Bill Gates Backs Climate Scientists

We take pills to fix our body, we'll just give pills to mofo Earth.

I think it's a great idea! We are smart enough to do that, we know that CO2 rising will raise the Avg temp 3-4 degrees by 2100, and the sea level will rise from 1-20 feet or so. If all the ice in the world melted, then the ocean could rise 200 feet.

The earth will go on, this has happened before, but the effects on coastal cities world wide would cost hundred's of trillions.

I'm 100% behind using technology to save these cities. Mars would only save a few 100 people if even that.
 
One problem with this comparison is that unlike "Global warming", "Global cooling" never reached scientific consensus....

Are you talking about scientific consensus like this http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204301404577171531838421366.html. By the way, when did science become a consensus process? What is the criteria of that consensus, 80%, 90%, 100%? Did you learn about the scientific method in school? Science has always been about validation and/or disprove by data. Even the deepest held scientific principle can be disproved by one experiment if that experiment can be replicated or validated. The recent released temperature data from the Met office should at least give the scientists some pause on the warming theory. http://current.com/community/936399...or-15-years-earth-facing-possible-ice-age.htm.
 
Are you talking about scientific consensus like this http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204301404577171531838421366.html. By the way, when did science become a consensus process? What is the criteria of that consensus, 80%, 90%, 100%? Did you learn about the scientific method in school? Science has always been about validation and/or disprove by data.

Don't take me for a kindergartener, of course I know what the scientific method is. What is clear is that you are the one who does not know what consensus is, because you used that terrible Wall Street Journal article as part of your argument. As it turns out, almost every one of the scientists mentioned in that article has not produced any notable peer reviewed publication related to climate in the past decade. In fact, hardly any of those scientists even study climate. So what if one of them has a Ph.D in Physics? That doesn't make him an expert on Climate. Also never mind the fact that a rebuttal made by actual climate scientists was made shortly afterwards, or that 255 distinguished scientists from the National Academy of Sciences wrote wrote a similar letter less than 2 years ago.

Even the deepest held scientific principle can be disproved by one experiment if that experiment can be replicated or validated. The recent released temperature data from the Met office should at least give the scientists some pause on the warming theory. http://current.com/community/936399...or-15-years-earth-facing-possible-ice-age.htm.

Hmm, which article more weight, one written by actual scientists from one of the leading scientific programs in the United States, or some random article off the internet that has already been shown to have numerous errors and omissions?. I think that is a pretty obvious question.
 
Good luck with that. AGM is unfounded. Temperature rises increases CO2 production, not the other way around. Its shown in the ice cores, geologic data and anything else global warming scientist cite as evidence.

If they wanted to disprove global warming, all they need to do is compare geologic temperatures to geologic CO2 levels. Scientists have ...and it does. Scientists can even pinpoint the body temperature of a dinosaur that died hundreds of millions of years ago, yet global warming scientist don't use this for their research? Come on.

Instead, idiot supporters are looking at 1/600 millionth of the earth's history to support their grant funding. What a joke.

The economy is being destroyed and billions of dollars wasted on this faux pursuit that could be going to legitimate science.
 
The economy is being destroyed and billions of dollars wasted on this faux pursuit that could be going to legitimate science.

As usual in these threads, nebulous claims of billions of dollars being spent with no actual citation or evidence. Climate change deniers consistently claim that billions or tens of billions of dollars are being scammed but never give any detail beyond that.

Show us the money you think is being wasted, and do try not to vaguely overstate annual budgets of NASA or the UN by 10000% while you're at it.
 
Good luck with that. AGM is unfounded. Temperature rises increases CO2 production, not the other way around. Its shown in the ice cores, geologic data and anything else global warming scientist cite as evidence.

It is not the other way around, you have no idea what you are talking about. CO2 is a greenhouse gas. The Earth emits longwave radiation into the atmosphere that is partially absorbed by greenhouse gases such as CO2 due to their absorption spectra. Naturally then, if there is more CO2 added to the atmosphere, than more longwave radiation is absorbed as well, leading to a net increase in temperature. Without the greenhouse effect, Earth would not be capable of supporting life as we know it, as Earth's emission temperature is a mere -18 deg C, which can be calculated from Planck's Law.

