Cloud Services Suffer from Performance Problems, Tests Find

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Australian researchers conducted a series of tests on the cloud-computing services of Amazon, Google, and Microsoft to measure response times and other performance metrics. What the researchers found was not what those companies want to hear: all of them suffer from regular performance and availability issues.

"None of the platforms have the kind of monitoring required to have a reasonable conversation about performance," she said. "They provide some level of monitoring, but what little there is caters for developers, not business users. And while Amazon provides a dashboard of how much it is costing you so far, for example, there is nothing in terms of forecasts about what it will cost you in the future.
 
I would have liked to have seen more details of their research.

That is always one thing I myself thought would be a problem with those types of services. You are not always going to have a stable connection to sites out there on the web. You can have a slowdown on your end or they can have on on their end so that would low down the performace of the service. On top of that depending on how it is setup, if all companies trying to do a lot of larger stuff at the same time you would probably notice a decrease in preformance for awhile. So it might make it easier on you for not having to have your own, server but the you might be giving up some availability and preformance to get somebody else to take care of tha aspect for you.

That way, after people start to use the service more and these companies get a feeling for what they need load balancing wise some of those problems will go away.
 
Was it a little hazy or just spotty service?

The article really doesn't give much info. I guess you will have to go listen to their talk at that conference to find out for usre.

It almost sounds as if it just slowed down on Amazon and Microsoft with Google timing out as it was taking longer than the service will allow for something to process.

Other than that they didn't like that lack of information that you recieved about the performance of the service. Which I guess they mean such as how many people are logged in at a time, how long they were logged in, processing load of the server and stuff like that.
 
I would have liked to have seen more details of their research.

That is always one thing I myself thought would be a problem with those types of services. You are not always going to have a stable connection to sites out there on the web. You can have a slowdown on your end or they can have on on their end so that would low down the performance of the service. On top of that depending on how it is setup, if all companies trying to do a lot of larger stuff at the same time you would probably notice a decrease in performance for awhile. So it might make it easier on you for not having to have your own, server but the you might be giving up some availability and performance to get somebody else to take care of that aspect for you.

That way, after people start to use the service more and these companies get a feeling for what they need load balancing wise some of those problems will go away.

QFT

I've never understood why so many people are willing to accept cloud computing as a viable concept without having a rock-solid infrastructure in place.
Don't get me wrong; the fact that the Internet works as well as it does is a sheer miracle in my eyes.
Having said that, it's still a fragile infrastructure that vacillates wildly in terms of performance at a given point in time.
The same goes for Software as a Service.

Network infrastructure wonks are the folk who are most rabid when it comes to issues like reliability and speed, which makes it all the more puzzling that clouds and SAAS have gained such traction in the network world.
 
The cloud has a LOT of problems facing it. One I like to point out is storage costs. 1 TB of cloud storage it UBER exspensive. Then the REAL cost of bandwidth as a pure cloud needs unlimited bandwidth. Until these issues are addressed, sure you'll see TONS of cloud based stuff but local capcity and storage will still be just as important.

The fact is the cloud is really just another name for thin client from ten years ago. The promise of the cloud is lower cost. That's simply not the case today for all applications.
 
Back
Top