California Bans Texting While Driving

No I don't think your your anti cell phone, and from the whole black box forum is well it is apparent that you among others would rather see this great nation turn into some perfect mixture of a fascist and socialist country. Where everyone has the same money no one is poor, and the government has made it so bad thing don't happen my making anything that the slightest amount of affecting anybody in a bad way illegal. People need to stop getting involved in in what other people are doing and stop policing your neighbor just because of some story you heard on the news.

Ummm you got me wrong there bud :) I hate socialists, I also hate fascist. I am a big believer in you reap what you sow and you don't see me saying everyone has to have the same money.

I guess my viewpoints are diffrent, because I have lost family members to distracted drivers and friends to drunk drivers and I did live in a country that was questionable at best for a big part of my life. I have seen first hand what happens when government gets all involved. I also happen to commute bumper to bumper all the way home an hour each way every day, so I can share my experiences with bad, terrible, and drivers who text on their phones.

I'm a person who has an issue when others can get killed for the enjoyment/convenience of others.

Here is an idea to completely fix all un-needed texting/talking on the cell phone while driving.

Make EVERY vehicle have a device that blocks any and all cell phone signals inside the car while the car is moving.

If there is an emergency, you can hit an Emergency Button on the phone which will automatically dial 911 on a special signal that isn't blocked by the vehicle.

Or you could just have cell phones have a speed detector on them that makes them not work past say 10mph unless you hit an Emergency Button that dials 911.

That is probably the easiest solution since the GPS sattelites are already in place.

Yeah, the problem with that is that it infringes on rights of passengers too.
 
Ummm. Have you ever seen the statistics of texting and driving?

Do you support drivers who are driving over the legal limit? What about drug users using while driving? What about both? It is said that texting is more dangerous than both of those things. So hell, if you can text, I can drive drunk.

Oh and please stop with the nonsense that "if you oppose it then you must be guilty of it", that is sheer strawman tactics right there. For the record, I don't drink, never have and never will, for the other record, I don't even have a text plan on my phone becaue I think it's stupid when you can just call a person, on the other record, I don't talk when I drive, I have a carphone if I really needed to use it that badly (which I don't even use, so there was no point for me paying out the ass for that feature anyways). Oh yeah, and to top it off, I carry two cellphones and a pager, so if you think I'm an anti phone nut or something, think again. I expect the same respect I give in return on the roads.


Sorry as for the texting and driving statistics, I haven't seen anything recently. could you show some links where I can read up on them. Or maybe you can fill me in on a couple things. In 06 How many accidents where the drive responsible was texting? How many accidents happened total in 06? How many text accidents where fatal? How many total accidents where fatal? % of Text accidents on City roads? % of text accidents on Highway? % of all accidents on City roads? % of All accidents on highway? % of fatal text accidents on highway, % on City roads? % of all Fatal accidents on Highway, % on city.

I need that information before I would make any reasonable judgment and refuse to condemn something just because you hear about one or two incidents in the news.
 
I think this should definitely be implemented in more states. Problem is that entering a number into the phone is still allowed (since using the cell phone is still allowed) so it's pretty tough to catch people in the act.

I admit that I'm guilty of answering my phone when I'm driving but I always try to avoid making any calls when driving. See too many people looking at their phones for too much time and they SUCK at driving.
 
Ummm you got me wrong there bud :) I hate socialists, I also hate fascist. I am a big believer in you reap what you sow and you don't see me saying everyone has to have the same money.

I guess my viewpoints are diffrent, because I have lost family members to distracted drivers and friends to drunk drivers and I did live in a country that was questionable at best for a big part of my life. I have seen first hand what happens when government gets all involved. I also happen to commute bumper to bumper all the way home an hour each way every day, so I can share my experiences with bad, terrible, and drivers who text on their phones.

I'm a person who has an issue when others can get killed for the enjoyment/convenience of others.



Yeah, the problem with that is that it infringes on rights of passengers too.
But isn't that how everyone dies. If someone falls down the stairs and breaks their necks, wasn't those stairs for the amusement of someone else. Should stairs be banned because they they are dangerous. No someone should be expected to maintain those stairs and are responsible (could even go to prison) if something bad happens with them.

