BOTH drives have MBR, whoops!

Darknyt

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 10, 2004
Messages
400
So I have two drives that have a MBR on them and would like to access the old one - of course it doesn't want to recognize with the new boot drive.

Short story, installed Win 7 RC on a new WD black caviar. Then along comes Win 7 Pro - I get another new WD black caviar and put Win 7 Pro on that and unhook the old boot drive.

However, I have data I want off the old Win 7 RC drive - how do I get it back? I assume I need to get rid of the mbr on the Win 7 RC drive, but not sure how to do this and save data.

Ideas? If I just try to plug it in, it won't recognize. If I boot up with it connected, sometimes it wigs out the startup sequence and fails to boot.
 
Normally on SATA drives you have to tell the BIOS specifically which port or device name it needs to boot from, since SATA doesn't have a master/slave arrangment like IDE did. There should be something like Boot Device Priority and then Boot Disc Priority

I have done disc images on computers and had 2 seperate working copies of Windows on 2 internal harddrives, but it boots normally because it only looks at one of the drives.
 
unfortunately i can choose boot device priority (hdd, cd-rom, etc) but it's not showing me hd options.

May be that it doesn't recognize the other drive anymore.

Can't get it to see that drive very often. I try hooking it up while running, down etc and most times it's like the other drive doesn't exist.

That's why I'm thinking I need to get rid of it's mbr, maybe corrupted or something so I can just use as a data drive.

I can have the older RC drive hooked up and windows will just ignore it usually, like it's not even there. Can't see it in disk management, device mgr, etc.

A couple of times I've gotten the non-os partition on the RC drive to show up and tried to transfer stuff off but it didn't last and stopped showing part way through data transfer.
 
unfortunately i can choose boot device priority (hdd, cd-rom, etc) but it's not showing me hd options.

May be that it doesn't recognize the other drive anymore.

Can't get it to see that drive very often. I try hooking it up while running, down etc and most times it's like the other drive doesn't exist.

That's why I'm thinking I need to get rid of it's mbr, maybe corrupted or something so I can just use as a data drive.

I can have the older RC drive hooked up and windows will just ignore it usually, like it's not even there. Can't see it in disk management, device mgr, etc.

A couple of times I've gotten the non-os partition on the RC drive to show up and tried to transfer stuff off but it didn't last and stopped showing part way through data transfer.

1) Switch off your computer
2) Double check your cables. Make sure both drives are properly connected.
3) Start the computer and enter the BIOS. Make sure both drives are detected. In the "Boot" menu, enter "Hard Disk Drives" and make sure that the drive containing W7 Pro is the first/only HDD in the boot order.
4) Save and reboot
5) W7 should start. If the partitions on your second HDD shows up, copy the files over. If they don't show up, enter disk management and verify that your drive is detected and, if necessary, assign drive letters to the partitions.

Success?
 
If I just try to plug it in, it won't recognize.
Probably because AHCI isn't enabled for hotswap.

If I boot up with it connected, sometimes it wigs out the startup sequence and fails to boot.
Probably because your computer is getting confused as to which drive it should boot from.

If I can't correct the boot order this is when I connect the drive thru a USB external enclosure.
 
AHCI not enabled for hot-swap? Without AHCI you have no hot-swap support.

As for the boot sequence, if all you can select is "HDD / CDROM" then there should be a second menu where you define the boot order of the HDDs. Check your BIOS more closely; or put up screenshots if you really can't find it. I think you're just overlooking the right options.

TS: why do you want to get rid of the MBR? Do you want to destroy data, or do you want to access data on your second drive? Please formulate a clear question.
 
So I have two drives that have a MBR on them and would like to access the old one - of course it doesn't want to recognize with the new boot drive.

Short story, installed Win 7 RC on a new WD black caviar. Then along comes Win 7 Pro - I get another new WD black caviar and put Win 7 Pro on that and unhook the old boot drive.

However, I have data I want off the old Win 7 RC drive - how do I get it back? I assume I need to get rid of the mbr on the Win 7 RC drive, but not sure how to do this and save data.

Ideas? If I just try to plug it in, it won't recognize. If I boot up with it connected, sometimes it wigs out the startup sequence and fails to boot.

#6: Was the above not clear? I'll check the bios again to be sure, thanks for the idea.

#4: Done that probably 9 or 10 times. It has only recognized once and is not showing up in disk management.
 
Last edited:
Well, it almost is starting to sound as if maybe the drive is dying. Surely someone with your font changing abilities has all his important stuff backed up though ~.^


DO YOU KNOW WHAT AN RMA IS???????? CAN YOU SEND A PACKAGE WITHOUT ANY OUTSIDE ASSISTANCE???? CAN YOU SUCCESFULLY NAVIGATE TO A POST OFFICE AND MAKE IT HOME?????

I put the important stuff in red so you wouldnt miss it. Sometimes people put it in huge letters and they come across as total jerks.........
 
If you want to recover data, that means you do not wish to overwrite that data. So you do not want to format/remove the MBR, but you want to copy your valuable data to somewhere safe.

So, copy your files from HDD1 to HDD2, where HDD1 contains your valuable files. After that you can do to the MBR whatever you want for whatever reason - as you got your valuable files off the drive.

I assume you know how to backup your files. If that's so, is there any remaining question or issue you would like to have addressed?
 
@Darknyt

I'll try to list one that seems sensible at this time.