The link to climate change and human activities come from the fact that we increase the CO2 concentration in our atmosphere by burning fossil fuels and destroying our biosphere. Fossil fuels are named as such because they are composed of dead biomass, which naturally contains carbon like all other organic lifeforms. Burning it releases more carbon into the atmosphere as CO2.

So yes, increasing the carbon dioxide levels in our atmosphere will increase temperature. However, keep in mind that there are additional factors that influence the temperature. For instance, CO2 levels were higher in the Jurassic period. However, the sun was also cooler, so the climate back then was not significantly warmer than it was today.

If they wanted to disprove global warming, all they need to do is compare geologic temperatures to geologic CO2 levels. Scientists have ...and it does. Scientists can even pinpoint the body temperature of a dinosaur that died hundreds of millions of years ago, yet global warming scientist don't use this for their research? Come on.

Actually, climate scientists have made a very good approximation of mean global temperature far into the past through examining tree rings or ice cores, which ironically enough is something you mentioned earlier. The reason behind the natural swings in mean temperature are also well understood. However, the swing in temperature we are observing today is largely unprecedented. The greenhouse effect in conjunction with undisputed evidence that the CO2 concentration in our atmosphere is greatly increasing through our burning of biomass is the basis for Anthropogenic Climate Change.
 
this is pretty much like taking the painkiller, the problem is the pain is still there.
 
And yet you ignore how QUICKLY its warming, which is the entire issue.

You mean like how there has been no significant warming for the past 15 years?

To quote a recient story:
The supposed ‘consensus’ on man-made global warming is facing an inconvenient challenge after the release of new temperature data showing the planet has not warmed for the past 15 years.
Based on readings from more than 30,000 measuring stations, the data was issued last week without fanfare by the Met Office and the University of East Anglia Climatic Research Unit. It confirms that the rising trend in world temperatures ended in 1997.
 

No one takes you as a kindergartener unless you act like one. You misinterpreted (purposely or not) what I meant. I meant "Science has never been a consensus process, it is all about hypothesis and data verification". If that is the case, why the talk about consensus (by the like of Al Gore)? By replying the way you do, you don't understanding scientific method even though you claim you do.

Your definition of consensus is the consensus of those with peer reviewed articles. The peer reviewed articles that no one outside of the climatology church could get the model and data to verify, that could not be verified now because of missing data, that were produced by the corrupted peer review process. What happened to the consensus of those 1500 scientists that Al Gore mentioned? You mean there are 1500 scientists with peer reviewed articles on climate research.

And what kind of rebuttal is that. Nobody can understand what is going on with climate science except the high priest of the climate research? No one can understand and critique their paper other than those in the church of climate research? Esteemed physicists and Nobel scientists in prestigious university cannot understand the so called climatology science? We should all listen to the fraud high priests that control the IPCC and the peer review process as exposed by the climategate emails in 2009.

http://assassinationscience.com/climategate/

and the more recent leak in 2011.

http://foia2011.org/

The rebuttal said "Climate experts know that the long-term warming trend has not abated in the past decade. In fact, it was the warmest decade on record. Observations show unequivocally that our planet is getting hotter..." The warmest decade on record? So they don't have data for the Medieval Warming Period? The planet is getting hotter and the warming has not abated? So either these experts are lying or the Met Office is lying. I do think Met Office data trumps phony statement from Kevin Trenberth. It said "And computer models have recently shown that during periods when there is a smaller increase of surface temperatures, warming is occurring elsewhere in the climate system.." So they are relying on their computer model, a computer model that needs constant tweaking to explain new anomaly. What happens to the model predication of large temperature increase in the IPCC report?