What use is it for the police officer to sit down write a ticket to possibly the one driver that could actually function with in the laws while texting, and having three more drivers get farther down the road texting and those be the ones that are horrible drivers. The officer looking for careless drivers as a whole and instead of wasting time and energy on a practice that may or may not have any impact on their driving capabilities. Don't ban something to ban something, Just go after the ones that it does affect poorly. We already have a law for that and its careless or reckless driving. If your not driving carelessly or recklessly then that means your driving fine, does it really matter at that point whats going on in your car.
 
I'm not sure if this law will help (I hope it does). Would be great if your car disconnected you from SMS networks. ;)

I think people tend to forget that your in a 2000 pound hunk of metal with speed and momentum behind it. Anyone that cannot take that seriously needs to have their license revoked.
 
Sorry as for the texting and driving statistics, I haven't seen anything recently. could you show some links where I can read up on them. Or maybe you can fill me in on a couple things. In 06 How many accidents where the drive responsible was texting? How many accidents happened total in 06? How many text accidents where fatal? How many total accidents where fatal? % of Text accidents on City roads? % of text accidents on Highway? % of all accidents on City roads? % of All accidents on highway? % of fatal text accidents on highway, % on City roads? % of all Fatal accidents on Highway, % on city.

I need that information before I would make any reasonable judgment and refuse to condemn something just because you hear about one or two incidents in the news.


Texting while driving impairs driving skills more than being drunk or high, according to new research carried out by the UK's Transport Research Laboratory (TRL) for the roadside assistance organisation, the Royal Automobile Club (RAC).
http://www.cellular-news.com/story/33703.php

The study found that reaction times deteriorated by over one-third (35%). This was worse than alcohol at the legal limit (12% slower) and driving under the influence of cannabis (21% slower) Drivers also drifted out of their lane more often. Steering control was 91% worse, compared to 35% worse when under the influence of cannabis.
http://www.cellular-news.com/story/33703.php

Cell phones or texting have been linked to several fatal crashes around the country, including a fiery crash that left five cheerleaders dead in upstate New York in June. Police said text messages were sent to and from the 17-year-old driver's cell phone seconds before her vehicle crossed into the opposite lane and hit a tractor-trailer
http://www.insurancejournal.com/news/east/2007/10/31/84666.htm


I suppose I don't need to tell you about the tour bus or the train that recently derailed while the operators were texting while operating.


If your not driving carelessly or recklessly then that means your driving fine, does it really matter at that point whats going on in your car.

So do you agree that if you are on drugs or over the legal limit that it's fine as long as the cop thinks you are driving fine?
 
I do talk on the phone while driving, but I have a Hands Free device on my car's Visor. I use voice dialing and never have to touch my phone while on the road. But texting while driving is a horrible habit. Its like when Women/Teenagers put on make-up while driving? :confused: WTF?? I agree people just need to stop acting like D U M B @ $ $ E S. Period.
 
How about just a setting, since these phones all have GPS, that if you are moving faster than $25, you loose text and phone call abilities, and only have call ability through a hands free?

Heck, If I have that, and can prove ti to my insurance company, how about a discount?
 
How fucking dumb do you have to be to text or talk on a cell phone while driving???
(headset not included)

I mean, do you really need to legislate these things?
The fine shold be 200 or even 2000 dollars, not 20.

I do not want to be on the same road as some idiot who text messages while driving 60 MPH or even 10 MPH.:mad:
 
http://www.cellular-news.com/story/33703.php


http://www.cellular-news.com/story/33703.php


http://www.insurancejournal.com/news/east/2007/10/31/84666.htm


I suppose I don't need to tell you about the tour bus or the train that recently derailed while the operators were texting while operating.




So do you agree that if you are on drugs or over the legal limit that it's fine as long as the cop thinks you are driving fine?

None of those answered my questions. None of those even approached how big of a deal it is. Do you have any links that actually covers the realworld affect of texting and not just the aftermath of an accident, or some simulation somebody ran.

I am not suggesting That Drunk driving or Driving while High are good ideas. Infact I think overall they are bad ideas. But what matter is it to anyone including the police if they don't have probable cause to inspect, If I am driving within the parameters of the round, obeying all traffic signals, come to complete stops, and concede right of way, what matter is my personal state of mind. We start going after the high, the drunk, the distracted, what about the angry, or the depressed, or the frightened.
 
How fucking dumb do you have to be to text or talk on a cell phone while driving???
(headset not included)

I mean, do you really need to legislate these things?
The fine shold be 200 or even 2000 dollars, not 20.

