Blu-ray Sales Up

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It looks like Blu-ray disc sales are up 91% while hardware sales (including the PS3 and recent sub $199 players) are up by 25% as well. The more you analyze the numbers, the less impressive they are but at least they are doing better and movie prices are going down as well.

Well, at least half of those 11 million Blu-ray players are PS3s, which had a US install base of 5.7 million in December, meaning slightly less than half are standalone players. Nearly 75 percent of units are BD-Live compatible. Lopping off the 50 percent that are PS3s, that means roughly half of the standalone players in the US are BD-Live players, so they're relatively recent purchases.
 
Throw out the half that are PS3s? Why would you do that? I'll be the first to admit that I originally didn't think the PS3 mattered with respect to the HD wars, but as it turns out, the PS3 has generally been among the best BD players available and relatively inexpensive, when compared to comparable stand-alone device (no, the $98.00 special at Walmart isn't comparable).

Regardless, BD is marching along towards becoming the dominant format, just as many of us have said for well over a year.
 
Throw out the half that are PS3s? Why would you do that?

He was merely breaking down the number of new BR players lumped into that "75% are BD-Live compatible" category, not trying to discount those sales.

My PS3 is my Blu-ray player, I have no need for another.

What I wish they would work on is the MOVIE PRICES.

New releases / triple AAA titles are still retardedly expensive and even old "has been" movies that sell for $4.99 on DVD are $10 - $15 over the standard DVD price. (disclaimer: we are talking about retail sales where you walk in and buy the damn movie when it comes out, not buying off eBay, Amazon, Craigslist etc. etc. etc.)
 
Regardless, BD is marching along towards becoming the dominant format, just as many of us have said for well over a year.

Yup, its only a matter of time. As it stands, Blu Ray players, drives, and media have fallen in price at a significantly faster rate than DVD did in the same period of time. DVD had the advantage of competing against VHS (inferior technology) and Laserdisc (unweidly and expensive) so it was an obvious choice, while Blu Ray is competing against DVD and downloading, both of which are "good enough" for lots of people (I think DVD and most video streaming is garbage).

That said, its only a matter of time until Blu Ray players continue to replace DVD player in new sales as they get cheaper and cheaper.

As a hardcore videophile (I had Laserdisc back in 1990 and got my first DVD player in 1997), I couldn't be happier with Blu Ray. It has delivered the absolute best image and audio quality for a significantly lower price than other previous formats have.
 
disclaimer: we are talking about retail sales where you walk in and buy the damn movie when it comes out, not buying off eBay, Amazon, Craigslist etc. etc. etc.

More people should be buying Blu Rays on Amazon. Their prices are ridiculous (30%-60% off all the time), and on top of it they have constant "buy 2 get 1 free" deals, things like that. Replacing my DVD library has been cheaper than when I bought those same DVDs in the first place!
 
All the anti-Bluray/Sony hate is funny. Some people need to eat some crow.

What I wish they would work on is the MOVIE PRICES.

New releases / triple AAA titles are still retardedly expensive and even old "has been" movies that sell for $4.99 on DVD are $10 - $15 over the standard DVD price. (disclaimer: we are talking about retail sales where you walk in and buy the damn movie when it comes out, not buying off eBay, Amazon, Craigslist etc. etc. etc.)

Walmart has a tone of "AAA" titles for $10. Most DVD's arent $5 either. New DVD prices are still $20. DVD prices arent going down, yet Blurays are.
 
More people should be buying Blu Rays on Amazon. Their prices are ridiculous (30%-60% off all the time), and on top of it they have constant "buy 2 get 1 free" deals, things like that. Replacing my DVD library has been cheaper than when I bought those same DVDs in the first place!

true shame those offer arnt available to us via amazon.co.uk. last time i ordered from amazon.com i got slapped with import duty
 
true shame those offer arnt available to us via amazon.co.uk. last time i ordered from amazon.com i got slapped with import duty

People in the EU get hosed on everything. :(

When I see what computers, movies, music, video games, etc etc cost over there it always bums me out. My relatives from the UK usually buy things here when they come over, given that it will work with what they have back home. :)
 
I get all my Blu-Ray movies from Blockbuster.