The whole rebuttal is about a) trust us, no one understands this except us experts b) Those guys are not qualified c) Low carbon economy is the best thing since slice bread (how come they are now the expert in economy?). d) Just continue to give us more money. The rebuttal did not address the key points in the original article.
1. There is no incontrovertible science, that include pseudo science like climatology.
2. The lack of global warming for well over 10 years now. The warming is only missing if one believes computer models where so-called feedbacks involving water vapor and clouds greatly amplify the small effect of CO2. Kevin Trenberth tried to brush off his email stating "The fact is that we can't account for the lack of warming at the moment and it is a travesty that we can't." Everyone can read the leaked email and see if it was a misquote.
3. The broken peer review process. The high priests that control the peer review process in Science and Nature, and threaten editors (like Dr, Freitas of Climate Research) of other climate research journals if they dare to publish opposing article. If you are not one of us, you don't get to publish.
4. CO2 actually is better for plant growth and agriculture.

and I am surprised that you did not list the rebuttal to the rebuttal http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970203711104577201483976477936.html

Everyone who is interested in this subject should read from both the "warmists" side and the "deniers" side, the leaked emails, and clearly understand the data and the method used to come out with the conclusion. You can then come down with your own conclusion, whether for or against. The best book I have read so far that tracks the global warming debate is http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1906768358/ref=oh_o04_s00_i00_details. I believe in open debate on important subject such as climate change. I do not believe in suppressing dissenting argument through hiding information, deleting emails, control of peer review process, ridiculing and threatening people, claiming high authority and telling people that it is a consensus, that it is settled (that means no more discussion).

And by the way, the article http://www.skepticalscience.com/media_v_reality.html is such a BS article. Just quoting what you said, why would I believe in a random article off a website? If you want to talk about weight, I would take Claude Allegre over these dudes any time? What makes these dudes qualified to talk about climate change? Arg, I see, they are with the warmist, and therefore are qualified. Did they have any peer reviewed article? What about reading articles from some other website such as www.climateaudit.org. At least they have peer reviewed articles now (after being dragged through the mud).

This is the temperature data http://www.cru.uea.ac.uk/cru/info/warming/ posted by Phil Jones, one of the high priest. Do not read his conclusion 'cause he is misleading you with words. Just look at the temperature chart. The temperature goes up and down from before 2000 to 2010. The smoothed out temperature curve stays level from 2000 to 2010. Also, 2010 is not the 3rd warmest year. It is the fourth, it is surpassed by 1934, 1998 and 2005. 1934 is the warmest year on record.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
...Actually, climate scientists have made a very good approximation of mean global temperature far into the past through examining tree rings or ice cores ...

Stating this exposes your shallow understanding of what's going on with the tree ring study. Do tell us how do one calculates global temperature from tree rings? and also tell us why the tree rings of recent decades do not sync with the recent rapid rise in global temperature?
 
Ignoring the FUD in this thread, I'd just like to point out that most climate scientists are quite skeptical of geo-engineering "solutions" to increased CO2 forcing.
 
@bbqrooster
The analogy makes perfect sense, and believe it or not, it does happen all the time in other fields. For example, My physician may commonly give nutrition advice, but their M.D. does not necessarily make them experts on nutrition, especially when compared to a registered dietitian. And it is an important one. All that WSJ showed was that 16 scientists, most of them not having any publications pertinent to climate or climate change, refute that the earth is warming, with no real evidence to back it up.

There is a clear difference between the articles you and I posted here. I reference an article from NASA that claims that the Earth is warming. NASA has teams of many esteemed climate scientists who contributed to the article, such as James Hansen. On the other hand, the article you provided was authored by a man who not only is not a climate scientist but rather one that has connections to the Global Warming Policy Foundation, a well known "skeptic" think tank. You take it even further and make a blanket statement arguing that one of the claims from NASA, chiefly that 2010 is the warmest year on record and that the top 10 warmest years on record happened in the past decade, is simply flat out wrong.

Since you just said my article was "BS" for no real reason other than saying the same about yours, let me quote the front page of skeptical science's website:

Scientific skepticism is healthy. Scientists should always challenge themselves to improve their understanding. Yet this isn't what happens with climate change denial. Skeptics vigorously criticise any evidence that supports man-made global warming and yet embrace any argument, op-ed, blog or study that refutes global warming. This website gets skeptical about global warming skepticism. Do their arguments have any scientific basis? What does the peer reviewed scientific literature say?

As I said in another thread, I believe that skeptical science is a good website because it provides actual science in its discussions, which is copiously backed up by peer reviewed publications. I also suggest realclimate.org, as well, as it too provides actual scientific discussions on climate change. What you and most other "skeptics" do is literally what the above quote says, find some blog or article that says "Nope, it's definitely not warming!" without showing any true scientific evidence. I am not simply making appeals to authority, unlike you I actually have an educational background in climatology and meteorology. Since you do not, your best argument is that "The peer review is broken". The real "climategate" (not taking e-mails that are clearly out of context as evidence against AGW) is the offensive statements made against climate scientists such as referring to global warming as a "religion" or dismissing climatology as mere "psuedoscience".

