buy external HD or build external HD?

eddie500

Gawd
Joined
Jan 23, 2003
Messages
1,009
What is a better option for a SATA external, buy a premade package, or buy the harddrive and external enclosure separately?

I want to get large HD like 1+ terabyte
 
I always build mine. Sometimes it's cheaper, sometimes not. However, you will always have a longer warranty on the drive if you buy it separate from the enclosure.
 
There are advantages to building your own, even though it might cost a bit more with the pricing of external hard disk drives being equal to or even sometimes less than bare OEM or retail drives.

First, you get your choice of disk, specific brand, make, and model including the warranty that is carried with that particular brand.

Second, you get the choose particularly which external casing you wish to get, if aesthetics or functionality, or input ports are important to you (eSATA, USB, Firewire, etc).

Thirdly, and possibly the most important, is that the disk drive is covered separately by a separate warranty, not as the external unit itself, so it makes swapping the disk out for whatever reason possible without voiding your warranty, which almost every retail external hard drive forbids you to do.

That, and retail external hard drive cases are generally inferior to third-party external hard drive cases, take your pick. :)
 
This is kinda off topic here, but if you have an external SATA hard drive, can you plug the drive in and off while the computer is running, just like you would with a USB external drive?
 
This is kinda off topic here, but if you have an external SATA hard drive, can you plug the drive in and off while the computer is running, just like you would with a USB external drive?
On modern systems, yes. Hot plug/swap is part of the AHCI specification. Activate AHCI mode in your system's BIOS if you have not done so already, and you're good to go.
 
Does activating AHCI if it has not ever been on ever cause any stability issues?
 
[LYL]Homer;1034265315 said:
Does activating AHCI if it has not ever been on ever cause any stability issues?
It'll either boot successfully, or it'll blue-screen. If it blue-screen's then you just reboot, go into bios and disable AHCI so you can troubleshoot. It may require a simple registry hack, or an AHCI driver install/re-install.

Another vote for building your own, especially if you can scoop up a drive with a 5 year warranty.
 
It'll either boot successfully, or it'll blue-screen. If it blue-screen's then you just reboot, go into bios and disable AHCI so you can troubleshoot. It may require a simple registry hack, or an AHCI driver install/re-install.

Another vote for building your own, especially if you can scoop up a drive with a 5 year warranty.
Most likely STOP error in that scenario is STOP 0x0000007B. Vista has built in support for AHCI, so a Vista install should have an AHCI driver to plug in without needing the user to install one. This is not the case with XP. Just another reason why I have not looked back on Windows XP.
 
Back
Top