Build Critque.

K3Fallout

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 27, 2007
Messages
317
I'm building a new C2D system and I've been researching for months and have came up with this:

Intel Bad Axe 2

Corsair 520w psu

BFG 7600GT

Seagate Barracuda 7200 rpm 160gb

Antec P182 (I'm going to wait for this to come out)

Intel E6300 (currently waiting for the price drop in April)

CORSAIR XMS2 1GB 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 675 (I don't need 2gb all right away, I'll get another gig of this in the future.)

Either a Lite On or Samsung optical drive. Still comtemplating whether to get IDE or SATA.

Also contemplating to replace the stock cpu heatsink/fan with a Zalman 9500 or something.

Now just one question. I do plan on buying two more 120mm fans for the p180/182 since if i recall from the reviews, you can add an optional two more at the front where the grills are. It would be nice to hear some recommendations for fans, but if anything I'll get two more Tricool fans. I think led fans should be neat since I can see them from the grill.
EDIT: Also to add, I already bought the psu,hard drive and video card.
 
I have recently made the transition from IDE to SATA optical drives and i love it, the smaller cables are a ton easier to manage and look alot better as well. I dont really see much performance difference but the looks were worth it
 
Actually, I don't really know about the budget...I'm just guesstimating around 800+ but I really don't want to push it to 950-1000. I probably did already, but I'm practically buying one part or two a month.
 
You're goin with a 7600GT, so I'm assuming you don't need crossfire. So, to save money, drop the board to a P965Express board, like the GA-965P-DS3 or -S3, rev3.3. That way, you have the budget for 2GB, so go for the Patriot eXtreme Performance DDR2-800 2GB LLK sticks. They're $165AR. 2GB of ram would give you better performance over the BadAxe2 board.

$123 - Gigabyte GA-965P-DS3 Socket T (LGA 775) Intel P965 Express

$215 - Patriot eXtreme Performance 2GB (2x1GB) DDR2-800 PDC22G6400LLK ($50MIR)

Yate Loon fans are nice. I'd also suggest the Scythe SFF21F 120x25mm S-Flex, Thermaltake A2368 120x25mm, or the Panaflo FBA12G12L1BX 120x38mm. Those push more air than the Yate Loons and are just as quiet.
 
You're goin with a 7600GT, so I'm assuming you don't need crossfire. So, to save money, drop the board to a P965Express board, like the GA-965P-DS3 or -S3, rev3.3. That way, you have the budget for 2GB, so go for the Patriot eXtreme Performance DDR2-800 2GB LLK sticks. They're $165AR. 2GB of ram would give you better performance over the BadAxe2 board.

$123 - Gigabyte GA-965P-DS3 Socket T (LGA 775) Intel P965 Express

$215 - Patriot eXtreme Performance 2GB (2x1GB) DDR2-800 PDC22G6400LLK ($50MIR)

Yate Loon fans are nice. I'd also suggest the Scythe SFF21F 120x25mm S-Flex, Thermaltake A2368 120x25mm, or the Panaflo FBA12G12L1BX 120x38mm. Those push more air than the Yate Loons and are just as quiet.

QFT. Save some money, and retain your quality. You ought to be very happy you're getting a lot of bang for your buck!
 
Well.. what's wrong with the corsair ram I picked? I really don't think I need 2 gigs right now since I don't even plan on using vista for another year or so. Help me recall, does the DS3 have 3 pci slots or 2? I don't really plan on doing uber hardcore insane ocing because I've never any type of ocing at all, so I decided on the BX2 for the stability it apparently has. Btw, this will also be the first time I ever assembled a computer.
 
The DS3 has 3 PCI slots.

Nothing is wrong with the Corsair RAM you picked. Enginurd was merely trying to say that if you switch the mobo to the GA-965P-DS3, a very stable mobo whether or not you overclock, you'll have enough money in your budget for 2GB of RAM.

While the Bad Axe is a good mobo, I think it's a bit overkill for your budget. So like others have already suggested, I recommend you get the Gigabyte GA-965P-DS3 mobo instead. Like Enginurd said, 2GB of RAM is better than an expensive motherboard.

If you're still wondering why we keep pushing for 2GB of RAM, it's quite simple: Better performance whether or not you have Vista. And right now RAM prices are so damn cheap. Three months ago, 2GB of low quality RAM would've set you back $200. Now you can get 2GB of high quality RAM for about $200. Lower quality ram is even cheaper too.

