Building A New C2D Machine (Advice?)

Carlosinfl

Loves the juice
Joined
Sep 25, 2002
Messages
6,633
Guys - I posted in here since I just want a general idea of what you guys think of this system. I am looking to get a new machine to replace a SMP box that is just melting the polar ice caps from my room.

Anyways - Before I post the hardware - please note I WILL NOT be over clocking this machine or using SLI GPU's. It's just something to play Supreme Commander and C&C3.

Let me know what you guys think can be changed or if I am just totally off.

- Intel Core 2 Duo e6600 = $308 w/ Supreme Commander from Newegg.com

- eVGA 8800 GTS = $294.99

- Mushkin Extreme Performance DDR2 RAM 2GB = $254.99

- Asus Motherboard P965 = $179.99

What do you guys think?
 
If you're not going to overclock, then why do you need that expensive RAM for? You really don't need

You'll still get pretty good performance from this pair of RAM:

G.SKILL F2-6400CL5D-2GBNQ 2GB (2 x 1GB) DDR2 800 RAM - $125

Oh and Intel is cutting prices on its CPUs on April 22nd. So if I were you, wait till the 22nd before you buy that E6600. By then it will $224. Thats a savings of $84!

Oh and what kind of power supply do you have? With the kind of system you're building, you're gonna need a good power supply.
 
Thanks for the RAM suggestion. It was a combo deal with the motherboard so I just went with it but the RAM you suggested looks good too. I just want RAM that is great performance for gaming but not to the fact that I have to overclock it.
 
No prob but you haven't answered one of my questions yet: what power supply do you have?

Oh and what's your budget?
 
I would suggest getting another motherboard. P965 is lacking in PATA support. 650i board is better buy for you.
 
I would suggest getting another motherboard. P965 is lacking in PATA support. 650i board is better buy for you.

If you're building an entirely new system, I'd suggest dumping all IDE devices in some way or another. If you want, salvage the optical drives. The HDDs you can put into external enclosures and use as backups. You could also get a PCI IDE Controller card instead, and make use of those PCI slots, lol.

If you're not overclocking, theres no need for any ram faster than DDR2-533, nor such a nice motherboard. If you're not overclocking, just go for the P5B instead of the deluxe. However, I urge you to overclock, even just a little :p These chips have so much headroom that they're STABLE while highly overclocked! Well, at least keep it as an option later down the road. And if you'd like to do so, go with the P5B-E instead, or the GA-965P-DS3, along with the 2GBNQ ram that Danny suggested.
 
If you're building an entirely new system, I'd suggest dumping all IDE devices in some way or another.

If you're not overclocking, theres no need for any ram faster than DDR2-533, nor such a nice motherboard. If you're not overclocking, just go for the P5B instead of the deluxe. However, I urge you to overclock, even just a little :p

LOL ditch those Pata devices! :p

Yeah, if you dont OC just get DDR2-533 MHz RAM.
266 mhz is C2D's native FSB setting anyway.

But like eniginurd, I must say, you SHOULD overclock a Conroe! :p

Regardless, good luck with your build. it will definitely be fast.
 
I'd HIGHLY encourage you enter the world of overclocking, even if it's just a minor overclock. HIGHLY recommend it. No harm done. I'd even help you all along the way, with as conservative or settings as you wish. You can feel free to AIM me or PM me.

Also, I'd suggest you wait for the price cuts as well, or go for the e6420 now off shopblt since it's already very well priced, even preprice cuts. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if the e6420 came out at that price when it did launch.
 
Never overclocked a machine before perhaps I would not know where to start or what components to use.

My power supply is a nice 650W Antec.

I have 2 S-ATA optical drives and 4 S-ATA dard drives so I don't think P-ATA will be used.
 
My suggestion would be:

$308 (free ship) - Intel Core 2 Duo E6600 (w/ OEM Supreme Commander)
$169 (free ship) - G.Skill 2x 1GB DDR2 800 (same chip as your muskin micron D9, save $60 over muskin!)
$259.99 (20MIR+6.13ship) - EVGA 320-P2-N811-AR GeForce 8800GTS 320MB (w/ OEM Supreme Commander)
$189.99 (+6.94ship) - ASUS P5N32-E SLI Plus (always leave room for upgrade, this board is quad core rdy and SLI rdy)

you can gimme the extra Supreme Commander ................................... jk'ing :D

To be honest, this is really not a good time to build a c2d system especially with 8800 gpu at this moment, cuz intel is gonna drop c2d prices on 4/22 (read more here and here). So that means if you wait for another week, you can possibly get a QUAD CORE Q6600 for the same price u paid for a E6600. And the reason why 8800 is not a good buy atm is that ATI's R600 is coming out soon, rumor has it that it has greater performance vs 8800 and the price may affect 8800's price (evga step-up program will save u, so no big deal)
 
How long would it take for those price cuts to get to Europe? Does anyone have an idea? Should it be right away or is there some delay?
 
Never overclocked a machine before perhaps I would not know where to start or what components to use.

My power supply is a nice 650W Antec.

I have 2 S-ATA optical drives and 4 S-ATA dard drives so I don't think P-ATA will be used.

With the latest generation of hardware it literally takes 20 seconds and changing a single number in the BIOS. I am not exaggerating in the slightest, that is all you need to do. Get a 6 series board, all intel chipsets are obsolete.
 
So that means if you wait for another week, you can possibly get a QUAD CORE Q6600 for the same price u paid for a E6600.