This is why consensus absolutely matters, but at the same time, it does not mean that the case is closed either. However, as it stands with the scientific community, the world is warming, and that it is mostly attributed to human cause. I have provided actual scientific explanations in some of my other posts in this thread, and I could certainly provide more. What we are currently questioning is how much we should expect our climate to change, and possible solutions.

@drako
Yes, you are correct. This is an example of REAL skepticism. Geo-engineering carries on the potential of unknown side effects to our climate. In my opinion, cutting back fossil fuel emissions in favor of renewable energy sources is a more practical alternative, but the reality is that developing countries will insist on increasing their fossil fuel usage. That is why investing more research in geo-engineering could have some potential significance.

Also, a rather thorough explanation in regards to estimating mean global temperature through tree rings and ice cores is provided in the IPCC's third assessment here: http://www.grida.no/publications/other/ipcc_tar/?src=/climate/ipcc_tar/wg1/069.htm#fig220
 
@BassDX, you are at it again. The debate is not about the number of scientists who have proclaimed to be on one side or the other. If the debate is about I have more people than you, then it is not a scientific argument. There are lot more real skeptical scientists than just those 16. I can also say that all 37 of those climate scientists have profit and career motives. If I set up a 10 billion dollar fund to support research on finding fault with AGW, I can assure you that there are lots more of skeptical scientists than current. The debate is really on the examination of the method and the validity of the data. The problem with people like you is to claim the "deniers" are not “qualified”. Climate Science is not just the domain of self-anointed climate researchers. Climate Science is derived from other physical science discipline. The data analysis also involves a lot of statistics, which is not an exclusive domain of Climate Science. Telling me that other scientists are not capable of understanding and commenting is just asinine.

I don't know what article I posted you are talking about. I posted an article that contains the Met Office temperature data at the end of my comment to show the flat lining of the temperature between 2000 and 2010. This is an article by Phil Jones, the head of CRU. Are you saying he is connected to Global Warming Policy Foundation. That would be hilarious. I did not claim 2010 was not one of the hottest year. I said 1934 was the hottest year, and certainly not within the last decade. I can also claim that you are flat out wrong if you say it is not.

Whatever you say about skepticalscience.com and realclimate.org, I can also say that climateaudit.org is about real discussion and research. Just by dismissing websites of opposing viewpoint shows your narrow mindedness in viewpoint. Actually, I read that skeptical science article even before you posted it. That's why I could reply that quickly on it. So what if you have a degree in Climatology and Meteorology. You are actually now claiming to be the authority instead of relying on “appeal to authority” argument. Your degree could be a cause of group think and a detriment to a broader viewpoint. Look, the earth could be warming. The earth has gone through periodic warming and cooling all by itself. The earth warming or cooling is not the debate here. It is about man made warming (AGW). I only believe data validation (the scientific method). The hockey stick is shown to be fraudulent (Before you reply to this, read the book http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1906768358/ref=oh_o04_s00_i00_details first). The recent flat temperature data does not help. I am definitely on the skeptics’ side at this point. You are also trying to whitewash the leaked emails by claiming they are CLEARLY out of context. You see, I have a BS detector. Whenever I see words like CLEARLY, CONSENSUS, A MATTER OF FACT, my sensor automatically perks up because the author is trying to impress me and get me not to think any more. Look, you and I cannot proclaim ourselves the bearers of truth. The emails are real and are best left to the audience to judge by themselves. I don't think I use the word "religion" myself. Moreover, I did debate with a lot of warmists and they were truly faith believers. I at least can have a conversation with you without you descending into name calling. I called Climate Science as "pseudo science" because it is not a science you can do experiment with like Physics and Chemistry. That's my definition of pseudo science. Sorry if this term offended you.