And since this is your first time assembling a PC, some advice: Read the manual and take things slowly.
 
Oh, wow I see. Thanks for letting me know about the ram tidbit no one told me about that. For the DS3, is it good stock? Because majority I've seen people oc the heck out of those things. Also looks like I'll need to get a firewire controller card if I go for the DS3 since I need that firewire. Still allows for two more slots which is do-able. How is the onboard sound? As you can see from my OP, I didn't include a sound card in it. EDIT: Also at that patriot ram posted for me, looks like I'd need to purchase today or tomorrow to be qualified for the rebate. Which I hope I don't have to so soon.
 
Onboard sound is all right I guess. I'm not sure considering I'm a bit hard of hearing.

Yes the DS3 is stable as stock. If it's stable while OC'd then its stable as stock.
 
Alright. Well I guess if I go for the DS3 then I'd better invest into a sound card as well since I do do a fair bit of gaming. Which I planned to do the same for the BX2, but I think the onboard sound for that would hold me out for awhile atleast. Boy, decisions decisions.
 
Hm... I guess my post from work didnt go through, lol, cuz I dont see it here. Anyhow, Danny pretty much said everything I was trying to say.

Also, if all you're doing is web browsing, yahoo games (or poker), word processing, and media playback, then no, you don't need 2GB of ram... nor a Core2Duo for that matter. If thats all you're really doing, save your money and go with an X2 3600+ build instead... or heck, even a single core would do, hehe.

Now, if you multitask alot, do any photo/video editing, play any 3d games, do any 3d rendering, media ripping/encoding, then you'll definately want 2GB and a Core2Duo.

If you just want a system to last you a while, go with your original plan of 1GB and upgrade later. But don't waste money on features you'll never use. Stability doesn't cost that much, lol. Also, using OC'able parts leaves the door open to the possibility, instead of shutting it out. Keep your options open. Again, if you'll be gaming at all, go with 2GB.

Onboard sound on the DS3 is great unless you're an audiophile. If you're an audiophile, I hope you have some nice, expensive speakers to go with that pricey sound card. Otherwise, stick with onboard. Upgrade to a soundcard if you're unhappy with the onboard hd audio.
 
Makes sense. Well I think I'll go total up everything and see what kind of price it is. If it's too high, I'll definitely consider the DS3 route.Are there any type of Overclocking for Dummies type of guide out? Maybe I should google it for myself. All I'm trying to do is build some ground first then add the little tidbits after, hence the 1gig now and a gig later I decided on at first. However, there are still some unanswered questions. The bits about the fans since I'm going for a P180/182 case and whether I should go for SATA or IDE optical drive.
 
Search the overclocking Sub forum here for more about the DS3 overclocking. Oh and go for the SATA drive for better air flow and possibly faster speeds. Check out my earlier post about the Yate Loons.
 
Alright, will do. I'll try to add up the subtotal right now for the BX2 build and go from there.

EDIT: Alright, I did the calculations and it came out to about 691.44$ but it's not including the optical drive or case yet since I really can't predict the price of the P182 and I'm still choosing an optical drive(stupid thing to debate about,I know). I also didn't add the price of additional fans but I doubt they would break the bank. I used the price of an E6300 when it comes to the april price cuts and it should be about 163$ right? Also, this price is with the inclusion of the ram I chose in the OP. Overall, I think that price isn't that bad.


EDIT 2: ..Should I consider an after market cpu heatsink?
 
You can reaach pretty good overclocks on the stock Intel cooler. With that said, I say get an aftermarket cooler for better cooling and possible higher overclocks.
 
Hmm. Alright. I'll go look at reviews and whatnot. Any recommendations from yourself?
EDIT: Also just realizing that you are an owner of the P180 yourself, did you install two fans where the grills are like what I'm planning on doing? I recall skimming through threads and if you wanted to do that, you'd have to leave out one of the hard drive cages or something simliar, I really don't know. Another pretty stupid question.. how can you tell when the fan is an exhaust or intake fan? Just want to clear the air so I won't have to ask this when the actual assembling occurs.
 
Bumperoo. Actually, don't answer my previous post, the question(s) are pretty stupid.
 
