California Bans Texting While Driving

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I know some people might be upset over the ban on texting while driving law but, for the most part, it is a good idea to keep drivers attention on the road. Do you think it is a good law? Makes you wonder why only 7 states have banned texting while driving, doesn’t it?

California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger has signed a law making it illegal to read or send text messages while driving in California. The bill imposes a 20 dollar fine for a first offence and 50 dollars for repeat offenders using any electronic devices to read or send messages, starting next year.
 
I admit I have been guilty of it before, but it really is a dumb and irresponsible thing to do. I think it's a good idea.
 
I think it's a great idea.. but how will they enforce it?

2im9ok2.jpg
 
Great great concept. Now they should ban cellphones completley on the road and any other non-car related activity (makeup, reading paper, etc).
 
The only other addition to the law that I could think of is imposing temporary license revokation after a certain number of offenses.

Other than the above it's a very welcome piece of news. I for one am tired of seeing people playing with their phones and not paying attention to the road.
 
Great great concept. Now they should ban cellphones completley on the road and any other non-car related activity (makeup, reading paper, etc).
What about manually gauging my tire pressure whilst driving? :D
 
Like driving while on the phone, it will only continue.
 
I think it's a great idea.. but how will they enforce it?

2im9ok2.jpg

By looking at your phone records at the exact time of any accident.
If they determine you were the cause you may get jailed!
Enough of a deterrent?
 
How do you suppose they'll enforce this? I mean seriously, how do they know if you are texting or flipping through your address book to call someone?
 
By looking at your phone records at the exact time of any accident.
If they determine you were the cause you may get jailed!
Enough of a deterrent?

No you just delete your messages...they can try to get your records from the cell phone company but they need subpoena or warrants I think.
 
The only other addition to the law that I could think of is imposing temporary license revokation after a certain number of offenses.

Other than the above it's a very welcome piece of news. I for one am tired of seeing people playing with their phones and not paying attention to the road.

I would vote a three strikes, you're out rule. Same goes for talking on the phone while driving.
 
How do you suppose they'll enforce this? I mean seriously, how do they know if you are texting or flipping through your address book to call someone?

If you're texting, you'll be in a car wrapped around a tree.
If you're looking up and number, you'll just be flipped over in a ditch.

If you're smart, you'd pull over first before playing with the phone.
 
No you just delete your messages...they can try to get your records from the cell phone company but they need subpoena or warrants I think.

Super easy to get if you just detrailed a train or you just killed yourself in the accident.
 
If you're texting, you'll be in a car wrapped around a tree.
If you're looking up and number, you'll just be flipped over in a ditch.

If you're smart, you'd pull over first before playing with the phone.

If you're smart, you'd not use the stupid phone at all while operating a vehicle.

Though I admit to being guilty of this, I don't do it often. Maybe once a week if that and my phone conversations last less than 30 seconds.
 
Do we really need another law. We have one, its careless driving. If I am driving poorly pull me over. Some people drive poorly no matter what they are doing, and some have the ability to handle multiple things at the same time with no less care and attention then a "un-distracted driver". People will probably snap at me but the last thing we need is to have police officers pulling over texters to hit their quotas instead of taking the dangerous drivers off the road. We need to learn as a people that we need to police ourselves and worry about ourselves and stop having laws passed, just cause. Just because it makes it safer doesn't mean its a good idea. we need to stop making it easier and easier for us to be on the wrong side of the law and we need to stop giving away our rights (different thread).
 
Are you kidding me? these laws arent already in place?? omg thats just illogical.. weve had those laws for a number of years now....

i've kinda caused a traffic accident texting.. and i wasnt even driving.. i was walking through the cbd of perth not looking where i was going a car needed to turn left into a driveway but i wasnt paying attention.. normally i'd do that quick 2-step jog to get past.. by the time i looked up. a bus hit him from behind... uh yeah.. and people actually behind a wheel texting.. thats just insane.. :confused::eek:
 
Do we really need another law. We have one, its careless driving. If I am driving poorly pull me over. Some people drive poorly no matter what they are doing, and some have the ability to handle multiple things at the same time with no less care and attention then a "un-distracted driver". People will probably snap at me but the last thing we need is to have police officers pulling over texters to hit their quotas instead of taking the dangerous drivers off the road. We need to learn as a people that we need to police ourselves and worry about ourselves and stop having laws passed, just cause. Just because it makes it safer doesn't mean its a good idea. we need to stop making it easier and easier for us to be on the wrong side of the law and we need to stop giving away our rights (different thread).

qft I guess there are only 2 of us in here that think this is a useless law. The $20 fee is hardly going to make someone stop, but it will make the state some extra $$.
 