I just got Taken, the new one, for $14.99. Pre-viewed Blu-Rays with the original cases. All the movies here like that are $5.99, $9.99, $14.99 and $19.99.
 
He was merely breaking down the number of new BR players lumped into that "75% are BD-Live compatible" category, not trying to discount those sales.

My PS3 is my Blu-ray player, I have no need for another.

What I wish they would work on is the MOVIE PRICES.

New releases / triple AAA titles are still retardedly expensive and even old "has been" movies that sell for $4.99 on DVD are $10 - $15 over the standard DVD price. (disclaimer: we are talking about retail sales where you walk in and buy the damn movie when it comes out, not buying off eBay, Amazon, Craigslist etc. etc. etc.)

Steve, if you bought your DVD's at a B&M in 1999-2000, you were paying some fairly high prices for movies (and articles from that period say that they were more than VHS). OTOH, if you bought online, there were deals to be found. And if you were shopping on line and going to places that posted all of the coupons that gave you 5 off 15 or 10 off 20 or 25, there were even more deals....but those only happened because Buy.com, real.com and similar sites were operating on the .com model that it's ok to lose money if you gain market-share.

What's more, $5.00 movies were unheard of for DVD at this stage of the game. It's simply ridiculous to claim BD's are too expensive without looking at how old the technology is and what prices were like when a similar product was the same age.

I wouldn't pay retail for BD, but if you bought all your movies at BBY in 99-2000, you were paying 20 or more for most titles. A year or 2 later is when the prices finally came down at retail outlets.
 
true shame those offer arnt available to us via amazon.co.uk. last time i ordered from amazon.com i got slapped with import duty

I imported my copy of Planet Earth from Amazon.uk. About 35 bucks shipped. Nevertheless, as a rule, everything in Europe costs more.
 
I really love Blu-Ray and I'm glad it's catching on. Some of my friends who questioned why I invested so much in it at the beginning are now adapting to it, and the 50GB burnable disks are a great help as well for backing up my huge collection of media.
 
The PS3 have been pretty successful driving blu-ray to the masses. Even though the reception could be better, with some media price cuts it would probably be. Without it standalone players should have been much cheaper from the beginning.
 
Regardless, BD is marching along towards becoming the dominant format, just as many of us have said for well over a year.

I find it odd that people continue to carry on this line of thought while ignoring the fact it will always be more expensive to make a BR player compared to a DVD player due to the physical hardware BR decoding requirements and BR fees not to mention the price of physical BR media.

One could assume that DVD players and DVD media will be very popular for some time.
 
Steve, if you bought your DVD's at a B&M in 1999-2000, you were paying some fairly high prices for movies (and articles from that period say that they were more than VHS). OTOH, if you bought online, there were deals to be found. And if you were shopping on line and going to places that posted all of the coupons that gave you 5 off 15 or 10 off 20 or 25, there were even more deals....but those only happened because Buy.com, real.com and similar sites were operating on the .com model that it's ok to lose money if you gain market-share.

What's more, $5.00 movies were unheard of for DVD at this stage of the game. It's simply ridiculous to claim BD's are too expensive without looking at how old the technology is and what prices were like when a similar product was the same age.

I wouldn't pay retail for BD, but if you bought all your movies at BBY in 99-2000, you were paying 20 or more for most titles. A year or 2 later is when the prices finally came down at retail outlets.

QFT, once again, one of the few voices of reason here. :)
 
I find it odd that people continue to carry on this line of thought while ignoring the fact it will always be more expensive to make a BR player compared to a DVD player due to the physical hardware BR decoding requirements and BR fees not to mention the price of physical BR media.

One could assume that DVD players and DVD media will be very popular for some time.

