Burned by PNY, twice over

Tanis143

Gawd
Joined
Aug 18, 2001
Messages
606
Ok, I’m posting here to let people know about this. To fully appreciate why I feel I've been burned, I'll have to explain the whole thing.

Rewind to early 2003. I was happily fraggin on CS one night when *poof* computer shutdown. Tried to reboot, no go. So, after breaking my system apart I find out my vid card is toast. No problem I though. I had bought a PNY retail Gforce4 Ti4200 from Best Buy, and like all good hardware geeks I kept the box and all paperwork just in case this happened. Well, after finally finding PNY's phone number *thank you google* I spend a full hour going through their endless phone support til I get a live human. After I get my RMA, I include my original receipt *stupid me, you’ll find out later* and all else that came with the card. Well, I had a delivery confirmation on the package to make sure it got there, which it did 5 days later. Fast forward 3 months. Yes, 3 months. After 3 calls to PNY, and as many guarantees that it would arrive 2 weeks later, it finally did. Lo and behold, after sending them a retail, Ti4200 with 128 meg ram, I received an OEM, with only 64meg ram! WTF?? So I call them up and speak with 2 supervisors and basically was told, “Sorry, that’s what you get”. Fine I said, no more PNY and I tell everyone I know to avoid them like the plague. Now, fast forward to about 2 weeks ago. My son is using my replacement Ti4200 in his system. All of the sudden his computer starts to reboot with every application he tries to open. Reload windows, same thing. Put a new hard drive in, windows loads fine, everything starts to work until I load the vid card drivers. Same thing all over again. So I go to pull the card out and put it in my system, and this is what I found:

badcaps.jpg


Yep, bad capacitors. So, being strapped for cash, I decide to hunt around and try to find some replacement capacitors. Well, I will be honest and say I do not know a whole lot about electrical engineering. So I took the card to a local electronics repair shop and had the guy look at it so he could tell me exactly what caps I need. What do I find out? PNY designed this card to fail. Why do I say that? Well, the guy tells me that a good capacitor engineer will put a cap in a system at no less than twice the voltage of the circuit. Well, this vid card runs at 5v on the main circuit and these caps were only 6.3 v. Why is that you might ask? Well, after so many years of turning the pc on, surges happening naturally, heat building up, etc, the caps will start to fail. And this is what happened to me. Now, roughly 3 years after I purchased this card I’m stuck with it. I feel I like bought a top of the line car only to have it replaced with the baseline model that had an engine that was designed to get stress cracks in the block after 50,000 miles. So, to one and all, avoid PNY!
 
Damn, I guess everyone who has PNY card, it dies after a while. My friends PNY GeForce 4 Ti4200 died too. Don't know what was the reason though. I stay away from PNY and tell everyone else to stay away.
 
Yeah I bought a PNY Geforce Ti 4200 a couple years ago and it didn't even work out of the box. :( I have a BFG 6800 GT OC now and it rocks, can't go wrong with BFG.
 
This needs to be brought to the attention of major tech news sources I think. That's just not cool. I've heard of planned obsolescence, but this is just ridiculous!
 
Yeah, I have NEVER liked PNY. Horrible company. I love BFG, my 6800gt is a sweetheart, and their customer support treat me like I'm their soulmate o_O
 
Trying to find links, but a lot of Ti4200s had bad caps- unlike Abit, these were never covered with or without warranties. This is not specific to PNY. (Lots of links for Gainward, I thought I heard that it was nVidia's own fault though- could be wrong.)
I had a PNY Ti4400 that died, they replaced it with a 256MB FX5600- meh. Now I'm happily running a PNY 6800 unlocked, but I'll probably still end up with a BFG next time around.

For some apps, the 64MB Ti was actually faster. While it had less RAM, the clockspeeds were slightly higher. In today's games, however, the extra RAM would definitely be more useful.
 
