Can Internet Posts Get You Fired?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Time magazine has once again brought up the issue of people getting fired for posts they make on social media sites.

Still, "this case doesn't answer the question of when an employer can discipline an employee just for speaking badly about the company on something unrelated to work," says Gary Phelan, an employment lawyer with the Connecticut firm of Cohen & Wolf. "There are also basic defamation and slander laws under which the employer can sue," and maybe win, if an employee post is defamatory and untrue.
 
While there are protections in place for free speech, employees have to be careful or they could wind up on the wrong end of a defamation/libel/slander suit too.

And, most states are right-to-work / right-to-hire / at-will, meaning they can fire you for no reason at all, any time they want. Most employers' biggest mistake is actually TELLING people why they are fired.
 
Right, people get fired for this stuff all the time. The only time an issue arises is when the manager is stupid enough to admit why.

Which imo is complete crap, an employer should not be able to fire an employee over non work related activities when not on company time. They don't own us. That said, I am coming to the conclusion that most work laws allowing an employer to terminate without a paper trail need to be abolished. They don't benefit the employee in any way.

Then again, I have never seen someone fired for something like this that was what you would call a "good" employee any
 
anyhow*

never type with your mouse cursor hovering over quick reply. If you bump the touchpad you have the above unfinished thought.

ugh for no edit for at least 30 seconds or something.
 
Right, people get fired for this stuff all the time. The only time an issue arises is when the manager is stupid enough to admit why.

Which imo is complete crap, an employer should not be able to fire an employee over non work related activities when not on company time. They don't own us. That said, I am coming to the conclusion that most work laws allowing an employer to terminate without a paper trail need to be abolished. They don't benefit the employee in any way.

Then again, I have never seen someone fired for something like this that was what you would call a "good" employee any

I have.
I agree with you. There is a disturbing trend of late where it seems whatever company you work for basically owning you inside and out of the workplace...or alternately workplaces using non work related resources to decide to hire you or not.
The system is broken and as usual is out to shit on the workers and younger generations.

That said there is another side to this to be fair. Everyone needs an outlet to work frustrations. I 1000% believe this...I also believe it is only natural progression for things like internet posts to become a voice for this...no different than conversing at a bar/restaurant etc. HOWEVER, exercise some degree of mental capacity when doing so. Simply put the stupid is overwhelming and by using some measure of forethought a majority of these issues can be avoided. (photos of yourself at a party with beer in hand is fine, pictures of a throwing up in the gutter or with coke residue under your nose probably not as good to have on a public page) or alternately don't use name/address/etc of the work place you are shitting on...or if you do don't make your social media visible to everyone...

so it does go both ways and i think both sides are being utterly stupid in the issue. whether its high paying, low paying or you love it or hate it...a job is ultimately still a job and for the majority of people you are only required to be "on the job" when you are there.
 
Had a friend that was fired over an email.
It had some religious content and a department head was an atheist and had her fired.
I told her to get a lawyer; it was completely groundless; and highly discriminatory.
She decided not to pursue it because she knew that person would do everything to make her miserable if she got the same position back.
She was probably right.
 
They'll fire you for bashing the company, but they sure as heck wont give you a raise for praising them :)
 
People are just not using common sense. You don't bad talk the company in earshot of your boss. It's common sense, right. The problem here is that people are, for some reason, not realizing that Facebook, Twiitter and the like are within earshot of the boss. To make matters worse, they do even more stupid crap like freinding their boss or not making themselves anon which is easy with those sites.
 
Just more fail by stupid people.

I was told along time ago, don't take (or let someone take) any picture you wouldn't want your mother to see.

Same with the internet, don't post anything you wouldn't mind your Boss/Wife/Ex, etc reading.


I have no problem with a company firing someone for bad talking the company, or whatever other reason they want. Usually it's the final straw, or just an excuse to get rid of a bad/maginal employee.

Stupid activity like illegal drug use, bad mouthing managers, etc by employees (even on thier own time) is a reflection of that persons personality/behavior, and is a good predictor of future activity/behavior, including at work. The alternative is to have rules like some of the unions, where it's almost impossible to get ride of bad workers, and the good workers have to pick up the slack, while the bad workers keep collecting thier paychecks.
 
People are just not using common sense. You don't bad talk the company in earshot of your boss. It's common sense, right. The problem here is that people are, for some reason, not realizing that Facebook, Twiitter and the like are within earshot of the boss. To make matters worse, they do even more stupid crap like freinding their boss or not making themselves anon which is easy with those sites.
^This

I'll fire every one of my employees if I come across something slanderous enough...there isn't any difference between that and walking past a slanderous conversation. I'll never list that as the reason they got fired so good luck taking me to court.
 
Had a friend that was fired over an email.
It had some religious content and a department head was an atheist and had her fired.
I told her to get a lawyer; it was completely groundless; and highly discriminatory.
She decided not to pursue it because she knew that person would do everything to make her miserable if she got the same position back.
She was probably right.

Circulating an email containing beliefs of a specific religion is discriminatory, even if unintentionally so.
 