1. With both your old and new WD disks connected to motherboard
2. Boot latest Linux LiveCD from CDROM (Fedora/Mandriva/Ubuntu/Knoppix/misc). They usually have NTFS-3G already integrated so you can try to mount your Win7 disks inside Linux.
3. After login into Live CD environment, In Fedora's case, you can see a Computer Icon. Double click and it will open up to show more icons. Example Hopefully you can see 2 more icons 500GB Disk and 750GB disk. Double click on the disk icon to open the disk content.
4. If you are lucky and everything OK, copy your files quickly to the other disk or external USB drive.

The reason I recommend: In case you really have problem, the Linux system boot message and system logs sometimes give clear information.

I'll try to give an example, last time I had a failed disk for Macintosh. I have limited knowledge with Macintosh, the Windows environment mounted disk in usb enclosure but hung for long time. I finally did the LiveCD route and could read from the Linux system messages that the drive had a lot of bad media reading errors.

run the command inside Linux terminal

dmesg --> shows boot message

cat /var/log/messages --> generic system messages
 
If you want to recover data, that means you do not wish to overwrite that data. So you do not want to format/remove the MBR, but you want to copy your valuable data to somewhere safe.

So, copy your files from HDD1 to HDD2, where HDD1 contains your valuable files. After that you can do to the MBR whatever you want for whatever reason - as you got your valuable files off the drive.

I assume you know how to backup your files. If that's so, is there any remaining question or issue you would like to have addressed?

Thanks for your input but it's as though you didn't read the original post with your backup comment. You didn't address really any questions but confirmed what I guessed about the mbr from my first post.

I cannot access the second drive reliably anymore. I assume it's because the mbr is screwing things up.
 
Last edited:
Well, it almost is starting to sound as if maybe the drive is dying. Surely someone with your font changing abilities has all his important stuff backed up though ~.^


DO YOU KNOW WHAT AN RMA IS???????? CAN YOU SEND A PACKAGE WITHOUT ANY OUTSIDE ASSISTANCE???? CAN YOU SUCCESFULLY NAVIGATE TO A POST OFFICE AND MAKE IT HOME?????

I put the important stuff in red so you wouldnt miss it. Sometimes people put it in huge letters and they come across as total jerks.........

Nice, smartass. The formatting just made it easy to see the question.

Did you bother to read the huge bolded type while you were mocking it? Apparently not because your comment pretty much ignored it.

An RMA isn't going to solve anything I listed in my first post. Did you read the first post?

Why did you bother to post again? This was your entire contribution to this thread?
 
@Darknyt

I'll try to list one that seems sensible at this time.

1. With both your old and new WD disks connected to motherboard
2. Boot latest Linux LiveCD from CDROM (Fedora/Mandriva/Ubuntu/Knoppix/misc). They usually have NTFS-3G already integrated so you can try to mount your Win7 disks inside Linux.
3. After login into Live CD environment, In Fedora's case, you can see a Computer Icon. Double click and it will open up to show more icons. Example Hopefully you can see 2 more icons 500GB Disk and 750GB disk. Double click on the disk icon to open the disk content.
4. If you are lucky and everything OK, copy your files quickly to the other disk or external USB drive.

The reason I recommend: In case you really have problem, the Linux system boot message and system logs sometimes give clear information.

I'll try to give an example, last time I had a failed disk for Macintosh. I have limited knowledge with Macintosh, the Windows environment mounted disk in usb enclosure but hung for long time. I finally did the LiveCD route and could read from the Linux system messages that the drive had a lot of bad media reading errors.

run the command inside Linux terminal

dmesg --> shows boot message

cat /var/log/messages --> generic system messages

Thanks for the idea, I'll give it a shot.
 
#4: Done that probably 9 or 10 times. It has only recognized once and is not showing up in disk management.

Is it detected by the BIOS? If not, then you have a hardware problem.

Forget about the MBR, it's irrelevant if the drive doesn't show up in the BIOS or in disk management.
 
Forget about the MBR, it's irrelevant if the drive doesn't show up in the BIOS or in disk management.

Yep and just in case you missed it, connecting the drive via USB will make the MBR a moot point.
 
Is it detected by the BIOS? If not, then you have a hardware problem.

Forget about the MBR, it's irrelevant if the drive doesn't show up in the BIOS or in disk management.

Yes, I probably have a couple issues there. MBR happened first, but now after a couple dozed tries, I probably fubar'd the whole drive. Maybe.
 
SATA is hot swap.

Just plug the drive in and leave the cable from the board to the drive unplugged from the drive.

Then when your booted in win7 pro. Plug the Sata cable back into the drive.

Wa la :rolleyes:
 
I read all the posts. from the following statements made by the OP

1) "If I just try to plug it in, it won't recognize. If I boot up with it connected, sometimes it wigs out the startup sequence and fails to boot."

2) "Can't get it to see that drive very often. I try hooking it up while running, down etc and most times it's like the other drive doesn't exist."

3) "I cannot access the second drive reliably anymore."

leads me to believe it may be a possible mechanical failure. In which case the way to recover data is from you backup copies. And rma the drive to get one thats not mechanically broken. You CAN have data recovered by a professional if you choose to do so , albiet it is extremely pricy.

My suggestion to recover your data still stands. RMA the bad drive, and recover from your backups.
 
Back
Top