Do we really need another law. We have one, its careless driving. If I am driving poorly pull me over. Some people drive poorly no matter what they are doing, and some have the ability to handle multiple things at the same time with no less care and attention then a "un-distracted driver". People will probably snap at me but the last thing we need is to have police officers pulling over texters to hit their quotas instead of taking the dangerous drivers off the road. We need to learn as a people that we need to police ourselves and worry about ourselves and stop having laws passed, just cause. Just because it makes it safer doesn't mean its a good idea. we need to stop making it easier and easier for us to be on the wrong side of the law and we need to stop giving away our rights (different thread).

I've been saying this for a long time.
 
Do we really need another law. We have one, its careless driving. If I am driving poorly pull me over. Some people drive poorly no matter what they are doing, and some have the ability to handle multiple things at the same time with no less care and attention then a "un-distracted driver". People will probably snap at me but the last thing we need is to have police officers pulling over texters to hit their quotas instead of taking the dangerous drivers off the road. We need to learn as a people that we need to police ourselves and worry about ourselves and stop having laws passed, just cause. Just because it makes it safer doesn't mean its a good idea. we need to stop making it easier and easier for us to be on the wrong side of the law and we need to stop giving away our rights (different thread).

I have yet to see a drive who can be fully capable of driving on the road and avoiding hazzards while keeping a text conversation going.

You can be good and great at driving and texting, it just takes one screw up and you kill an innocent person. If you really have to text so bad while in transit, then carpool or take the bus.

It's stupid to argue about multitasking while driving, it's been proven that accidents are increased dramatically.


With this logic of careless driving, I should be able to drink and drive, but only when I am driving poorly should I be pulled over....am i right?
 
It's sad we have to regulate people and protect them from their own stupidity. Why does Cali always have to be the leader on taking actions on clowns? I think talking on the cell phone while driving should also be illegal. If it's an emergency, pull off the side of to a side road, shoulder, etc. If it's an extreme case as in "I need to talk on the cell phone and drive - my wife is pregnant", That's a different then that average user who cannot shut their trap for ten whole minutes and drive;But it's a marginal case anyways...
 
No you just delete your messages...they can try to get your records from the cell phone company but they need subpoena or warrants I think.

Here in the UK, its easy for the police to get, I presume the same will apply.
 
It's sad we have to regulate people and protect them from their own stupidity. Why does Cali always have to be the leader on taking actions on clowns? I think talking on the cell phone while driving should also be illegal. If it's an emergency, pull off the side of to a side road, shoulder, etc. If it's an extreme case as in "I need to talk on the cell phone and drive - my wife is pregnant", That's a different then that average user who cannot shut their trap for ten whole minutes and drive;But it's a marginal case anyways...

You are not protecting people from themselves, you are protecting other people from stupid people such as you and me. While we may be able to do limited multi tasking, others can't. While we may be able to have a drink or two and still use good judgment, others can't. It's always the few who ruins it for the rest.

And this was triggered by that train accident with the captain kicking it back and texting instead of monitoring his rails... because of him, a ton of people had to die.
 
I too am guilty of occasionally talking on the phone while driving, however those conversations have always been less then 30 seconds. I agree with the above posts by saying another law isn't what is needed, and will most likely have no affect. Texting while driving is simply a bad habit that needs to be broken. I say we beef up the funding for the common sense campaign! Common sense for President in 09!!!! :D
 
is it just me, or does anyone else think its far more dangerous to text while driving compared to talking while driving???
 
is it just me, or does anyone else think its far more dangerous to text while driving compared to talking while driving???

Texting has been rated more dangerous and fatal than driving drunk or under the influence of drugs combined.
 
Do we really need another law. We have one, its careless driving. If I am driving poorly pull me over. Some people drive poorly no matter what they are doing, and some have the ability to handle multiple things at the same time with no less care and attention then a "un-distracted driver". People will probably snap at me but the last thing we need is to have police officers pulling over texters to hit their quotas instead of taking the dangerous drivers off the road. We need to learn as a people that we need to police ourselves and worry about ourselves and stop having laws passed, just cause. Just because it makes it safer doesn't mean its a good idea. we need to stop making it easier and easier for us to be on the wrong side of the law and we need to stop giving away our rights (different thread).

"Police ourselves..."??? :rolleyes: You're kidding, right? Mind you I wholeheartedly agree that we don't need more misguided laws on the books. But at the same time, people do really stupid things. Things which endanger themselves and those around them. And we expect our government to try to protect us from those people.

Personally, I question how enforceable this law will be. But I'm of the opinion that $20 and $50 fines are far too lenient. If you really want to discourage this practice, the penalties need to be at least 10X higher. Otherwise it's nothing more than a slap on the hand, and it provides no motivation for police officers to try and catch violators.
 
"Police ourselves..."??? :rolleyes: You're kidding, right? Mind you I wholeheartedly agree that we don't need more misguided laws on the books. But at the same time, people do really stupid things. Things which endanger themselves and those around them. And we expect our government to try to protect us from those people.

