Zangmonkey
Supreme [H]ardness
- Joined
- Jul 6, 2005
- Messages
- 5,895
...and was willing to maneuver the whole country into an unpopular war to accomplish it. He spent American lives and money and dragged out a horrendous war longer than it needed to be, when it was otherwise just about over. Is that supposed to be an okay thing to do?
That said, the point I was getting at before wasn't about moral judgment. My point was twofold:
First, World War II is not the reason for US interventionism, because US interventionism started a half century before World War II.
Second, World War II isn't even a good reason for continued US interventionism, because if it were not for previous US interventionism, the war never would have happened. That doesn't mean the US was solely to blame; that's not what I'm saying at all. There were so many different choices that different people made, which led to events unfolding the way they did. Ultimately, the Nazis, the fascists, and imperial Japan are morally culpable for World War II, but the whole situation could still have been avoided by a number of wiser choices on the part of the US and the World War I Allied Powers.
We cannot control what evil men will do. Saying, "It's their fault" may absolve us of blame, sure, but it gets us no closer to making wiser decisions in the future, which will help us avoid history repeating. Regardless of who the good guys were (obviously the Allies, which is rare in war), World War II was still an indirect, unintended consequence of prior US intervention (among other things), without which it wouldn't have occurred. That's far from a glowing recommendation of the "proactive" approach Ualdayan brought up. Could anyone have foreseen what getting into World War I would eventually lead to? No, but that's kind of the point. It's incredibly reckless to involve your whole country in a war of choice and throw away lives and money, because you're extremely unlikely to foresee the ultimate consequences.
Your WW2 example is a red herring.
There can be and are genocides and atrocities committed which are completely unrelated to American Intervention.