As previously mentioned, the reason why you are fired and the reason you are fired don't necessarily have to be the same thing. Nobody is a perfect employee, and employers can use it to their benefit.

Now, as far as suing your employer for wrongful termination, this is a very tricky subject. Lawsuits are one of the last resorts, and I personally wouldn't sue unless it was the very last resort.

Employers don't like employees who sue. This not only includes your current employer, but any future employer you may have. At the same time, even if you somehow get your job back, you know you're going to have lots of talk about yourself going on behind your back. Just be a man (or woman) and move on. After all, there was a reason you talked bad about them in the first place, and there's seldom any good that can come out of staying in a place you're unwanted.
 
If I were to own a company, and one of my employees would badmouth the company on Facebook, I'd fire the employee in a heartbeat. That's the whole point of owning a business, the ability to make decisions which are good for the company. Simple really.
 
If I own a company, I want the ability to fire any of my employees for any reason. Does that mean I'm going to randomly fire people just because I can? No, it would be stupid to do so. If I over hear one of my employees bad mouthing me at a restaurant am I going to fire them? It depends on the employee, if they were a pretty shitty employee probably. If they're my star employee, I'd let it slide for sure. What changes from overhearing them at a restaurant to overhearing them on facebook?
 
People are just not using common sense. You don't bad talk the company in earshot of your boss. It's common sense, right. The problem here is that people are, for some reason, not realizing that Facebook, Twiitter and the like are within earshot of the boss. To make matters worse, they do even more stupid crap like freinding their boss or not making themselves anon which is easy with those sites.
Maybe you don't, we rag and trash the company and policy all the time, in front of and with managers and directors.

Product lines, raises, lack of raises, policy, etc.

My boss always claims he has the most cynical team he's ever run across.
 
Had a friend that was fired over an email.
It had some religious content and a department head was an atheist and had her fired.
I told her to get a lawyer; it was completely groundless; and highly discriminatory.
She decided not to pursue it because she knew that person would do everything to make her miserable if she got the same position back.
She was probably right.

I would have done it anyway, then kept records of everything said asshat did in order to force her out. Eventually, a manager on a vendetta will make an expensive mistake.
 
No edit :(

I am, of course, assuming the employee is in the right.
 
Yes you can. Browse on your breaks or your own free time. Work is work and right now I am on break.:cool:
 
^This

I'll fire every one of my employees if I come across something slanderous enough...there isn't any difference between that and walking past a slanderous conversation. I'll never list that as the reason they got fired so good luck taking me to court.

The road does run both ways yes, but at the end of the day you don't own them. I don't know your personal habits but provided you aren't actively seeking this information out fine. It is the ones who actively troll their employees information that are the problem in this.

If I were to own a company, and one of my employees would badmouth the company on Facebook, I'd fire the employee in a heartbeat. That's the whole point of owning a business, the ability to make decisions which are good for the company. Simple really.

See the above on actively looking. The difference is that you are extremely unlikely to hear them in person, while social media makes venting your frustrations a very dangerous thing. Sometimes people do say dumb shit just to vent without much intent.

That all said, I do have trouble finding any sympathy for people who makes asses of themselves on facebook then get fired over it. It is hardly like they are innocent victims. I just take issue with any employer poking around in my personal life and attempting to hold me responsible for my behavior off the clock.
 
I would have done it anyway, then kept records of everything said asshat did in order to force her out. Eventually, a manager on a vendetta will make an expensive mistake.

It was me I would have gotten a lawyer to make a point. The content of the email was pretty mild and it was not "pushing" anything. It concerning a hospitalized family member and and was along the lines of "please pray for them"
This was on a university campus and they are suppose to be open minded and tolerant of diverse beliefs but they were completely intolerant and vindictive.
She didn't violate any policy and her dismissal was totally unjustified.
But her point of view was probably the most correct. It was just an administrative assistant position and she had to work under a bunch of A-holes; so she didn't miss it.
 
It was me I would have gotten a lawyer to make a point. The content of the email was pretty mild and it was not "pushing" anything. It concerning a hospitalized family member and and was along the lines of "please pray for them"
This was on a university campus and they are suppose to be open minded and tolerant of diverse beliefs but they were completely intolerant and vindictive.
She didn't violate any policy and her dismissal was totally unjustified.
But her point of view was probably the most correct. It was just an administrative assistant position and she had to work under a bunch of A-holes; so she didn't miss it.

Quote : The United States has the material to become the most Totalitarian Country in the world. The U.S.S.R has the material to become the freest country in the world.

Mark Twain.

Conclusion: People are the same where ever you go.

Internet puts you in contact with your loved ones in a minute but it also allows immense control of others over those that give away their power. Just like a gun.
 
Putting something stupid, in writing, into what is essentially a permanent database can get one fired, sued, arrested, and sometimes killed. It is worse than just speaking something stupid.

In my area a cop killed someone under questionable circumstances. His publicly viewable facebook page listed his occupation as "human waste disposal". It will be a little harder for the city to defend the wrongful death lawsuit now ya think? Stupid cop. The lawyers are trying to get access other officers internet posts now.
 