All I can say is I'll never touch PNY with a ten foot pole after this. I can not even request an RMA for this card because my original reciept was shipped with the retail card I RMA'd. That was my fault, I know that. However, finding out that the cap's they put on the card were not up to standard was highly infuriating. Nothing like getting a product that is designed to fail so you have to purchase a new card. Well, it worked, I'll have to purchase a new vid card for my son, but I'll be damned if its going to be another PNY.
 
I had a PNY Verto Ti 4200 64MB version I bought in 2002. It died in 2004 and I called PNY. They shipped me a refurbished replacement that is working fine to this day. PNY was good to me, but hearing these stories, I worry about buying another PNY video card.
 
Yeah. PNY is teh suck unfortunately. :( Though like the others above said, the one model of the Gainward's were really frickin bad also (not sure I'm remembering what model it was....but IIRC it was a Geforce 4 4200 128 mb. I remember the old pink screen of death. :eek: Damn shame since the Ti 200 model from Gainward was excellent. I remember it overclocked far and above a Ti 500.
 
ShuttleLuv said:
Yeah. PNY is teh suck unfortunately. :( Though like the others above said, the one model of the Gainward's were really frickin bad also (not sure I'm remembering what model it was....but IIRC it was a Geforce 4 4200 128 mb. I remember the old pink screen of death. :eek: Damn shame since the Ti 200 model from Gainward was excellent. I remember it overclocked far and above a Ti 500.

The gainward 4200 had problems with the memory not the caps,i had one fail and they replaced it no questions very fast.
 
I had a Palit Ti 4200 64MB that died with bulging capacitors a while ago. From what I heard it was a pretty common problem with those cards. Have Creative one in one computer atm (with better capacitors) and so far it's doing ok.
 
6.3v is fine for a 5v circuit. When's the last time your 5v rail hit 6.3v?

The problem was that it was a crappy capacitor that was bound to bubble, just like the ones in tons of motherboards.
 
I think the computer industry was a different one several years ago and things have changed. I didn't know these stories when I bought a PNY 6800GT in February. It was $30 cheaper than any other card I could find and it was very well made. True to what you are saying, the circuitry on it was only designed for its specs: I can't overvolt it. But no matter, I was still able to hit 440/1190 with it overclocking, which is pretty good. I guess all companies have their lemons now and then :confused:
 
I dont think Ive heard of anyone that DID NOT have problems with PNY at the Geforce 4 era, a buddy of mine sent his PNY Ti4200 back lots of times, loved the Lifetime Warranty lol.

Are these stories happening still with Geforce 6 series ? I want to buy a PNY 6800 real bad.
 
it seems most people have teriffic luck with the 6800s.

Mine goes much faster than the specifications, and it runs beautifully :) Best upgrade i ever made :)
 
I've heard of people having problems with their PNY 4200's too, but I don't know anyone personally. That's a shitty thing to happen though =/
 
i also had a ti4200 64mb that just died one day i was installing cod when it went wasnt ewven playing a game or anything i to will never buy another pny card unless it is massivly cheap then i can sell it onm ebay and get a bfg of xfx
 
I find PNY customer server lacking, and the video cards dont seem to last. needless to say I do not buy PNY anymore...
 
Side NotE:

What is really sad is that the card was probably designed right until some CEO with no brains said what are you doing putting a 10V cap in a 5 volt circuit...put in a 5 volt cap. The engineer probably spent a week arguing with the CEO (being on the edge of being fired) and finally got them to support a 6.3V cap.

The company I work for has hard and fast rules on derating parts. We derate all capacitors by 40% right off the top. So at a minimum we would have a 8.4V cap. We also like to be paranoid (aerospace) so it would be a 10V capacitor min.

However...I don't think that is why your board died. Looking at your pictures...I don't think it is from overvoltage. That damage looks like excessive ripple current. Most PSU are shitty as all hell and under high load they tend to start going pretty bad with the ripple (usually high frequency). It doesn't affect circuit performance too much but it tends to burn out capacitors like mad. Ripple current is the #1 thing we tend to worry about when sizing capacitors in power circuits (much more than voltage rating).