No. Quad Core CPUs won't be coming down to the E6600 prices until the third fiscal quarter this year. Take a careful look again at that article you linked to. That means around summer to fall. So the E6600 is a good choice after the April 22nd price cuts. On another note, not many apps are taking advantage of dual-cores let along quad core. So there's not point in buying a quad-core CPU for a while.
 
alexlyc's choices are pretty spot on. The only thing I'd recommend you do differently is to order your cpu from www.shopblt.com. Get the e6420.
 
I just bought a E6400 with the same video card, and the first set of g.skill ram mentioned
and a 680i evga board (wanted it for the lifetime warranty and the fact that its loaded with everything you'll ever need for the mobo.)

I run SC and C&C 3 top notch @ 1680x1050 everything the entire way up, and it runs like a charm. I actually installed oblivion and same deal, runs like butter..

I would go for the E6420 since its only 218 ish right now.. then wait till a Q6600 drops to 266 in the second half of the year.. and simply sell or put the 6420 down to another rig.

Diff between 6400 and 6420 is the 4mb cache on the 6420 as theres only 2mb on the 6400..

I intend on upgrading to the quad core when they drop too..I'd say save your cash now, .. save 80$+ .. then just save up a little more and go quad + faster a couple months from now :)
 
No, actually, they're not. They're good for Crossfire and they also support quad core CPUs. Therefore, they're not obsolete.

Crossfire? ATI is obsolete after 8800, lol
And I hate to say it, but quad cores will be completely useless at the desktop level for quite a while. Dual cores remain mostly useless. Most people could still be running an OC'ed P4 Northwood and few would notice any significant difference. Core2duo runs cooler and is more overclockable. That is the extent of it's real world advantage. Multiple cores and hyperthreading are little more than marketing gimmicks in the PC market at this time. Nobody can even show conclusively that they "work". It's quite ambiguous, with people arguing on both sides of the issue. Now compare that to the GPU sector. There is far less ambiguity, hype and confusion. You will not find a single person anywhere arguing that the 6600 GT was either better or "no different in performance" than the 6800 GT. The difference is clear cut in any graphics app. Just load up Quake 4 and let the results smack you in the face.

After lots of experience, I've come to the conclusion that the CPU is overrated. It's a generalization, but fairly accurate.
Desktop level performance is all about the hard drive provided your CPU is not positively ancient.
Gaming performance is still all about your graphics card.
Neither of those are going to change anytime soon.
Take note, tech noobs, because I wish someone had told me these things earlier. There is too much fuss made in this industry about components which don't actually put out any quantifiable performance improvements.

It's interesting that the Core2's are such a highly regarded line of processors, yet if you read user reviews online most people readily admit that they experienced no noticeable performance improvements after upgrading from the P4. I do like my C2D but you've got to realize that the CPU is of secondary importance. Most people don't, I'd imagine. I certainly didn't for a long time.
 
all intel chipsets are obsolete.

No, actually, they're not. They're good for Crossfire and they also support quad core CPUs. Therefore, they're not obsolete.

Crossfire? ATI is obsolete after 8800, lol
And I hate to say it, but quad cores will be completely useless at the desktop level for quite a while. Dual cores remain mostly useless. Effectively, people could still be running an OC'ed P4 Northwood and performance wouldn't be significantly different. Core2duo runs cooler and is more overclockable. That is the extent of their "real world" advantage. Multiple cores and hyperthreading are little more than marketing gimmicks in the consumer market at this time.

After lots of experience, I've come to the conclusion that the CPU is overrated.
Desktop level performance is still all about the discs provided your CPU is not ancient.
Gaming performance is still all about your graphics card.
Neither of those are going to change anytime soon.
I wish I knew these things even a year ago.

Intel chipsets aren't obsolete, and they're actually the best selling chipsets on the market. There is still use for their chipsets, which is my main point, to counter your statement about them being obsolete. You need to lookup the definition of obsolete.

# old; no longer in use or valid or fashionable; "obsolete words"; "an obsolete locomotive"; "outdated equipment"; "superannuated laws"; "out-of-date ideas"
# disused: no longer in use; "obsolete words"
wordnet.princeton.edu/perl/webwn

# Obsolescence is when a person or object is no longer wanted even though it is still in good working order.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obsolete

Intel chipsets are still in use, and are still wanted by many people trying to avoid the problems with the nForce 600i series boards. They're the most stable chipsets for Core2Duo, so people still use and want them. Hence, they're not obsolete.
 
Yeah, I suppose one could throw that old dog a bone in terms of it's stability.

I know that my advice does not reflect market buying trends. See, I tend to look for the best-in-class at any given time and ignore everything else. So yeah, I read about all the problems people were having with 680i when it first came out. At that time I was still considering an intel board as a viable option. But then what happened? 650i hit. P5N-E SLI came out, and it got multiple BIOS revisions, and now all the user reviews are saying the thing is rock solid. So you see, that's what I'm going to pay attention to. If 9 out of 10 600-series boards on the market have stability issues, but the 10th one is rock solid, then I couldn't care less because that's the only board I'm going to get it. I'm going to be getting the P5N-E SLI in a couple of weeks and I would bet anything that the thing will be rock solid for me. In fact I KNOW it will because I own it's direct predecessor, the P5NSLI, which, despite having shitty OC'ing due to 570 chipset, worked right out of the box w/o issues. Every ASUS board is pretty much the same, once you own one you know what to expect from the next. It is mass-produced stuff, after all. There are exceptions to the rule but they are mostly limited to needlessly extravagant things like the Striker.

Haven't yet to RMA memory/CPU/video card/mobo for this generation of hardware. Haven't had any crazy shit happen. I think that's partly because I keep it simple, and also partly because this shit HAS gotten a lot simpler than it was several years ago. No question about that. Game may have gone into the dump with the console-ization of the market but we are experiencing the Golden Age of PC hardware.
 
Back
Top