It was me I would have gotten a lawyer to make a point. The content of the email was pretty mild and it was not "pushing" anything. It concerning a hospitalized family member and and was along the lines of "please pray for them"
This was on a university campus and they are suppose to be open minded and tolerant of diverse beliefs but they were completely intolerant and vindictive.
She didn't violate any policy and her dismissal was totally unjustified.
But her point of view was probably the most correct. It was just an administrative assistant position and she had to work under a bunch of A-holes; so she didn't miss it.

I work at a private school that has weekly chapel that all students must attend. We have a "no religious content or proselytizing" in official school work and email in our staff/faculty handbook.

We did fire someone for doing this before it was in the handbook. We just used the fact that they were using the school email system for things not strictly related to the school. I guarantee that she would have lost her case. Simply sending the email about a sick relative could easily be considered against company policy, they don't even need the religious argument.
 
Maybe you don't, we rag and trash the company and policy all the time, in front of and with managers and directors.

Product lines, raises, lack of raises, policy, etc.

My boss always claims he has the most cynical team he's ever run across.

That seems more like the exception rather than the rule. But every workplace and every boss are different.
 
^This. I'll fire every one of my employees if I come across something slanderous enough...there isn't any difference between that and walking past a slanderous conversation. I'll never list that as the reason they got fired so good luck taking me to court.

Manager of the year - obviously people's personal and social dynamics are no mystery to you. :rolleyes:

Managers should understand different personalities; successful corporations do no initiate "witch-hunts." Personal beliefs, as long as they are not public and inflammatory are not grounds for termination. However I do agree that judgment is the most important aspect of this comment (which apparently was not exercised in this example).

You can never manage a group of people who have nothing negative to say privately – it simply comes with the territory.
 
Hah, that would suck if I got fired because almost everything I "like" on facebook is porn or nudity related.
 
Wouldn't they have to prove that it's actually you that posted something?

What's stopping someone from making a fake account and using your name and posting stuff.

Or what if your account gets compromised/hacked.
 
Facebook should be off-limits for work. It should be blocked as a site, employees should not post about their work, and employers should not watch it like hawks for slip ups.

After work is done, work is done. It shouldn't matter if someone volunteers at a nursing home and is in bed by 9:30 or they start pounding shots and pass out in a cab without their phone.
 
I read stuff about people getting fired over things said online all the time. It's a very compelling reason to not post stuff about work online.
 
Manager of the year - obviously people's personal and social dynamics are no mystery to you. :rolleyes:
I'm not a manager, I'm the owner. Social dynamics aren't a mystery when they're spelled out for the world to see in a public arena.

Personal beliefs, as long as they are not public and inflammatory are not grounds for termination.
You clearly do not understand the definition of public then because and open Facebook account that anyone in the world with an internet connection can view is the very definition of public. You tried to back up your argument but ended up refuting it in the same sentence. impressive.

You can never manage a group of people who have nothing negative to say privately – it simply comes with the territory.
Once again, because it bears repeating, open Facebook accounts are not private...they're as public as it gets.
 
Facebook should be off-limits for work. It should be blocked as a site, employees should not post about their work, and employers should not watch it like hawks for slip ups.

After work is done, work is done. It shouldn't matter if someone volunteers at a nursing home and is in bed by 9:30 or they start pounding shots and pass out in a cab without their phone.
That's great in theory but in practice it doesn't work that way. People carry their troubles with them whether it be lashing out at their significant others because they're grumpy from a bad day at work or coming in with a bad attitude because their marriage is falling apart. I replaced two people last month because their personal lives were in shambles and it was influencing their work. It is impossible to keep the two separate.
 
it is almsot always against company policy at every company to post things online such as on goings at work, company secrets, salaries. hours. and if an employer found you you;'d get terminated.
 
The system is broken and as usual is out to shit on the workers and younger generations.

And then people wonder why younger generations have crappy work ethic. The company shits on me so why should I care about the job?
 
Manager of the year - obviously people's personal and social dynamics are no mystery to you. :rolleyes:

Managers should understand different personalities; successful corporations do no initiate "witch-hunts." Personal beliefs, as long as they are not public and inflammatory are not grounds for termination. However I do agree that judgment is the most important aspect of this comment (which apparently was not exercised in this example).

You can never manage a group of people who have nothing negative to say privately – it simply comes with the territory.

Says the subordinate. Business is business. In some cases the negative feelings can be addressed and changed while in others it needs to be stomped out. Not all environments are the same and it's not always within the managers realm of control to change it for the better. His job is not to be your life coach, it's to keep productivity up. Sometimes that's accomplished by keeping employees happy, sometimes it's not.

Newsflash, you probably aren't as special as you think. Most employees, at all levels, are interchangeable. Your business does not revolve around your existence.

Re-reading that I said you and your a lot. Not meant specifically at you Usquabach(I don't know your situation), but the royal "masses" you :D.
 
Back
Top