Please don't ask me to read these IPCC assessment reports anymore. These reports are sanitized and massaged. They would not tell you the data inconsistencies and assumptions that they have made in making up these things. As a climatologist, you should really understand how they come up with these graphs and whether the assumptions and methods used were reasonable. That’s why I asked you to tell us why the recent tree ring data does not jive with the temperature rise. Don't confine yourself to your favorite websites, look further for the explanation. I followed this debate since Mike Mann came out with the Hockey Stick paper in 1998. I always wondered how he came up with that chart. The truth has finally come out. It is a wonder how this chump Mike Mann can get to his current status. Since you are a climatologist, why don’t you contact Mike Mann and tell him you want his data and methodology so that you can verify his published papers? And let us know how it ends up. The AGW debate certainly has not ended, I definitely disagree with you that the question that warming is mostly attributed to human is settled. This debate is too important to gloss over by telling people the scientific community has a consensus. Your scientific community is confined to people of the same ilk. Your scientific explanation is high school science and it is still a theory when applied to the atmosphere. The key is whether you have unequivocal data to show clear linkage of CO2 and temperature rise. The validity of a computer model is through its predictive power. Has the computer model predicted anything that’s been verified? Finally, let us agree to disagree here.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Hurry, we need to 'cure' global warming before it gets so cold we can't cherry pick the numbers to hide the decline.

Isn't this typical of the best snake oil salesmen. Convince you that you're sick and then convince you they've cured you.
 
Hurry, we need to 'cure' global warming before it gets so cold we can't cherry pick the numbers to hide the decline.

Isn't this typical of the best snake oil salesmen. Convince you that you're sick and then convince you they've cured you.

Wait, so we shouldn't learn more about global climate change because humans might not be the main cause of it right now? Do I got this right? (shakes head).
 
Just admit it, advanced climate change deniers, you want the easy way out. You don't want to have to change your way of life, instead you want to stick your head in the sand and continue to consume, because it is easier.
 
Wait, so we shouldn't learn more about global climate change because humans might not be the main cause of it right now? Do I got this right? (shakes head).

He never said to stop learning about it. He is just not buying the snake oil. :p

They turned global warming into a for profit industry with themselves raking in millions. Now we are expected to believe, these guys would be willing to give up the money and the clout, and tenures, and all the other perks that seem to come with being a warmist, should they find out that they were not as correct as they thought. Truth is, these guys are no longer trustworthy, they act like politicians, not scientists. All dissent is crushed, not with logic, or evidence, but with blacklisting, attempts to discredit, extortion, and the like.

I am not going to say the planets weather is not changing, or that we have nothing to do with it. But, at this point, the warmists do not have much credibility with me.
 
Here is a clue for the clueless....................

Global warming and global cooling is directly tied to the decades long hot and cool cycles of the SUN.
We are in a hot cycle in the 70s they were in a cool cycle and the scientists were saying a new ice age is on the way.
Soon we will be out of this hot cycle and it will start getting cool again and we will have colder winters and cooler summers for a few decades.
 
He never said to stop learning about it. He is just not buying the snake oil. :p

They turned global warming into a for profit industry with themselves raking in millions. Now we are expected to believe, these guys would be willing to give up the money and the clout, and tenures, and all the other perks that seem to come with being a warmist, should they find out that they were not as correct as they thought. Truth is, these guys are no longer trustworthy, they act like politicians, not scientists. All dissent is crushed, not with logic, or evidence, but with blacklisting, attempts to discredit, extortion, and the like.

I am not going to say the planets weather is not changing (It is, it's a normal process AND humans can and one day WILL alter it...lol. I'm not saying that day is today though), or that we have nothing to do with it. But, at this point, the warmists do not have much credibility with me.

I agree with everything you said except one tiny part but I won't mention it. :)

Anyways, I agree, humans can ruin and usually do ruin everything with greed. I always thought it was incredibly funny how the government tried making us pay for our carbon usage while it does the worst damage to the planet (letting off a crazy amount of nukes, controlling laws/corporations, etc). It made no sense and just shows what the underlying cause was. Of course, more money (money grab)!

Hey Gov:
Wait, you allow big business to rape the planet for everything of value while you try to make the average person pay for their small part in their normal existence...WOW!!!

That's what sucks the most, they ( the rich, government, some scientists) took an incredibly important topic (Our planets health) and diminished its importance to the people by trying to unjustifiably make us pay them even more money. I swear the government is out of control.
 