Personally, I question how enforceable this law will be. But I'm of the opinion that $20 and $50 fines are far too lenient. If you really want to discourage this practice, the penalties need to be at least 10X higher. Otherwise it's nothing more than a slap on the hand, and it provides no motivation for police officers to try and catch violators.

Right on.

Definitely not enough to be a deterrent of any kind.
 
I have yet to see a drive who can be fully capable of driving on the road and avoiding hazzards .

You can be good and great at driving, it just takes one screw up and you kill an innocent person. If you really have todrive so bad, then take the bus.

It's stupid to argue about driving, it's been proven that accidents are increased dramatically.

Fixed for you. Is it really texting you have a problem with or poor drivers. Does it really matter if texting is the catalyst for being a poor driver in one instance or another. Does the Driver who gets into an accident texting any different then the driver who gets into an accident with out an instigator. Are we going to make laws for all forms of instigators, like changing the radio, changing a cd, grabbing your pop from the cup holder (because you could spill it), Smoking a cigarette? Why not have a law called distracted driving or better yet have a law that covers not only distracted driving but covers just plain bad drivers. I would call it something like careless or reckless driving.

With this logic of careless driving, I should be able to drink and drive, but only when I am driving poorly should I be pulled over....am i right?

Actually you are allowed to drink and drive. Look it up, its not illegal. Personally my problem is with everyone on the road who can't drive with in the normal guideline. Does it really matter in accident where someone dies and a person is clearly at fault whether the driver was, drunk, texting, eating, or just plain retarded.

And as for being pulled over. I don't think its right to pull anyone over without plausible cause. Should the police be able to search your house just because you might have unregistered guns? Should the police be allowed to give you a piss test anytime they want to make sure you aren't using illegal narcotics? Should the police be allowed to monitor your phone lines to make sure you not conspiring? Should the they be able to grab your computer anytime to scan it because you might have child porn on it, or better yet MP3's? But you think its right for police to randomly pull people over and have them do a drunk test, just because it makes you feel a little safer?
 
I have yet to see a drive who can be fully capable of driving on the road and avoiding hazzards while keeping a text conversation going.

You can be good and great at driving and texting, it just takes one screw up and you kill an innocent person. If you really have to text so bad while in transit, then carpool or take the bus.

It's stupid to argue about multitasking while driving, it's been proven that accidents are increased dramatically.


With this logic of careless driving, I should be able to drink and drive, but only when I am driving poorly should I be pulled over....am i right?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=klteYv1Uv9A
 
In other news, I just got arrested for driving with an expired license. Not revoked, not suspended, I just forgot to renew it because I moved and didn't get the notice. $200 bail, $500 tow/impound, $80 court costs.


Now if the state thought I was fit to drive at some point, wtf does it matter if it expired,?
 
Texting while driving is so stupid! Thank goodness they haven't banned e-mailing while driving.

:D
 
"Police ourselves..."??? :rolleyes: You're kidding, right? Mind you I wholeheartedly agree that we don't need more misguided laws on the books. But at the same time, people do really stupid things. Things which endanger themselves and those around them. And we expect our government to try to protect us from those people.

Personally, I question how enforceable this law will be. But I'm of the opinion that $20 and $50 fines are far too lenient. If you really want to discourage this practice, the penalties need to be at least 10X higher. Otherwise it's nothing more than a slap on the hand, and it provides no motivation for police officers to try and catch violators.

What the hell are you talking about. The government is not our parent. It wasn't even set up to be our friend. It was made to bring order, and help in communication, trade. It was not and should not have gotten to the point where its watching our every step. Texting while driving doesn't imply that there is going to be an accident. This isn't minority report, that had I not gotten a ticket, I would have caused an accident. Why should doing one thing that's legal while doing another thing that's legal be illegal. People do stupid crap all of the time are we going to create a law that bans just being stupid. Keep in mind that history will show (and has shown) the people who think this is a good idea are the ones that would be guilty of that crime.
 
Fixed for you. Is it really texting you have a problem with or poor drivers.

Both, because you can't be a good driver and text at the same time. A good driver would be one who pulls over or at least waits till he/she gets out of the car.

Actually you are allowed to drink and drive. Look it up, its not illegal.

Try drinking an open beer while you are driving like as you can with a pop.

Personally my problem is with everyone on the road who can't drive with in the normal guideline.

There ya go. Like people who are texting instead of driving.

Does it really matter in accident where someone dies and a person is clearly at fault whether the driver was, drunk, texting, eating, or just plain retarded.
:eek::eek:
Yes it does.