And yet BD is cheaper than DVD was at this stage of the game. DVD is a mature technology. Complaining that BD costs more than DVD is like complaining that an I7 costs more than a Pentium III 500 (even though when DVDs came out a cheap PIII would set you back as much, or more, than the slowest I7(s)). And if you want to transpose that to 99 or 2000, feel free to update the PIII to whatever Intel's $200-$300 CPU was at that time.
 
blueray is farcheaper than dvd was. remeber in 97 till 2001 we here in the uk were paying £30 to £50 on region 1 dvds imported from usa. back then region 2 dvds had less extras (not bothered about that) or worse crap sound and none anamorphic pictures. think by 2000 we started getting AC3 and DTS.

those dvds sold for £5 each on ebay when i flogged all my dvds last year:confused:
 
And yet BD is cheaper than DVD was at this stage of the game.

And pray tell why is that?

Because in the battle between VHS and DVD it was no contest which was better.

Between the BR and DVD not so much (the point of declining returns in picture quality vs dollars spent) and the BR group has a limited time to make market inroads before the next big thing comes along.

Were not back in the days of DVD and VHS boys, there are many different formats making inroads from streaming off the net to on demand cable.

Complaining that BD costs more than DVD is like complaining that an I7 costs more than a Pentium III 500 (even though when DVDs came out a cheap PIII would set you back as much, or more, than the slowest I7(s)).

I'm not complaining I'm pointing out a cold hard FACT, deal with it.

BR has higher decoding overhead than DVD, ergo due to the extra hardware requirements required for BR decoding and the lack of BR hardware volume sales DVD will always be cheaper.
 
And pray tell why is that?

Because in the battle between VHS and DVD it was no contest which was better.

Between the BR and DVD not so much (the point of declining returns in picture quality vs dollars spent) and the BR group has a limited time to make market inroads before the next big thing comes along.

Were not back in the days of DVD and VHS boys, there are many different formats making inroads from streaming off the net to on demand cable.



I'm not complaining I'm pointing out a cold hard FACT, deal with it.

BR has higher decoding overhead than DVD, ergo due to the extra hardware requirements required for BR decoding and the lack of BR hardware volume sales DVD will always be cheaper.

Whatever. It's cheaper than DVD was. You're making a speculative prediction about future prices, which is irrelevant. The prices are cheaper.

If you're happy with compressed DVD pictures, then buy those. If you're happy with even more compressed video from Apple or Amazon, then buy those, but that doesn't support your assertion that prices are high. Hell, streaming was touted as a tech that would hurt DVD sales back in 2001 or 2002....that didn't really happen did it?

The cost of licensing BD tech and media cost/production, in the future, is unknown. The BD Group may or may not decrease fees. Production of disks may or may not drop.

This thread deals with current prices and the current prices are less than what DVD was at this stage. If you don't see the value in it that's fine, but the price of an I7 doesn't drop to the price of a Celeron, just because you think that the I7 isn't a good value.

Player sales are increasing. Software sales are increasing. Market share is increasing.
I said it 6 months ago. I said it almost a year ago. I'll say it again, BD is the future. within 1.5 years, the masses will join the party.....just like they did with DVD.....the format that was threatened by steaming video (or so articles said, 7-8 years ago).
 
I've never understood what is the point of buying a movie in blue ray/dvd/whatever if you have already seen it. I guess people enjoy watching stuff again?
 
blueray is farcheaper than dvd was. remeber in 97 till 2001 we here in the uk were paying £30 to £50 on region 1 dvds imported from usa. back then region 2 dvds had less extras (not bothered about that) or worse crap sound and none anamorphic pictures. think by 2000 we started getting AC3 and DTS.

those dvds sold for £5 each on ebay when i flogged all my dvds last year:confused:

Let's not even talk about the cost of DVD set top boxes, optical drives, burners, and blank media. I'm guessing that lots of people here are either too young to remember or just how forget how expensive DVD was (let's not even talk about Laserdisc that preceded it).

Everything Blu Ray related has fallen in price exponentially faster than DVD did. The fact that it is as affordable as it is while being the frigging holy grail for video and audiophiles is remarkable.

Player sales are increasing. Software sales are increasing. Market share is increasing.
I said it 6 months ago. I said it almost a year ago. I'll say it again, BD is the future. within 1.5 years, the masses will join the party.....just like they did with DVD.....the format that was threatened by steaming video (or so articles said, 7-8 years ago).

