Comodo Hacker Says He's Protesting U.S. Policy

...and was willing to maneuver the whole country into an unpopular war to accomplish it. He spent American lives and money and dragged out a horrendous war longer than it needed to be, when it was otherwise just about over. Is that supposed to be an okay thing to do?

That said, the point I was getting at before wasn't about moral judgment. My point was twofold:

First, World War II is not the reason for US interventionism, because US interventionism started a half century before World War II.

Second, World War II isn't even a good reason for continued US interventionism, because if it were not for previous US interventionism, the war never would have happened. That doesn't mean the US was solely to blame; that's not what I'm saying at all. There were so many different choices that different people made, which led to events unfolding the way they did. Ultimately, the Nazis, the fascists, and imperial Japan are morally culpable for World War II, but the whole situation could still have been avoided by a number of wiser choices on the part of the US and the World War I Allied Powers.

We cannot control what evil men will do. Saying, "It's their fault" may absolve us of blame, sure, but it gets us no closer to making wiser decisions in the future, which will help us avoid history repeating. Regardless of who the good guys were (obviously the Allies, which is rare in war), World War II was still an indirect, unintended consequence of prior US intervention (among other things), without which it wouldn't have occurred. That's far from a glowing recommendation of the "proactive" approach Ualdayan brought up. Could anyone have foreseen what getting into World War I would eventually lead to? No, but that's kind of the point. It's incredibly reckless to involve your whole country in a war of choice and throw away lives and money, because you're extremely unlikely to foresee the ultimate consequences.


Your WW2 example is a red herring.
There can be and are genocides and atrocities committed which are completely unrelated to American Intervention.
 
Nobody cares what he is protesting, you intrude into something thats not yours and that is called "illegal" in our country.

Enjoy bubba, and don't drop the soap you skinny Iranian. You're f&@ked if you get caught buddy!

It sounds like you would just have them lynch him before any trial and burn the body, to make a statement on the rule of law. Or some rape will teach him.

Oooookay....
 
Your WW2 example is a red herring.
There can be and are genocides and atrocities committed which are completely unrelated to American Intervention.

Keep in mind that I'm not the one who brought up World War II. This line of discussion started because Ualdayan stated World War II is the reason for American interventionism. I was countering that not only did interventionism start prior to World War II, but World War II isn't even a good reason for it.

The issue of atrocities and genocides (which are usually civil war quagmires, but occasionally real genocides) are another issue that expand the scope of the topic beyond what I responded to Ualdayan to address. The history talk ended up hijacking the whole thread already, so I'm not sure if it's a good idea to get into a debate on that too.
 
I was countering that not only did interventionism start prior to World War II, but World War II isn't even a good reason for it.

I should clarify: World War II isn't even a good reason for it to be our default policy.
 
No way! Why would an Iranian or anyone in Iran have any reason to be pissed at the United States!?

There are so many effin ignorant, nationalistic buffoons in the U.S. Jeebus it is embarrassing. Here, read the following three books. It's just a start but maybe, just maybe, you won't be forever ignorant about our "foreign policy."

All the Shah's Men

War is a Rackett

Overthrow
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Also, I forgot to address something you said, DocFaustus: You said I should look deeper into what caused us to enter World War I. I didn't support my assertion that our entry was unnecessary, and I actually have to go, so I don't have time to get into a debate on that now. That said, if anyone reading this doesn't have a set viewpoint on that and is honestly curious, it shouldn't be hard finding historical material backing up the assertion that Wilson deliberately maneuvered us into war with Germany.

Germany caused the US to enter WW1. Generally the US wasn't very hip to entering the war but opinions changed when Germany tried to instigate a war with the between Mexico and US. They also tried to get Japan to do the same.

The telegram coupled with the civilian boats (yes I know many of those boats were transporting military stuff) being attacked were what swayed America's view and why we entered the war at the end.

