Black Editions

Master_Pain

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Apr 13, 2007
Messages
4,958
I know both the 5000 and 6400 are both black editions, but only the 5000 has an unlocked multiplier correct? And if not, which one would get the highest overclock? I know the 5000 is 65nm and only 65w, the Windsor is 90nm and 125w, so which one would be better? Even if the both were to hit 3.6 on air, I think the 5000 would still run ultimately cooler.
 
if the multi on the 6400 is locked why do they even call it a black edition?
 
All of the "Black Editions" have unlocked multipliers. That is what makes them "black".

I am not sure on which one overclocks better per cost, but I would assume that the 6400+ Black would ultimatly clock in higher. The 5000+ Black would be cooler as long as you keep the voltages down and have good cooling. There are variables in there so you need to factor those in. I do not have either CPU just for the record.
 
5000+ will most likely hit a higher final speed, but 65nm silicon is slower than 90nm at the same clock speed, plus, the 5000+ has 1/2 the L2, so you'll probably need an extra 5% oc on the 5000+ to make it equal performance ;)

that said, i own a 5000+ and love it.
 
Officially, the 6400 is supposed to have locked multipliers.

Unofficially - YMMV.
 
ya, thats what I thought. I seem to remember someone on here buying a 6400 black edition and the multipliers were locked. On a side note, how do you tell if your motherboard can go with a higher multiplier than the default? I have an Asus M2R32-MVP with a 5600 right now.
 
Its mostly the chips that limit it, low end mobos are the ones that you need to worry about. If some moron said his 6400+ BE was lock is because he did not know what he was talking about because its a 16x stock and thats as high as it goes.
 
So, basically the bios won't show the unlocked multipliers at all unless the cpu is actually bolted in correct? And unless you have a shitty motherboard.
 
can you get a motherboard to show multipliers in the bios without a cpu in? :p

and yeah, you need a board that is decent for overclocking and a BE chip. my 5000+ lets me select up to 25x... obviously that won't go over too well :p
 
The 6400+ BE is unlocked.

Not necessarily - as someone mentioned here and as I have found myself, some of them are locked, some are unlocked - AMD officially does not comment on the multiplier part for the 6400, which is stupid IMHO.
 
Not necessarily - as someone mentioned here and as I have found myself, some of them are locked, some are unlocked - AMD officially does not comment on the multiplier part for the 6400, which is stupid IMHO.

o rly, yours is locked? I have yet to see anyone complain about this yet.
 
I would think that the 5000 would also be able to hit the same speeds as a 6400 could, but running cooler, am i correct?
 
maybe, maybe not. it depends on your luck

the 65nm chips don't always run cooler, but they definitely do put out less heat. the die is tiny, so contact between the core and ihs is critical.. and not always perfect ;)
 
o rly, yours is locked? I have yet to see anyone complain about this yet.

I don't personally have one (just a lowly FX-62 haha), but I do have a slew of them infront me that I keep as replacements; played with a couple - both were locked.
 
I've got a 5000+ BE on the way... going to be fun to play with multipliers again... It's been awhile. I already have plans to see how far I can Underclock it too... hehe. Since I like quiet for cooling, I know I won't be pushing it too hard but looking forward to finding the "sweet" spot with the multi and FSB for my purposes.
 
K I found out the truth. the 6400+ is locked going upwards but not downwards. so yeah the 5000+ is pretty much the only true BE.
 
K I found out the truth. the 6400+ is locked going upwards but not downwards. so yeah the 5000+ is pretty much the only true BE.


i thought all A64s had unlocked lower multiplier, so how does that make the 6400+ BE any different than regular A64s?
 
They have the fastest stock clock. :p

yeah there is a normal retail 6400+ on newegg which makes the BE pointless. maybe they are just going to discontinue it for the new more retail looking version because AMD figured that out to.
 
Ya, but there are mixed reviews on whether or not the 6400 is unlocked or not. I wish we could get a definitive answer on this.

p.s. his girlfriend is stupid.

p.p.s. tiger direct sucks ass
 
I know both the 5000 and 6400 are both black editions, but only the 5000 has an unlocked multiplier correct? And if not, which one would get the highest overclock? I know the 5000 is 65nm and only 65w, the Windsor is 90nm and 125w, so which one would be better? Even if the both were to hit 3.6 on air, I think the 5000 would still run ultimately cooler.

The 5000 has an unlocked multiplier. It's 512 x 2 L2. Mine hit 3ghz with nearly stock voltage and runs cool.
I don't own the other Black edition chip so I don't know if it's unlocked or not.
 
Ya, but there are mixed reviews on whether or not the 6400 is unlocked or not. I wish we could get a definitive answer on this.

p.s. his girlfriend is stupid.

p.p.s. tiger direct sucks ass

It is unlocked only going downwards, not updwards like the 5000+. The only reason it's a black edition is because it's the fastest X2 they are likely releasing. AMD realized they were confusing people though that's why it comes in normal retail packaging now on newegg.com and I'm sure other sites will be selling it to once their inventory comes in or they run out of the black boxes. unless you do a monster overclock the 6400+ will still be faster than the 5000+ because it has twice the cache and also makes full use of ddr2 800 Ram. Most of the lower processors do not.
 
My 6400+ BE is locked other than the standard lower dividers from the standard 16x it does not have upper dividers. No idea why they called it Black Edition
 
i hit 3.5ghz @ 1.45v got real toasty fast though 67c:eek:

I'm at 3.2ghz 12 x 270 FSB using 1.32v 30c idle / 52c load.

not bad for 120 bucks:)

lol lets see here back in the day for 120 bucks you could get an amd 3000+ that will do 2.6-2.7ghz for that price. funny how things changed.
 
Back
Top