Just admit it, advanced climate change deniers, you want the easy way out. You don't want to have to change your way of life, instead you want to stick your head in the sand and continue to consume, because it is easier.

Though the global warming thing does seem pretty much BS to get funding, there is the more damaging aspect of pumping the air full of chemicals. Which causes things like acid rain etc. something which this frenzied we're all going to die stances seem to cover over.

The fact that fossil fuels are a limited resource is a big problem. If we wait 100 years before we start putting into place an alternative system there will be many more problems further down the line. Added to this the economic factors. "eco" fuels can be home grown, for pretty much free after an initial startup, no more reliance on foreign oil feilds, which pretty much have brought 3 wars and cost thousands of lives and crippled the economy in the last 15 years. Having an electricity bill of $0 or $0 in fuel costs to drive around does seem like a good thing...
 
Just admit it, advanced climate change deniers, you want the easy way out. You don't want to have to change your way of life, instead you want to stick your head in the sand and continue to consume, because it is easier.

No. I want the norm to change.
There is a myriad of reasons to reduce human emissions and consumption.

There is no reason to pretend that catastrophic climate change is one of them.
 
Ignoring the FUD in this thread, I'd just like to point out that most climate scientists are quite skeptical of geo-engineering "solutions" to increased CO2 forcing.

Precisely my point.

The knee-jerk policy reactions are invalid conclusions, and they are more dangerous than the problem we set out to resolve.
 
The knee-jerk policy reactions are invalid conclusions, and they are more dangerous than the problem we set out to resolve.
Personally, I just think it is very arrogant to think we can just throw some more shit into the atmosphere and/or oceans and not expect there to be unintended consequences. We've seen that kind of thing happen with weather modification which, thankfully, usually ends in complete failure.

It's interesting and somewhat depressing for me to read some of the stuff being posted in here. It's fine to have an opinion that differs with the mainstream, but the level of conspiracy being advocated for in here is similar to people who think 9/11 was an inside job or the moon landing was faked. There are bad apples in any field, but climate science isn't the corrupt cesspit that some people are making it out to be. It has become extremely politicized and that is no doubt a shame.

We can quibble about the amount of influence humans are having on temperature, but ultimately you can't logically question that our fossil fuel consumption will begin to force temperatures to rise. CO2 is undoubtedly a greenhouse gas, and its global concentrations are most certainly rising (along with CH4).

And regardless of your thoughts on global warming, there are indeed many other reasons to decrease our use of oil and coal. Air pollution, ocean acidification, drinking water quality, geopolitical security, cost certainty... all good reasons to invest now in alternative fuel/energy sources.
 
Global warming and global cooling is directly tied to the decades long hot and cool cycles of the SUN.
We are in a hot cycle in the 70s they were in a cool cycle and the scientists were saying a new ice age is on the way.
Soon we will be out of this hot cycle and it will start getting cool again and we will have colder winters and cooler summers for a few decades.
More scientists were warning about warming in the 70s than cooling. However, because the 70s were indeed a cold decade in the United States, the media picked up on those who thought we might cool and ran with it. In the scientific literature, global warming was still very much a concern. There was a legitimate concern that aerosol pollution that we were emitted in copious amounts could reduce incoming solar radiation and cool the planet, but we largely averted that by enacting much stricter air pollution laws culminating with the Clean Air Acts.

The sun does impact our climate, but most studies have found that the solar variability influence is smaller than that of greenhouse gas level changes. Even if you look at the past few years where global temperatures have marginally cooled, it can be better correlated to surface water conditions in the equatorial Pacific than the solar cycle.
 
More scientists were warning about warming in the 70s than cooling. However, because the 70s were indeed a cold decade in the United States, the media picked up on those who thought we might cool and ran with it. In the scientific literature, global warming was still very much a concern. There was a legitimate concern that aerosol pollution that we were emitted in copious amounts could reduce incoming solar radiation and cool the planet, but we largely averted that by enacting much stricter air pollution laws culminating with the Clean Air Acts.

The sun does impact our climate, but most studies have found that the solar variability influence is smaller than that of greenhouse gas level changes. Even if you look at the past few years where global temperatures have marginally cooled, it can be better correlated to surface water conditions in the equatorial Pacific than the solar cycle.

