% of the time customers do not tell you every thing, even if its just by accident.

not in my experience, which is also relative. also, you don't always take the customer's word 100% as proof of the problem. perceiving the symptoms of the problem combined with what the customer says usually leads to discovering the cause of the problem very quickly 90% of the time. the other 10% of the time is when people go for the diagnostic service, which is either $0 or $70 depending on your warranty.

0% of the time, in my experience, has a cable ever come loose on its own. also, 0% of the time, in my experience, has an unplugged cable INSIDE a computer been the cause of a problem.

i have spoken with people over the phone who didn't even realize that they didn't have their keyboard plugged in properly or they didn't even have their power cord plugged in properly.

these are usually older people who are senile and borderline delirious.
 
i saw this video a few weeks before i started working at the geek squad (i did some research about what i would be getting myself into). ever since then, i've always been waiting for a customer to come in with the same exact problem. there have only been a few times where a customer has had a "No Boot Device Found" problem. i've checked the BIOS to see if an HDD was detected and then I would check on the hard drive itself thinking in the back of my head "maybe this customer is intentionally trying to trick me, maybe they saw that video too!"

it's never happened though.
 
Only time I've had cables been an issue is when I sold a PSU to a lady who claimed she was positive it was the PSU that was wrong, and she was positive she could install it herself.

She brought the machine back 20 minutes later claiming it won't turn on, I can already see through the window on the case that the 24pin wasn't seated all the way, I take off the panel, push it down, put the panel back on, plug it into our "test bench" up front and it boots up fine.

Then another one where it was saying no HDD detected (this was sata though!) and it was because my dumbass colleagues who half-assed everything put together the system without plugging in the sata cable to the HDD (How did they even test it?) I don't know. But again, something that took 20 seconds for me to open the panel, plug in the cable, put it back on and turn the computer on.

Those are really the only 2 cases I've seen.

Or the one where I built a computer for a friend (like... 8 years ago, I was still pretty new to it) and I spent 3 hours trying to figure out why I wasn't getting POST, but was getting beep errors. I contact the motherboard manufacturer and the first thing they say is, well did you plug in power to the video-card... and then I had an epic face-palm... 9800 Pro without a Molex on the back = no boot... haha...

I almost had my friend RMA the motherboard too cause I thought that's what was wrong. But that was during the time I bought IDE drives over SATA because I couldn't figure out how to get XP to install on SATA drives. Silly noob -_-
 
it's not THE geek squad's fault. it was that employee's fault for being an idiot. it's not that all geek squad employees have a combined consciousness simply known as The Geek Squad which is in control of all geeks at the best buy stores. for a situation like this, it mainly boils down to the employee, NOT the company.

Of course its never that simple. A few guys can always make EVERYONE else look bad.

I see where you're coming from though so I'll leave it be.
 
Caveat emptor, caveat venditor.

Having worked in good, bad and just plain incompetent shops it can hard to rely on anybody but yourself and the people you trust to do quality work. Obviously, if you go to geek squad or any other shop that you don't know the reputation of it is because you don't know any better or don't have the time, patience or connections to patronize another shop. Hey guess what, folks... sometimes you take your chances and get a good tech, sometimes you get a tech who thinks they are an expert after reading one too many maximum pc articles on the loo and sometimes you get the asshat who wants to pull in a bonus by upselling those cables at %300 markup and a protection plan you likely will never use. Them's the breaks.

As far as diagnosing the problem, it is best to follow in the words of the immortal dr. house and always, Always, ALWAYS assume the customer is lying either by omission or subterfuge. Besides, if they knew what the hell they were taking about they wouldn't be taking it to geek squad or any other crappy shop in the first place.
 
Considering I've seen these types of "repair shops put to the test" reports for nearly a decade, believe me, if someone brings me a PC that "just stopped working" the first thing I do when I get it on the bench is open it and look around inside. Any tech that just plugs everything in and turns it on to see what the problem might be should be fired, period.

That's the dumbest thing ever...

And because of all these types of reports, you'd better be opening it and looking around, checking everything you possibly can before it gets turned on lest you find yourself on a video playing on the local news showing just what a boob you made yourself out to be. :D
 
something similar happened to me about 2 months ago,
I had a WD 400GB hard disk that just stopped working, I took it to a shop specialized in fixing broken hard disks, the guy their spent like 20 minuets explaining to me how hard it would be to fix it, he said he’ll have to buy a similar disk which will cost A LOT since I had a very “rare model” and then open both disks and connec them to a very expensive devise that I thought only he and Bill Gates has, then backing all the data to a third hard disk through a very complicated process , he said all that while the disk was in my hand before he even connect it to a PC
When I asked how much this would cost he said at least 400$, I hold my laughter and said thanks
I went to another shop and he told me that it’s mostly a PCB problem, and I can replace it myself if a bought a similar disk and offered to order a similar one for me for like $60, he said if it wasn’t a PCB problem I can still use the new disk which puts me in (quoting from him) a win win situation

haven’t done anything until now :)
 
This all makes me sad because I live in Salem, OR & being a computer nerd things like this shouldn't happen. TBH, in the free-lancing aspect I never even asked for a tip, I even refused any money because I feel what we can do is a gift in a way.

Some people just can't learn computer tech, but stories like these make me feel I can charge $10/hour for work and make a killing by just using craigslist
 
I know that a lot of us wouldn't pay $50/hr to have our computers fixed...but, for the most part we know what we're doing. If we don't, we post a question here and 100,000 smart asses can help us out.

Most of the people who pay to have their computers fixed don't even know what a forum us let alone know how to ask a question on one.

I think that $50/hr for me to go to one of my client's homes and fix something they can't is more than reasonable.

Hell, I charge $150 for a site visit (I do home theaters). And for that they get two hours. BUT, if it only takes 1/2 an hour to fix, it's still $150.

Here's how I look at it...It takes time to get there, time to get to your next job, and there's the expertise involved with fixing whatever was wrong. $150 is more than fair. And in a city as big as Toronto, the most people I could see in a day is 3. I know I've been to more homes in one day, but those days are VERY rare and completely exhausting.

So, if you want my help, you'll have to pay for it.

Or, you could call Best Buy or whatever and see what THEY charge!! LOL
 
This all makes me sad because I live in Salem, OR & being a computer nerd things like this shouldn't happen. TBH, in the free-lancing aspect I never even asked for a tip, I even refused any money because I feel what we can do is a gift in a way.

Some people just can't learn computer tech, but stories like these make me feel I can charge $10/hour for work and make a killing by just using craigslist
It's honest people like you that get crushed in this capitalist machine :(
 
Back
Top