-tReP
 
I had a PNY Geforce 4 Ti4600 (back when it owned) that died on me for no reason whatsoever, but, however they DID give me a replacement card because it was still under warranty. My mom still has her Geforce 3 Ti500 (for officework on an old machine) from PNY and it hasnt had one problem, so im not sure why some peoples cards f up and others do not. I now have a leadtek 6800 gt, but that does sound wierd.
 
hehe im still using my quadro 4 xgl 750(geforce 4200 with different drivers) i bought on ebay, it is a pny and has no problems.
 
my pny geforece 4 mx 440 64 mb works perfectly fine, even now when its overclocked, mem and core speed, by like 100 mhz. no problems for me.

i want a new card. playing half life 2 with it sucks!
 
I got 2 x PNY Ti4400 defective in a row, so no more PNY for me :(

oldmx
 
2, yes, count em' 2 PNY 6800 GTs that failed in 1-2 months! NOT OC'd!

I'm on my 3rd now and this one has lasted since Feb./March. However, I'm starting to have the same issues I had before with the other 2. :mad:

Thank God I bought the 7800 GTX from BFG.

PNY can suck it long.
 
I have a PNY 6800GT which is an OC champ and runs great... I think any card / board with a lot of juice pumping into it is fair game for blowing a cap eventually... it's just dumb luck... some caps live longer than others... and if there are power surges, that can really cause them to live shorter lives...
 
Caps are one of those few parts that really should be double rated for what they are used for, even if the voltage remains basically constant.

But dont Vid Card manufactuers base their cards on reference design? So its really Nvidias fault.

However, I will take note of their poor customer service. Sending back a crappier card...I dont think so. send the same or better if you want a repeat customer.
 
i remember that 2 of my friends who owned pny 6800 GT and pny 5200 fx. both sold em in few weeks later after they bought it. they told me that both cards had a heat issue and sux in coolin, too. when they were playin a game, the texture started to look ugly and showin some artifacts.

I strongly advise all of u not to use pny card period.
 
Matrix187 said:
I hope not... I get a power surge like every week.

well - your psu will buffer that from your pc boards... I was talking more about stable power from yoru psu... if your psu has bad voltage regulation, you might be more prone to blow a cap here or there... but only after a long time of this... unless it spikes hard... which will likely cause other issues also.
 
I'm amazed by the number of individuals posting in this thread that have had actual first hand experience with this brand of card failing. This is incredible for so many users to come forth already in such a small environment. I'd say if a laywer had heard about this sooner, he might have suggested a class action, and serious complaints to the FCC.
 
that does seem like the catch phrase of the 2000's... "class action suit" ;)
 
Yeah, PNY is pretty much fine now... their cards are of a much better quality and they rid of their "lifetime warranty" which basically meant a warranty until we stop making the card. My PNY 6800GT runs like a champ...
 
Shorty said:
Yeah, PNY is pretty much fine now... their cards are of a much better quality and they rid of their "lifetime warranty" which basically meant a warranty until we stop making the card. My PNY 6800GT runs like a champ...


Pretty much fine now?

Not in my eyes. My 6800GTs (notce the plural form) failed this year. LOL
 
a36steel said:
Yeah I bought a PNY Geforce Ti 4200 a couple years ago and it didn't even work out of the box. :( I have a BFG 6800 GT OC now and it rocks, can't go wrong with BFG.

Unless your poor.
 
I have two PNY Ti4200's that are working just fine.
One in a P3 850 and the other in a Tualatin 1.2ghz.
Never had a problem with either of them.
When I upgrade, the card replaced goes to the next box.
I only bought the second one because it was $79.95 at BestBuy [remember that crazy shit] and it was 128mb 8x agp and clocked higher[250/513] than the first one.
Maybe they suck now I don't know.
 
ray4389 said:
Unless your poor.


If you are poor then you shouldn't be upgrading your computer. You should be saving your money so you are not poor forever. ;)
 
Back
Top