Read: Zimmermann Telegram
 
Germany caused the US to enter WW1. Generally the US wasn't very hip to entering the war but opinions changed when Germany tried to instigate a war with the between Mexico and US. They also tried to get Japan to do the same.

The telegram coupled with the civilian boats (yes I know many of those boats were transporting military stuff) being attacked were what swayed America's view and why we entered the war at the end.

Read: Zimmermann Telegram

The Zimmermann Telegram may have come as a surprise, but it really should not have. Delivering arms exclusively to the Allied Powers, under the guise of civilian transport, was not some minor detail. It was a pretty big deal, and it severely compromised the neutrality of the United States. The US government was continually goading the Germans into attacking, to provide an excuse and pretext to the American people for the US government to enter the war. The US government was only feigning neutrality, and given the Balfour Declaration and its likely influence on Wilson's advisors, it was only a matter of time before the US entered the war i full. I'm not excusing the Germans here - the Zimmermann Telegram was a dick move - but they sent it to Mexico in anticipation of the US going to war with them, because the Wilson administration was already maneuvering things in that direction...against the will of the people, at least until an easily propagandized pretext arose.

One of beto's links really deserves to be posted twice:
War is a Racket
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I should elaborate a bit:
When the US was shipping arms and war supplies to the Allied Powers under the guise of civilian transport, it was pretty transparent to the Germans what was actually going on. Rather than remaining truly neutral, the US was "covertly" backing the Allied Powers and undermining the Central Powers every chance it got. However, the US government knew the Germans knew about all the shenanigans, so the whole charade was not for the benefit of the Germans. Instead of being meant to trick the Germans, the "civilian transport" story was meant to manipulate the American people. By engaging in this deception, the Wilson administration knew that it could continue goading the Germans into attacking, and once they did it enough times, the people would unite behind a war effort in response to "unprovoked attacks on passenger ships."

The Germans caught on to the game the Wilson administration was playing, so for a while, they restricted their submarine warfare and let war supplies through to the British when they knew attacking would be too risky. Time went on though, and the whole senseless war (which was by and large the biggest and most senseless pissing contest the world has ever seen) just dragged on. Instead of surrendering, the British were continuously getting supplies from the United States, basically using the US as their war machine. Unless and until that stopped, the British had little reason to finally surrender (to pretty decent terms at that) and let the war end.

Finally, the Germans got fed up and decided to resume unrestricted submarine warfare...but they knew that this would give the US government the pretext it needed to enter the war. At this point, they knew there was little left they could do to avoid war with the US. This wasn't because the Germans WANTED to fight the US - they had enough on their hands, and they were trying to finish the war - but because the Wilson administration was looking for a pretext to get involved. By issuing the Zimmermann Telegram, they hoped Mexico could distract the US long enough for the Germans to finish the war in Europe...but Mexico was too busy with their own civil war, and the British intercepted the communication, and it gave the Wilson administration the pretext it was looking for all along.

In short, the telegram was a dick move (even if it was kind of quid pro quo), and it was a stupid move, but it didn't actually cause the US to enter the war, so much as it caused the US to enter the war a couple weeks earlier than we already would have (when unrestricted submarine warfare resumed). The Wilson administration put the Germans between a rock and a hard place, so the Germans essentially had to choose between a never-ending war of attrition with the British or trying to end it quickly, thereby risking full-blown war with the US as well. It was within Wilson's power to remain neutral the entire time and totally avoid going to war...but that's not what he (and/or his advisors) wanted, so that's not what happened.
 
Not only that, but he first says we don't talk, then says we start all wars, then complains about Hiroshima. Does he have no clue about history? The reason we take a proactive approach to world affairs is BECAUSE of World War II (which, apparently he doesn't know - we didn't start WW2). We tried the sitting back, talking, not actively engaging, and look what it got us. Surprise attack that destroyed a large part of the navy of the time. Maybe he is a good hacker, but he certainly doesn't seem to understand world events or history.

He is from Iran where they don't even teach factual history. The Holocaust was all made up remember :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top