I do not want to be on the same road as some idiot who text messages while driving 60 MPH or even 10 MPH.:mad:

QFT.

It's bad enough when these same drivers? change lanes without signaling or run a red light or a stop sign because they were texting rather than watching the road. I don't mean to offend anyone here but I have noticed this happen most frequently with WOMEN drivers that just can't keep their eyes on the road while driving. I mean come on, is it really THAT important to be texting someone on your cellphone while driving at 55 MPH on the FREEWAY !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Ah... The "Train Accident" law. And they guy wasn't even texting...
 
I'm glad it's getting banned for drivers. I know a guy who drives like crap normally, and I've seen him drive while texting. Refused to ever ride with him again.
 
Ah... The "Train Accident" law. And they guy wasn't even texting...

Actually he had JUST finished texting, so he probably missed the first warning lights

I'm not even sure if this covers locomotives, would that not have to be a FEDERAL thing? Interstate transport, yet not leaving the same "road"

The fine is PITIFUL, should be $100 MINIMUM, I know they are thinking of "the kids" who screw up and forget, but it is a HELL of a lot easier to get that kind of money now.

$20 is a DAMN PIZZA!
 
None of those answered my questions. None of those even approached how big of a deal it is. Do you have any links that actually covers the realworld affect of texting and not just the aftermath of an accident, or some simulation somebody ran.

I am not suggesting That Drunk driving or Driving while High are good ideas. Infact I think overall they are bad ideas. But what matter is it to anyone including the police if they don't have probable cause to inspect, If I am driving within the parameters of the round, obeying all traffic signals, come to complete stops, and concede right of way, what matter is my personal state of mind. We start going after the high, the drunk, the distracted, what about the angry, or the depressed, or the frightened.

It isn't your state of mind.
It is the pure and simple fact of doing two things at once that demand your attention, vision, hands and eyes.
Distracting you from operating a 2 ton deadly weapon.
It's plain common sense.
You can bring up any idiotic statistic you wish to try and argue this away, but a operating a cellular phone manually is not compatable with safe driving.
In fact, I say a kid walk directly into a lamp post while texting, knocked him cold....that's unconscious........fortunately he was the only casualty.
 
In fact, I say a kid walk directly into a lamp post while texting, knocked him cold....that's unconscious........fortunately he was the only casualty.

IIRC it was London who started padding all the street poles and lights for people who walk and text... they had too many complaints and injuries. I'm not sure if I have the city right.

lol
 
Well this should have been a part of the "hands-free" law that went into affect earlier this year. I actually know of people that were pulled over that first day and told the highway patrol that they weren't talking on the phone but texting AND GOT AWAY WITH IT!!! I heard about this and about fell over in shock. Frankly, I think texting is more dangerous than talking for most. But the officers were actually letting people go that were admitting they were texting while driving as it wasn't an actual verbal conversation. Crazy, just crazy.
 
Do we really need another law. We have one, its careless driving. If I am driving poorly pull me over. Some people drive poorly no matter what they are doing, and some have the ability to handle multiple things at the same time with no less care and attention then a "un-distracted driver". People will probably snap at me but the last thing we need is to have police officers pulling over texters to hit their quotas instead of taking the dangerous drivers off the road. We need to learn as a people that we need to police ourselves and worry about ourselves and stop having laws passed, just cause. Just because it makes it safer doesn't mean its a good idea. we need to stop making it easier and easier for us to be on the wrong side of the law and we need to stop giving away our rights (different thread).

good idea but i agree with weasel here. If they're driving like an idiot because your texting, pull em over. if not, let em be. I am guilty of texting while driving, but i dont do it often, and when I do, my main focus is on the road, I will take 5 minutes to write a three word text if I have to (although I usually don't :p)


and I know some will/do say "well what about that 1 time out of 100 that something happens." do you lock yourself in your basement to keep yourself safe all the time?

I just don't like having yet one more law that stops me from doing something I have been doing safely for years (haven't even had a close call when on the phone driving, knock on wood though ;))
 
man Cali is late to this party.

Last month Minnesota passed that into law. No texting while driving.

I saw good. Issue is how do they enforce it? UNless a cop sees you (look for the idiot not watching the road).......
 
Holding or supporting a phone on any part of your body while driving is already illegal here in the UK, as is touching one that isn't in an approved holder. Bluetooth and voice dialling is the way I manage, to be honest it's a lot easier than way anyway.
 