Seconded x1000. Last summer I was saying that we'd have $100 players by Christmas 2009, looks like I was off by six months. Its only a matter of time, until then the shortsighted can keep making ridiculous arguments.
 
I've never understood what is the point of buying a movie in blue ray/dvd/whatever if you have already seen it. I guess people enjoy watching stuff again?
You don't ever watch something you've seen before? I hope you don't watch tv because they show re-runs all the time.

I would say that the majority of people do like watching and or reading the same thing over again. However, there are a lot of DVD sales that are because people didn't want to bother watching it in theater's. It can also be cheaper. Also, a lot of people buy dvd's of movies they have never seen before. Of course I also like Netflix.
 
All that said, and this is definitely off-off-topic and only speculation on my part, I don't think that Blu Ray is going to be the dominant format for burning and storage on devices like notebooks, and even possibly desktops in the same way that DVD was.

The inclusion of the SD card in the new Macbook Pros gave me an idea of where the potential future will be with devices like notebooks, and it probably isn't in optical media. There are many advantages SD cards have relative to formats like DVD and Blu Ray. The cost per gig of SD cards is dirt cheap and still dropping like a rock, the media and the slot itself is tiny, the read/write time is much faster than DVD or BR, and there are no moving parts (important for things like battery life). In Apple's constant effort to create lighter and thinner notebooks with long battery life and no compromise in power, I will not be surprised if Apple starts to phase out internal DVD drives on notebooks in the future (like they phased out floppies) and distribute their future retail software on SD cards as an option alongside DVD.

I dunno, from a power, speed, and size standpoint it makes way too much sense to me. Dumping a relatively thick optical drive with moving parts will result in a notebook that has an even thinner and lighter enclosure along with increased battery life. It might not happen but I won't be surprised at all if it does. I expect that other PC manufacturers will follow suit if this happens.

But again, for video and audio, Blu Ray absolutely can't be beat and the price from the POV of anyone who bought DVD in its first six years is great.
 
Whatever. It's cheaper than DVD was. You're making a speculative prediction about future prices, which is irrelevant.

ROTFL!

More so than rosy predictions of how BR is going to be the dominating format in the next year eh?

If you're happy with compressed DVD pictures, then buy those.

Strawman argument- Who said I was happy with DVD? I was just pointing out the facts which is simple. BR will not be the dominating format and why.

Dominating format = format most used.

You want to get all BR fanboy go for it, I enjoy giving a good slapdown.
 
ROTFL!

More so than rosy predictions of how BR is going to be the dominating format in the next year eh?

I didn't say it would be the dominant format in 1.5 years. I said the masses will join the party. It took 5.5 years for DVD revenue to exceed VHS. Let's repeat that 5.5 years. It took 6 - 6.5 years for DVD rentals to exceed sales. And THAT is when it was clear the masses had joined party.

Strawman argument- Who said I was happy with DVD? I was just pointing out the facts which is simple. BR will not be the dominating format and why.
Dominating format = format most used.
You want to get all BR fanboy go for it, I enjoy giving a good slapdown.

You didn't prove anything. You speculate that that the costs of BD are fixed and cannot drop to a point where the masses make it their format of choice.
 
I didn't say it would be the dominant format in 1.5 years. I said the masses will join the party.

Please educate us on the difference and stop moving the goalposts around.

It took 5.5 years for DVD revenue to exceed VHS. Let's repeat that 5.5 years. It took 6 - 6.5 years for DVD rentals to exceed sales. And THAT is when it was clear the masses had joined party.

There are alternatives to BR, there was not for VHS -> DVD for home media so it is not an apples to apples comparison.

Adoption rate of hardware is a meaningless yardstick IMHO, show me discs sales. There are FAR more people buying media hardware now than 1998.

You didn't prove anything. You speculate that that the costs of BD are fixed and cannot drop to a point where the masses make it their format of choice.

Strawman argument AGAIN, I never stated they were fixed.