And as for being pulled over. I don't think its right to pull anyone over without plausible cause. Should the police be able to search your house just because you might have unregistered guns? Should the police be allowed to give you a piss test anytime they want to make sure you aren't using illegal narcotics? Should the police be allowed to monitor your phone lines to make sure you not conspiring? Should the they be able to grab your computer anytime to scan it because you might have child porn on it, or better yet MP3's? But you think its right for police to randomly pull people over and have them do a drunk test, just because it makes you feel a little safer?

Now you are going way off topic and are just straw maning.
 
"Police ourselves..."??? :rolleyes: You're kidding, right? Mind you I wholeheartedly agree that we don't need more misguided laws on the books. But at the same time, people do really stupid things. Things which endanger themselves and those around them. And we expect our government to try to protect us from those people.

I agree to an extent. Stupid behavior that can get others killed is everyone's problem. As such I don't have a problem with banning texting while driving; assuming it works of course.

On the other hand, stupid behavior that harms only one's self (no one else) shouldn't be outlawed; heck it should be encouraged. What's a greater deterrent: a measly fine or the threat of death? If you decide to be a moron and do it anyway then that's your problem.
 
What the hell are you talking about. The government is not our parent. It wasn't even set up to be our friend. It was made to bring order, and help in communication, trade. It was not and should not have gotten to the point where its watching our every step. Texting while driving doesn't imply that there is going to be an accident. This isn't minority report, that had I not gotten a ticket, I would have caused an accident. Why should doing one thing that's legal while doing another thing that's legal be illegal. People do stupid crap all of the time are we going to create a law that bans just being stupid. Keep in mind that history will show (and has shown) the people who think this is a good idea are the ones that would be guilty of that crime.

Ummm. Have you ever seen the statistics of texting and driving?

Do you support drivers who are driving over the legal limit? What about drug users using while driving? What about both? It is said that texting is more dangerous than both of those things. So hell, if you can text, I can drive drunk.

Oh and please stop with the nonsense that "if you oppose it then you must be guilty of it", that is sheer strawman tactics right there. For the record, I don't drink, never have and never will, for the other record, I don't even have a text plan on my phone becaue I think it's stupid when you can just call a person, on the other record, I don't talk when I drive, I have a carphone if I really needed to use it that badly (which I don't even use, so there was no point for me paying out the ass for that feature anyways). Oh yeah, and to top it off, I carry two cellphones and a pager, so if you think I'm an anti phone nut or something, think again. I expect the same respect I give in return on the roads.
 
I agree to an extent. Stupid behavior that can get others killed is everyone's problem. As such I don't have a problem with banning texting while driving; assuming it works of course.

On the other hand, stupid behavior that harms only one's self (no one else) shouldn't be outlawed; heck it should be encouraged. What's a greater deterrent: a measly fine or the threat of death? If you decide to be a moron and do it anyway then that's your problem.

Agreed with that. If it doesn't hurt anyone else, there is no issue. So if you want to drive without your seatbelt on, and alone, that's your own business. The problem where I do have a problem is when it becomes other peoples problem and other people have to pay for the stupidity.

I'm a big believer in Darwinism so if someone wants to off themselves, go right ahead. :p
 
Ummm. Have you ever seen the statistics of texting and driving?

Do you support drivers who are driving over the legal limit? What about drug users using while driving? What about both? It is said that texting is more dangerous than both of those things. So hell, if you can text, I can drive drunk.

Oh and please stop with the nonsense that "if you oppose it then you must be guilty of it", that is sheer strawman tactics right there. For the record, I don't drink, never have and never will, for the other record, I don't even have a text plan on my phone becaue I think it's stupid when you can just call a person, on the other record, I don't talk when I drive, I have a carphone if I really needed to use it that badly (which I don't even use, so there was no point for me paying out the ass for that feature anyways). Oh yeah, and to top it off, I carry two cellphones and a pager, so if you think I'm an anti phone nut or something, think again. I expect the same respect I give in return on the roads.

No I don't think your your anti cell phone, and from the whole black box forum is well it is apparent that you among others would rather see this great nation turn into some perfect mixture of a fascist and socialist country. Where everyone has the same money no one is poor, and the government has made it so bad thing don't happen my making anything that the slightest amount of affecting anybody in a bad way illegal. People need to stop getting involved in in what other people are doing and stop policing your neighbor just because of some story you heard on the news.
 
Here is an idea to completely fix all un-needed texting/talking on the cell phone while driving.

Make EVERY vehicle have a device that blocks any and all cell phone signals inside the car while the car is moving.

If there is an emergency, you can hit an Emergency Button on the phone which will automatically dial 911 on a special signal that isn't blocked by the vehicle.

Or you could just have cell phones have a speed detector on them that makes them not work past say 10mph unless you hit an Emergency Button that dials 911.

That is probably the easiest solution since the GPS sattelites are already in place.
 
Back
Top