Budget Cuts Shut Down SETI

Guys, I wouldn't be afraid of Aliens blowing us away.

1: History on Earth shows that as species evolves, they become more civilized.
2: Considering that we are learning about planets around other stars, imagine where we'll be 500 years from now? If these advanced species have the ability to travel here and 'blow us away', they would of had the technology to know about us hundreds if not thousands or millions of years ago. It would of happened by now.

Next time you swat a fly, or step on an ant, think about how insignificant it was in your existence. We, as much as humanity likes to think we are the end-all, be-all, might be an insignificant gnat to such an advanced civilization that they would heard us, or keep us as "domesticated" livestock/pets. We don't know what the parameters would be for such an encounter, but as Hawking pointed out numerous times, it's not necessarily the Vulcan benevolent alien we might be looking at or a War of the Worlds invader type, it might be one that is just as ambivalent to us as we are to lesser beings.
 
Guys, I wouldn't be afraid of Aliens blowing us away.

1: History on Earth shows that as species evolves, they become more civilized.
2: Considering that we are learning about planets around other stars, imagine where we'll be 500 years from now? If these advanced species have the ability to travel here and 'blow us away', they would of had the technology to know about us hundreds if not thousands or millions of years ago. It would of happened by now.

So, you humans are evolved and stuff. Yet you still step on ants. It's a common rule in nature that given sufficient reason to (hunger, wanting something they have) all animals will kill other animals and not care that they have done. Also things of human nature would not necessarily apply to aliens. For example technology tends to accelarate during times of warfare.

Plus human culture is full of annoying crap. Imagine if they received "firday" over the interspace webs. That would probably be cause for a "scorch the whole earth" policy to come into effect from any civilized people. :p

There are great distances between here and the nearest habitable planets, so they may have the technology to see earth and it's people, but not to visit (due to lack of lightspeed/faster travel).
 
Glad to see this get cut. All these DC projects are a waste, but SETI was particularly silly. Now if they can just get rid of folding@home.

I wonder how much energy these dinosaurs are consuming. Given that most of the farms are old systems, they can't be energy efficient...
What? I can see not being excited about SETI, but folding is for a good cause.
 
Those dishes aren't exactly bought at K-mart :-P

I realize that, but did they put them on a credit card and are paying them off slowly? Or are they continuously buying new ones?

If it's the later, how about you say "ok we're a little underfunded this year, no new equipment.."
 
What a waste of money to be looking for ET. If you want to believe that life magically appears on any planet that has water in a liquid state, at least wait until we develop warp-drive technology before spending money looking for ET.
 
if aliens are anything like us, we would be fucked.

besides, I think the reason we have not seen any is not because of any prime directive, but because any race that approaches the technology to space travel probably destroys their habitat and extincts themselves.
 
Next time you swat a fly, or step on an ant, think about how insignificant it was in your existence. We, as much as humanity likes to think we are the end-all, be-all, might be an insignificant gnat to such an advanced civilization that they would heard us, or keep us as "domesticated" livestock/pets. We don't know what the parameters would be for such an encounter, but as Hawking pointed out numerous times, it's not necessarily the Vulcan benevolent alien we might be looking at or a War of the Worlds invader type, it might be one that is just as ambivalent to us as we are to lesser beings.


lol, reminds me of the old world maps.
"Here there be monsters"
 
Even if there were other planets with people broadcasting radio signals, those signals would be far, far too weak for us to detect.

The closest star to earth is too dim to be seen with the naked eye. It radiates more energy in a second than humans have created in all history. We can't even see any planets in other solar systems, so how are we going to detect artificial radio signals? (All these supposed extra-solar planets are believed to exist by inference, not because they've been seen. Also, even the toughest Earth microbe would die instantly on most any of them.)

Here's a clue: Star Trek is just a TV show. SETI is stupid.
 
Even if there were other planets with people broadcasting radio signals, those signals would be far, far too weak for us to detect.

The closest star to earth is too dim to be seen with the naked eye. It radiates more energy in a second than humans have created in all history. We can't even see any planets in other solar systems, so how are we going to detect artificial radio signals? (All these supposed extra-solar planets are believed to exist by inference, not because they've been seen. Also, even the toughest Earth microbe would die instantly on most any of them.)

Here's a clue: Star Trek is just a TV show. SETI is stupid.

You can see venus at certain times. Its known as the "Morning star" and the "evening star" and is one of the brightest objects in the sky lots of the time (people have mistaken it for UFOs). The nearest star (not counting the sun) and several other planets are visible (which is how people knew about them in ancient times).

Alpha Centauri is the forth brightest star in the sky, the 5th nearest star sirius is the brightest (it's part of the great dog constellation).

Photo of planet in another solar system.

Radio astronomy has been used for a while.

AHumans don't stand a chance :p
 
Even if there were other planets with people broadcasting radio signals, those signals would be far, far too weak for us to detect.

The closest star to earth is too dim to be seen with the naked eye. It radiates more energy in a second than humans have created in all history. We can't even see any planets in other solar systems, so how are we going to detect artificial radio signals? (All these supposed extra-solar planets are believed to exist by inference, not because they've been seen. Also, even the toughest Earth microbe would die instantly on most any of them.)

Here's a clue: Star Trek is just a TV show. SETI is stupid.

On the grander scale, I think there ought to be more habitable planets out there than we could ever imagine, even just in our observable universe itself.

But I do agree that SETI doesn't stand a chance in detecting communication signals from these planets that are scattered around our universe. SETI is merely looking in our own backyard while there's a whole large universe out there that it cannot reach.
 
Do you not know anything about politics? Not signing a defense bill will do absolutely nothing about saving money.

Do you not understand basic economics? If you don't spend the money, you still have it. :rolleyes: Ending this decade of war would solve many many economic problems. For some reason, people would rather old people die than to stop interfering in world affairs unilaterally.
 
Democrats sign the same fucking spending bills. They cry about defense spending publicly but keep on signing the budgets.

Democrats aren't much worse but Republicans have a strange ire to cut bills that hardly impact the national budget.

Both sides need to man up and start with Defense cuts , doing that alone will make a giant difference. Get out of Afghanistan , lower the permanent soldier count in both countries. Back the hell out of Libya , we've done our one saving act .. its up to the rebels and NATO (not using our Air force either).

A one paragraph solution to a huge portion of Debt in this country. Yet it won't ever get done , thats the worst part.
 
Back
Top