All ABSOLUTE BS.

The #1 source of green house gas (CO2) is THE OCEAN. A gas naturally by produce of decomposition. The idea of human activity "tipping the scales" is beyond ridiculous. A major volcanic eruption spews more toxic and green house gasses into the atmosphere than what the industrial revolution did. A volcanic eruption is 100% natural and there are several going on around the world at one time. Only the monsters make the news.
You people have to realize that the Earth itself can render the human race null and void by 100% natural forces.
THE REAL PROBLEM is not that there are competing theories of why it seems to be warmer now, etc, etc. It is there is a Cabal of banksters looking to CASH IN ON CARBON CREDITS and we will ALL BE FORCED TO PAY HIGH PRICES FOR ENERGY~!!!
Carbon credit trading will will make the banksters rich and we will have to foot the bill for the whole world wide scam!!!!
DO NOT BE MANIPULATED BY JUNK SCIENCE. The goal of these "scientists" is to get their GRANT MONEY. And that can only happen if they report "we are all gonna die unless we get more grant money to study this further!!"
The goal of the BANKSTERS is to get rich. WE WILL have to pay for this crap!!!!
 
All ABSOLUTE BS.

The #1 source of green house gas (CO2) is THE OCEAN. A gas naturally by produce of decomposition. The idea of human activity "tipping the scales" is beyond ridiculous. A major volcanic eruption spews more toxic and green house gasses into the atmosphere than what the industrial revolution did. A volcanic eruption is 100% natural and there are several going on around the world at one time. Only the monsters make the news.
You people have to realize that the Earth itself can render the human race null and void by 100% natural forces.
THE REAL PROBLEM is not that there are competing theories of why it seems to be warmer now, etc, etc. It is there is a Cabal of banksters looking to CASH IN ON CARBON CREDITS and we will ALL BE FORCED TO PAY HIGH PRICES FOR ENERGY~!!!
Carbon credit trading will will make the banksters rich and we will have to foot the bill for the whole world wide scam!!!!
DO NOT BE MANIPULATED BY JUNK SCIENCE. The goal of these "scientists" is to get their GRANT MONEY. And that can only happen if they report "we are all gonna die unless we get more grant money to study this further!!"
The goal of the BANKSTERS is to get rich. WE WILL have to pay for this crap!!!!

"The ocean" produces CO2 in the same way the forest fires produce CO2.
decomposition and oxidation liberates carbon.

But you are thinking on a short-term scale.
The CO2 from the ocean, like the CO2 from forest fires is a zero-net change of atmospheric carbon in the global scope of things.

The only CO2 released is what had been absorbed within the last thousand years or so.

The difference now is that we are liberating carbon which has been sequestered for millions of years.
It's the impact of that liberation that is being studied.
 
Here is a clue for the clueless....................

Global warming and global cooling is directly tied to the decades long hot and cool cycles of the SUN.

False
Global average temperatures, during the recent deep solar minimum, do not support that statement.
 
But I thought Connor MacLeod has been working on a solution for a while now.
 
All ABSOLUTE BS.

The #1 source of green house gas (CO2) is THE OCEAN. A gas naturally by produce of decomposition. The idea of human activity "tipping the scales" is beyond ridiculous. A major volcanic eruption spews more toxic and green house gasses into the atmosphere than what the industrial revolution did. A volcanic eruption is 100% natural and there are several going on around the world at one time. Only the monsters make the news.
You people have to realize that the Earth itself can render the human race null and void by 100% natural forces.
THE REAL PROBLEM is not that there are competing theories of why it seems to be warmer now, etc, etc. It is there is a Cabal of banksters looking to CASH IN ON CARBON CREDITS and we will ALL BE FORCED TO PAY HIGH PRICES FOR ENERGY~!!!
Carbon credit trading will will make the banksters rich and we will have to foot the bill for the whole world wide scam!!!!
DO NOT BE MANIPULATED BY JUNK SCIENCE. The goal of these "scientists" is to get their GRANT MONEY. And that can only happen if they report "we are all gonna die unless we get more grant money to study this further!!"
The goal of the BANKSTERS is to get rich. WE WILL have to pay for this crap!!!!
The fact that you harbor so much anger over something that doesn't even really affect you shows that you are approaching the science from a biased viewpoint. And I'm not concerned about being manipulated... thank you very much. I have a Masters in atmospheric science and can evaluate the literature on my own.

