BTX style cases

KCoover86

n00b
Joined
Aug 27, 2004
Messages
8
So what do you guys think of the recent BTX style cases? I'm referring to cases that flip the standard ATX board upside down so the cpu is at the bottom where cool air traditionally comes in. I'm mainly referring to the Silverstone Temjin 6 and Lian Li v1000. I like the "wind tunnel" idea of the Temjin 6, even if it does seem gimmicky. The Lian Li design doesn't make sense to me though... why put the power supply at the bottom of the case? Unless it's mounted upside down, wouldn't the heat rise to the cpu?
 
I thought the Lian Li's design was okay for a non-OC'd system, the case has enough venting to do a very good job with only it's two fans and keep everything at acceptable temperatures... Between the price, the wiring hassle, and the odd design, it didn't do much for me as an enthusiast case tho.

I was just checking out Anand's review of the TJ06 tho (hadn't realized it had a pseudo-BTX desgin like the Lian Li when I saw it earlier), I kind of like it... In fact, if it were entirely aluminum I'd be all over it, heh, 'course it'd probably be $200+ then but... Dunno, NewEgg has 'em for $130-ish which is kind of pricey for a steel full tower.

If it were cheaper I'd be all over it as well despite it being made of back-busting steel. I like the design of it overall tho, very smart, I've been wanting someone to come up with a simple but effective compartmentalized design like this for a while, it works so well on Apple's cases you'd think people would be copying it all over the place.

Looks like wiring it up would be easier than it is on the Lian Li, bit harder to hide wires than on a smaller case w/a removable tray but Most of the wires will go up to the top part anyway (which you don't have to show if you're gonna tack on a window :D ). I think they went overboard with the front pannel port cables (check out the pic on Anand's review) but as I have those ports on other bay devices I usually don't plug 'em in and could care less.

Considering the TJ06 at the moment for a system I'm building... Was going for a compact Praetorian but I could use the 5 bays (DVD, DVD+RW, Audigy bay, 20x4 LCD) and I like the Temjin's design.
 
P.S. Both the Lian Li and the Silverstone seem sooo much smarter in design compared to the Gateway BTX case that was on [H]'s front page the other day... I know OEM cases are far from design masterpieces but from an air-flow point of view the Gateway didn't seem like an advancement at all even tho it was refference BTX design...

Why didn't Intel just shift to a pseudo BTX while keeping the ATX spec, doing something like Silverstone has? Seems so much easier... :rolleyes:
 
because it is intel. they do what they want and everyone else just has to deal with it.

Greg
 
Back
Top