Nah there is no such thing as a stupid question. All the top fans are exhaust. No, you don't have to leave out the hard drive cages if you want to add two front fans. I've pretty left everything stock and its working out well for me. Hard drives don't get too hot and my CPU iis at a good temp (40C-50C)
 
Alright, good to know. How was managing the cables in the case for you? In my current desktop, the cables are like a giant spider web or a concoction of vines, it's horrible.
 
Wasn't too hard. Most of the wires have been pushed or hidden to the side. It did take me a while to wire up a clean system but I knew that when I bought it.

Here's a couple of links for you to read:
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=960173
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1023499
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1119933
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1136374
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1111018
http://www.silentpcreview.com/article255-page12.html <- the TIPS & HINTS FOR ASSEMBLY section

It's a bit extra work with the P180 but man do I love that case. :)
 
thanks a bunch for the links Danny. If I decided to go for an after market cpu heatsink, I think I might decide on the Tuniq since when I searched it here, everyone liked it in a p180. Still deciding on the case fans.. :D
 
I also recommend the Ninja. I have both, the Tuniq and the Ninja, but I like the Ninja better. It cools better in my situation. Supposedly, the Tuniq is better with high airflow cases, while the Ninja is better in low airflow cases. I had no case when testing (it was sitting on my desk), and the Ninja cooled better than the Tuniq. Maybe I should lap my Tuniq... but I'm too lazy, lol.

BTW, I gave some fan recommendations above, in case you missed it. You could do better than the ones you chose. The ones I listed push more air, and are also quiet.
 
Yeah alright there,thanks for the bumpage. I'll keep on reading about the HSF,thanks. As for the fans I'm just going to get 3 led yate loons from jab-tech for the p180/182. Two for where the hard drive cages are, and the top vent but not sure if I should still do that after reading this http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=939843&highlight=p180+yate+loon though because of the age of it, this may have changed but I really have no idea. How was the installation for the tuniq and ninja? You think a novice like me can do it without smashing something against the wall out of frustration?
 
Oh my. I had a hard time going through the vines of power supply cables and ide cables when I swapped hard drives for the first time. It took me two hours. I bet this build will take me days to build.
 
Ahh I remember my first build. Took me four hours to build, two hours to install the OS, two hours to clean up everything, and three hours of troubleshooting right afterwards.

Anyway don't worry too much about it. It gets easier the more you do it and the more you read up on it.
 
Trial and error I suppose. Though I hope I don't do any 'error' with parts that costs hundreds of dollars..Ehh. Anyhow, for the cpu heatsink I guess my choices are the tuniq, ninja, infinity. I'd still like an answer for the replacing of the fan for the top vent for the p180/182 :).
 
I say just leave it stock. The stock Antec Fan is pretty quiet and puts out quite a bit of air. But replace all the other fans with yate-loons :).
 
Mmm. Ok so how many fans are there in the p180 exactly? Lol. EDIT: Also, I came with the idea of replacing the top vent fan with a yate loon led because I'd thought it would be neat for a blue glow to be there. EDIT #2: Also, since I'm going to get them from jab tech as seen here http://jab-tech.com/YATE-LOON-120mm-Clear-Case-Fan-with-four-blue-leds-D12SL-12-pr-3625.html

What does it mean when they say it has open corners? I'm also assuming that these don't come with fan screws so.. does the case come supplied with some fan screws or do I have to get those to? Does it matter what kind I get?
 
P180 does 2 in the back upper, one in the upper front, and one in the lower middle. The upper-front and lower-middle aren't really needed.

Also, I do NOT recommend using a Yate loon on the top: It's a sleeve bearing, and sleevebearing fans have a shorter life, and are louder, hwne in the vertical position like that.

Also, some fans are closed corners (there's a solid tube of plastic from the upper to the lower flange) and some are open corner (no plastic tube between flange). The P180 upper fan requires an open corner fan.

They do come with fan screws. I suggest you use the ones that come with the P180 though.
 
Alright,thanks a bunch.I'll keep reading as usual. EDIT: Does any one know if the Yate Loons are open or closed chassis? Trying to find the right screws. Sorry for all these questions, I just dont want to run into any (more atleast) problems.

EDIT: Gah, nevermind a simple google search answered that. Who would've thunk it.
 
Actually, no I can't think of any at the moment but I'd thought maybe someone else may have comments and what not. If anything I'll just let this thread disappear and make another when all my parts are actually here. :)
 
Back
Top