BR hardware WILL ALWAYS be more expensive than DVD due to decoding overhead and there is no economy of scale savings yet. Fact.

BR license fees higher, Fact.

BR media prices higher, Fact.
 
I missed this in the article-

11 million Blu-ray players in the US, including PS3s.

Number of DVD players sold in the second quarter of 2009, 5 million.

So... there is just about the same number of DVD players sold in two quarters than the total installed BR base since BR introduction.

Fanboys, sheesh.
 
Adoption rate of hardware is a meaningless yardstick IMHO, show me discs sales.

^^^This! While I know that there are 5.7 million PS3's in the US, but that doesn't mean that everyone of those people are purchasing Blu-rays.

This thread title is a bit of a misnomer, it should be changed to Blu-ray hardware sales up. Unless someone has some disc sales numbers that show otherwise.
 
There are alternatives to BR, there was not for VHS -> DVD for home media so it is not an apples to apples comparison.


Uh have you ever heard of Betamax (which was superior to VHS in every way) and Divx (not the codec)? Laser disc has always been a competitor to all these formats as well.
 
^^^This! While I know that there are 5.7 million PS3's in the US, but that doesn't mean that everyone of those people are purchasing Blu-rays.

This thread title is a bit of a misnomer, it should be changed to Blu-ray hardware sales up. Unless someone has some disc sales numbers that show otherwise.

Hmm, all I can find is that they said disc sales were up 91%, but no data to back that up. Anyone else find anything?
 
Uh have you ever heard of Betamax (which was superior to VHS in every way) and Divx (not the codec)? Laser disc has always been a competitor to all these formats as well.

Ah, very true! I had forgotten about them.

Laser disc was *the* premium item to have back in the day too, one might be inclinded to compare it to BR in the BR vs DVD.

Must have VHS on the brain since it won the early format war and I'm digitizing several hundred hours of racing & baby footage so I can banish my VHS deck from the living room.

Personally I think DVD and BR have thier places in the market and there is room for both.
 
Just get over it sales for Blu ray is up while DVD's is down. The transition is happening and being blind to it will only make you more irritated when you found out your wrong. Dvd's had the same kinda push when it was included in the PS2. Guess what yes maybe there PS3 can do more then just play Blu Rays but guess what now when that person thinks about renting a movie they will have the option of buying/renting a Blu Ray disc. Then the more it becomes natural for said transaction the more people will enjoy the new format and spread word of mouth. I know a lot of people who have a PS3 (excluding me my Blu Ray is in my PC) and have a few Blu Ray movies because of it. Yeah they probably wont double dip on there movies but they will buy new movies that they don't have on Blu Ray.
 
Ah, very true! I had forgotten about them.

Laser disc was *the* premium item to have back in the day too, one might be inclinded to compare it to BR in the BR vs DVD.

Must have VHS on the brain since it won the early format war and I'm digitizing several hundred hours of racing & baby footage so I can banish my VHS deck from the living room.

Personally I think DVD and BR have thier places in the market and there is room for both.

So true. Choice is a good thing not a bad thing. That is why we are losing on the energy game because we wanted one superior format (gas, coal) instead of different standards that might accommodate certain niche markets. It's more profitable to have one standard but all these companies are going to have to figure out that table has turned they are going to have to deal with it. So Blu Ray, DVD, Digital Streaming/Downloads are all going to live together and it will be the best option.
 
Uh have you ever heard of Betamax (which was superior to VHS in every way) and Divx (not the codec)? Laser disc has always been a competitor to all these formats as well.

In a way you buttress my position that BR will NOT be the dominating format in the near future.

Laser disc and betamax were claimed to be better than VHS but still lost. I state claimed because I have no experiance with betamax, just Laserdisc which was pretty cool.
 
ROTFL!

More so than rosy predictions of how BR is going to be the dominating format in the next year eh?



Strawman argument- Who said I was happy with DVD? I was just pointing out the facts which is simple. BR will not be the dominating format and why.

Dominating format = format most used.

You want to get all BR fanboy go for it, I enjoy giving a good slapdown.