It isn't your state of mind.
It is the pure and simple fact of doing two things at once that demand your attention, vision, hands and eyes.
Distracting you from operating a 2 ton deadly weapon.
It's plain common sense.
You can bring up any idiotic statistic you wish to try and argue this away, but a operating a cellular phone manually is not compatable with safe driving.
In fact, I say a kid walk directly into a lamp post while texting, knocked him cold....that's unconscious........fortunately he was the only casualty.

I am not saying that texting while driving doesn't affect your attention at all. What I am saying that drivers who are capable of consuming all necessary information of the road and interpreting that can spare a moment here or there to press a button on their phone and enough of those spare moments they can eventually press the send button. These people can do that with out being being a danger to others. Find me a person who gets into an accident texting, and I will show you someone that was a bad driver to begin with or he wouldn't have been trying a task that he didn't have the skill to pull off. This doesn't just apply to texters either, what about as I brought up before, drinking a beverage, changing the radio, changing a cd, what about people that have to use the retarded wheel on their Ipods that are docked in their car?

You either have to get rid of it all or none. It doesn't make sense to screw one type of person over and then give a pass to another Just because you don't like the other one so much. You don't think you can text and drive good police yourself, and don't. Let the cops pull over the careless drivers on the roads (which can include some texters) instead of pulling over that guy who answered a text at a stop light.
 
These laws make me laugh because they are impossible to enforce, and frankly, reek of technophobia.

Unless you ban use of a cellphone outright, then theres no way to know if they were texting or using some other of the phone's functionality. Many of us use our phones for GPS, for example. Really unless they see you driving erratically, you're not gonna get pulled over. In Washington State, the cell phone ban is a secondary offense, i.e. you have to be speeding or doing something else and then they ding you with the cell phone ticket.

The trend is somewhat disturbing, though. I, for one, despise all these stupid nanny state laws enacted because they "sound like a good idea" not because they make any logical sense. The problem with cell phones is that unless you're a weirdo or a recluse, they are probably required for your work or your social life. Those of us with busy lives are almost always driving somewhere. Yet, people want to ban everything relating to cell phones.

Some people wish to ban talking on a cell phone (without headset) while driving, but if you use a handsfree, its fine. The problem with this is that studies have shown that it's not the act of talking on the phone that's distracting, it's the act of talking PERIOD. Should we also ban talking to your passengers? The whole "two hands on the wheel" argument is pretty weak as well. I know very few people who drive with both hands anyway, cellphone or not. If a tight corner is required, thats one thing, but one hand is sufficient for any other maneuver. Two hands on the wheel is a remnant of pre-power-steering days.

Some people wish to ban texting while driving. Great idea, since this is probably more of a distraction than regular cell phone conversations and is rarely used for business. (Though the trend of texting for businesses is increasing.) Unfortunately unless the person is lying dead in a ditch with a half-written text message on the phone in their hand, there's no way to show they were trying to send a text. If a cop decided to pull me over mid-text I'd just erase it, set my phone down and tell them I was accessing my voicemail. Just more half-assed nanny state laws that are unenforceable.
 
Unless you happen to be a touch texter, it is HIGHLY dangerous, FAR more than taking your eyes off the road to change the radio station.

WAAY back in 89' I was visiting my relatives in Australia and my uncle had his company car outfitted with a hands free cellphone (mike in the visor).

Nobody is banning Hands free because of the fact that it IS just like talking to a passenger and THAT would never pass ANYWHERE (radios were once considered when the studies came out but they were FAR to ingrained at that point)

Talking (phone or passenger) you just have to remember that DRIVING is job #1
 
This is a good thing. Even I recognize that I'm a frigging menace on the road when writing texts or emails while I'm driving.
 
I just read an article that your response time is 35% slower, triple that of when you are under the influence of drugs or alcohol.
 
This is a good thing. Even I recognize that I'm a frigging menace on the road when writing texts or emails while I'm driving.

The friggin menace are poor drivers. Not what they happen to bei doing at the time that consumed what little attention they had for the road. Take care of the bad driver not the useful toy.
 
Now ban smoking, eating, drinking anything, pressing buttons on your radio, and talking while driving. I've seen a guy leaning back on his motorcycle going 65 while texting. Is it smart? No, and if I see someone going slow and poking at their phone I honk at them and give them the finger. Bad drivers cause accidents, not texting. The people getting distracted by texting will just get distracted by something else if they aren't texting.
 
