Budget Cuts Shut Down SETI

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Well this just sucks. I wonder why there isn't more private sector funding or big support from Hollywood, you know all those guys believe in aliens.

A collection of radio telescopes dedicated solely to listening out for extraterrestrial life has been put into "hibernation" because of a lack of funds. The Allen Telescope Array in northern California has a combined collecting area of one hectare, and was funded by Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen.
 
I see others have already noted the error in the headline and made the point I was going to make. (Yes, SETI was not shut down, the ATA was.)
 
That's because the government know something about ET already.

Dun Dun Dun!
 
Isn't there a million loonie-bin whacos in the US convinced that ET has probed them...??? If everyone of them sends in $1, the ATA can resume operations.... C'mon, you know you wanna get probed again...:eek::cool::D
 
And what is the importance of ATA in the SETI as a whole?. Even if they aren't shutting down SETI they are in fact reducing its scope.
 
ATA annual operation cost is 1.5 million a year. Isn't that a drop in the bucket in government/private spending cost? Must be more to the story than just budget reduction. If I was part of the budget reduction team I would at least ask if ATA can be tasked to something more productive (not to say searching for ET isn't productive, but it's not quite priority), like say, faster communications with the ISS and perhaps to moon bases in the future?
 
ATA annual operation cost is 1.5 million a year. Isn't that a drop in the bucket in government/private spending cost? Must be more to the story than just budget reduction. If I was part of the budget reduction team I would at least ask if ATA can be tasked to something more productive (not to say searching for ET isn't productive, but it's not quite priority), like say, faster communications with the ISS and perhaps to moon bases in the future?

They are looking for more funding, ATA is on standby currently. One proposition is helping the USAF track space debris.
 
Techinically speaking, if there is no new data, then SETI is going to be dead eventually.

There's only so many times you need to FFT a signal for a give space in the sky: Once

The likelihood of SETI finding anything was incredibly small to begin with due expected small small signal gain to the distortions (low S:N ratio) introduced by our own atmosphere.
 
SETI is a waste, at least the way they are doing it.

ET life would be using something way more advanced than the Hydrogen spectrum to communicate (because of wave travel time). We're looking in the wrong places.
 
Glad to see this get cut. All these DC projects are a waste, but SETI was particularly silly. Now if they can just get rid of folding@home.

I wonder how much energy these dinosaurs are consuming. Given that most of the farms are old systems, they can't be energy efficient...
 
they could just hire someone to stand in the field and look at the sky and get the same results. "Nope can't see any Aliens" it would be a lot cheaper.
 
as someone who has been doing compute work for seti@home since it started, one of the great things it has done is to help bring about network computing for a great many other projects.

its interesting to see how its gone from taking my computer days to process a signal batch to now each of my OC 460GT's do a work unit in mere minutes. along side the other network computing jobs my computer at home is doing right now.
 
ATA is pointless. Intelligent life is not going to communicate across the cosmos with radio waves.
 
I do not think SETI is a great idea. The Aliens may have more advanced technology, and may see us as a "nuisance species" and wipe us to save Earth. Or they may not like to get unsolicited calls...
 
1.5 million per year... I have to ask, what exactly did that money fund? How many people really need to run that kind of operation?
 
they could just hire someone to stand in the field and look at the sky and get the same results. "Nope can't see any Aliens" it would be a lot cheaper.

+1 Well said. Too bad there are so many similar programs that we're funneling money to.
On the bright side the Republican budget got rid of ATA, and they'll still be in office next year to give us another round of cuts. Let's just hope Obama is in such a "cooperative" mood.
 
Guys, I wouldn't be afraid of Aliens blowing us away.

1: History on Earth shows that as species evolves, they become more civilized.
2: Considering that we are learning about planets around other stars, imagine where we'll be 500 years from now? If these advanced species have the ability to travel here and 'blow us away', they would of had the technology to know about us hundreds if not thousands or millions of years ago. It would of happened by now.
 
Guys, I wouldn't be afraid of Aliens blowing us away.

1: History on Earth shows that as species evolves, they become more civilized.
2: Considering that we are learning about planets around other stars, imagine where we'll be 500 years from now? If these advanced species have the ability to travel here and 'blow us away', they would of had the technology to know about us hundreds if not thousands or millions of years ago. It would of happened by now.

It's a minority in any civilization that actually 'progress' in any comprehensive manner. The rest of the world utilizes their advancements for whatever purpose they see fit. Look at our civilized world.
 
+1 Well said. Too bad there are so many similar programs that we're funneling money to.
On the bright side the Republican budget got rid of ATA, and they'll still be in office next year to give us another round of cuts. Let's just hope Obama is in such a "cooperative" mood.

On the bright side? They shut down a *resource* that could be used for more productive purposes, all to save a $1m pittance and shake their fist at ... well, at imagination, quite frankly.
 
+1 Well said. Too bad there are so many similar programs that we're funneling money to.
On the bright side the Republican budget got rid of ATA, and they'll still be in office next year to give us another round of cuts. Let's just hope Obama is in such a "cooperative" mood.

Most of the funding was from private groups.
 
SETI wasn't shut down, the ATA was shut down.

Indeed and the ATA is only shutdown til Federal funding comes through on 2013 than its back in business. In the meantime they will be doing fundraisers so I'm sure it might even come up before than.

This slows down progress but it isn't the end of SETI as we know it.
 
I love how many of you think these programs use MASSIVE amounts of Government funding. NASA uses 1/2 of 1 percent of the budget ... a far cry from the Apollo glory days. SETI gets a tiny sliver of money from Federal funds.

Lets all ignore the giant elephants in the room (Social Security , Medicare and the biggest of them all Defense spending) and just let the Republicans shrink everything down that they lack the intelligence to grasp.
 
I love how many of you think these programs use MASSIVE amounts of Government funding. NASA uses 1/2 of 1 percent of the budget ... a far cry from the Apollo glory days. SETI gets a tiny sliver of money from Federal funds.

Lets all ignore the giant elephants in the room (Social Security , Medicare and the biggest of them all Defense spending) and just let the Republicans shrink everything down that they lack the intelligence to grasp.

Democrats sign the same fucking spending bills. They cry about defense spending publicly but keep on signing the budgets.
 
ATA annual operation cost is 1.5 million a year. Isn't that a drop in the bucket in government/private spending cost? Must be more to the story than just budget reduction. If I was part of the budget reduction team I would at least ask if ATA can be tasked to something more productive (not to say searching for ET isn't productive, but it's not quite priority), like say, faster communications with the ISS and perhaps to moon bases in the future?

Yes, that is a tiny sum of money from the Governments view. Reports are that the Tomohawk missiles we launched in Libya cost about $1-1.5 million each, and we launched over 100 of them.
 
Democrats sign the same fucking spending bills. They cry about defense spending publicly but keep on signing the budgets.

Do you not know anything about politics? Not signing a defense bill will do absolutely nothing about saving money.
 
If they turned them back on, and pointed them at DC, they would
not find any intelligent life there either....;)
 
Back
Top