Basically he's saying you're a rose-colored glasses past viewer. I bought a couple of DVD players and movies when they were still "new" technology. I can start giving you the UPC codes of the movies I bought from BB (and Amazon) 4 years after DVD was released in the US that cost more than BD. I bet you wouldn't hazard a guess as to how much my Das Boot flipper disc cost, on sale. I can guarantee that it was more expensive than any BD I've bought D&D or otherwise, online or brick and mortar.

The basic rule is that newer = more costly. I'm sorry but the same arguments used against DVD at that time are being trotted out again with BD. The only difference now is that a consortium controls it vs Toshiba owning the DVD forum. What I see is a bunch of people that really don't know jack and sh*t about entertainment devices blathering on incessantly. Laserdisc failed for multiple reasons (although it was a charming failure, and certainly long-lived) that manufacturers learned hard lessons from.

Complain, whine about copy protection (some do, while inexplicably embracing DRM locked downloads), region coding (whereas some download services refuse to download through an anonymizer or outside the US), et al. BD has too many companies behind it that have invested too much money in it. That was why, even though I never picked a side overtly in the HD-DVD vs BD war, I thought BD would win. Here's Toshiba, owning all the patents by it's little lonesome self looking to extend their fiat rule (and handsome patent license profits) of the DVD forum. In the other corner was pretty much the rest of the CE industry looking for a piece of the pie and to end Toshiba's dictatorship. HD-DVD was pretty much destined to lose, just like the Sony Betamax. Heck, it didn't even have "superiority" going for it long-term.

Long story short mate, downloads are going to spin their wheels for at least another decade as the infrastructure just isn't there to support millions downloading. Flash media isn't gonig to succeed in that time frame either. BD may be the last disc format we have, but I'm willing to wager one more iteration yet.

Oh and BD will probably still be the dominant "back-up" format in most households because, unlike a flash drive (or other flash media) you can easily label it. We won't even have a + / - scenario like DVD did because Toshiba was being a c*ck-sucker.

Since you consider the dominant format being the most used, BD has got quite a while of free time yet. It took YEARS after US$100 players rolled out for DVD to truly supplant VHS.
 
I bet you wouldn't hazard a guess as to how much my Das Boot flipper disc cost, on sale. I can guarantee that it was more expensive than any BD I've bought D&D or otherwise, online or brick and mortar.

Not sure what your point is, I spent $79 for the Terminator 2 directors package on VHS.

Worthless now, I can't even get rid of it on Ebay.


The basic rule is that newer = more costly. I'm sorry but the same arguments used against DVD at that time are being trotted out again with BD. The only difference now is that a consortium controls it vs Toshiba owning the DVD forum. What I see is a bunch of people that really don't know jack and sh*t about entertainment devices blathering on incessantly. Laserdisc failed for multiple reasons (although it was a charming failure, and certainly long-lived) that manufacturers learned hard lessons from.

Long story short mate, downloads are going to spin their wheels for at least another decade as the infrastructure just isn't there to support millions downloading.

News flash for you mate- Millions are downloading video content as we speak.

Flash media isn't gonig to succeed in that time frame either.

Brick and motar stores are already selling preloaded flash cards with music, video is just a matter of time.

BD may be the last disc format we have, but I'm willing to wager one more iteration yet.

Very possible the last optical format we have but I doubt it, DVD even CD still has huge value for the PC and console market.

Oh and BD will probably still be the dominant "back-up" format in most households because, unlike a flash drive (or other flash media) you can easily label it.

ho-ho-ho! I call you on that one! They are practically giving hard drives away and they have a huge value over BR, you can erase the drive and use it for something else.

I'll take flash or HD over optical backup anyday of the week.

I just picked up 3 TB for less than $199 shipped.
 
Oh and BD will probably still be the dominant "back-up" format in most households because, unlike a flash drive (or other flash media) you can easily label it. .

I don't know a single person who backs up on optical.

Tape or external hard drive.
 
company I used to work for mainly used HD's for back up, optical for stuff we didn't have on a regular back up timer but felt it should have some sort of safe clause to it.
 
Back
Top