The friggin menace are poor drivers. Not what they happen to bei doing at the time that consumed what little attention they had for the road. Take care of the bad driver not the useful toy.

Oh, absolutely, but that said a good driver texting will turn into a bad one, no question.

And it will obviously make a bad driver even worse. :)
 
Great idea. I can't count the times I saw a driver not paying attention to the road while talking to texting.
 
How fucking dumb do you have to be to text or talk on a cell phone while driving???
(headset not included)
About as dumb as you have to be to believe that you can multitask and drive at the same time.
 
I am not saying that texting while driving doesn't affect your attention at all. What I am saying that drivers who are capable of consuming all necessary information of the road and interpreting that can spare a moment here or there to press a button on their phone and enough of those spare moments they can eventually press the send button. These people can do that with out being being a danger to others. Find me a person who gets into an accident texting, and I will show you someone that was a bad driver to begin with or he wouldn't have been trying a task that he didn't have the skill to pull off. This doesn't just apply to texters either, what about as I brought up before, drinking a beverage, changing the radio, changing a cd, what about people that have to use the retarded wheel on their Ipods that are docked in their car?

You either have to get rid of it all or none. It doesn't make sense to screw one type of person over and then give a pass to another Just because you don't like the other one so much. You don't think you can text and drive good police yourself, and don't. Let the cops pull over the careless drivers on the roads (which can include some texters) instead of pulling over that guy who answered a text at a stop light.

You ARE kidding right?
You are going to sit there and say you can text message on a little bitty text pad or cell phone while driving in freeway traffic at 7:30 AM on a Monday on a 6 lane freeway at 60 MPH. Get the fuck out.

I would not even venture anybody could text going 10 MPH on a 2 lane road at noon on Sunday without endangering everybody.

How many accidents and deaths are acceptable in your risk profile of this??? one, six, one hundred????

Face it, Americans and anybody else for that matter who thinks this is OK, are stupid and think nothing will happen to THEM, and the rules don't apply to THEM. So we DO have to legislate common sense. I see this same logic applied to sticking your finger in the electric socket.........does there need to be a law that tells you it could kill you????
How about child saftey seats????? We have a law about that......do we need it, no; but some idiots let their kids ride in the payload section of pickup trucks at 60 MPH......is that ok??? 9 out of 10 times no one gets hurt, so I guess it's fine, huh??

Driving an automobile is a privilege, not a god-given right. These new laws are down-right stupid when you think of them.............but tell that to the parents of the 6 girls who died in Rochester, NY at noon in broad daylight because their driver was texting at 50 MPH.

You obviously don't have children or a family, nor do you care about anybody but yourself. I can live without texting or talking on my cell phone for the 20 or 30 minutes I'm in the car to be as safe as I can, for me and everybody else on the road.
Please don't think this is a bad idea..........if one life is spared or changed because of this law it was a good idea. It's still stupid to need it, but it's more stupid to think people believe they can get away with texting while driving a car.
 
Good natured nanny law? Probably. Enforceable nanny law? Most likely not unless there was a blanket ban on any hand-held device used by the driver. Should these laws be enacted anyway even if they're difficult or impossible to enforce?

On a side note even hands-free phones can be a major distraction. If you got a call telling you that your mother just died, would you really be concentrating on the road?
 
I dislike having an additional law made for this. I always dislike it when our stupidity forces simple common sense to be legislated. But I can see easily why the insurance companies would back a law like this, every accident averted saves them money.
In OK we have just one that covers most of those "common sense while driving laws". They call it distracted driving. Applying makeup, hand dialing your cell, texting, turning around to yell at your kids in the back seat, watching TV, reading a paper, etc., etc., while driving can get you a ticket. Only rarely hear of it being enforced though.
 
I always dislike it when our stupidity forces simple common sense to be legislated.

The problem is that stupidity is everywhere and that common sense is not very common.

Not sure how effective or enforceable this law would be; I'm guessing that it would be used more often to fine someone after they cause an accident - too late to make a difference. Only after several such accidents make the headlines will people start getting a clue that they shouldn't text while driving. Maybe.

Just making it a law won't prevent it; might not deter it significantly either. You'll still see many people driving around with a cell phone to their ear in New York.
 
Back
Top