Sure, one goal of scientists is indeed to get grant money. I'm sure whatever job you do is purely motivated by altruistic goals and you would be just as happy to have no salary. Most scientific studies approach the question from a pragmatic standpoint. Researchers are neither looking to prove something is valid nor invalid. They just make an observation and then seek to explain it. For example, Arctic sea ice is receding. A typically study does not begin with "Is this the result of global warming?" but rather "What is the cause of this trend?" and it just so happens that global warming fits the best. But new theories are always on the horizon. The beauty of science is that there aren't any rigid dogmatic positions, but rather our picture of a particular system is always evolving. Of course, that philosophy is rather incompatible with our polarized political system, so I'm not surprised that it is twisted by certain folks and the result is opinions such as yours.

For the record, the ocean is neither a permanent source nor a permanent sink. It wants to equilibrate with the atmosphere, so if concentrations are higher in the ocean CO2 will make its way to the atmosphere and vice versa. And on geologic timescales the ocean is most definitely a CO2 sink, as CO2 is absorbed by the water and then deposited as carbonate rocks. That process is the reason that our atmosphere is not like that of Venus.

Btw, your volcano idea is completely wrong. The largest eruption in recent history, Mount Tambora, released an estimated 100 million tons of CO2 into the atmosphere. In recent times humans have been emitting about 30 billion tons of CO2 yearly.
 
Oh and you are going to have to pay high prices for energy regardless if Dr. Hubbert is correct.
 
The #1 source of green house gas (CO2) is THE OCEAN.

You fail at the most basic Atmospheric Science 101. The ocean is a CO2 sink, not a source.

Dr. Righteous said:
A major volcanic eruption spews more toxic and green house gasses into the atmosphere than what the industrial revolution did.

Wrong. Human activities currently release about 130 times as much CO2 into the atmosphere each year as volcanoes do. Really large volcanic activity, which has not been seen since the Middle Ages, tends to cool the Earth with sulfur dioxide.
 
Who made us the climate czars for the world?

We held a worldwide vote, but none of the animals voted. I guess it's up to us, then.

Honestly, it doesn't say Bill Gates is funding a project to change the Earth's climate deliberately, it says he's funding research into the idea. Is there something wrong with that? The day Bill Gates is ready to buy a fleet of ships to pump some kind of chemical nonsense into the atmosphere, I'll be right there poking holes in the hulls with everybody else. For now, I don't see the problem with doing this research. It may help, or it may prove to be completely bonkers; We won't know unless we do the research. One day it might matter regardless of whether the Earth heats up because of us or because of some other reason, so arguing over the reasons why Earth might or might not warm up seems pointless to me.
 
Here is a clue for the clueless....................

Global warming and global cooling is directly tied to the decades long hot and cool cycles of the SUN.
We are in a hot cycle in the 70s they were in a cool cycle and the scientists were saying a new ice age is on the way.
Soon we will be out of this hot cycle and it will start getting cool again and we will have colder winters and cooler summers for a few decades.

And here's a clue for you : look at the trend since 1900 - UP. That means the next cooling period won't be as cool as the 70s, and the next hot period will be hotter than now. That is the one that could cause places like NYC to start flooding.

Derp, but who cares since we'll all be like 50+ years old by then anyway, right? It's our grandkids problem... :rolleyes:
 
What I find hilarious is the fact that some people think that the billions and billions of tons of gasses we dump into the atmosphere all the time somehow has no effect at all. So it doesn't accelerate planet warming at all? It just disappears?

Well hurr durr where duz it goez then?!?!11one!?

I find it hilarious that people still believe we live in some sort of glass snow globe...
 
Honestly, it doesn't say Bill Gates is funding a project to change the Earth's climate deliberately, it says he's funding research into the idea. Is there something wrong with that?
A bunch of folks I know who do research into geo-engineering schemes seem to have the viewpoint that since we may have to rely on such ideas at some point, we might as well research them now so that we don't screw things up too badly when we actually do try and implement them. ;)
 
Back
Top