ClamAV for Windows on WHS?

I have used this for 2 years or so. I believe it detects only viruses and not other malware so I do not use it as much. I found when fixing other peoples machines from infections that clamwin rarely finds anything when avast, malwarebytes, superantispyware find dozens of viruses and take a few passes alternating each program to remove the nasty infections.

No it does not do real time detection. That was actually the reason for me to want this program. I mean since you really can not have 2 programs doing real time protection its nice to be able to schedule a second one to run when I want in addition to the real time protection that my other AV provides. Only if clamwin detects malware..
 
Last edited:
Actually i think the no live scanner is a good thing. For those security conscious people that do not need a virus scanner anyway, the live scanning feature of commercial antivirus just slows down your whole computer; as any I/O access will first be processed by the virusscanner. Thus, at times when you really need the performance, the virusscanner will slow everything down. It's possible an older pc without virusscanner runs faster than the latest core i7 with normal HDD and virusscanner; that still could make the I/O go so slow that basically you wasted your beautiful system.

So for those who do not want to cut their performance in half (or even smaller chunks), this virusscanner is great as it allows you to only be active when you want to scan for virusses. That also implies you're still the primary virusscanner yourself; it puts more responsibility in your hands. I would argue that if you can be contaminated with a virus then it's too late already; since every day new exploits/virusses appear and trying to get you solid protection is impossible; of all the malware probably only 1% is covered. There's just too much junk out there. And false positives can be nasty too.

Generally clam is used as virusscanner for email/storage on non-windows systems, like in the email server. But should have some use for security conscious windows people as well.
 
ive used NOD32 for several years, its active virus scanner takes less then 20mb of RAM and even when doing a full sytem scan, takes almost zero CPU time. unless you have a very old system, an good active scanner will not slow your system down. the only time i see it degrade performance at all is when downloading very large (500+mb) files from internet, it takes 5 seconds to scan the file after it finishes downloading before you can open it. not a big problem.

scanning files when they are accessed also eliminates the need to do full system scans for the most part. as any viruses coming in will get detected, and even if there is a virus hiding somewhere, it will be found the first time the system tries to access it.

i have found that certain programs (norton is HORRIBLE) are resource hogs, but if you find a good program, there should be no problem. ive been using windows security essentials on a few computers and like it as well. its free from microsoft.

i use clamwin portable when cleaning peoples computers from virus infections. its a good lite on demand virus scanner, but nothing more.
 
ClamAV has one of the worst ratings I've seen for anti-virus. I'd use Avira, Avast or Microsoft Security Essentials...all are rated very high in known viruses and Avira and MSE are rated pretty highly for unknown virus detection...and all of them are free.
 
Avira is the most annoying program in the world unless you pay them to stop the popups. the free version is as annoying as loading your computer intentionally with malware.
 
Avira is the most annoying program in the world unless you pay them to stop the popups. the free version is as annoying as loading your computer intentionally with malware.

Go into the advanced security properties of avnotify.exe and disallow execute access from all of the users listed for it. I also disallow changing permissions so that the updater can't (or shouldn't) change them back.
 
I use MSE on my regular PCs, but the cheapest solution for WHS I've found that does real-time scanning is avast. I've been considering getting avast's WHS license, but it's a bit high for me.
Reason I need real-time on the WHS is mainly for the others that I give access to the server. I'm not so worried about myself, since I'm good about not randomly clicking. However, when other family members have access to the server and I see MSE has been catching stuff on their computers, I get a little worried.
 
Back
Top